Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not help Scouts…

393 replies

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 10:54

Name changed as identifiable.

Ive caused a bit of fall out, and didn’t expect it. I’m a bit of an accidental scout leader, not the main Akela but there weekly. My children went through scouts, the youngest is aging out. I’ve always been happy enough to help, I like kids. It’s not however something I’m hugely attached to either. I stayed mainly as they were short of leaders, and I enjoy it enough when there.

A parent complained that at camp they are feeding and housing the adults, we don’t pay to attend camps and we do eat.

Group section leader agreed, apparently other local packs do charge leaders for food over the weekend.

I didn’t get funny or stroppy, but I did say I’m out for camps. I said I don’t mind giving up my time, but it was a line for me to give up my weekend and pay for the pleasure. If I ate at home (large family) my food costs no where near the cost as the difference between cooking 5/6 portions is absorbed in the weekly food bill the same. Plus the scouts tend to overbuy and spend a lot more than is really needed tbh.

Another leader has now contacted me to say how strongly they disagree with me, also that I’m jeopardising the camp as they are already short on leaders. GSL has implied if I’m not committed maybe I should leave. Parents are moaning apparently.

The more I think the more pissed off I am. Tbh I’m ready to leave anyone between the increase in behaviour issues and local politics in the district. Camps have a horrible side of severe sleep deprivation and I also sometimes lose work shifts going or family commitments.

Is it really normal to begrudge volunteers their food and board in exchange for a weekend away for £50 and amazing activities laid on? I know when I was a teacher we were also included in costs spread among the kids. With 30/40 kids it’s hardly the bulk of the bill either

OP posts:
Picklechamp · 06/11/2023 11:41

I actually made a stand on this for a youth organisation I spent many years volunteering for. I was asked to take a group of young people on an International tour. I explained I was happy to do this, but would expect to be heavily subsidised. I needed to take annual leave, and would be working hard on the trip. It was as though the other members of the committee, mostly older, wealthier, and retired hadn’t considered this. Once pointed out they agreed to cover the costs of volunteers, and this has now become the norm. As a result it has become easier to recruit new volunteers, who now feel their hours of graft are valued.

FrustratedRose · 06/11/2023 11:38

I don’t do Scouts or Guides, but I do volunteer to help out with several local youth groups. We’ve recently lost the paid member of staff from the organisation we’re affiliated with and they haven’t managed to replace the position yet.

This has meant that a couple of us have had to step up in to organising events etc. While we’ve yet to encounter ‘why aren’t the leaders paying for themselves?’ situation, the entitlement of some parents has flabbergasted me! We have a relatively small team, all of whom otherwise work full-time. The whinging that we haven’t put on as many events as last year or that certain things aren’t on at times they want is getting incredibly frustrating. I genuinely enjoy what we do and offering opportunities to the children, but fgs we’re all volunteers, not skivvies for certain parents!

YADNBU to just up and walk away. If one of our parents suggested the leaders should be paying for all the activities we organise for the children, I’d up and leave them in the lurch without a second thought.

WaltzingWaters · 06/11/2023 11:38

They’re being ridiculous! I’ve not done it myself but friends have been guide leaders and I know how much effort they have to put in. No way should you also have to pay to take other people’s kids away! I bet the complaining parents would never volunteer to go and look after loads of kids for a weekend and pay for the privilege!

Chrysanthemum5 · 06/11/2023 11:38

I used to be on the scout committee and this was constant. Parents complaining at paying for camp; not wanting to help to keep costs down; complaining our fund raising wasn't innovative enough; moaning if leaders were unavailable etc. some of the parents had 4 children in the troop but never volunteered to help at anything. In the end I gave up - my son had left scouts years before so I was donating time to make a great experience for others. Which was fine until I realised how little the other parents cared

Falifornia · 06/11/2023 11:38

Guide Leader here - I'd be out the door at speed, possibly more pissed off at the GSL than the whinging parents TBH!

Dragonsandcats · 06/11/2023 11:37

I would walk away. of course your food and drink should be covered, you’re giving up your weekend for the benefit of the scouts, not for you!!

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 11:36

I’ nearly replied to point out if I said ‘I’ll bring my own food’, packed lunches and I pop out for chips or something, they will not make a noticeable saving off the food bill anyway. Everything is in bulk 🤷‍♀️

But, I think I’d rather just bow out

OP posts:
NutellaNut · 06/11/2023 11:35

Do they think you’re getting a lovely free holiday out of it?! How pathetic. Tell them to fuck off. If the camp can’t go ahead because of it, tough shit. Let the cheeky fucker parents who begrudge paying a couple of quid each when split between the group step in and save the day.

CurlewKate · 06/11/2023 11:34

There are always school parents who think teachers should pay for the "holidays" they get on school trips too....

Sarri · 06/11/2023 11:33

Wow, I really hope our group's Brownie leaders dont have to pay when they all go to camp, they are awesome and give up their free time, the parents are well aware and very appreciative of that, we all chip in for thank you gifts. I will check, and we'll also start chipping in towards camp costs if that is the case.

I'm so sorry your volunteering hasn't been appreciated OP, but glad to have learnt a bit more about the ask on leaders.

MrsAvocet · 06/11/2023 11:33

I'd walk away too.
They can ask the parent who complained to take your place.

Fredella · 06/11/2023 11:32

Former beaver leader here. Leaders in our group do not pay anything to attend camps, and I believe this is the case across the District. The commitment of time and effort is quite enough on its own.

BadSkiingMum · 06/11/2023 11:31

Oh dear lord! How penny-pinching, awkward and mean spirited.

The Charity Commission is very clear that volunteers should have out-of-pocket expenses met by charities and other voluntary organisations. So even if you paid for food then it would be reasonable for you to claim it back!

I would be tempted to write an open letter, giving an account of what has happened and saying that you are happy to support this final camp so that it can go ahead (obviously completely up to you if you want to or not) but that you will be doing it on the same basis as before and stepping down from the troop immediately afterwards.

LostMySocks · 06/11/2023 11:29

I'm a Guide leader. We always absorb leader site fees and food on unit camps. As others have said the exception is large scale camps like Wellies where we have to pay a leader charge but then there are activities for us and we don't have to organise all the food and activities so it is (a bit) more relaxing and less work for us.

We also offer mileage to leaders who might otherwise struggle. We also have access to grants to support leaders and girls otherwise we risk excluding members and helpers.

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 11:28

drspouse · 06/11/2023 11:11

I used to do Brownies and unfortunately there are a lot of leaders who say "it's my hobby, I should pay to do my hobby" which leaves the rest of us for whom it's volunteering and/or a way to help out with their own DCs' activities going "well I'm not going to" and looking unhelpful.

I'm with the OP, no way would I pay and no way would my DD's group expect me to.

Yes , I had a ‘hobby’ comment. Also ours is a generally affluent pack, lots of money. I have a larger family, earn less. I’m not poor but it’s a squeeze. I’m not prepared to use a limited budget for scouts and cut back on treats for my children.

OP posts:
BrontëParsonage · 06/11/2023 11:28

@SecretsOfSunshine what is up with those parents?! You couldn’t pay me enough danger money to help out at a Scout camp! My DD1’s Rangers leaders gave up a week of their summer holiday each to take 50 girls wild camping in Sweden. I’m assuming that we all contributed to the leaders’s costs - and I know that they also fundraised via the local Rotary Club etc - but I do not begrudge a penny. If I were wealthy (which I most definitely not), I would have offered to pay for a leader flight ticket. Thank you for everything you have done for the Scouting movement.

FictionalCharacter · 06/11/2023 11:27

Cryingbutstilltrying · 06/11/2023 11:18

Walk away op, no good deed goes unpunished as they say.
I am a Brownie leader and I don’t do weekend things or camps for exactly this reason. I work weekends and it would require me to use annual leave, which is not how I want to use it! Paying for the privilege of having no sleep getting other people’s kids to behave? I don’t think so.
I lay it on very thick that my leaders and I are volunteers, it completely baffles the parents but I do get a few thank yous each term.
Once my DD is finished with Guiding I will be off too. The levels of entitlement have gone through the roof in recent years.
Thank you for all you have done for the kids in your troop x

That’s exactly it, entitlement, and these parents are causing Scouting and Girlguiding to die off. It’s incredibly sad.

EarthlyNightshade · 06/11/2023 11:26

Oh, I'd be so annoyed!
My DH volunteers and while parents are annoying (most never ever help out even though they are meant to do so once a term) I don't think they have stooped this low.
I think you need to walk away completely and not just from camps. If you know the particular parents who complained, you could suggest their names as a replacement for you as their "ethos" matches the troop's very nicely.

towriteyoumustlive · 06/11/2023 11:26

YANBU!

You're already giving up your free time and in a position of responsibility (and would have to take a child to hospital if required) so a free meal is the least they can offer you.

On school trips, teachers do not pay. Most companies that organise school trips offer a free teacher place per 10 kids. But again, it's a huge amount of planning and stress and giving up free time (and additional childcare costs sometimes!), so if you had to pay, you just wouldn't do it!

I am a scout secretary so just an admin role (no kids in cubs/scouts any more), and although I have no contact with the kids, I'm still expected to do all their online training which takes ages!

If they're going to not appreciate the time and effort you put in, then personally I'd just leave. There are SO many young people organisations that would LOVE to have someone like yourself to give up time and effort, so I'd suggest finding another organisation that would appreciate you.

SecretsOfSunshine · 06/11/2023 11:22

Dixiechickonhols · 06/11/2023 11:19

I wouldn’t be guilt tripped. What about leaders who can’t afford to pay especially younger ones. Awful precedent to set and not inclusive.
What happens if you say I’d have loved to have volunteered but I can’t afford the £30, my contribution was 48 hours free labour but if that’s not enough I’ll have to pass.

My food at home though has very little cost. I budget well and also have a large family who are still eating in my absence. Between them tbh they’ll just eat my portion. I don’t save anything at all eating at camp.
I work shifts, a shift I can’t do at camp is also £180 lost to me. I really don’t save

OP posts:
BaconMassive · 06/11/2023 11:22

I never once thought that the volunteers for this sort of thing would have to pay their own way in terms of food etc. It's not like they are quaffing champagne and oysters.

CornedBeef451 · 06/11/2023 11:21

I really hope we covered the cost of the leaders who took DD to the Rangers camp!

I'm so sorry this has happened, how rubbish when you give up your time, petrol and most importantly your sleep!

SussexSeaGal · 06/11/2023 11:21

I'm a Group Scout Leader and have organised numerous camps. We would never charge leaders for attending a camp, it's a ridiculous idea.

OwlOfBrown · 06/11/2023 11:20

This is a slightly tricky one and is something we discuss when I take my Brownies on residentials. You would have to pay for food at home so why should you get it free on camp when the children aren't.

However, I tend to be of the same opinion as you, and think that all leader costs should be absorbed in the cost to the young people. If I don't go, then the residential doesn't happen. There are a lot of costs to me, not all of them monetary, involved in taking young people on residentials (the time spent planning, the lack of sleep, the annual leave I have to take from work, the fact that the last residential I ran in the summer ended with me taking 3 days sick leave because I came back with such a horrendous cold). I think children paying leaders' costs is the least they can do.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/11/2023 11:19

I wouldn’t be guilt tripped. What about leaders who can’t afford to pay especially younger ones. Awful precedent to set and not inclusive.
What happens if you say I’d have loved to have volunteered but I can’t afford the £30, my contribution was 48 hours free labour but if that’s not enough I’ll have to pass.