Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teaching your child to say Thank you

85 replies

Bbq1 · 06/11/2023 08:55

A 'Parenting Expert' has apparently come up with a 'new hack' to teach your child to say Thank you. It involves handing something over to your child and lightly holding onto the item until the child says Thank you. You then release. The article says this is a new technique that nobody knows about... My son is 18 and this was something I would do automatically when he was young to remind him to say Thank you. Only having to hold the item for a couple of seconds. Am i wrong in thinking that most parents do this automatically and it's not a new idea?

OP posts:
wherethewildtbingsgo · 06/11/2023 11:23

@TheJubileePortrait you are being much less kind to her than you think you are. She exists in the world not just in your family and you're doing her a disservice by not teaching her social skills. As someone else very eloquently put it- you say please and thank you not because of how it makes you feel but because of how it makes the other person feel. It's not really relevant if she actually feels thankful.

wherethewildtbingsgo · 06/11/2023 11:21

@NotLactoseFree this would drive me bananas. You sound much more patient than me though- I would certainly have reminded him by now!

NotLactoseFree · 06/11/2023 11:13

TheCompactPussycat · 06/11/2023 11:09

Exactly this.

You teach your children from an early age to say thank you or please at the appropriate time.

And it isn't about whether they (your kids) "mean" it or not. Nobody cares whether your child is really thankful for the biscuit they've just been given. Because it isn't about them and their feelings. It's all about the other person's feelings.

This. DS has a good friend. He's a nice enough kid. But he has never once said please or thank you to me and now he's a teenager, I'm really starting to get annoyed and it makes me dislike him. It's not fair, but there you go, my opinion of him is lower because he can't be assed to say "please" when he asks me for a glass to get some water.

NotLactoseFree · 06/11/2023 11:11

It's not a new technique, but frankly, in light of how few children seem to have even basic manners, perhaps it's not a bad idea that someone is out there suggesting it!

My children are broadly well behaved and polite, but I still have to remind them to say please, and thank you etc. And I'll keep reminding them until it happens without them having to think about it because as someone upthread said, it's about being polite functional adults and if you don't get it right, you're disadvantaging your children. I don't think that means you have to be obsessively insisting that they can only hold a fork one way or that they should be completely familiar with different wine and water glasses by age 13 (unless they're royals!), but basic politeness and consideration are important.

when my children complain because I ask them to be polite, I remind them that my entire career (a good one, if I do say myself) started with a second interview over lunch. There is no doubt that as part of the role involved being out and about meeting people, the lunch was at least partly about ensuring I could behave appropriately, eat politely etc, while in public. I got the job.

TheCompactPussycat · 06/11/2023 11:09

Bulletin · 06/11/2023 11:02

Exactly. I cringe at the modern parenting idea that you should never tell your child to say please, thank you or sorry. You should just role model it until they understand the context.

I taught my kids to say what they needed to say at appropriate times, whether they fully understood or even meant it when they were very little. They’ve grown up into extremely polite and kind adults who have always been well liked by others.

It is a disservice to your kids and overthinking of basic parenting to say that you should not teach your children the social norms of the country they are in.

I never had to ‘hold on’ to things though to teach them…

Exactly this.

You teach your children from an early age to say thank you or please at the appropriate time.

And it isn't about whether they (your kids) "mean" it or not. Nobody cares whether your child is really thankful for the biscuit they've just been given. Because it isn't about them and their feelings. It's all about the other person's feelings.

Bulletin · 06/11/2023 11:02

wherethewildtbingsgo · 06/11/2023 09:56

I couldn't agree with this less. Please and thank you aren't about whether you mean it or not. They are social constructs and only learnt by teaching. It's not polite to take something from someone and not say thank you.

I also do lots of gentle parenting but this sort of gentle parenting is genuine madness. There are some things that are required in the world and need to be taught by parents. Simply waiting for your child to learn it from watching is not enough. And it also doesn't necessarily mean they "mean it" if they are simply copying.

Having said all that I wouldn't hold onto
Something until they have said thank you. Seems unnecessarily confrontational. I just remind them to say thank you if they haven't already. It's not really about whether they mean it or not. And tbh I'm not sure I even "mean it" when I say please and thank you and how are you and how was your day and can I get you a drink and would you like some food etc etc when I say it to people. It's just required to be a decent functioning human.

Exactly. I cringe at the modern parenting idea that you should never tell your child to say please, thank you or sorry. You should just role model it until they understand the context.

I taught my kids to say what they needed to say at appropriate times, whether they fully understood or even meant it when they were very little. They’ve grown up into extremely polite and kind adults who have always been well liked by others.

It is a disservice to your kids and overthinking of basic parenting to say that you should not teach your children the social norms of the country they are in.

I never had to ‘hold on’ to things though to teach them…

NowItsSpring · 06/11/2023 10:58

Personally have never done that but it seems so many 'new' parenting techniques are just things many people have always done but presented as a new hack and branded with a new label. For please and thankyous, we just modelled this always saying please and thankyou ourselves, so it was the norm in our household.

Bbq1 · 06/11/2023 10:55

ShirleyPhallus · 06/11/2023 10:22

Maybe people you’d think they were rude for calling them baldy WinkGrin

Haha, probably! I didn't notice I'd written that and I can't edit!

OP posts:
Kitcaterpillar · 06/11/2023 10:32

ShirleyPhallus · 06/11/2023 10:00

It’s a very weird thing that adults do to force children to have good manners and then rarely have them themselves.

Adults might say thank you but I think please is far less used as less formal speech patterns are more accepted (Ie, “could you pass me a banana from the fruit bowl?” sounds fine but you’d make a child add please)

Not to mention the adults who bark SORRY when they actually mean “excuse me please”. Again - you’d make a child say the latter but seemingly adults don’t need to say this themselves.

For as long as my child views me as her personal butler, she can say please.

TheJubileePortrait · 06/11/2023 10:30

wherethewildtbingsgo · 06/11/2023 10:05

They aren't but you're allowing them to do it to other adults apparently because they don't know them. I've got a family member who has a similar approach to you. It doesn't come across that their DC simply doesn't know us...it comes across that they are rude. And it also puts them at a social disadvantage. Not to mention the fact it's probably a pointless thing to impose as they will be required to say please and thank you at school and nursery.

I am allowing her to be comfortable, yes. She doesn’t speak in front of other adults she doesn’t know yet, and that’s okay.

If people want to think she’s rude they can go right ahead. It doesn’t bother me. I know she is a polite and kind little girl who just doesn’t feel comfortable speaking to other adults yet, so the opinion of a random person we meet along the way is irrelevant to us.

NorthernSpirit · 06/11/2023 10:29

This doesn’t need to be complicated.

Parents modelling manners is all that is needed.

I work in hospitality and you would be amazed at the amount of adults / parents who lack basic manners. If kids don’t see their parents using manners you know they will unlikely use them going forward.

honeylulu · 06/11/2023 10:29

It's not a technique I've used but it certainly doesn't sound original!

I agree with posters saying that politeness/manners seem to be lacking in the younger generation. I've been quite strict on insisting on please and thank you for my children. They needed a LOT of reminding but eventually it sank in.

I know a lot of gentle parents who just model politeness but don't ask/remind their kids to say the words and ... they don't ... at all. I sometimes have to grit my teeth during play dates. It's all "I want", "haven't you got any snacks", "I don't like that" ... a yes please or no thank you would be so much more pleasant and smooth the path for an easier life for them too!

My son who is now an adult told me recently that when he and his mates got into scrapes they'd always send him to talk to the teacher etc as he could usually politely charm their way out of the mischief afoot as he had nice manners and "spoke properly". I'm not proud he was naughty obviously but it shows the value and usefulness of politeness.

ShirleyPhallus · 06/11/2023 10:22

Bbq1 · 06/11/2023 10:20

I wouldn't ask anyone for anything without adding a please. To me asking baldy for a banana sounds rude and I would automatically add a please whoever i was asking. Then a thank you

Maybe people you’d think they were rude for calling them baldy WinkGrin

Flittingaboutagain · 06/11/2023 10:22

Well yes, especially to his face 🤣

Bbq1 · 06/11/2023 10:20

ShirleyPhallus · 06/11/2023 10:00

It’s a very weird thing that adults do to force children to have good manners and then rarely have them themselves.

Adults might say thank you but I think please is far less used as less formal speech patterns are more accepted (Ie, “could you pass me a banana from the fruit bowl?” sounds fine but you’d make a child add please)

Not to mention the adults who bark SORRY when they actually mean “excuse me please”. Again - you’d make a child say the latter but seemingly adults don’t need to say this themselves.

I wouldn't ask anyone for anything without adding a please. To me asking baldy for a banana sounds rude and I would automatically add a please whoever i was asking. Then a thank you

OP posts:
Bbq1 · 06/11/2023 10:17

It's not confrontational at all. It's gentle hold on for a second and maybe with a verbal prompt too. It comes after you have modelled saying please and thank you and dc have learnt to use manners and are saying it regularly. It's just a reminder if they forget. It's holding for a second as child remembers to say Thank you. Ni confrontation required. My ds is incredibly polite and always has been. People regularly commented on it when he was younger .

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 06/11/2023 10:17

I've never done that, never heard of it either. Both of my children always say please and thank you though, I think there's far better ways of teaching this.

Sparklfairy · 06/11/2023 10:14

TheJubileePortrait · 06/11/2023 09:51

No, I don’t and wouldn’t do that.

Manners are important yes, but they’re pointless if the child doesn’t actually mean please/thank you/sorry.

Instead I role model, and at nearly 3 DD1 says it nearly all of the time with me. She won’t say it to strangers who give her things because she’s not comfortable in front of adults she doesn’t know, so I role model and say “thank you”.

In time as she gets older and more confident it will come. She is a very polite and kind little girl.

There's plenty of things I do/say that I don't really mean, and plenty of things I'd LIKE to do/say that I don't. It's called having social skills.

You're also expecting your toddler to apply critical thinking skills she just doesn't have yet - modelling you accurately would involve her analysing why you say thank you but she doesn't have to. True modelling would come from her seeing that you do, what you already ask of her.

wherethewildtbingsgo · 06/11/2023 10:05

TheJubileePortrait · 06/11/2023 10:01

@wherethewildtbingsgo You don’t need to agree with it. They’re not your children 😂

They aren't but you're allowing them to do it to other adults apparently because they don't know them. I've got a family member who has a similar approach to you. It doesn't come across that their DC simply doesn't know us...it comes across that they are rude. And it also puts them at a social disadvantage. Not to mention the fact it's probably a pointless thing to impose as they will be required to say please and thank you at school and nursery.

TheCompactPussycat · 06/11/2023 10:04

TheJubileePortrait · 06/11/2023 09:51

No, I don’t and wouldn’t do that.

Manners are important yes, but they’re pointless if the child doesn’t actually mean please/thank you/sorry.

Instead I role model, and at nearly 3 DD1 says it nearly all of the time with me. She won’t say it to strangers who give her things because she’s not comfortable in front of adults she doesn’t know, so I role model and say “thank you”.

In time as she gets older and more confident it will come. She is a very polite and kind little girl.

Does role modelling really work any differently though? Since your nearly 3 year old cannot see inside your mind to know whether you actually mean please/thank you/sorry, all you are really doing is teaching them to parrot you. It isn't any different to reminding them to say the words. It's just a different technique to exactly the same end.

TheJubileePortrait · 06/11/2023 10:01

@wherethewildtbingsgo You don’t need to agree with it. They’re not your children 😂

ShirleyPhallus · 06/11/2023 10:00

It’s a very weird thing that adults do to force children to have good manners and then rarely have them themselves.

Adults might say thank you but I think please is far less used as less formal speech patterns are more accepted (Ie, “could you pass me a banana from the fruit bowl?” sounds fine but you’d make a child add please)

Not to mention the adults who bark SORRY when they actually mean “excuse me please”. Again - you’d make a child say the latter but seemingly adults don’t need to say this themselves.

wherethewildtbingsgo · 06/11/2023 09:56

TheJubileePortrait · 06/11/2023 09:51

No, I don’t and wouldn’t do that.

Manners are important yes, but they’re pointless if the child doesn’t actually mean please/thank you/sorry.

Instead I role model, and at nearly 3 DD1 says it nearly all of the time with me. She won’t say it to strangers who give her things because she’s not comfortable in front of adults she doesn’t know, so I role model and say “thank you”.

In time as she gets older and more confident it will come. She is a very polite and kind little girl.

I couldn't agree with this less. Please and thank you aren't about whether you mean it or not. They are social constructs and only learnt by teaching. It's not polite to take something from someone and not say thank you.

I also do lots of gentle parenting but this sort of gentle parenting is genuine madness. There are some things that are required in the world and need to be taught by parents. Simply waiting for your child to learn it from watching is not enough. And it also doesn't necessarily mean they "mean it" if they are simply copying.

Having said all that I wouldn't hold onto
Something until they have said thank you. Seems unnecessarily confrontational. I just remind them to say thank you if they haven't already. It's not really about whether they mean it or not. And tbh I'm not sure I even "mean it" when I say please and thank you and how are you and how was your day and can I get you a drink and would you like some food etc etc when I say it to people. It's just required to be a decent functioning human.

TheJubileePortrait · 06/11/2023 09:51

No, I don’t and wouldn’t do that.

Manners are important yes, but they’re pointless if the child doesn’t actually mean please/thank you/sorry.

Instead I role model, and at nearly 3 DD1 says it nearly all of the time with me. She won’t say it to strangers who give her things because she’s not comfortable in front of adults she doesn’t know, so I role model and say “thank you”.

In time as she gets older and more confident it will come. She is a very polite and kind little girl.

WingingItNoMore · 06/11/2023 09:49

I'd not heard of this and it wouldn't have occured to me, I think. Sometimes it's ok to state the bleeding obvious. What worked well with my two is to just model saying thank you. So every time they passed me something or did something I asked them to I said thanks. And I use please and thank you myself when talking to them. They both picked it up very quickly. For someone else something else might work better. It's good to have an arsenal of tools. I assume very few things in parenting are actually brand new.