Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teaching your child to say Thank you

85 replies

Bbq1 · 06/11/2023 08:55

A 'Parenting Expert' has apparently come up with a 'new hack' to teach your child to say Thank you. It involves handing something over to your child and lightly holding onto the item until the child says Thank you. You then release. The article says this is a new technique that nobody knows about... My son is 18 and this was something I would do automatically when he was young to remind him to say Thank you. Only having to hold the item for a couple of seconds. Am i wrong in thinking that most parents do this automatically and it's not a new idea?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheCompactPussycat · 07/11/2023 13:19

ZebraDanios · 07/11/2023 11:54

@TheCompactPussycat I ask because I remember the first time one of my children (as a toddler) thanked me for (of all things!) cutting their nails for them - that’s not necessarily something you’d expect a thank you for, let alone insist on, so it really surprised me that they thought to do it unprompted. I was genuinely wondering, if you relied on “hacks” like holding onto an object until you got the right response, how you go about fostering something approaching genuine gratitude. I totally agree with all the comments here about the importance of giving thanks whether you mean it or not, but heartfelt gratitude is surely still something to aim for.

Edited

That's too cute!

I've never actually done the 'holding on to things' method but I think it's a legitimate method. I've only ever modelled appropriate behaviour with the occasional prompt with my own children though (who are beautifully polite young adults now).

Heartfelt thanks is certainly an ideal but I think it's something that develops later. Not all thanks needs to be heartfelt (e.g. I'll say thank you to a cashier in a shop but it's not really genuine gratitude; it's more a simple acknowledgement). I don't think you can teach genuine gratitude. It's a feeling you get when someone has done something genuinely kind that makes you want to express your gratitude. However, you can talk about it with your children when they are old enough to grasp the concept of wanting to say thank you because they recognise that someone has done something nice for them rather than being just what's expected.

Canwehaveaminute · 07/11/2023 12:49

Sorry I haven't read the full thread. Not trying to put the boot in with something other people have mentioned. I hate that. Sorry.

Canwehaveaminute · 07/11/2023 12:48

Manners are important yes, but they’re pointless if the child doesn’t actually mean please/thank you/sorry.

Good manners are for the benefit of the other person. If somebody hands me a pen, I generally don't feel deep gratitude but it's important that the other person feels like I've acknowledged and appreciated what they did. When I'm asking for a 'cappuccino, please', I'm not really pleading or desperate for my coffee, but I want the person serving me to feel respecting. To say there is no point if the person saying it doesn't mean it is just silly. The whole point is to be respectful to the other person, or at least appear to be.

ZebraDanios · 07/11/2023 12:07

@TheCompactPussycat Also - I absolutely take your point that the “holding on” thing is used alongside modelling, but the impression I get from the way the OP is phrased is that the parenting expert in question is presenting the “holding on” method as so revolutionary that you’d think either the expert or the intended audience had never thought of modelling either.

(That was a really clumsy sentence, sorry - hope it makes sense!)

ZebraDanios · 07/11/2023 11:54

@TheCompactPussycat I ask because I remember the first time one of my children (as a toddler) thanked me for (of all things!) cutting their nails for them - that’s not necessarily something you’d expect a thank you for, let alone insist on, so it really surprised me that they thought to do it unprompted. I was genuinely wondering, if you relied on “hacks” like holding onto an object until you got the right response, how you go about fostering something approaching genuine gratitude. I totally agree with all the comments here about the importance of giving thanks whether you mean it or not, but heartfelt gratitude is surely still something to aim for.

northernbeee · 07/11/2023 11:45

You'd be surprised how many kids don't say thank you. I work in a school (in a very nice area) and most of the kids don't say thank you.

Fionaville · 07/11/2023 10:21

ZebraDanios · 06/11/2023 21:20

It involves handing something over to your child and lightly holding onto the item until the child says Thank you. You then release.

I expect to be torn to shreds for this, but to me this is no different to holding a treat over an animal’s head until they beg or do some kind of other trick for it. I’m sure plenty of parents are fine with that, but it makes me uncomfortable, personally.

The thing is, I never had to hold onto anything. I wouldn't sit there in some demented game of tug a war with a toddler. After a couple of times of saying "Thank you" a certain way while handing them things, toddlers just say it. It's just about consistency. It feels so basic to me, I'm genuinely surprised that everyone doesn't do it.

TheCompactPussycat · 07/11/2023 10:07

karpouzi · 07/11/2023 09:54

I think what has changed is not to tell your kid when you hand over something “what do we say?” and expect a response “thank you” but rather just model it by saying thank you every time yourself.

I don't think that's a change. That's just one of the techniques for teaching manners that parents have been using for millennia. Modelling behaviour has, by it's very nature, always been the main method for teaching children how to behave. Verbal and physical (holding on to an item) reminders are just used to reinforce the modelling.

I really can't understand why people think it's something new.

PuttingDownRoots · 07/11/2023 10:05

Parenting a child with speech delay and selective mutism really made me rethink forcing manners.

DD was unable to say thank you. She would freeze. So I just used to say it on her behalf. A lot of the time she was able to give a quick smile... other times eye contact was also out of reach.

Fortunately most people picked up on the subtle clues that she couldn't speak rather than wouldn't.

Shes 12 now. It still happens occasionally. There's probably people who do think she's rude. But most people pick up on the non verbal stuff.

I've met a lot of other children like her!

Bluevelvetsofa · 07/11/2023 10:04

It’s learning the habit of polite social exchange. It also applies, I think, to thanking someone for a gift, whether it’s in person or otherwise. It used to always be a letter, but now a text or call is acceptable. I stopped buying gifts for family members who never acknowledged the gifts I sent. It’s impolite to not respond when someone has done something for you.

TenderDandelions · 07/11/2023 09:56

I've been doing it with children since I was practically a child myself! I remember with my nieces even when they were toddlers just starting to speak, holding an item and saying "ta" as they took it. My SIL and friends have all done it with their children and now they're tweens they're all still very polite and it gets commented on regularly.

Unfortunately there seems to be a lot of children that this same technique should be used for that are old enough to know better.

I've helped out at a few friends and family kid's birthday parties and barely any kids said please or thank you when I've been handing out food, drinks, party bags, etc. Even if the parents see, they don't say anything! So rude!

karpouzi · 07/11/2023 09:54

I think what has changed is not to tell your kid when you hand over something “what do we say?” and expect a response “thank you” but rather just model it by saying thank you every time yourself.

Sennelier1 · 07/11/2023 09:48

I’ve done this with my children (now 38 and 36) and still do with my grandchildren (6, 4 and 1). My children agree. With the very little ones I do give them the [cookie] even if they don’t say thank you yet. The older they get the more I insist on saying thank-you.

TheCompactPussycat · 07/11/2023 09:41

ZebraDanios · 07/11/2023 07:43

Also, though, if you train a child to thank you for an object by holding onto the object until they say thank you, how do you train them to thank you for doing something for them? You can’t exactly keep hold of an action until you’ve got the response you want…

I think you're being too black and white about this, although I suspect that's purposeful.

It's just a non-verbal prompt that you can use some of the time whilst using a verbal prompt at other times. It's not a single method to use every time you want a please or thank you.

Holly60 · 07/11/2023 09:22

The thing is I would argue we want the use of please and thank you to basically be second nature as it's so much less effort then 😂.

I was taught to say please and thank you very naturally with a big open smile. I've found all my life people have been very willing and happy to do things for me. It's made my life so easy in a way.

That's what I wanted for my children, so I actively reminded them every time. Once it's in there you never unlearn it.

GnomeDePlume · 07/11/2023 09:04

As PPs have said, it is about learning the habit of saying please and thank you.

Totally ingrained in me. DH would crack up when, as students, I would go to the bar to get a round in please may I have 5 pints of lager, 3 pints of bitter and two packs of pork scratchings. It never occurred to me there was any other way to ask for something.

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 07/11/2023 08:02

Bbq1 · 06/11/2023 09:47

Manners sre so important aren't they. Your dc's friends will grow up to be the adults who make me cringe in restaurants - those who reel off a big order to the server without one please or Thank you. So rude.

Ugh my friend does this - plus syebsays "can l get..." so l rarely eat out with her these days!

Itsnotchristmasyet · 07/11/2023 07:52

ZebraDanios · 07/11/2023 07:41

@Itsnotchristmasyet I guess I see it as kind of underestimating a child’s cognitive abilities to think that the only way to teach them to do something is to take exactly the same approach as you would to an animal that can’t learn any other way. To my mind the “you’re not getting this until you perform for me” approach is a world away from just reminding a child what to say.

I see what you’re saying but I think it’s just a way to build habits.

I do think dogs and children are very similar and I believe in rewarding good behaviour.
I wouldn’t punish a dog or child for doing something wrong.

If someone gives me something then I automatically say thank you, so you’re teaching a child to do it and reminding them, until they start doing it on their own.

ZebraDanios · 07/11/2023 07:43

Also, though, if you train a child to thank you for an object by holding onto the object until they say thank you, how do you train them to thank you for doing something for them? You can’t exactly keep hold of an action until you’ve got the response you want…

Hadalifeonce · 07/11/2023 07:43

I have used the 'holding on' method for over 20 years, with my own children and others visiting my home.

ZebraDanios · 07/11/2023 07:41

@Itsnotchristmasyet I guess I see it as kind of underestimating a child’s cognitive abilities to think that the only way to teach them to do something is to take exactly the same approach as you would to an animal that can’t learn any other way. To my mind the “you’re not getting this until you perform for me” approach is a world away from just reminding a child what to say.

HelpMeGetThrough · 07/11/2023 07:35

There is always a "hack" for something these days, that so called experts think they have invented. 9 times out of 10, they haven't.

We were always told our two boys were very polite and they still are at 16 and 21. We didn't actively teach it, we would always say please and thank you to them, just like we would anyone else and I guess they learnt from that.

It didn't need a "hack", just common sense.

Itsnotchristmasyet · 07/11/2023 07:29

ZebraDanios · 06/11/2023 21:20

It involves handing something over to your child and lightly holding onto the item until the child says Thank you. You then release.

I expect to be torn to shreds for this, but to me this is no different to holding a treat over an animal’s head until they beg or do some kind of other trick for it. I’m sure plenty of parents are fine with that, but it makes me uncomfortable, personally.

That’s how you would train an animal though.

A puppy learns to sit because you’ve got the treat that it wants and you’re rewarding good behaviour.

Children and puppies need to be taught.
Using a treat for a dog or reminding a child what to say, isn’t cruel.

Itsnotchristmasyet · 07/11/2023 07:26

I’ve always done this with my child too.

I work with teens with SN too and we always remind them to say please and thank you, so in the real world people won’t think they’re rude.
I believe most teachers and TAs do the same in mainstream.

Plilywhite · 07/11/2023 07:15

As a mother of a child with autism this thread confirms my fears that people just assume he is rude and I am a bad parent . My son is 4 and although he has please almost always there at home, he really struggles with thank you unless reminded. Out and about please and thank you rarely happen unless he knows you well and he will not even look at the person as they are handing him something or ask him if he would like something. I usually model thank you and speak for him so not to lead to more overwhelm from him in a situation he is already struggling with. If he does manage to say it himself it is often unclear and late and people aren’t paying enough attention to hear him anyway or have already moved on.

I have a just turned two year old daughter who says it without prompting so modelling does work and manners are something I care about.