Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what should happen now? DD attacked by other students

433 replies

RainInNovember · 06/11/2023 12:31

DD is 15, shes had a few issues with people, got into a few arguments, nothing major and mainly over whatsapp etc, she does seem to get involved in the drama. But a lot of her friends are similar and there are often fallings out but then friends again the next week.

I just had a message from dd at school. she said two girls who she used to be friends with have waited outside her lesson for her and followed her. once she was on her own they put a coat over her head and started punching her in the head and pulling her hair and dragging her about.

she has told school and she said the girls are currently in isolation, I have called school who said they're investigating now and will call me back shortly.

I have never dealt with anything like this before. I just want to know what to expect and how seriously they should take it.

OP posts:
Giantgold · 07/11/2023 17:21

Forsakenalmosthuman · 07/11/2023 15:07

My child's school brushes assaults under the carpet all the fucking time.

What is it otherwise like?

Forsakenalmosthuman · 07/11/2023 15:07

My child's school brushes assaults under the carpet all the fucking time.

Giantgold · 07/11/2023 14:51

This sounds a ghastly school

bombastix · 07/11/2023 13:36

What an awful school.

I mean, blaming someone for being hit. What rubbish. I don't get hit someone if they ignore me or don't answer my questions.

TizerorFizz · 07/11/2023 13:34

It’s knowing what’s going on between the girls! Schools are not courts. They do and can make judgements on behaviour they see. Don’t forget that in a school, disruptive back chat, talking inappropriately, not following instructions and arguing are all grounds for discipline and suspension. Not the same as the general public so it’s best not to confuse the two. If constant arguing and falling out are a feature in class, all these girls could have been suspended should it be intrusive enough.

Yalta · 07/11/2023 13:33

School haven't said different to me than what my daughter said. Although they made out it was more heat of the moment because dd was ignoring their questions/comments so they followed get and then attacked as she wasn't giving them the attention

So according to the school it was your dds fault. If only she had answered their questions, if only she had given them her attention then they wouldn’t have felt compelled to attack her

This comment and the war comment and being petty comment.

All add add up to staff members who need to go and work elsewhere.

I wonder if you could ask the pastoral care woman what would happen if your dd attacked her. Would your dd get a days suspension as it is her first offence

I would also point out to this woman that she is hardly likely to complain further as there is a war going on and it would be petty to do so.

Hibiscrubbed · 07/11/2023 13:26

As suspected, the school have minimised (telling the girls there’s a war on and they’re arguing), victim blamed (saying your daughter was ignoring the perpetrators thus suggesting she’s partially or fully at fault), tried to manipulate you into not going to the police (telling you that if you report you may damage the perpetrator’s chance of becoming a lawyer) and dished out the most pathetic ‘punishments’ (one day isolation, going up to two if they physically attack her again).

I mean, what the fuck is all that?!

I’d escalate it within the school, utilise their policy against them and involve the governors and local authority.

Myfabby · 07/11/2023 13:10

TizerorFizz · 07/11/2023 10:59

@RainInNovember I can assure you NO school would not permanently exclude for certain misdemeanours. Try attacking and harming a teacher and it would be instant PE. Same with violently attacking another child when obvious lasting harm is done. Your school is fobbing you off with this.

Could you move schools. This clearly isn’t working for DD. Maybe a new start? Get away from the drama?

I would hope so, but apparently hitting a librarian and pointing a (water) gun at her is ok and was told by more than a handful of mumnetters that she was over-reacting so who knows?

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4928291-to-think-he-should-be-expelled-for-threatening-me-outside-school?page=1

To think he should be expelled for threatening me outside school? | Mumsnet

Do I just need to suck it up ? I am being routinely assaulted and threatened by students in my new job which I have been at for one term. I am curre...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4928291-to-think-he-should-be-expelled-for-threatening-me-outside-school?page=1

Nicole1111 · 07/11/2023 12:31

RainInNovember · 07/11/2023 08:44

Oh and the teacher (pastoral) said to DD that there's a war going on and you girls are being petty about things like this, it's a lovely school with lovely people and I'm sure the girls feel ashamed of their actions.
Dd said they were laughing as they walked away

This is disgusting. Get everything they said to you written down while it’s all fresh in your mind and then write a letter asking how the school can justify victim blaming and calling an assault complaint petty. Also ask for contact details for the governors.

anyolddinosaur · 07/11/2023 11:53

Time to speak to the head about the appalling behaviour of the pastoral staff. If not happy with the response and the proposal for safeguarding going forward take that to the governors .I'd also be asking to speak to a more senior police officer.

TizerorFizz · 07/11/2023 11:15

Most attacks on teachers don’t follow years of falling out dramas and making up. They are usually carried out by Dc with SEN and severe behaviour management needs. Dc who might end up in prison.

TizerorFizz · 07/11/2023 11:12

Leave for 6th form. All the more necessary to stop the arguments and have a calmer life!

Crumpleton · 07/11/2023 11:11

RainInNovember · 07/11/2023 08:44

Oh and the teacher (pastoral) said to DD that there's a war going on and you girls are being petty about things like this, it's a lovely school with lovely people and I'm sure the girls feel ashamed of their actions.
Dd said they were laughing as they walked away

Wonder if all that had been done to your DD by these girls had been done instead to one of the teaching staff would the outcome be the same.

TizerorFizz · 07/11/2023 11:10

Just to add: I worked for a LA negotiating new schools and pru places for PE children. Occasionally they were first offences but they were more serious than that described here. I would also expect the school to get to the bottom of why these girls fall out with each other all the time. It’s unhealthy and counter productive. DD needs to disengage. I see she didn’t want to answer but this needs to be matched to them backing off. So all of them need to change. Find new friends maybe? Are other girls now sympathetic or not contacting dd? What about other friends? Many girls do not have this falling out and making up sagas. Mine didn’t. They all need to be talked to about avoiding conflict and what being a friend actually means. Then you can find a group with your values. But, if you do keep falling out and stoking the fire, you get girls like this doing things like this.

I would ask for guidance on what to do now. How can the school help? What can friends do? How can she be kept away from the girls and I suggest no social media with them either.

RainInNovember · 07/11/2023 11:02

TizerorFizz · 07/11/2023 10:59

@RainInNovember I can assure you NO school would not permanently exclude for certain misdemeanours. Try attacking and harming a teacher and it would be instant PE. Same with violently attacking another child when obvious lasting harm is done. Your school is fobbing you off with this.

Could you move schools. This clearly isn’t working for DD. Maybe a new start? Get away from the drama?

She has her GCSEs this year but it's certainly something to think about if necessary

OP posts:
TizerorFizz · 07/11/2023 10:59

@RainInNovember I can assure you NO school would not permanently exclude for certain misdemeanours. Try attacking and harming a teacher and it would be instant PE. Same with violently attacking another child when obvious lasting harm is done. Your school is fobbing you off with this.

Could you move schools. This clearly isn’t working for DD. Maybe a new start? Get away from the drama?

Redissuereader · 07/11/2023 10:14

I've been reading all the excellent advice you've had so far but given today's updates just want to point you back to a previous poster's suggestion of flagging up the safeguarding policy - saying they haven't got a crystal ball is not going to impress OFSTED that they are taking peer on peer abuse seriously. Please do get the relevant documents together, the anti bullying policy, the safeguarding policy and email a complaint setting out that the punishment is too lenient given the offence, that they have a duty of care to your daughter to ensure she is safe on the school grounds, and that the are victim blaming rather than actually dealing with it in an appropriate manner. I would also speak to the Police again and say that you want the matter taken further, not just passed to the school, if they say there is nothing more they can do, ask them for details of their complaints procedure.

Changednamesforthis22 · 07/11/2023 09:39

One day isn't long enough to be a deterrent. They should have been put in isolation for a week to bore them to tears and separate from your daughter for a little bit.
There's no good reason to jump on someone and attack them, can't believe the school.

Lolitt · 07/11/2023 09:39

2023aaa · 07/11/2023 09:32

They may have their own procedures, but unfortunately for them they don’t get to override the law. A criminal assault has taken place.

OP, I’d go back to the police and clearly state what you want to happen.

Oh, and as for the school fobbing you off with ‘but she wants to study law!!’, that would just motivate me further to f- that up for her. No-one who violently attacks another person should be working in any part of the justice system.

She would not be studying law - period.

Totally agree with this. These girls should not be studying law!!! 🙄

2023aaa · 07/11/2023 09:32

indianwoman · 07/11/2023 08:47

These things happen in school on a fairly regular basis . School don't call the police to report, they would call them if they can't stop the fight or threat. They have their own procedures in dealing with investigations and consequences.

They may have their own procedures, but unfortunately for them they don’t get to override the law. A criminal assault has taken place.

OP, I’d go back to the police and clearly state what you want to happen.

Oh, and as for the school fobbing you off with ‘but she wants to study law!!’, that would just motivate me further to f- that up for her. No-one who violently attacks another person should be working in any part of the justice system.

She would not be studying law - period.

Pizzahunt · 07/11/2023 09:15

Sorry this is happening to your daughter. Sounds like the school don’t want to take any responsibility for this incident.
Can you speak to the girls parents to get a feel for how they might deal with this moving forward.
The pastoral teacher is just patronising and sounds like they’re in the wrong job.
No wonder people take the law into their own hands when the authorities fail to protect innocent victims.

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/11/2023 09:00

Stokey · 07/11/2023 08:22

I'm not surprised she's feeling anxious.

I also think the "crystal ball" comment is appalling when you're looking for reassurance from the school that your daughter won't be assaulted. This should be a basic right of each child going to school.

That and the comment about the perpetrator studying law makes me think they're not taking it seriously enough, and would make me want to escalate to head or governors.

The OP has to use the school's complaints policy - it isn't a case of "escalating" to the head, because the head has made the decisions re: action.

She can request a meeting with the Head to discuss the issues, but if the head says they're following the published school behaviour policy, then escalating a complaint to the governing body will result in them ascertaining whether or not the policy was followed correctly - they cannot and will not increase the punishment.

The OP should, however, pressure the police, who are lying when they say their "hands are tied".

TattiePants · 07/11/2023 08:59

@Evaka he found 3 out of 4 of the meetings very helpful. In each meeting was DS, DH, head of 6th form and one of the boys. The first 3 seemed to grasp the seriousness of what they’d done, promised it would never happen again and understood the impact on DS.

The final meeting was an absolute disaster. This was with the boy who’d by far done the most (whipped DS with a leather belt across his bare back, sexual assault etc). The boy’s father had asked to be included and both us and school agreed as we assumed he wanted to apologise. The dad said nothing to DH, never apologised or even asked how DS was. The only time the dad spoke was to complain how long the process had taken and that his DS had had it hanging over him over Christmas! Thankfully the head of sixth form shut him down and pointed out that she was more concerned how it had affected DS. His son hardly apologised and complained about the harshness of his sanctions. Thankfully he’d left (or was pushed) a few months later.

Hughs · 07/11/2023 08:50

RainInNovember · 07/11/2023 08:44

Oh and the teacher (pastoral) said to DD that there's a war going on and you girls are being petty about things like this, it's a lovely school with lovely people and I'm sure the girls feel ashamed of their actions.
Dd said they were laughing as they walked away

I think that's enough now for a formal complaint. This plus the victim blaming, the studying law comment, the crystal ball comment, the ridiculous punishment and the refusal to put any measures in place to keep your DD safe.
And I would go back to the police and press them to do something about this.

indianwoman · 07/11/2023 08:47

2023aaa · 06/11/2023 13:52

I’m sorry, what? I think the biggest question here is why the police weren’t called as soon as the incident happened. What is the school thinking?!

So what if they were put in isolation? That’s no consequence to a teenager and won’t affect them in any way. They've got away with it.

A violent crime has been committed and the correct authorities need to be informed immediately. That’s not the school.
It’s up to the police and CPS to investigate and, hopefully, prosecute.

If you saw a person attacked in the street, what would you do? Phone the police, obviously!
Why should it differ because they’re teenagers in school? Let the little criminals get what they deserve. I hope your DD is OK.

These things happen in school on a fairly regular basis . School don't call the police to report, they would call them if they can't stop the fight or threat. They have their own procedures in dealing with investigations and consequences.

Swipe left for the next trending thread