Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pull out of house purchase as new development being built 300 metres away

65 replies

Rumblestrips · 05/11/2023 21:40

Name changed for this. I’m about £3k into a house purchase (fees plus survey, solicitors) and just happened to google new housing developments near me and was gutted to learn that an already in progress 1800 home development will extend within the next five years to within 300m of the house I’m buying.

In between the side of me and the development will be eight existing houses and a narrow lane and a high hedgerow (I don’t know if the hedge will remain). The development will be built in the field behind the hedge. In front of me is the same narrow road and an existing row of houses and the development will extend into the field behind these houses. I don’t know if this will form enough of a buffer between me and the new houses.

I am obviously kicking myself that I didn’t find this out sooner before paying for solicitors but glad to have discovered it before any exchange of contracts.

According to planning documents that I’ve found online, there will be a new road built to serve the development. It’s not clear whether the lane running outside my house will have an access road onto this new road. There will be a new roundabout built about 1km away. A new primary school is currently under construction a good distance away.

I am potentially willing to walk away despite being this far through the process. I am not bothered about inconvenience from the construction process as that won’t last forever. I am worried about the impact that the development may have on the tone and character of the local area, which is a village. I am worried about the increased traffic and congestion in the area even though the development will have its own road. I don’t like the sound of the new roundabout as that is very urbanising.

Things which make the decision difficult are that my child attends the local school, it’s a great location for my job and I love the existing area. A couple of the houses which will be closer to the development than me were bought at least two years after the planning permission was granted. So either those buyers didn’t know, or weren’t bothered. Maybe I should knock on doors and ask.

I’m not sure whether to pull out or not. I don’t want to throw the baby out with the bath water and miss out on a house in an area that ticks so many boxes. But I don’t know if I will like being close to a new housing development as the place may lose its rural feel.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Iwasafool · 20/12/2023 17:05

5thCommandment · 18/12/2023 19:51

Blimey there are so many I'll-informed nimbys. Classic mums netters moaning without any understanding of how something works.

We need loads and loads (millions) of new homes. And they raise the prices in an area, offer shops more footfall, help the council with more tax, developers pay millions in contributions towards services, it often leads to upgrades nearby to benefit established communities, it now by law (environment act) has to include a net gain in biodiversity so good for nature.
300m is also quite a distance away and you have no legal right to a view.
It's a positive for so many reasons, people need to get off their "sod everyone else without a home" high horses and support new housing.
Buy your home and enjoy the positives it brings.

They also overwhelm NHS services. The development close to me is 400 houses, there are other developments in the town. The local GPs have raised concerns that they cannot cope with anymore but the plans went ahead anyway.

It is already almost impossible to get a GP appointment and it is actually impossible to get a NHS dentist, footfall in the local shops and a bit of biodiversity doesn't make up for that if you are ill and/or in pain.

5thCommandment · 18/12/2023 19:51

Blimey there are so many I'll-informed nimbys. Classic mums netters moaning without any understanding of how something works.

We need loads and loads (millions) of new homes. And they raise the prices in an area, offer shops more footfall, help the council with more tax, developers pay millions in contributions towards services, it often leads to upgrades nearby to benefit established communities, it now by law (environment act) has to include a net gain in biodiversity so good for nature.
300m is also quite a distance away and you have no legal right to a view.
It's a positive for so many reasons, people need to get off their "sod everyone else without a home" high horses and support new housing.
Buy your home and enjoy the positives it brings.

UnfriendMe · 18/12/2023 19:41

BigFatLiar · 05/11/2023 22:04

Doesn't matter where you buy, chances are someone will start building nearby.

This is so true and sad. I don't understand this about the UK. It's a small island ffs, at some point they have to stop building no matter how many homes are allegedly in the backlog or will green space just all be bulldozed to put more and more ugly ass houses? This just seems like insanity.

Nevermind31 · 06/11/2023 12:04

Are there many houses in the area you need/ want to be in, within your price range? Or are you going to end up moving into the new estate?

jessycake · 06/11/2023 11:14

Where I live you would be hard pushed to find anywhere without a large development , new ones are announce every week . If not now, it's likely to happen in the near future . It would be less upsetting if any of them were truly affordable .

Baffledandalarmed · 06/11/2023 10:48

YANBU.

It’s not only the fact it’s a huge development, it’ll be

  • the dirt and dust that covers your car/house/garden for the next year+
  • the grit and debris on the road that ends up damaging your tyres (and yes they are meant to clean the roads but they won’t do it every day)
  • the eyesore of a new development
  • the increased strain on local resources and removal of the ‘community’

Consider the £3K to be a timely reminder to thoroughly research an area before you buy. Better £3K now than utter misery later.

Ariela · 06/11/2023 10:18

If there's no access between the new houses and your road, and the new estate keeps the ancient hedgerow, then I think you'll be fine. What you will need to do is keep an eye on that hedge, see if there's any tree group or rural access group that monitor old hedges and trees, as the developers are likely to just chop it down as quickly as they can, as this makes development of the site easier without having to navigate existing - this happened to a swathe of trees with a TPO when an estate was built, they just cleared half of them one morning before the council manged to come out and stop them. Meant they manged to get planning for an additional 3 houses.

What you'll likely find is that the new houses will be highly priced, the village will be more viable for amenities (pubs, shops, schools, buses etc). My best friend lives in the far end of a road that was closed before a similar sized development was built - so she lives in the 'countrified' end of the road, there's a section where it's closed to traffic but remains a footpath, and it then continues as a different named road beyond. Later, about 8 years ago, a further 600 estate was built on the other side of the road/footpath to the first estate. House prices on this estate were very high as it's countryside beyond and very desirable school/transport. This has meant the 'country' end of the old road has become 'the' road to live on in the area, and house prices have doubled whereas the first estate's houses have only gone up by half as much in that time.

FrankieStein403 · 06/11/2023 09:54

As pp said - check the online planning application(s) there will be site plans and impact statements as well as elevations and renderings to give you an idea of how the thing will look.

However as pp have also said bear in mind that anything that looks expensive (for the developer) may well be omitted!

Skyscrapers921 · 06/11/2023 09:41

I wouldn't buy it

VeronicasCloset · 06/11/2023 09:38

bigpawsjames · 06/11/2023 09:35

@VeronicasCloset I'm a property lawyer and that's totally incorrect

Really? Please tell me which part of the CON29 reveals planning applications for adjoining properties?

bigpawsjames · 06/11/2023 09:35

@VeronicasCloset I'm a property lawyer and that's totally incorrect

Itsjustmeee · 06/11/2023 09:34

What about if you pull out
my son has the insurance and originally his sellers said they would move out ( they own a house next door that they are doing up ) or break the chain if there is an issue with their onward purchase

now there is is issue and they don’t want to move out / break the chain and my son is thinking of pulling out as he didn’t want to be in a chain
I don’t think his insurance will cover him for this

pastaandpesto · 06/11/2023 09:21

Is is really 1800 homes? That is an absolutely MASSIVE development. How many houses are there currently in the village? What will this new development mean in terms of a percentage increase of homes?

Jellycats4life · 06/11/2023 09:21

twattydogshavetwattypeople · 06/11/2023 08:34

It's up to you, but civilised existence is perfectly possible within 1km of a roundabout.

Yes, I’m a bit confused as to why a roundabout 1km away will ruins the village’s, well, villagey feel.

It all sounds a bit NIMBY to me.

Hmindr68 · 06/11/2023 09:14

You could be describing my village. The construction is about half way through.

Our village didn’t really have a rural feel though. Having fields around a village doesn’t make it rural. Having a farming community at the heart of a village makes it rural (that’s the next village over).

The roundabout has actually been great at slowing traffic. I’m one house and a road away from the development, and don’t really notice it, but the houses adjacent to a different side of the development (the downhill side) have experienced flooding issues since the construction.

Im really surprised that we haven’t noticed more road traffic, but the dog walking routes are busier.

we did notice that the developers took eff all care of hedgerows. Ripped up and replaced with fences and manicured landscaping.

CasperGutman · 06/11/2023 09:04

New houses are a cloud with a silver lining. At least local shops, churches, cafés, sports clubs etc. are likely to remain viable for longer with more potential customers/members around.

WonderingAboutBabies · 06/11/2023 09:01

What happens to the mortgage offer, if I pull out can that be ported to the new property?

Yes but offers have a time limit - check the letter you'd have received from your lender for an end date.

Also worth mentioning - my in-laws have lived in their house for about 15 years and now have new houses being built nearby. It's one of the potential risks of living on the outskirts of a village/town/city. The traffic has already increased and the project isn't even halfway done yet. Trees and hedgerows ripped down to make way for construction vehicles. They said they'd be finished last year, they're only 30% of the way through the build. It's so awful. I wouldn't buy.

findingmeeee · 06/11/2023 08:59

And bear in mind you might find the locket hedgerow just mysteriously gets burned to the ground one day even if it is meant to be preserved...

findingmeeee · 06/11/2023 08:59

Honestly OP the developers might go against what the planners sign off and just say whoops sorry we didn't mean to...

There is a small development of about 20 homes down a lane off my quiet road. I'm far enough away it hasn't really affected me but they cut down loads of trees that should have stayed according to plans and so on (it's in a conservation area). The building work itself is disruptive for those nearby and can take such a long time. So many people down the little lane tried (and mostly failed) to sell their houses. The development has totally spoilt that end of the village, it hasn't been done in a way that is in keeping and everything that was ripped out was mature and anything new is so going it all just looks so bare. It'll be 20 years before it looks remotely well grown.

ElsieMc · 06/11/2023 08:59

Do not rely on anyone saying that a high hedgerow will be preserved. I have lived in my home 25 years and a few months back a neighbour stripped out an ancient evergreen hedgerow boundaring a listed building, changing the landscape of the small village.

I contacted the Council who told me that unless the hedge bordered agricultural land there was nothing they could do legislation wise. They are bullies and always have been (neighbours). However, they did intervene because neighbours also threatened to cut down ancient trees as well. They were told to undertake works on the trees to make them safe at their cost and warned them of their duty of care should anything happen.

I would walk away op. I have also lived by the disruption of building works and its inevitable impact on your life. Builders generally break the rules, eg very early morning starts (think 6 am here) and weekend working. When the Council deign to visit, they simply tell them it didn't happen.

mushroom3 · 06/11/2023 08:53

Have you looked at the plans on the Council's website? Any idea who the developer is so that you can look at their other developments online? Is it blocks of flats or family sized homes? Is this a council's development or private? It may make the area even more sought after!

twattydogshavetwattypeople · 06/11/2023 08:34

It's up to you, but civilised existence is perfectly possible within 1km of a roundabout.

Chalkdowns · 06/11/2023 08:28

Do a bit more research. It seems to me that so many areas have new developments being built close by. In my immediate family my mother, and two siblings all live in different areas and local villages are being hugely extended that bring housing developments close to all 3 of their homes. It’s really very sad for the people that live there. So depending on where you are, you may find this is the case now and in the future anyway.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 06/11/2023 08:27

The developments take years to build as well. You can think that the disruption won't last that long, but eg there is a housing development near(ish) to us which has a ten year plan! Fortunately we are not near enough to be affected by the noise and disruption but if you go for a walk in other parts of town you can hear it.

Iwasafool · 06/11/2023 08:23

OrigamiOwl · 05/11/2023 22:45

I'd be dropping this like it's hot I'm afraid. These things turn into mission creep. There won't be a road planned for next to your house...until suddenly there is.

Yes this is what we have found.

Swipe left for the next trending thread