Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not help Scouts…

393 replies

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 10:54

Name changed as identifiable.

Ive caused a bit of fall out, and didn’t expect it. I’m a bit of an accidental scout leader, not the main Akela but there weekly. My children went through scouts, the youngest is aging out. I’ve always been happy enough to help, I like kids. It’s not however something I’m hugely attached to either. I stayed mainly as they were short of leaders, and I enjoy it enough when there.

A parent complained that at camp they are feeding and housing the adults, we don’t pay to attend camps and we do eat.

Group section leader agreed, apparently other local packs do charge leaders for food over the weekend.

I didn’t get funny or stroppy, but I did say I’m out for camps. I said I don’t mind giving up my time, but it was a line for me to give up my weekend and pay for the pleasure. If I ate at home (large family) my food costs no where near the cost as the difference between cooking 5/6 portions is absorbed in the weekly food bill the same. Plus the scouts tend to overbuy and spend a lot more than is really needed tbh.

Another leader has now contacted me to say how strongly they disagree with me, also that I’m jeopardising the camp as they are already short on leaders. GSL has implied if I’m not committed maybe I should leave. Parents are moaning apparently.

The more I think the more pissed off I am. Tbh I’m ready to leave anyone between the increase in behaviour issues and local politics in the district. Camps have a horrible side of severe sleep deprivation and I also sometimes lose work shifts going or family commitments.

Is it really normal to begrudge volunteers their food and board in exchange for a weekend away for £50 and amazing activities laid on? I know when I was a teacher we were also included in costs spread among the kids. With 30/40 kids it’s hardly the bulk of the bill either

OP posts:
celticprincess · 07/11/2023 19:42

Wow. I’m a teacher and a brownie leader. Never paid for myself on a residential or trip yet. With school we had to factor in the price of a supply teacher for the week when a new head made us change from giving up our half term holiday to go when only a few teachers would volunteer to going in term time when all the teachers suddenly wanted to go. We calculated the cost from the supplier - PGL - and then also added the cost of the supply teacher then the trip cost was split by the number of kids going. I’d given up several half term holidays sore that to travel by bus to France from the north west for a Monday to Friday visit. No overtime, no tie off in lieu. But not cost to me financially. Brownie trips have been the same and absorbed by the unit. I’ve paid for my own kids to attend but not myself.

MrsScarecrow · 07/11/2023 19:40

Maybe suggest the parent who complained take your place

Lindyloomillion1 · 07/11/2023 19:38

Thank you for all your time and help with the kids. My kids have all benefited from volunteers like yourself.
I'm absolutely shocked to hear that some people think you should pay for yourself whilst giving up your time, money and holidays for the kids. It's absolutely outrageous!
Say no and walk away. As someone else said, there are so many other groups who could use your time without being nasty about it x

Shutyourcakehole · 07/11/2023 19:33

NRTFT but just wanted to add my bit

My DC used to attend scouts. Every so often, they'd go on camps or day trips out. I absolutely expected that in the costs to parents it would include covering the VOLUNTEER leaders expenses too. They didn't get paid to provide this club during the rest of the weeks, just £10 a month to cover the hire of the hall where they met, so covering their other day trips/camps seemed nothing less than perfectly reasonable to me. They were providing my child with a wealth of experiences, knowledge and fun, while being a childminder. It gave me and DH the odd weekend day/night to ourselves. It was worth every penny.

Anyone who thinks a volunteer who enriches our children's lives doesn't deserve their expenses paid with a small collective contribution is an entitled tight-fisted c*nt!

Unfortunately, my DC left as his group also suffered with low numbers of volunteers, so these experiences became fewer and fewer. Meets started getting cancelled, trips and camps started becoming far less frequent and my DC became very bored. The life enriching experiences dwindled and the enthusiasm for Scouts went with it.

I'm now starting to wonder if the low volunteer numbers is a result of something similar.

OP, YANBU. The parents complaining are evidence of the epidemic of entitlement sweeping through society lately, and its bloody tragic.

I wouldnt blame you if you left.

Thisismynewname23 · 07/11/2023 19:29

You’ve been so good to give up your time, I wouldn’t pay for the privilege I would say I’ve enjoyed my time but I’m done, different if your children still attended I would be more inclined to stick it out but get your time back

user1471534433 · 07/11/2023 19:18

As a Scout leader myself, if I had to pay for the privilege of camping in wet November, like I did last weekend, I really would object. In terms of choldcare costs for a weekend, Scout camp is amazing value.

Midsizegal29 · 07/11/2023 19:09

We used to get this when taking kids in school trips. The staff places are generally free because they have to have x number of adults accompanying them. If the adults don’t go (usually giving up more than their usual working hours!) then the trips don’t run. It’s not exactly a day off for staff- you are working 😂 some people are just miserable!

pomers · 07/11/2023 19:08

I was a scout leader for a number of years (lost count of how many people just “didn’t have time”🙁). Leaders never paid for food.

Moonshild · 07/11/2023 19:07

Having been involved with cubs when my children were younger - I understand how you feel. Unfortunately there are never enough parents who are prepared to give up their time.
To complain that you are being fed at camp when you are looking after their children seems a bit petty - time to step away. Do not feel bad if the camp doesn't go ahead - it is time someone else took over.

I ran the school PTA for ages and stepped down when I realised it was taking over my life - everyone complained that they didn't want to do it and I was unreasonable to step down - someone stepped up when there was no choice.

Its hard to step aside when it is in your nature to help but sometime you just have to

fetchacloth · 07/11/2023 19:07

Fuck them if that's their attitude.
You are giving up your family time for free and this is how you're repaid? Sheesh 😡
No way would I do that again.

LalaPaloosa · 07/11/2023 19:04

Couldn’t agree more. You owe them nothing. You’ve contributed more than most already. Walk away.

ILoveEYFS · 07/11/2023 18:28

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 11:01

I did 😂

Now camp is at risk of not going ahead

I enjoy scouting and have for many, many years. All four of my boys joined as beavers and are now leaders, Explorers and a scout. I'll put my GSL hat on for the next bit.
As a leader/assistant/helper, you give up your time, energy and money (fuel, lost shifts etc) to give the kids a great time. I have never, nor would I ever, charge £50 for a weekend. I don't know of any group that charges £50, maybe £10-£20
The leaders with your group don't sound very scout-like IMO.

The day I stop enjoying it, is the day I give up.

Stay because you enjoy it. If you don't, leave. If the camp doesn't go ahead, it is the parents and leaders complaining that are letting the kids down, not you. Your GSL should be supportive not telling you to leave.

You have 4 options.

  1. Stay
  2. Leave
  3. Find another group that appreciates you.
  4. Move and come to my group 😁
NoDought · 07/11/2023 18:26

That’s ridiculous and so ungrateful. They really have bitten the hand that feeds them, I find that so spiteful that the parents have done that. Good riddance to them, you sound like you have done enough for them already.

Skyelils · 07/11/2023 18:20

tell em to get stuffed

budgiegirl · 07/11/2023 17:50

PuttingDownRoots · 07/11/2023 15:14

Just off the top of my head I can think of five of my Cubs whose parents would struggle to volunteer. Not due to fecklessness, just life, like disabled siblings.

Plus having a parent around ruins the dynamic. We actually discourage parents volunteering with their child's section if possible. I celebrated when my younger child graduated out of Cubs into Scouts so she wasn't my responsibility anymore.

Surely most groups would make exceptions for someone in difficult circumstances though?

We love a parent volunteer! It's our main leader recruiting tool. We have 6 leaders in our cub pack, two are parents of current cubs, four used to have cubs in the pack, came along to help on a regular basis and stayed on after their children moved on to scouts. We don't really find it a problem as far as the dynamics go. The parents who are only interested in helping their own child don't last long anyway, once we start asking them to help out in other areas.

@PuttingDownRoots out of interest, how do you go about recruiting leaders, if not though parent involvement?

Wellhellooooodear · 07/11/2023 17:21

Tell them to do one. Let the CFs complaining step up and get involved. This sort of thing is why people give up volunteering.

Dixiechickonhols · 07/11/2023 16:49

Most of us Leaders in our Rainbows/Brownies and Guides don’t have children in groups. That seems to befuddle some parents - which dd is yours… one leader is childfree by choice. Mine has aged out but I’m still here.
If we have parent help on a trip then we would usually put them with a different group not their own dc.

PuttingDownRoots · 07/11/2023 16:44

Until this term I was the only leader who was also a current parent.
Weve had three parents volunteer this term... all of whom have chosen the "not my child section" option as they agree with the idea

It works for us. Another local pack recently folded as they relied too heavily on current agents who then stopped as soon as their child aged out.

electriclight · 07/11/2023 16:44

I haven't rtft because I think the first reply summed it up - fuck them.

I'd resign and make it widely known that this was the 'last straw' - along with the behaviour issues you mentioned.

I'm shocked that parents have raised this, despite your huge time commitment and the cost of turning down paid working shifts to attend. What an appalling sense of entitlement and disrespect. Fuck 'em.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/11/2023 16:40

PuttingDownRoots · 07/11/2023 15:14

Just off the top of my head I can think of five of my Cubs whose parents would struggle to volunteer. Not due to fecklessness, just life, like disabled siblings.

Plus having a parent around ruins the dynamic. We actually discourage parents volunteering with their child's section if possible. I celebrated when my younger child graduated out of Cubs into Scouts so she wasn't my responsibility anymore.

We never discouraged parent helpers because without them we'd have folded.

However, we did allocate adults on trips to groups that didn't include their own child and regular helpers were encouraged to help at bits of the session that their child was least likely to want to do.

Sometimes it can't be helped though

It's amazing how many of the parents complained about the trip thing. Although they soon grumblingly accepted it when I explained that the three more serious problems we had on trips were caused by parents who had their own child in their group.

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2023 16:36

PuttingDownRoots · 07/11/2023 15:14

Just off the top of my head I can think of five of my Cubs whose parents would struggle to volunteer. Not due to fecklessness, just life, like disabled siblings.

Plus having a parent around ruins the dynamic. We actually discourage parents volunteering with their child's section if possible. I celebrated when my younger child graduated out of Cubs into Scouts so she wasn't my responsibility anymore.

Where are you going to get mysterious volunteers from if it's not parents?!!! There are some very elderly leaders across district who quite frankly can't do a lot of the more physical stuff anymore but they control their groups and there's no progression plan for leaders. These groups are at risk of folding in the future.

Seriously! Our group prefers leaders children to have at least some activity/opportunity away from their parent but it cant be avoided at times.

In an ideal world... Except it's not ideal.

DontGoJasonWaterfalls · 07/11/2023 16:36

YANBU at all. I'm an accidental leader in girlguiding and I can just about afford to pay for my daughter's subs and to go on the trips etc. There's absolutely no way I could afford to pay for myself as well, never mind the fact I'd be paying for the "pleasure" of working bloody hard the entire time 😬

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2023 16:31

PuttingDownRoots · 07/11/2023 15:14

Just off the top of my head I can think of five of my Cubs whose parents would struggle to volunteer. Not due to fecklessness, just life, like disabled siblings.

Plus having a parent around ruins the dynamic. We actually discourage parents volunteering with their child's section if possible. I celebrated when my younger child graduated out of Cubs into Scouts so she wasn't my responsibility anymore.

Our group would definitely make some exceptions for mitigating circumstances. But we'd probably expect some assistance. Even if it was to make a cake for a fundraiser. We have a couple of people who do admin and don't have contact with the kids at all.

There's always ways that you can help.

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2023 16:28

MrsAvocet · 07/11/2023 14:52

Forced "volunteering" doesn't work for lots of reasons. It's also hard to enforce.
We did try it at the club I help run at one point as we were often low on marshals for competitions. We said that every competitor in the series had to provide someone to marshal at one event. Not a big ask, but people just didn't comply. And whilst we would have been within our rights to refuse entries on that basis, some of the kids are as young as six. Who is going to refuse to let an excited young child compete in something they love because their parents are feckless? I could never bring myself to turn a child away for something they have absolutely no control over. Perhaps I'm just too soft and if I'd stood my ground it would have worked. But for me, the whole point in volunteering is to benefit the kids and whilst I have no problem at all disciplining them if they misbehave themselves, it just doesn't sit right with me to punish them for their parents' failings.

You are too soft 😉

Seriously groups need to set out expectations for parents from the start and understand that participation isn't optional. No volunteering no place for your kid. Otherwise EVERYONE ends up losing out as parents get fed up by the shirkers and drop out of volunteering too and the group goes bump.

Our experience is the richer the parents the more they just want to buy their place (not at going rates of course!). They don't want to volunteer because their time is too precious to waste on their own kids. The more deprived areas of district have less issues with leaders because they know alternatives aren't available to them putting in the effort. Those troops struggle more with finances.

PuttingDownRoots · 07/11/2023 15:14

Just off the top of my head I can think of five of my Cubs whose parents would struggle to volunteer. Not due to fecklessness, just life, like disabled siblings.

Plus having a parent around ruins the dynamic. We actually discourage parents volunteering with their child's section if possible. I celebrated when my younger child graduated out of Cubs into Scouts so she wasn't my responsibility anymore.

Swipe left for the next trending thread