Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what should happen now? DD attacked by other students

433 replies

RainInNovember · 06/11/2023 12:31

DD is 15, shes had a few issues with people, got into a few arguments, nothing major and mainly over whatsapp etc, she does seem to get involved in the drama. But a lot of her friends are similar and there are often fallings out but then friends again the next week.

I just had a message from dd at school. she said two girls who she used to be friends with have waited outside her lesson for her and followed her. once she was on her own they put a coat over her head and started punching her in the head and pulling her hair and dragging her about.

she has told school and she said the girls are currently in isolation, I have called school who said they're investigating now and will call me back shortly.

I have never dealt with anything like this before. I just want to know what to expect and how seriously they should take it.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 09/11/2023 13:26

I am sure that no-one has said that parents can demand PE, (I'm not going back to look).
What posters have said is that schools very rarely PE pupils for this sort of thing, and it doesn't matter whether the violence is against pupils or staff.
And that the root of this is down to the government making it policy not to PE an penalising schools that do.

Pumpkinpie1 · 09/11/2023 13:25

Why have the police said their hands are tied?
your daughter was assaulted and the girls admitted it. Not only that they are continuing to harass her.
If the police can’t clarify I would formally complain. This response isn’t good enough

TizerorFizz · 09/11/2023 13:07

That’s because heads have been given power! That’s what they wanted. I just think people should not give incorrect advice and the op should take a sensible route through to achieve more. It starts with the complaints procedure at school. However it is solely the head’s decision to PE or not based on their policies. Ofsted will look at exclusions at a school when they visit and want to see they match policies and are fair. Parents cannot demand another Dc is excluded and keeping social media posts sent by a third party is not helpful unless it’s comments that would lead to suspension or exclusion. We can probably see why good heads are hard to find! Good money but not easy is it! ?

FrippEnos · 09/11/2023 12:24

TizerorFizz · 09/11/2023 08:45

I would read this re Ofsted. It will not be looked at.

You are really just proving the point that the school will not do anything unless it is forced to do so.
And even in forcing a school to do something there are very few routes to take.

2023aaa · 09/11/2023 12:13

As for the wannabe law student, start contacting local sixth forms and colleges to give them a heads up. It’s not defamation if it can be proven through her school records.

They won’t want her. Bye bye uni!! 👋

2023aaa · 09/11/2023 12:11

FFS, I’m so sorry this is happening.

This is exactly what I and several other posters meant when we said the punishment given by the school won’t have any impact on them.
People like this literally don’t care if they’re ’put in isolation’.
Not a single fuck given because it doesn’t change their life in any way, shape or form. It’s not a consequence. It’s the equivalent of a doss lesson.

I agree with taking your safeguarding concerns to absolutely everyone you can - LA, Ofsted, you name it.

Oh, and don’t forget the power of a good old Google review! Schools don’t like when their reputation is threatened.

Tabloids always a great option too - they’ll bite your hand off for a story like that because it generates outrage and therefore engagement.
Yes they’re rags, but you can just see the headlines of ‘Child violently assaulted but local school looked the other way’ going viral. The child usually stays anonymous in those articles, so absolutely go ahead and name and shame the school!

School will soon realise they’re got getting out of this with their image intact.

TizerorFizz · 09/11/2023 08:45

I would read this re Ofsted. It will not be looked at.

To ask what should happen now? DD attacked by other students
Crumpleton · 08/11/2023 21:11

Seriously....This girl really does sound as though she needs taking down a peg or two.
It doesn't surprise me after the so called punishment that she received, it wasn't really much of a deterant so not much of a worry to her.

I do wonder in these cases how concerned, if at all, the parents of these bullies are.
When I Worked in a school I remember complaining to the head teacher about a boy A that had kick another boy B (where it really hurts) and was a bit taken a back when they replied that if they told A off his mum would come in a go mad at them. Is there any chance this head could be like that?

As a pp said if possible take your DH into school and complain and do contact OFSTED, that's probably one thing that the head really won't want you to do.

TizerorFizz · 08/11/2023 21:03

There’s a lot of poor info on this thread. Every single head has the power to exclude. LAs never make this decision. And no, the police do not charge for a first offence. See attached.

To ask what should happen now? DD attacked by other students
scrunchie2 · 08/11/2023 20:41

Rocksonabeach · 08/11/2023 19:21

The fact she wants to do law is a reason to escalate it even more IMO to make sure it is recorded with the police. Insist on the police that you want them to charged - one punch in the head could kill. Do you want a solicitor who punched someone in the head so much for caring about the rights of others.

Doesnt matter on school or out of school have the police involved and insist on a criminal charge of assault. 15 is too old to put up with this kind of behaviour.

it was premeditated and designed to terrify - I imagine your DD was traumatised even if she is masking. Phone the police back and insist on them taking responsibility and the same with the headteacher.

in my experience one day exclusion is not enough - she will be back tomorrow and pissed off - in my experience kids need to be shown boundaries and the no police action could set up a bully for life eg I punched someone police weren’t interested!

You realise you can't insist the police charge on anything, it's for them investigate and decide on the outcome of that- not anyone else.

Eybyegum · 08/11/2023 20:03

They are heading towards a harassment charge. If your dd has evidence of the shoving in the corridor from the girl who tried to get her next to her in RE then that’s already 3 events. Harassment is 2 or more. I would be back on to the police if school do not get this sorted tomorrow. As pp said, any change in class/ routine should be done by the bullies not your dd.

Rocksonabeach · 08/11/2023 19:21

The fact she wants to do law is a reason to escalate it even more IMO to make sure it is recorded with the police. Insist on the police that you want them to charged - one punch in the head could kill. Do you want a solicitor who punched someone in the head so much for caring about the rights of others.

Doesnt matter on school or out of school have the police involved and insist on a criminal charge of assault. 15 is too old to put up with this kind of behaviour.

it was premeditated and designed to terrify - I imagine your DD was traumatised even if she is masking. Phone the police back and insist on them taking responsibility and the same with the headteacher.

in my experience one day exclusion is not enough - she will be back tomorrow and pissed off - in my experience kids need to be shown boundaries and the no police action could set up a bully for life eg I punched someone police weren’t interested!

Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 19:16

Towriteyoumustlive.

I hear stories like this all the time from my DD2 who is a teacher in a Inner City Comprehensive. It is actually frightening and everybody just seems to want to brush it under the carpet.

It is not 'normal' falling out to put a jacket over someones head. It is very serious and anyone who does that is a serious risk or needs the fear of god putting in to them.

I feel sorry for some kids who end up facing the sternest, consequences from schools. These kids often stand up to this ongoing subversive bullying. Often they are the ones who end up Suspended or Excluded because they are the ones who are seen hitting the bullies !

The schools are unaware or most likely do not want to know what is going on. I think teachers are frightened !

FrippEnos · 08/11/2023 19:14

Giantgold · 08/11/2023 07:57

Are you seriously saying that if a child glassed a teacher in the face - they wouldn’t be permanently excluded?

As that would be an extreme example, yes they would be permanently excluded.

But the other poster is incorrect many acts of ABH and GBH do not see pupils permanently excluded.

Many will either stay within the same school, be given a managed move or pushed in to Alt provision.

But permanently excluding child has become much harder and is not easy to do.

towriteyoumustlive · 08/11/2023 19:05

@RainInNovember

Write down all your facts and evidence, then present it tomorrow.

The bit about the girl asking that your DD sits next to her in RE etc... is just further evidence of the bullying. The RE teacher will no doubt be able to back that up.

I work in a school and a girl in my Y7 tutor group was being picked on and physically bullied. Needless to say that the two main culprits had quite a hefty suspension and will be re-suspended should they so much as breathe near her when they get back.

Schools need to gather evidence, so your daughter's friends are doing a great job of helping gather more evidence.

WearyAuldWumman · 08/11/2023 18:58

I'll reiterate: when you go in @RainInNovember ask whether risk assessments have been put in place for the perpetrators. They won't be allowed to give you that info, but it'll worry them - it'll show them that you've done your homework.

Ask them what safety measures they've put in place to protect your daughter's physical and mental wellbeing.

They might well try to fob you off with an offer to change your daughter's classes and to let her leave classes and/or school early to avoid the bullies. That's not acceptable, in my view. It happens a lot - it's putting the onus on the victim to modify their behaviour/routine rather than the perpetrators.

Bluntly, if anyone should be inconvenienced or distressed by a change of timetable, it should be the thugs.

WearyAuldWumman · 08/11/2023 18:47

RainInNovember · 08/11/2023 16:42

Dd just had a message from a boy in her class saying RE teacher was doing a new seating plan and Girl 1 said can (dd) sit next to me, we're best mates!!

And Girl 1 & 2 bragging in two different lessons to people about the attack.

I'm going in tomorrow I've had enough

If at all possible take your husband or another adult with you? Again, with my former middle manager hat on, you need an adult witness with you.

Also, as I've said before, you may need to lawyer up. (A letter should be sufficient.)

ETA I am so bloody angry on your behalf. I've seen so much of this shit over the years.

There will be decent staff in the school, but their hands are tied. You need to become 'that' parent - push like mad.

Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 18:43

There is anarchy in some schools and these schools appear to without the means to ensure discipline is upheld. This is very frightening for the future of this country. The Kids concerned might come in next time and attack someone with a weapon who knows a 'Pepper Spray a Taser or a Knife'. This is not me scare mongering . The kids concerned are not at all bothered about their conduct. Putting a coat over someones head really concerns me. This is not spear of the moment falling out stuff but organised gang type stuff !

The school need to get a grip very quickly or this could get out of control very quickly. Putting anything over someones face is a serious act and has connotations of being 'kidnapped' robbed or being pulled out of a car.

slore · 08/11/2023 18:18

WhatWhereWho · 08/11/2023 17:46

Complain to the governors tell them you are involving the local authority and Ofsted about safeguarding. And then follow through. Sometimes schools only act when their reputation becomes a factor.

Absolutely this.

Keep going higher and higher. Make formal complaints to everyone you can think of.

bombastix · 08/11/2023 17:53

RainInNovember · 08/11/2023 16:42

Dd just had a message from a boy in her class saying RE teacher was doing a new seating plan and Girl 1 said can (dd) sit next to me, we're best mates!!

And Girl 1 & 2 bragging in two different lessons to people about the attack.

I'm going in tomorrow I've had enough

I can't empathise enough how difficult you should be.

I would make a guess that both of these girls have parents who are difficult too. You need to be demanding; institutions like schools often shaft reasonable people because they are scared of the other side who looks more difficult. In some ways it's like dealing with a bully yourself. You have to hit them far far harder than they did to make sure that they know to leave you alone for good.

WhatWhereWho · 08/11/2023 17:46

Complain to the governors tell them you are involving the local authority and Ofsted about safeguarding. And then follow through. Sometimes schools only act when their reputation becomes a factor.

GoldDuster · 08/11/2023 17:15

RainInNovember · 08/11/2023 16:42

Dd just had a message from a boy in her class saying RE teacher was doing a new seating plan and Girl 1 said can (dd) sit next to me, we're best mates!!

And Girl 1 & 2 bragging in two different lessons to people about the attack.

I'm going in tomorrow I've had enough

I'd keep her off until this is sorted out satisfactorily. Imagine if you had to go into work knowing that your colleagues had recently put a coat over your head and punched you repeatedly, and were barging you as you moved about the building, and engineering ways to get in physical proximity to you. There is absolutely no way we would expect adults to deal with this shit, it's ridiculous.

My friend recently pulled her teen DD out of school after a long and sustained string of incidents involving physical attacks and intimidation which the school were determined to play down. She wishes she had gone in harder from the start but she trusted the school to do the right thing, yet the only thing they were focussed on was covering their arse. You're only going to get one chance to sort this out, do what you need to do.

RainInNovember · 08/11/2023 16:42

Dd just had a message from a boy in her class saying RE teacher was doing a new seating plan and Girl 1 said can (dd) sit next to me, we're best mates!!

And Girl 1 & 2 bragging in two different lessons to people about the attack.

I'm going in tomorrow I've had enough

OP posts:
WearyAuldWumman · 08/11/2023 16:09

slore · 08/11/2023 15:16

That's infuriating. The head of year is victim blaming and insinuating trouble for your daughter for her reaction to repeatedly being assaulted and threatened.

Why shouldn't a 15 y/o victim seek advice and comfort from their mum when assaulted?

The truth is he doesn't want her to tell you anything, because he wants to keep the assaults under wraps.

It's like all these brutal school beating videos that end up on social media and in the press: the schools' reactions are usually self-righteous declarations that filming itself will be banned, and anyone caught filming or sharing such incidents will be punished severely.

This benefits absolutely NOBODY but the schools themselves and the perpetrators. It encourages a culture of silence and violence.

Agreed, @slore .

Recently a video showing an attack in a region where I used to work went viral in Scotland. The Director of Education made the usual statement about keeping young people safe and the challenges caused by Covid.

In actual fact, such assaults in the region have been going on for years - it's just that they weren't filmed.

One of the things that I don't miss since giving up my full-time job is stopping assaults. Mind you, even as a supply teacher I've had to do that once. Frankly, I'm now too old and unfit for it. (Arthritis slows me up these days.)

WearyAuldWumman · 08/11/2023 16:05

GoldDuster · 08/11/2023 14:20

The school have got to either disappoint you, or the parents of the other girls. They're currently probably trying to work out which route will be the easiest. Make sure it's not you.

This.

My experience as a middle manager in a school tells me that it's the so-called 'pushy parent' who is listened to.

I'm not suggesting that you go down this route straight away, OP, but if you have legal insurance you might consider a lawyer's letter?

Swipe left for the next trending thread