Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not help Scouts…

393 replies

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 10:54

Name changed as identifiable.

Ive caused a bit of fall out, and didn’t expect it. I’m a bit of an accidental scout leader, not the main Akela but there weekly. My children went through scouts, the youngest is aging out. I’ve always been happy enough to help, I like kids. It’s not however something I’m hugely attached to either. I stayed mainly as they were short of leaders, and I enjoy it enough when there.

A parent complained that at camp they are feeding and housing the adults, we don’t pay to attend camps and we do eat.

Group section leader agreed, apparently other local packs do charge leaders for food over the weekend.

I didn’t get funny or stroppy, but I did say I’m out for camps. I said I don’t mind giving up my time, but it was a line for me to give up my weekend and pay for the pleasure. If I ate at home (large family) my food costs no where near the cost as the difference between cooking 5/6 portions is absorbed in the weekly food bill the same. Plus the scouts tend to overbuy and spend a lot more than is really needed tbh.

Another leader has now contacted me to say how strongly they disagree with me, also that I’m jeopardising the camp as they are already short on leaders. GSL has implied if I’m not committed maybe I should leave. Parents are moaning apparently.

The more I think the more pissed off I am. Tbh I’m ready to leave anyone between the increase in behaviour issues and local politics in the district. Camps have a horrible side of severe sleep deprivation and I also sometimes lose work shifts going or family commitments.

Is it really normal to begrudge volunteers their food and board in exchange for a weekend away for £50 and amazing activities laid on? I know when I was a teacher we were also included in costs spread among the kids. With 30/40 kids it’s hardly the bulk of the bill either

OP posts:
budgiegirl · 08/11/2023 13:35

Phineyj · 08/11/2023 11:17

The waters are significantly muddied though aren't they?

There are extra curricular activities that charge a realistic fee, may make a profit for someone, and those leading are paid.

There are extra curricular activities that charge a somewhat subsidised fee, run at breakeven or a loss, and may have free places, bursaries and scholarships for those who meet the criteria. Usually leaders for these are paid but there are unpaid volunteers too and sometimes legal requirements (e.g. for a certain number of trained chaperones for a theatre production).

Then there are extra curricular activities like Scouts etc that are run on a shoestring, charge a small amount and the leaders aren't paid.

There absolutely are entitled parents but it's often not made clear what basis a particular group runs on or what fees actually cover.

It's a recipe for misunderstandings all round.

Especially with so many more women in the paid workforce now. Sadly the value of volunteering time is higher when it's a trade off with paid work. For both the leaders and parents being asked to volunteer.

Why are the water muddied? Does it really matter if the person taking your child away for the weekend is a volunteer, or gets paid? Either way, surely it's fine that food and accommodation are covered? Either as part of your salary, or as out-of-pocket expenses as a volunteer.

As a cub leader, we always cover leaders expenses (even petrol if requested, although no-one ever claims for this). If parents come to help on camp then we cover their food and accommodation expenses.

I've found this thread really interesting. I must admit when my daughter was briefly a Rainbow I didn't understand there was an expectation that parents volunteer nor was this explained when I signed her up. I definitely don't remember either of my parents ever volunteering during my entire time in Brownies and Guides (70s and 80s)

Not every group will need to ask for parental help - it will generally come down to the number of leaders and the size of the group. In the 70s and 80s, there were often enough leaders, and there wasn't the same rations of leaders/children that are required nowadays.

inloveandmarried · 08/11/2023 13:11

T1Dmama · 08/11/2023 11:45

This is dreadful!
it’s a given that teachers, scout/guide leaders etc get into events and eat using the fees paid by the attendees,
I would send an email saying
”I am very sorry but after years of volunteering for the Scouts, I am disappointed that some of you feel I am not committed!, I have given up a lot of time to enable children to attend Scouts, and have given up weekends for camps, often turning down paid work to do so!… I find the suggestion that scout leaders should not only give up 48 hours to attend camp, but should also have to pay for the privilege a step too far. I am sorry that I’ve had to drop out of camp, but I simply can’t afford to loose pay and then have to pay to attend the event I’m giving up time and money for.
many thanks!

This is a good response. Send them this!

inloveandmarried · 08/11/2023 13:05

Not read the whole thread and I apologise.

Usually with all school trips (I know this isn't one) there is a little extra added to the costs to cover the teachers that have to give up their time to do these life building trips.

You are doing them a huge service. It's voluntary work! So not only are you not getting paid but parents are expecting you to cover your costs whilst freely supervising their children!

Basic rules of volunteering for large organisations surely, that you should not be out of pocket when offering your time for free.

I cannot get over how unreasonable this request is. I think firm words are needed to convey how unreasonable this request is and what you already give freely.

WotNoUserName · 08/11/2023 12:59

TheaBrandt · 08/11/2023 11:07

Who are these people that bitch about volunteer led activities for your offspring?! Reveal yourselves and explain the other side.

My lovely friend ran guides for years (her children were not involved at all). Her last straw was when at the guides request they had an end of term chill out session and one set of parents sent an email criticising that there weren’t enough wholesome activities that week. They sent the email smugly signed from both of them. Was the last straw. Friend binned guiding and unit folded. Hope they were pleased with themselves.

That reminds of the time two women removed their sons from Beavers because we did some health and fitness sessions (using an outdoor gym at the park) and then gave the kids a snack - not healthy enough, we should ban biscuits! And we hadn't invested them after 2 weeks, and called one the wrong name (out of a colony of 26, when I call my own kids the wrong name most times I open my mouth!)

They had a right moan and quite frankly I was glad to see the back of them, because who needs that sort of hassle as a volunteer looking after their kids for nothing!

Moonshild · 08/11/2023 12:48

That’s a really great response

LifeExperience · 08/11/2023 12:19

I was a Girl Scout co-leader and we always used troop money to buy food for everyone going to camp--girls, leaders, etc. It never would have occurred to us to do otherwise nor is it a misuse of funds. My husband was a Boy Scout leader and it was the same.

Bow out. These self-centered parents don't appreciate you.

jlpth · 08/11/2023 12:05

I'd definitely quit, right away and suggest that perhaps the complaining parent would like to go in your place.

DyslexicPoster · 08/11/2023 11:55

If you want to leave and this is the final straw then leave, and say why.

I am school governor and have heard teachers moaning about us, a lot, saying we are never present. We do monthly, multiple learning walks, we are doing meetings almost two monthly, I was sitting next to them at a school fair! They was being paid to show up, I wasn't. Pissed me right off. Just because I haven't been on a learning walk in that teachers class doesn't mean we are never there.

Same at NCT. Being made to feel like a leach as you got a small % off your NCT sales if you volunteered.

You need to get something out volunteering, be it giving back, experience, warn and fuzzy feelings, you belive strongly in the cause etc. You don't need it to feel like it's causing you harm. No wonder no one wants to volunteer

T1Dmama · 08/11/2023 11:45

This is dreadful!
it’s a given that teachers, scout/guide leaders etc get into events and eat using the fees paid by the attendees,
I would send an email saying
”I am very sorry but after years of volunteering for the Scouts, I am disappointed that some of you feel I am not committed!, I have given up a lot of time to enable children to attend Scouts, and have given up weekends for camps, often turning down paid work to do so!… I find the suggestion that scout leaders should not only give up 48 hours to attend camp, but should also have to pay for the privilege a step too far. I am sorry that I’ve had to drop out of camp, but I simply can’t afford to loose pay and then have to pay to attend the event I’m giving up time and money for.
many thanks!

Phineyj · 08/11/2023 11:17

The waters are significantly muddied though aren't they?

There are extra curricular activities that charge a realistic fee, may make a profit for someone, and those leading are paid.

There are extra curricular activities that charge a somewhat subsidised fee, run at breakeven or a loss, and may have free places, bursaries and scholarships for those who meet the criteria. Usually leaders for these are paid but there are unpaid volunteers too and sometimes legal requirements (e.g. for a certain number of trained chaperones for a theatre production).

Then there are extra curricular activities like Scouts etc that are run on a shoestring, charge a small amount and the leaders aren't paid.

There absolutely are entitled parents but it's often not made clear what basis a particular group runs on or what fees actually cover.

It's a recipe for misunderstandings all round.

Especially with so many more women in the paid workforce now. Sadly the value of volunteering time is higher when it's a trade off with paid work. For both the leaders and parents being asked to volunteer.

TheaBrandt · 08/11/2023 11:07

Who are these people that bitch about volunteer led activities for your offspring?! Reveal yourselves and explain the other side.

My lovely friend ran guides for years (her children were not involved at all). Her last straw was when at the guides request they had an end of term chill out session and one set of parents sent an email criticising that there weren’t enough wholesome activities that week. They sent the email smugly signed from both of them. Was the last straw. Friend binned guiding and unit folded. Hope they were pleased with themselves.

CLCB07 · 08/11/2023 10:03

Both my kids go to cubs. I would not begrudge the leaders a meal and refreshments for all the work they do.

blondiepigtails · 08/11/2023 10:01

Shit like this from lazy entitled and rude parents is one of the reasons that our rural community no longer has a Scout group. The leaders packed it in and I don't blame them.

Needathickskin · 08/11/2023 10:00

Time to walk away and draw your boundaries.

I understand your frustration- I run a constituted Community group and have spent so many thankless hours putting things together and applying for funding. However; I’ve been amazed at the total ingratitude and unpleasantness from some. Dreadful.

Phineyj · 08/11/2023 09:43

I've found this thread really interesting. I must admit when my daughter was briefly a Rainbow I didn't understand there was an expectation that parents volunteer nor was this explained when I signed her up. I definitely don't remember either of my parents ever volunteering during my entire time in Brownies and Guides (70s and 80s).

I volunteer with my child's music theatre troupe and we are rarely offered so much as a cup of tea and quite often berated for not knowing things no-one has told us. The chaperoning training is also at the volunteer's expense! They try to sell it to volunteers as a fun activity. They are constantly trying to guilt us into doing more.

It is not fun; it is tiring and also quite boring and sometimes a little worrying - I am actually trained in safeguarding and first aid but they have never actually asked if I am...

Volunteers definitely shouldn't be out of pocket and if you want them to commit and stay you have to actually manage them and be nice to them. And respect their time and effort!

Hankunamatata · 08/11/2023 08:04

Waves. Hello. I'm scout leader, same sort of role. No way would I pay myself to take the scouts away. I'm giving up my time, my petrol to drive there. I usually buy kids treats
I would say exactly the same as you. Luckily my parents arnt cf they really appreciate it and a little amazed we take kids off their hands lol

HJ40 · 08/11/2023 07:50

I'd just stop.

Money is precious but time is also precious. If people can't see the value in it, there's no point in you giving it.

I do an entirely different type of volunteering, and I am shameless about selecting events based on how well they look after the volunteers. I'm normally there from 7am - 6pm. Some events think one sandwich and one drink is sufficient. I don't go back to ones like that. I'm giving up my time and paying for fuel, plus some equipment which I need. The least they can do is stretch to some ruddy food.

Conversely, many events are well briefed and the people in charge are absolutely charming. It's a pleasure to help at those and I happily do so.

Tamuchly · 08/11/2023 06:37

Another very grateful Cub/Scout parent here. I would happily pay MORE to include covering Leaders food if it needed because the level of commitment you show being there every week, planning and organising is worth that even before you factor in the camps!
I have volunteered for Girlguiding for over 3 years previously but left after some entitled parents started taking liberties that ultimately impacted on my family life. Arriving late by up to 30 minutes to collect their daughters meaning that my own dd was late to her club which started 45 minutes after we were meant to finish!

Volunteering is a wonderful thing to do, I highly recommend it but, no, it’s not something you should have to pay for.

TheaBrandt · 08/11/2023 05:49

Agree - note none of the complainant type parents emerge on threads like these to explain themselves. Usually on longer threads you get at least a few trying to justify the opposing view but not here. Who on earth are they?

UsingChangeofName · 07/11/2023 23:19

It really is heart warming to see all the wonderful support on this thread.

I wish the balance were more like this in my real life experience.

Thanks everyone, I might save this thread and read it again when I am fed up.

TriciaA1991 · 07/11/2023 23:14

Beamur · 06/11/2023 11:07

Guide Leader here - adult volunteers and Leaders costs are absorbed by the unit. Gratefully as without their time none of this would happen.
I'd step away from this unit - these are shoddy attitudes. If you still want to volunteer there will be other Scout or Guide units very happy to have you.

Another one here. Any Leaders/GSL expecting you to pay are not reading the guidelines, plus all the rules of volunteering - it shouldn't cost you to volunteer..... Camp is VERY hard work.

Patchworksack · 07/11/2023 23:07

YANBU and thank you for the hours and hours of your time that you have contributed!

Soapyspuds · 07/11/2023 22:49

I would be done with it all after that.

Yourcatisnotsorry · 07/11/2023 22:40

As a scout parent no way would I expect leaders to pay for their own food or accommodation at camp! Assuming you are eating the same as the kids not ordering Michelin starred deliveries for the leaders 😂

Toomuchtrouble4me · 07/11/2023 22:39

They are nuts. You are volunteering and looking after their kids all weekend, including nights! Work out the fees for that per hour and they begrudge you a bit of sausage n beans. Stuff that. Leave.