Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not help Scouts…

393 replies

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 10:54

Name changed as identifiable.

Ive caused a bit of fall out, and didn’t expect it. I’m a bit of an accidental scout leader, not the main Akela but there weekly. My children went through scouts, the youngest is aging out. I’ve always been happy enough to help, I like kids. It’s not however something I’m hugely attached to either. I stayed mainly as they were short of leaders, and I enjoy it enough when there.

A parent complained that at camp they are feeding and housing the adults, we don’t pay to attend camps and we do eat.

Group section leader agreed, apparently other local packs do charge leaders for food over the weekend.

I didn’t get funny or stroppy, but I did say I’m out for camps. I said I don’t mind giving up my time, but it was a line for me to give up my weekend and pay for the pleasure. If I ate at home (large family) my food costs no where near the cost as the difference between cooking 5/6 portions is absorbed in the weekly food bill the same. Plus the scouts tend to overbuy and spend a lot more than is really needed tbh.

Another leader has now contacted me to say how strongly they disagree with me, also that I’m jeopardising the camp as they are already short on leaders. GSL has implied if I’m not committed maybe I should leave. Parents are moaning apparently.

The more I think the more pissed off I am. Tbh I’m ready to leave anyone between the increase in behaviour issues and local politics in the district. Camps have a horrible side of severe sleep deprivation and I also sometimes lose work shifts going or family commitments.

Is it really normal to begrudge volunteers their food and board in exchange for a weekend away for £50 and amazing activities laid on? I know when I was a teacher we were also included in costs spread among the kids. With 30/40 kids it’s hardly the bulk of the bill either

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 06/11/2023 21:37

BitofaStramash · 06/11/2023 20:29

Your GSL is a total idiot for pandering to this.

Of course leaders should not be paying. You are giving your time.

Exactly.

Our group has been known to boot problematic parents who take the piss, don't help out when asked and are cheeky fuckers. Unfortunately that means their children are asked to leave as the result of their behaviour.

It makes for a much better experience for everyone.

Sadly it doesn't remotely surprise me that parents say this either. They come out with all sorts of eye rolling bullshit, but cos we have a policy that if the parents don't agree to help occasionally their kid doesn't get a space.

At this point, after having helped at a session, parents then appreciate the leaders a lot more... Cos they are glad they don't have to help for another 10 weeks!

It really filters out the difficult parents!

FSTraining · 06/11/2023 21:18

easylikeasundaymorn · 06/11/2023 21:13

while I don't disagree with your point that breaking things down by what we put in/get out in a society isn't the best way of looking at it, your second point doesn't really make sense -the current working generation only need the generation behind them to pay for their pension because they are themselves paying the pensions of the generation above them, because that's the way the system was set up
if we instead got back what we individually put in nobody would 'owe' anyone anything
(and that's assuming there's going to even be a state pension in 20/30 /40 years anyway!)
to be fair most childfree people are probably putting in more than they get out of 'the system'

(also also as a civil servant I do get free tea and coffee in work, sorry....!)

Actually, the point I was making was that everyone in my generation is going to need a pension, to have medical professionals on hand, maybe have someone else paying the bulk of taxes for roads etc when we get old, whether we have children or not. So begrudging funding the education of the people who will do all that on the grounds that you don't have children is short sighted (and given the amount of work it takes to raise a child, a bit freeloading).

It's perhaps not the best example compared to the scouts but it's a similar "me, me, me" mindset combined with a lack of awareness of how much they either do or will rely on others.

easylikeasundaymorn · 06/11/2023 21:13

FSTraining · 06/11/2023 14:42

Sign of the times. We live in a mean spirited country full of freeloaders who begrudge others the reasonable "perks" that come with volunteering.

It's part of the same mindset as people who would complain if civil servants were offered free tea and coffee at work or people without children complaining about taxes spent on education, when they full well intend to draw a state pension off the incomes of those children without doing any of the hard graft of raising a family.

while I don't disagree with your point that breaking things down by what we put in/get out in a society isn't the best way of looking at it, your second point doesn't really make sense -the current working generation only need the generation behind them to pay for their pension because they are themselves paying the pensions of the generation above them, because that's the way the system was set up
if we instead got back what we individually put in nobody would 'owe' anyone anything
(and that's assuming there's going to even be a state pension in 20/30 /40 years anyway!)
to be fair most childfree people are probably putting in more than they get out of 'the system'

(also also as a civil servant I do get free tea and coffee in work, sorry....!)

AuntyMabelandPippin · 06/11/2023 21:07

Another ex GSL here.

I would never, ever expect a leader to pay for themselves. Absolutely dreadful of your Group to ask for payment from volunteers. If you're not getting anywhere with your GSL, speak to your District Commissioner.

BitofaStramash · 06/11/2023 20:52

I don't fully agree with you about parents going away during camps though. If our DC are not home why should we not take advantage of that? We usually try to be relatively nearby the camp so would probably be quicker to get there than if coming from home. I appreciate not all parents would think like that

I had to close a camp early and send all the children home due to an outbreak of vomiting.

(Caused by parents sending a child they admitted later they thought was maybe coming down with something)

Myself and another leader had to wait several hours for the parents of one child to return from a mini break. The wait was extended further as they stopped for a pub lunch on the way home.

Even though we repeatedly phoned for updates and asked them to contact someone else to collect their sobbing child.

Eventually an angry (at us) grandma turned up.

By all means take advantage but don't take the piss and make sure there is an alternative emergency contact.

soupmaker · 06/11/2023 20:32

OMFG. I'm astounded at the attitude of parents towards scout leaders. My 2 DC have had brilliant experiences with beavers, cubs and scouts. The camps and weekends away have all been amazing and worth way more than we paid for them. Me and another mum always make a couple of full tins of brownies, tablet, and millionaire shortbread for the leaders to take with them. Least we can do.

BitofaStramash · 06/11/2023 20:29

Your GSL is a total idiot for pandering to this.

Of course leaders should not be paying. You are giving your time.

BettyBallerina · 06/11/2023 20:14

Leave and let another parent volunteer. It’s pathetic. I was a scout leader and left because I got fed up of giving up so much of my time , only for (some) parents to whinge.

Ihadenough22 · 06/11/2023 20:11

I can't believe how entitled some parents out their are when in reality your giving up your weekends to bring their kids away and do certain things with them. Then your in a position of responsibility to care and keep them safe. Now they expect you to pay your costs for this.
In your situation I would be thinking of leaving and letting those above you the reason why.
You also mentioned that your kids were getting to the age of finishing scouts so you could use this as an excuse to leave either.

I know someone in a similar position to you who has been a volunteer for a few years. Like you they have had to deal with certain situations and parents. I know at this stage they will be leaving their group in the next few months.

Do these people not release that with out volunteers there kids could not have scouts, sports events ect.

weirdoboelady · 06/11/2023 19:29

Datafan55 · 06/11/2023 18:02

I left Brownie leading as I was coming up against similar issues. Not from the parents (as far as I know), but from the leaders! Coming up against District Commissioners saying of course you can't get a petrol refund for that, and we charge our leaders for eg a panto ticket (when taking brownies to a panto or somewhere is like herding cats :-)). I was dirt poor and only putting petrol in my car to go to the meetings (in a nearby village that the DCs had sent me too). Had so much time and willingness, but sadly couldn't stay. This from an affluent district with wealthy packs that offered help to parents if they needed it ...

EXACTLY my point. Scouts and similar organisations have serious responsibilities to ensure equal access for all and to uphold their own values! Excluding those volunteers who can't afford to donate is completely outrageous. Everyone should be recompensed for their expenses, and those who CAN afford can always donate the money back.

WhatsCookingFlora · 06/11/2023 18:54

JESUS. If some kind people I trusted volunteered to take my two for an activity weekend, I'd happily pay for their meals AND bring them a thank you gift at the end of it (then I'd get in a hot bath and not get out of it again until Sunday pick-up 😂)

Honestly, OP, I think it's time to bow out of this group. CFs.

Shinyandnew1 · 06/11/2023 18:52

Well, maybe the complainers and group leaders will have to rethink their plan!

HeckyPeck · 06/11/2023 18:48

Dixiechickonhols · 06/11/2023 17:21

It does sound natural end point for you Op don’t feel bad at all think about all the hours you have contributed over the years and difference you have made.
Is it just one parent complaining re your free food and others now moaning as camp may be cancelled?
I wouldn’t be guilted into camp. Time for someone else (moaning parent) to volunteer.

I agree with this.

Think how much you'll enjoy your free time once you step down.

Hopefully the Moaning Myrtles will learn a valuable lesson too.

FlameGrilledSquirrel · 06/11/2023 18:46

I'm a trustee of a scout group and we don't expect leaders to pay.

Frankly, if parents want to start being that petty they can start to pay real costs for two full nights of accommodation, full board, full supervision and a wide range of activities.

It would cost a HELL of a lot more than the money that's charged now. Can't have it both ways.

MaryPoppinPills · 06/11/2023 18:36

ADC Scouts here

No you should not have to pay for camps or food.

Happy to speak over PM

Datafan55 · 06/11/2023 18:02

I left Brownie leading as I was coming up against similar issues. Not from the parents (as far as I know), but from the leaders! Coming up against District Commissioners saying of course you can't get a petrol refund for that, and we charge our leaders for eg a panto ticket (when taking brownies to a panto or somewhere is like herding cats :-)). I was dirt poor and only putting petrol in my car to go to the meetings (in a nearby village that the DCs had sent me too). Had so much time and willingness, but sadly couldn't stay. This from an affluent district with wealthy packs that offered help to parents if they needed it ...

strawberry2017 · 06/11/2023 17:54

Well all those parents who complained can take them to camp can't they! I'd leave. You did it for your kids, you have done your time leave them to it x

cakewench · 06/11/2023 17:45

YANBU. I do not volunteer with Scouts but my DS does (he didn't go through Scouts properly; he started this as a DofE exercise and has just carried on, which is lovely. I'm only adding this because the only reason I never got involved with scout volunteering is because he wasn't one!) however I've volunteered for several other activities/ PSAs/ NCT/ etc for many years.

These parents have the actual audacity to complain AND the leaders are actually agreeing with them? You really need to just step away at this point because if that's the culture there, you won't change it alone. You've done an amazing run for them and they should be thankful.

FWIW everything I know about residential trips involves the cost of leaders meals being covered by the children's fees. It's a matter of a few pounds per child, at most, and should be considered a cost of running it.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 06/11/2023 17:30

I'm with you.
I've been a Cub/Explorer leader for 7 years. I will give them time, but refuse to do anything that will cost me money - although I have never been asked to pay for my own food at camp, I have turned down various non-compulsory training courses that would have cost me £29-£250+. If the GSL wants me to do it that much, the group can fundraise and pay.

rookiemere · 06/11/2023 17:29

I can't believe people begrudge you food at scout camps when you are volunteering. Not the point but it's hardly Michelin starred meals is it ? More likely lowest common denominator crowd pleasers such as spag bol or the like.

I used to be secretary on our Group Exec committee and they should know about this - unless that's the forum where this has already been aired. To lose a weekend volunteer for the cost of what could be £5-10 per day's worth of food is beyond ridiculous.

I'd back out and be sure to let people know why. It's so disappointing when volunteers are not respected ( mind you DH has been known to moan about teachers free holidays until I put him right on the matter ).

Dixiechickonhols · 06/11/2023 17:21

It does sound natural end point for you Op don’t feel bad at all think about all the hours you have contributed over the years and difference you have made.
Is it just one parent complaining re your free food and others now moaning as camp may be cancelled?
I wouldn’t be guilted into camp. Time for someone else (moaning parent) to volunteer.

TimetoPour · 06/11/2023 17:16

I can’t believe I’ve actually read this.

As a parent of two scouters (beavers/cubs/scouts) , I will be eternally grateful to those of you that give up your time to enrich our children’s lives and knowledge. I would never begrudge paying for the leaders and when ours have been to camp, I generally bake cakes and biscuits to provide snacks for the entire group to help in a different way. I know the ideal “thanks” would be to volunteer- but I don’t really like kids 😂.

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 17:03

One thing I’ve reflected on a bit today also - I’m getting older. I am starting to struggle on camp, with lack of sleep or uncomfortable sleeping. I can’t manage it like I used to. I end up writing off days afterwards, not carrying on as usual. It’s maybe a natural stopping point even with all this aside

OP posts:
SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 17:01

RedToothBrush · 06/11/2023 13:27

DH is heavily involved in Scouts.

The ethos of our group is 'keep the leaders happy because without the leaders you can't run the group'.

The troop pay for and feed the leaders.

BUT my bug is that some of the leaders over buy food heavily for camp or buy expensive options. I do the shop for one camp and ALWAYS keep in mind I'm buying for the least well off - so buy the minimum possible for the least amount. We have a spreadsheet we use to buy exact amounts which works well.

I did it in June and kept food for the weekend for 40 to under £6.50 per head - that was Friday tea (hot dogs), Breakfast (sausages, eggs, beans, bread, cereal, milk, orange juice one day and then bacon instead of sausages the other), sandwiches for lunch for two days - (choice of cheese, ham or tuna mayo) with a biscuit, fruit (either apple or banana) and then spag bol for the other night (with veggie alternative) and a cheap cake (usually slice of swiss roll with custard). Then hot choc, squash and tea/coffee (usually have some in stores at least). I think £6.50 for five meals is decent really even though that is a fair amount of food so no one can argue that the kids aren't being well fed. I genuinely couldn't do it for less unless we cut the food amount. HOWEVER I know other leaders have spent far more on other camps.

I would put it straight that you won't be doing camps if you have to pay, you think that too much money is spent on food (perhaps offer to do a shop to demonstrate just how much they are over spending which would save the cost of at least one leader) but if they are insistent that you are 'not committed enough' then thats fine with you and they can stick it.

Its REALLY not the way to run a troop. You tell the parents to stick it (plenty more kids out there that want a place) and look after the leaders - mainly cos a lot of parents are quite frankly a bunch of wankers.

I think the real issue here is the cost of camps generally and the poor planning and budgeting going on.

You have my sympathy on this - this is a suicidal move for the troop.

I agree we spend too much on food, but I don’t have the energy to get involved- though I’ve voiced it.

For context though in 15 years we’ve only ever had one parent request financial support to attend. The free school meals are probably near zero in the pack, I can see it’s not a forefront issue

OP posts:
Un7breakable · 06/11/2023 17:00

Camp can't run without leaders so leaders costs are part of running the camp.

Same with school trips (although companies tend to provide free teacher places).

Very few people are going to pay to spend time with other people's children, dealing with all the associated issues and getting very little sleep. If the parents are complaining surely they are happy to pay and help out 😂