Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my brother how I feel

60 replies

eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 13:31

It's an ageing parents one. My dad has had declining health for years, he had a major op this year he's struggling to recover from, can't drive, has deteriorated dramatically, and all the care has fallen to my mum etc. It's been a really awful year.

But my brother won't stay in contact. It can be months between phone calls, he's visited once this year. Whenever he does visit, he puts it off for as long as possible before confirming, and then it's a last minute rush where we can't plan to do anything nice and sometimes I can't even see him (as he'll visit when I'm working so it's too late to get cover).

This is not new. I've told him before how upset this makes mum and dad. He promises to ring more often and make proper plans to visit - but he doesn't.

Dad's 80th birthday was this weekend. I invited him and his partner a month ago. A week prior, after me chasing, he made a load of excuses as to why he couldn't come - and they were very poor excuses. No plans to visit another time. My parents were so upset.

And here's my AIBU: I smoothed it over with mum and dad, like I always do, saying well I'm sure he'll visit soon, sounds like he's been busy/unwell etc. What I really want to do is ask him WTF he thinks he's playing at. And ask him why doesn't he give a shit? To say we had a good childhood, he was the golden sodding child, and THIS is how he repays them? My DH thinks I shouldn't say anything and he's probably right, but I'm so fed up of everything being on me and having to deal with a very sad mum and dad at what's already a difficult time - and it was dad's 80th after all. Be good to hear what other people think.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CountTo10 · 07/11/2023 10:41

I started reading this and actually wondered if you were my sister! We have the same issue with our brother who admittedly lives in another European country. Our 89 yr old Dad has deteriorated rapidly in the past 6 months and frankly his hobby in life is now preparing for death (as in decluttering the house etc etc). Our Mum is 82 but an over anxious nightmare who manages to make every situation worse and makes my Dad's life a misery.

My sister and I ensure one of us visits at least once a week and there's regular texting in between. We take them for days out etc. Brother does nothing and very very rarely makes contact. He will come for Christmas but again leaves it to the very last moment and stays as short a time as he can get away with.

He was the golden child but frankly looking back that manifested as our over anxious mother totally smothering him. He only went to play group once she managed to get a volunteer role there. When he went to school she became a dinner lady at the same school. The irony was as soon as he went to Uni he went to one three hours away then got a job six hours away before eventually moving to a different country. So your brother may have been the golden child but it isn't always rainbows and roses.

However I would be speaking to him and getting him to up contact. That's what we've had to do. Otherwise I think they see him for 5 days at Christmas and that would be it.

Tara336 · 07/11/2023 10:26

@Lieblingsessen my DF is in a care home, the house was in a state because DF has never been keen on parting with money or keeping things nice. DF is controlling and an emotional abuser, now he is out of the home DM wants to make it hers, just after DF was sectioned the heating was condemned so that needed replacing and because DM has never been allowed to make decisions she doesn't where to start. She didn't even gave the confidence to choose a paint colour. DB is lazy and will not help I just feel that after all the years of DF crap DM deserves a nice place to be. I'm not a doormat I'm trying to put right what has been so wrong in her life.

PastorCarrBonarra · 06/11/2023 22:59

eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 19:59

Thing is, he was always the golden child. Literally. I had to stand on my own two feet from 18, when I left home, never asked for anything, and was basically left to get on with it. He had so much more support, it was never his fault when he got into (a lot of) trouble, got given a flat, a job... I had none of that. So he can't say he had it bad - I saw it, and he didn't.

I still think that he might see the early years differently and that he might be carrying ambivalent or antagonistic feelings towards your parents for some reason.

I am genuinely not having a dig at you, OP. You are under pressure and I sympathise. It’s just that I’d be interested in what he’d have to say if he posted on here.

Of course …..It may well be that he’s simply a self-centred weasel and that your parents have not really misstepped.

Why not meet him for a drink and have a candid conversation?

Acornsoup · 06/11/2023 22:10

From what little you have said it does seem like your brother could have good reason for the distance. It is very possible that you don't know why he is distant.

"Thing is, he was always the golden child. Literally. I had to stand on my own two feet from 18, when I left home, never asked for anything, and was basically left to get on with it. He had so much more support, it was never his fault when he got into (a lot of) trouble, got given a flat, a job... I had none of that. So he can't say he had it bad - I saw it, and he didn't."

Why did you leave home at 18 OP? Why was your brother in a lot of trouble?

My dad's not the most amazing dad ever, sure, but my god he's had a traumatic life and a terrible time lately with ill health
*
Why is your Dad not the most amazing Dad ever?

I think you have probably justified your brothers distance without given too much away in those two paragraphs.

His experience doesn't have to be worse than yours. Did you know what it was like for him if you weren't there?*

Velvian · 06/11/2023 21:37

I think if you both want want to understand each other, it would be better to say, 'look, is there something I don't know about that's causing you to distance from mum and dad?'

The fact you mentioned that he get into a lot of trouble does suggest that there was perhaps some issues.

I've seen it in both DH and my families, the teens that got into a lot of trouble were not sufficiently protected by their parents.

That may well not be the case for your brother, but I think you should ask him with an open mind.

Hbh17 · 06/11/2023 21:26

CalistoNoSolo · 06/11/2023 19:14

I voted YABU for several reasons. You say he was the golden child but you have no idea of his reality growing up. Nobody asks to be born - expecting a child of any age to care for their end of life/very ill parents is wrong, end of. You can play the martyr but nobody else has to play along. Your parents are adults who made their own decisions, you're protecting them from themselves. Leave your brother alone, he clearly doesn't want to have anything to do with his parents and you can't force it.

Good response!

Hbh17 · 06/11/2023 21:22

Your brother doesn't have to visit if he doesn't want to (indeed, neither do you). You can only deal with your own relationship with your parents, however you want that to be. Just let your brother do his own thing, whatever he wants that to be.

Noicant · 06/11/2023 21:17

eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 19:59

Thing is, he was always the golden child. Literally. I had to stand on my own two feet from 18, when I left home, never asked for anything, and was basically left to get on with it. He had so much more support, it was never his fault when he got into (a lot of) trouble, got given a flat, a job... I had none of that. So he can't say he had it bad - I saw it, and he didn't.

Your parents don’t sound like they were very kind to you. Why is it that you feel the need to be very kind to them?

pickledandpuzzled · 06/11/2023 21:12

Stop taking responsibility for him- and currently you are.

When your parents mention him, say ‘no idea, sorry.’ Listen patiently to their sadness and agree with them that it’s very upsetting, shit, whatever they say.

Send him a last message saying you won’t be chasing him anymore as you are plenty busy enough already.

Noicant · 06/11/2023 21:04

If he was the golden child and you were considered lesser why are you making so much effort to protect your parents from his disinterest?

Acornsoup · 06/11/2023 21:01

NotSorry · 06/11/2023 21:00

I listened to a podcast earlier this year and have been following this wisdom ever since so that I can live a peaceful life, it really helped me

• If someone wants/is able to do something, they will

• You can’t make someone else change

• Stop being mad that people aren’t who you want them to be

Exactly this :)

NotSorry · 06/11/2023 21:00

I listened to a podcast earlier this year and have been following this wisdom ever since so that I can live a peaceful life, it really helped me

• If someone wants/is able to do something, they will

• You can’t make someone else change

• Stop being mad that people aren’t who you want them to be

Neodymium · 06/11/2023 20:51

eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 19:59

Thing is, he was always the golden child. Literally. I had to stand on my own two feet from 18, when I left home, never asked for anything, and was basically left to get on with it. He had so much more support, it was never his fault when he got into (a lot of) trouble, got given a flat, a job... I had none of that. So he can't say he had it bad - I saw it, and he didn't.

Sounds typical of the people I know who were given everything. They are entitled and selfish. I don’t think giving your kids everything does them any favours in the long run.

i wouldn’t make excuses for him. You shouldn’t baby your parents like that. He is their son, he’s a product of how he was raised by them. Not your job to cover for him.

my dh isn’t close to his mum. But she was cold and distant growing up and showed no interest in our kids. As my mum always says you make your own bed and then you have to lay in it.

ohsuzannah · 06/11/2023 20:43

I looked after my dmum and was at her house every day, especially if she was ill. My dbro would come over once a month to cut the grass and my what a hero he was, helping his old mum 😂
There's a lot of them around!

willowthecat · 06/11/2023 20:37

Missing an 80th birthday for no real reason seems very uncaring - has he always been like this ? Is he selfish in other aspects of his life ? Did he effectively disappear once he was an adult ? Is there any history of estrangement/arguments ? Did your parents make excuses for him when they were younger ?

Lieblingsessen · 06/11/2023 20:37

eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 19:59

Thing is, he was always the golden child. Literally. I had to stand on my own two feet from 18, when I left home, never asked for anything, and was basically left to get on with it. He had so much more support, it was never his fault when he got into (a lot of) trouble, got given a flat, a job... I had none of that. So he can't say he had it bad - I saw it, and he didn't.

I find this very sad OP. It seems that your parents emotionally pushed you out of the home as they were so focussed on your brother. But now that they want (need) you, you appear to be so grateful and are doing everything for them, even if it's at times too much. Why, after how they dismissed your needs when you were younger and instead gave everything to your brother?

ASkarsMissus · 06/11/2023 20:28

I wouldn’t waste your breath. It won’t change him or his behaviour and will only cause you more heartache. I have similar issues with a brother and an aging parent and I’ve really had to distance myself from him as it’s just so hurtful to see how he treats our mum. He behaves as if she’s a stranger. I have told myself that although we grew up in the same house he is a different person from me and his experience was not mine. Sometimes I tell myself it’s his coping mechanism to push her away. Whatever it is, deep down I find his behaviour hard to forgive. I have my own grief to process over her failing health and lose enough sleep without trying to work out what’s going on with him. He’s an adult, as is your brother and it’s up to them to live with whatever regrets they have in the future, if they even have any. For the sake of your own mental health please try and focus on your own relationships with your parents while you have them.

Lieblingsessen · 06/11/2023 20:25

Tara336 · 06/11/2023 19:16

My DB lives 5 miles from DP I live 150 miles away and am chronicly ill, guess which one of us spent the weekend decorating DM bedroom, assembling furniture etc? He does absolutely bugger all for her, barely visits DF in his care home and quite frankly I say what I think now on the subject but it gets me absolutely nowhere.

Just why did you decorate your DM's bedroom when you are chronically ill?

Your DB didn't do it because he knew you would do it. Maybe just say no next time your DM wants a job doing around the house and tell your DM to ask your DB instead. In other words stop being a doormat, even for relatives. Your health is more important!

girlfriend44 · 06/11/2023 20:23

How selfish?
Is he expecting an inheritance when they die?
Does he have children and would he like it done to him?

Is there any reason given as to why he is like this?
Has your mum asked him directly?

eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 20:16

TicTacNicNak · 06/11/2023 20:02

My brother is the same OP, so I sympathise.

My mum is 87 and we lost my dad a few years back. On his deathbed me and DBro promised him we'd look after mum for him. Ha! It's been me doing all the work. Admittedly I do live much nearer (he's a couple of hours away and I'm round the corner) but he can't even be bothered to call half the time. It can go weeks on end without a call and months without a visit. When he does visit he'll do a couple of jobs for her then spend the rest of his visit on his phone or iPad. No doubt when mum goes he'll be the one posting sad stuff on FB about how much he misses her.

I've tried talking to my DBro about it, and he'll improve for a short while but then revert back to type. He was the golden child also. If your brother is like mine then don't expect any conversation to have a long lasting effect.

Sorry your brother is similar - they do sound similar (right down to making an effort for a few weeks before reverting to type).

Thanks everyone for comments and perspectives. I won't say anything but equally I'm not going to make excuses for him any more. It's on him now.

OP posts:
eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 20:04

Neighbours23 · 06/11/2023 18:06

I’m really sorry that you’re going through this. I have something similar, and it’s so difficult and upsetting. From the outside it may seem/ feel obvious that you should stop covering for your brother, but when you’re in it it can be so much harder than that - you love your parents and don’t want them to be hurt. There is likely also real anger and hurt about feeling forced into this position that impacts you so much, but that you feel powerless to influence.

I don’t think you can really change him, although it may be that there will be a way you can get across to him how much pain he causes, both them and you. Or maybe at some point he will shift a bit, who knows? I’ve not found the solution in my situation, I’m trying to learn to not let it cause me so much pain but it’s not easy.

I’m sorry this isn’t really an answer but I hope you find people you can talk to (a therapist helped me). Good luck and look after yourself.

Thank you, and sorry you are going through something similar. A lot of you have said the same thing, and you're right. I guess I want him to change, I'd like to have that normal, happy family that cares about each other, does stuff together, but I don't and I need to accept that.

I don't need his help really: I've never had help from anyone and certainly never from him, so I don't expect it. And I am lucky in that I have an amazing DH and great friends in similar situations, whose practical advice is invaluable. I'm just staggered that even now, on his dad's 80th, be just CBA. My dad's not the most amazing dad ever, sure, but my god he's had a traumatic life and a terrible time lately with ill health - even my teenage kids were like, 'yeah, let's go celebrate with him cos he's had such a shit time lately'.

OP posts:
TicTacNicNak · 06/11/2023 20:02

My brother is the same OP, so I sympathise.

My mum is 87 and we lost my dad a few years back. On his deathbed me and DBro promised him we'd look after mum for him. Ha! It's been me doing all the work. Admittedly I do live much nearer (he's a couple of hours away and I'm round the corner) but he can't even be bothered to call half the time. It can go weeks on end without a call and months without a visit. When he does visit he'll do a couple of jobs for her then spend the rest of his visit on his phone or iPad. No doubt when mum goes he'll be the one posting sad stuff on FB about how much he misses her.

I've tried talking to my DBro about it, and he'll improve for a short while but then revert back to type. He was the golden child also. If your brother is like mine then don't expect any conversation to have a long lasting effect.

eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 19:59

PastorCarrBonarra · 06/11/2023 19:15

He’s put his boundaries in place and his reasons for doing so may be selfish and petty, or they may not. He may see childhood differently to you.

In any case, you won’t be able to change his behaviour so focus on yourself and give no more than you can manage.

Thing is, he was always the golden child. Literally. I had to stand on my own two feet from 18, when I left home, never asked for anything, and was basically left to get on with it. He had so much more support, it was never his fault when he got into (a lot of) trouble, got given a flat, a job... I had none of that. So he can't say he had it bad - I saw it, and he didn't.

OP posts:
eyeslikebutterflies · 06/11/2023 19:57

AmiablePedant · 06/11/2023 17:50

Not exactly helpful, but please insert here an extended feminist rant on the subject of male offspring who think it is only the daughter's (or daughters') duty to help frail and aging parents. It is so deeply unfair. Was he always a careless, oblivious jerk, from childhood onward, OP?

Yes, always. I know he won't change, it's just so deeply, deeply disappointing.

OP posts:
maryberryslayers · 06/11/2023 19:53

It's his choice what relationship he has with his parents, not yours. He doesn't owe them for his childhood.

You complain that 'it's all on you' but you do those things because you want to, no one is forcing you.