Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who pick up ‘lost cats’

189 replies

SweeetFemaleAttitude · 06/11/2023 08:48

Wtf is their thought process? All our local Facebook groups have a stream of a version of ‘I just found this cat…’ and a picture of a healthy calm cat.
They take them home, then post they have them and are looking for the owners. They drop them at the vets, or they post their location for other nutters to go find the cat. Or they decide it’s hungry and feed it every day. Today’s post that triggered this moan says ‘I just found this cat at xxxx. Seems friendly, where can I take it for scanning’. Has a picture of an adult cat being stroked on someone’s lap that looks healthy.
The better end just get them scanned, though even that tbh I don’t get for a one off encounter with a healthy cat.
It’s once in a blue moon there’s a reason like the cat has an injury, or seems neglected or is in an unsafe location or has moved into their garden full time.
I’m on all the local lost cat groups and fb just because I have a friendly cat. Last year he went missing for four weeks due to being taken in, he’s also been fed at numerous other houses over the years who’ve decided he’s a (very fat) stray (in robust health). None scanned him, though one tracked him here and said he was their stray they’d taken in after I’d had to shave off some matts in his fur.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Ylvamoon · 06/11/2023 10:45

There is a simple solution: keep your cat on your property.

Irregardless · 06/11/2023 10:41

This summer we had a cat in our garden every day, drinking water from the bird bath. It looked healthy and happy. But when it started to get colder I noticed the cat was there almost all the time, and it cried when we went out and it looked miserable. So I put a photo on fb, and mostly got abuse from people. But last month I decided to feed the cat (we have a cat of our own), and then suddenly a teenage boy replied that it was his cat. He and his mum came straight away and were so happy they cried. The cat had been gone since May, when they moved into a new house. I’m so glad I posted on fb.

Betty000 · 06/11/2023 10:38

My cat was stolen and taken to vets 20 miles away FFS. I got her back but she was then taken again several months later. I believe by the same woman. She was taken from just outside our back garden. She used to pop on pub next door for snacks and this woman insisted she must be starving. No, she’s a greedy madam who didn’t like the dry food we fed her, despite it being better for her. I never understand people who do this, essentially stealing someone else pet.

TeenLifeMum · 06/11/2023 10:35

We had a situation where a couple “adopted” a local stay they found. They took it to the vets and because the cat was white she had an increased risk of skin cancer in her ears so they had the tips removed. Actual family who owned the cat lived 3 doors down and were absolutely livid. The cat went home every day and wasn’t stray at all.

Shithole101 · 06/11/2023 10:31

I agree @SweeetFemaleAttitude and I have seem comments that say. Looks like a cat has found his home congratulations. I see it as stealing the cat belongs to someone. If they are feeding it every day they are encouraging it to their home. It's a well known thing that cats roam it's not new . Also I feel bad for children who's cats go missing due to so called do Gooders

Changednamesforthis22 · 06/11/2023 10:26

This is one of the reasons why you should always get your cat microchipped and update the details if you move or change phone number.

Whinge · 06/11/2023 10:21

Onus had to be on the owners of missing cats to be active on cat boards and put a paper message collar on etc, it's no use criticising the innocent/gullible victims who don't know the ideal etiquette

Or people could just stop feeding cats that don't belong to them. Confused

@Opp If your friend and her neighbours want a cat then they should rescue one from a reputable charity, not entice a friendly well cared for cat into their homes.

TentChristmas · 06/11/2023 10:19

We’ve only taken one cat to be scanned. It would follow my DH home every evening and sit outside the window in the rain and actually try and pull the window open to get in if it was open a jar, the same with the front door he would wait for us to go in or out. After about a week of this we thought we had better check incase someone wasn’t missing them. Turns out he was our neighbours 😂

Wellyrambles · 06/11/2023 10:17

We had this on our road.

I actually saw a woman enticing the local friendly cat into her house with treats, then later that day another neighbour who's cat it actually was , was knocking on doors and put a a Facebook post enquiring if anyone had seen him.

Cats can be quite sociable - and they are also chancers. If there's a chance their may be food available in a house , they will happily go in. They also roam over a few streets but how this equates to people taking in a ' lost' cat because they like the look of it is beyond me.

Just another example of how ignorant and clueless we have become as people I guess.

Opp · 06/11/2023 10:16

If you have a cat that you let out this is one of the risks. Cats are clever and know what they're doing. You can't control how the community will respond to a cute seemingly needy cat so instead. I think these cats can bring communities together and they can bring out kindness and caring and alleviate loneliness. At least they're not being brought in by cat torturing psychopaths and turning up with a tail missing. My friend and his neighbours have had a visiting/communal cat for the past couple of months which they acquiesced to after it turned up and persistently demanded to be let in day after day. They now have a WhatsApp group so check it's okay and being fed the right food etc. They love it, it's getting fresh fish, (no bones) cat milk, the lot. My friend tried to get it in the cat box to get it to the vets after I begged him to get it scanned and it went nuts and as far as I know it's not yet been. I mention every time they should take it when I speak to them. Cat is happy as Larry. It's not on any communal boards and whoever owns it (if it is owned) hasn't put a message collar on. So what can you do. Onus had to be on the owners of missing cats to be active on cat boards and put a paper message collar on etc, it's no use criticising the innocent/gullible victims who don't know the ideal etiquette

Alargeoneplease89 · 06/11/2023 10:14

Rakszasa · 06/11/2023 08:53

YABU and I have a solution. Keep cats at home, where they should be, and make them garden enclosure so they can explore the outside if you think that's what they need. Safer for your cat, better for you, as you'd spend more time with it, and less of a nuisance for wildlife and everyone else who has to experience your cats wandering wherever they want.

Give over, most cats need exercise... would you keep a dog just in the garden?

I say this as an owner of a housecat he's a specific breed that has to be kept in but I'm not naive enough to say all cats should be confined to a garden.

Yes, seems like some weird craze were people hijack your cat and want to wear this invisible cape of they are heroes

NotLactoseFree · 06/11/2023 10:13

People are morons. We had a fat ginger cat. The first time we put him on a diet... he gained weight as he just upped his scavenging and hunting. He was fat, but healthy, glossy etc. He was also a proper night cat - so was at home all day sleeping, then, after supper, would go out (if the weather was nice - winter he just stayed in! Grin) Usually back early hours of the morning.

He started coming home a bit later - just dead on 7 when we got up to feed him. And we realised some moron was feeding him breakfast, and he was then coming home for a second breakfast. How on earth they thought he was hungry was completely beyond me.

They subsequently clearly tried to keep him as he disappeared for 2 days and we were frantic, then in the middle of a rain storm, he came bursting through his cat flap soaked to the SKIN. we think they tried to keep him inside and he finally legged it through the door when they were off guard.

On the plus side, he stopped going wherever he'd been going and the new food we had him on for weight loss started to work!!!!!

Wotchaz · 06/11/2023 10:08

Not relevant, but I saw an insta video yesterday where a little girl carried a “lost cat” into the house. It was a raccoon 😂.

My little wobble cat is indoor only, but when we went through a phase of having a regular timid feline visitor to the garden I just took a picture, put it on the local fb and had a nice chat with the owner who reassured me he had a lovely home. Wouldn’t have occurred to me to try and abduct him!

SallyWD · 06/11/2023 10:07

Some cats are stray or run away from neglectful homes though. We adopted a stray and believe me did everything we could to try and locate owners (posters around the neighbourhood, speaking to neighbours, taking to vets to check for microchip) but nothing. The cat was extremely thin and didn't leave our garden. She definitely wasn't going "home", she lived under our bush. So after several weeks we adopted her.
But I agree some people jump the gun.

RumNotRun · 06/11/2023 10:07

@BovrilMartini That happened to my gorgeous grey cat. He was a big cat, not fat as such, just a solid build. He'd go off for wanders but always come back home. A few neighbours knew him so they'd keep their eye on him too.

One day he had been out on wanders and not come home. I was on FB and the local PaH vets had a post saying does anyone know whose cat this is. It was mine. I phoned them up, an old lady has taken him in as he "was starving". They gave her my number to arrange getting the cat back. She told me he had clearly been starving as he wolfed down the roast chicken she gave him.

Sadly he ended up moving in with her as she fed him nothing but roast meat and fish. I have a suspicion he's also now a house cat as no one ever saw him wandering the gardens. She also called him Mr Grey which is gross and creepy.

Mrsjayy · 06/11/2023 10:06

Oh no the Swans do people not realise the fences are to keep people out and not the swans in 😆

IfIcouldchooseagain · 06/11/2023 10:06

It’s a big problem where I am (affluent area of busybodies). Often it’s people who’ve had other pets in the past, like dogs. They cannot intellectually grasp the concept that a cat is a wild animal that wanders freely then returns to its home base to allow its ‘owner’ to feed it. They don’t understand that a cat can take its own collar off. They expect all cats to look in the prime of life and anything elderly will be stolen then dumped at a vet as ‘I found this sick stray’. They want to ego-boost of having ‘helped’ without the commitment of actually rescuing a real stray cat from a shelter.

I’m particularly sensitive about this issue because when my sick elderly cat escaped house-arrest, some idiot decided she must be a malnourished kitten, took her in and fed her and kept her for a while. They only took her to a vet for scanning when they began to suspect she was ill. She had been on a special diet for her illness and what with them giving her the wrong food, plus the shock of being taken and trapped, she died soon afterward. The vet said it was the shock and stress of being taken that killed her.

Mrsjayy · 06/11/2023 10:03

My neighbours put a paper collar on their "stopout" of a cat ! It was all over our fb page as being half starved and neglected it was being fed at every other house 😂

I don't know what the solution is but I think people should leave them be unless it's injured or owners ask on SM if anybody sees their cat.

hobbledyhoy · 06/11/2023 10:03

YANBU
It's either complete stupidity or as a PP mentioned, a performance to elicit attention about what a Good Samaritan they are.
On mine it's related to swans. They live on two ponds nearby which have fences round them and whenever they leave the confines of the fence, people are calling the RSPCA or asking for residents with keys to unlock it so they can get back in.
Thankfully someone eventually told them to stop being so bloody stupid and that they had wings which they'd used to get out so imagine they'd be able to get back in should they wish to.

Headshoulderscheeseontoast · 06/11/2023 10:00

Sometimes it works though

My neighbour found a cat a few months ago, it was hanging around her house for consecutive days and crying for food. Absolutely beautiful cat!

After a couple of weeks of posting on social media, turns out the cat was lost and from a considerable distance, about 15 min drive.

The owners hadn't neutered the cat so it was wondering miles. He wasn't chipped either.

Had she not posted on social media I don't think that cat would have been found by its owners.

Plankingplanks · 06/11/2023 09:58

Personally I can't stand all the "my cat has been missing for 2 (insert other ridiculously short period of time) hours - please can you check your sheds" posts. Listen love, I wouldn't even go check my shed if one of my teenagers came back a bit late, I'm certainly not doing it for your bloody cat.

Ace56 · 06/11/2023 09:56

maisouimaisoui1 · 06/11/2023 09:31

Do any people with roaming cats ever consider how many birds your happily roaming cats take out? It makes me SO sad. I've got a neighbour who I've seen insisting on Facebook that her cat never hurts anything, and the bloody thing is always wandering through my garden with birds in its mouth. It's like a weird blindness thing. "Oh my outside cat doesn't catch birds." Yes. Yes, it does. Own it.

So what if they catch birds? Mine catches mice too. Animals catch other animals, it’s just the circle of life…unless the birds are a particularly endangered species (unlikely). Cats are meant to roam and not to be kept indoors all day.

Whinge · 06/11/2023 09:54

BovrilMartini · 06/11/2023 09:48

This happens all the time on my
local FB page. Multiple posts a week that go

Photo of normal looking cat in garden
Does anyone recognise this cat? I think it’s lost. I offered it a tin of tuna/tray of smoked salmon/bowl of cream/tub of Dreamies and it then all. It’s starving! I’m taking it to the vet

Then multiple comments of ‘Poor thing’ You’re so good’

Then multiple comments of ‘Poor thing’ You’re so good’

Yep. I'm convinced these sort of people don't actually care about the cats, they only post so others can tell them what a saint they are. Hmm

twattydogshavetwattypeople · 06/11/2023 09:52

spiderlight · 06/11/2023 09:46

Cats are bad enough, but there was a post on our local FB group a couple of weeks back, quite late in the evening - 'Has anyone lost this hedgehog?' 😂

OMG I suppose it will be rats next.

casuarinatree · 06/11/2023 09:50

Multiple posts of healthy, normal looking 'lost' cats on my local FB as well who are always hungry and friendly.

People are idiots.