Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what should happen now? DD attacked by other students

433 replies

RainInNovember · 06/11/2023 12:31

DD is 15, shes had a few issues with people, got into a few arguments, nothing major and mainly over whatsapp etc, she does seem to get involved in the drama. But a lot of her friends are similar and there are often fallings out but then friends again the next week.

I just had a message from dd at school. she said two girls who she used to be friends with have waited outside her lesson for her and followed her. once she was on her own they put a coat over her head and started punching her in the head and pulling her hair and dragging her about.

she has told school and she said the girls are currently in isolation, I have called school who said they're investigating now and will call me back shortly.

I have never dealt with anything like this before. I just want to know what to expect and how seriously they should take it.

OP posts:
RainInNovember · 07/11/2023 08:44

Oh and the teacher (pastoral) said to DD that there's a war going on and you girls are being petty about things like this, it's a lovely school with lovely people and I'm sure the girls feel ashamed of their actions.
Dd said they were laughing as they walked away

OP posts:
Evaka · 07/11/2023 08:34

TattiePants · 06/11/2023 21:05

@RainInNovember I'm sorry this has happened to your DD but unfortunately we have experience of this as DS was assaulted at school (sixth form) just before Christmas last year by four boys. DS left the school building immediately after the assault so we collected him, took him home then we decided to go back to school to talk to someone in person. DS also knew that some of the attack had been filmed. In our case both school and the police acted perfectly so this is what I think worked well and what you should expect for your DD.

School
Spoke to Pastoral Lead who immediately retrieved the footage and ensured it was deleted.
The four boys were immediately suspended pending investigation.
The school called the police themselves and reported the assault.
Head of Sixth Form kept us updated at all times.
Agreed absence from school for DS whilst investigation was happening.
CCTV retrieved from corridors.
Witness statements taken.
Four boys suspended till end of term.
Meeting with school to discuss progress to date and reintegrate DS back into school before end of term.
After Christmas holidays, each boy was interviewed by school with their parent.
Suspended for a further week and had to sign a behaviour contract. If they didn't stick to contract they would be out of sixth form.
Restorative justice meeting for DS with each boy.
Assembly for whole of sixth form on the bystander effect (lots of DCs watched but didn't intervene).

Police
Police called us and as a priority visited within an hour.
Took details of assault and told DS his options (to prosecute or not). Gave us a crime number and contact details.
Visited school for video of assault.
Called us several times over Christmas to help DS decide what to do.
DS didn't want to prosecute so police visited each boy at home and warned them what could have happened and what would happen if they assaulted someone again.

We also had a call from social services offering support if we needed it (we didn't).

This is what you should expect from both the school and police although being sixth form for us rather than in the lower school gave the school a few more options. We were told that a number of the leadership team wanted to expel. Fortunately for us, 3 out of the 4 boys have now gone.

Edited

@RainInNovember so sorry that your daughter's gone through this. Hope she's OK today.

@TattiePants what a brilliant response. Can I ask how your son found the individual meetings with the lads who attacked him?

DailyMailHater · 07/11/2023 08:22

I can’t believe the leanancy of the punishment they have received - this was a premeditated physical assault (they waited for her and knew hat they were going to do) they are old enough to understand right and wrong and the consequences

a day suspension is not proportionate to the incident I would be telling the school that I as t satisfied with the outcome or there attitude to ensuring DD was safe at school going forward

comments like - she wants to study Law and this could affect her and I don’t have a crystal ball are totally inappropriate in the circumstances

Stokey · 07/11/2023 08:22

I'm not surprised she's feeling anxious.

I also think the "crystal ball" comment is appalling when you're looking for reassurance from the school that your daughter won't be assaulted. This should be a basic right of each child going to school.

That and the comment about the perpetrator studying law makes me think they're not taking it seriously enough, and would make me want to escalate to head or governors.

Pelegrinfalcon · 07/11/2023 08:21

Although they made out it was more heat of the moment because dd was ignoring their questions/comments so they followed get and then attacked as she wasn't giving them the attention

nice bit of victim blaming. I think school is handling this appealingly.

RainInNovember · 07/11/2023 08:12

I've actually let her stay home today she's really anxious.

School haven't said different to me than what my daughter said. Although they made out it was more heat of the moment because dd was ignoring their questions/comments so they followed get and then attacked as she wasn't giving them the attention,

School said whatever the behaviour, for a first offence the punishment is always a one day suspension

OP posts:
TizerorFizz · 07/11/2023 07:55

@Teateaandmoretea I rather thought, after reading most comments, many people posting thought it should end up in court. All sorts of language have been used around prosecution charges. I don’t think it should. Yes, the police could visit the offenders but as it’s a 1 day suspension they really would not get involved.

I also think the punishment doesn’t appear, on the face of it, to fit the alleged crime. So there’s more to this. The school behaviour and punishment policy would give further clues and details of the investigation which took no time at all, but “pressing charges”, as suggested, does infer a court hearing. I agree. Never going to happen.

RainInNovember · 07/11/2023 07:50

Stokey · 07/11/2023 07:11

How's your daughter feeling this morning? It sounds very traumatic.

As well as the punishments, you need to ask the school to outline what steps they will take to ensure these girls will not be able to re-victimise your daughter

Also agree with re-engaging with the police and saying you wish to pursue an investigation into an assault that occured.

Well she doesn't want to go to school, but I've said it's best to go today while the girls aren't in school.

I did ask school if my daughter is at risk of being targeted once they're back, was told she doesn't have a crystal ball and that they will have to sign a behaviour contract and if it happens again will face a 2 day exclusion !!

OP posts:
Teateaandmoretea · 07/11/2023 07:29

TizerorFizz · 06/11/2023 23:10

@k1233
We do not “press charges” in the uk. That’s tv speak. The police have to gather evidence. If they believe they have sufficient for a criminal prosecution to go ahead and witnesses willing to give evidence in court, they can go to the Crown Prosecution Service to see if they agree. If they don’t, no court case. CPS consider the evidence, the chance of success in court and whether going to court is in the public interest. Many school cases won’t meet the public interest threshold. There can be private prosecutions if you have deep pockets.

There are a lot of other options available to the police. Paying a visit to warn, cautions. No one thinks that this would land up in court.

Stokey · 07/11/2023 07:11

How's your daughter feeling this morning? It sounds very traumatic.

As well as the punishments, you need to ask the school to outline what steps they will take to ensure these girls will not be able to re-victimise your daughter

Also agree with re-engaging with the police and saying you wish to pursue an investigation into an assault that occured.

Flipdiddle · 07/11/2023 06:02

RainInNovember · 06/11/2023 19:57

just had a acall from the police . it sounded like their hands are tied really but she said to tell school that i wanted positive action taking and that i will escate to the education authority. she sounded sympathetic but like they wont take it further

That doesn’t make sense

Did your daughter not want to report it?

TizerorFizz · 06/11/2023 23:10

@k1233
We do not “press charges” in the uk. That’s tv speak. The police have to gather evidence. If they believe they have sufficient for a criminal prosecution to go ahead and witnesses willing to give evidence in court, they can go to the Crown Prosecution Service to see if they agree. If they don’t, no court case. CPS consider the evidence, the chance of success in court and whether going to court is in the public interest. Many school cases won’t meet the public interest threshold. There can be private prosecutions if you have deep pockets.

WearyAuldWumman · 06/11/2023 22:46

Weepatchesoflove · 06/11/2023 20:15

@Theresit ~ It was my understanding that the age of criminal responsibility is 12 years old in Scotland, has this changed?

In most cases, Police Scotland will not deal with someone under the age of 16, since those under the age of 16 are normally passed to the Children's Panel, rather than the courts.

My former school had a case where a teacher was punched by a 15 yr old boy. His parents tried to have the teacher charged, because the teacher put out a hand to stop the second punch.

The boy wasn't charged for anything until he turned 16 and was caught breaking into cars.

JSMill · 06/11/2023 22:21

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia I totally agree. There's a very popular secondary school in my borough which claims to have no bullying. I didn't even consider applying for a nano second!

AproposofEverything · 06/11/2023 22:14

After school confirmed whether they’ve checked for phone footage? It seems like they’ve made a very quick decision on all of this.

k1233 · 06/11/2023 21:57

What exactly did you ask the police? Did you tell them your daughter was assaulted at school, there are multiple witnesses and you want to press charges for assault or did you just ask them what to do in this situation.

Where I live (not UK) the criminal code definition of assault is application (or threatened application) of force without consent. It is cut and dried in this situation. I'd be arguing for aggravated circumstances as they followed her and planned the attack. I would not allow the police to brush me off and I'd be pushing for both assaulters to be formally charged. If you don't stand up for your daughter, no one will.

As for one wanting to study law, I'd suggest she has neither the aptitude nor intelligence to do so.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 06/11/2023 21:49

MoreThanEnoughSoFar · 06/11/2023 14:36

Depends on the school. Some schools sadly will sacrifice victims and avoid calling the police, so not to get in the media.

Given the choice between attending a school that brushed poor behaviour under the carpet and one that called the police and was in the press for doing so, I know which I'd rather attend.

Always be suspicious of a school with a perfect reputation. Ask why.

TheFifthTellytubby · 06/11/2023 21:47

RainInNovember · 06/11/2023 19:57

just had a acall from the police . it sounded like their hands are tied really but she said to tell school that i wanted positive action taking and that i will escate to the education authority. she sounded sympathetic but like they wont take it further

I really don't understand this. Why is a criminal assault any less criminal just because it takes place on school premises?

TizerorFizz · 06/11/2023 21:35

The school hasn’t had time to investigate this properly. So it’s hasty in its decisions. Dc can be permanently excluded for a first offence if it’s bad enough. He’s this incident been over exaggerated? We don’t know that either. Witnesses? What did they say?

JSMill · 06/11/2023 21:34

maddening · 06/11/2023 20:58

Why are the police's hands tied?

They're not. It's a choice.

TizerorFizz · 06/11/2023 21:27

No school has a policy of not excluding. They should follow their policies. What’s the whole story here? I’m wondering about the extent of what’s been going on.

SoySaucePls · 06/11/2023 21:18

@TattiePants what an amazing response.

Those girls should be suspended for much longer than a day. It’s just a joke, what the school have offered.

OP I’d urgently get in touch with your MP also and ask what further measures can be taken legally by the school.

Also, I’d consider keeping your DD off school once the bullies return and say the school is unsafe. They aren’t following safe guarding because the girls haven’t been disciplined properly and could do it again.

Id also be asking the head what the next punishment will be if the girls do it again.

Id say to the head you are considering a complaint to the local council and ofsted because the action taken is meaningless and won’t be enough of a deterrent.

I absolutely hate the policy of not being able to expel, some kids are rotten through and need to go elsewhere. They screw up kids’ lives and it’s grossly unfair they get to stick around, no matter how sickening they are.

It’s successive governments saving money by not having separate units for these kids. They instead just fuck everyone up. Save money but instead it ends up spent on cahms because there’s so much mental health problems caused by the terrible environment that is some secondary schools.

cansu · 06/11/2023 21:17

It is extremely unlikely that a student will be permanently excluded for a single physical incident. The bar for permanent exclusion is very high. The school will need to use their behaviour policy which will likely include fixed term exclusions of varying lengths and / or isolation. The police are also unlikely to get involved in this kind of incident as the OP has discovered.

ttcat37 · 06/11/2023 21:16

RainInNovember · 06/11/2023 19:57

just had a acall from the police . it sounded like their hands are tied really but she said to tell school that i wanted positive action taking and that i will escate to the education authority. she sounded sympathetic but like they wont take it further

Their hands are tied by who? They are not dictated to by the school as to what they can and can’t investigate. It’s not up to the school. Explicitly tell them that you want the police to take action against the girls that assaulted your child (if that is what you want).