Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never got the fuss about ‘When Harry Met Sally’

207 replies

Monetm · 05/11/2023 21:20

Just reading a review of Meg Ryan’s new romcom which compares it to When Harry Met Sally as if the latter was some kind of holy grail of filmmaking. AIBU to remember it as a pretty white bread and basic film that has some decent performances and doesn’t actively insult your intelligence, but really isn’t anything special? The speech Billy Crystal gives her at the end about how he loves the little crease in her forehead, or whatever it is, I honestly find really cheesy and cringe. I don’t particularly think they have chemistry. I liked Meg Ryan better in ‘In the Cut’. I would think less of anyone who told me they loved WHMS.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 10:03

DrMarshaFieldstone · 06/11/2023 09:54

The OP!! 🤦🏻‍♀️

Whoops I didn't notice that! Blush That will teach me to read the full post!

Sorry I didn't realise the OP said that.

@Monetm I agree that the film is overrated, but YABU to think less of someone who likes it. People have different tastes, and it's a bit rude to say that you think less of people who like it. Saying you think less of them does make you come across as if you think you're superior to people who like it, and puts you in a bit of a bad light. I don't think I am superior. I just don't like the film. That's it!

Ktime · 06/11/2023 10:01

I think the problem with WHMS is Billy Crystal. He is just not fanciable, and a romcom lead should be.

LadyBird1973 · 06/11/2023 10:00

LA is fab too. I don't care if it's a bit misogynistic and flawed - people are flawed. It's a product of its time and that's okay.
I also don't feel that all films have to be diverse and reflect modern values - irl people don't always have diverse friendship groups or all agree on what the 'right' values are. Films like Pretty Woman would never have been made if we had thought too much about the reality of prostitution, for example. Some people might think that's a good thing, but I'd miss it!
My favourite of the rom coms is Notting Hill - so totally unrealistic but a lovely film nonetheless.

SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 09:57

@LadyBird1973 Thing is I am not 'judging it' as of now, I saw it about 33 years ago and thought it was crap then. There were much better 'rom com' type films about at the time, like Working Girl, Dirty Dancing, Pretty In Pink, and Pretty Woman. This was just boring and a bit crap. (IMO.)

I am sure some people will think the 4 films I named here are boring/crap. That is their right, and I don't care. I'm not going to mock them or accuse them of jumping on any bandwagon.

CanIPetThatDawg · 06/11/2023 09:57

The Op’s claim ‘I would think less of anyone who told me they loved WHMS.’ does comes across as having been written by an 11 year old who has nothing but scorn for someone who's into a different boyband to her. People are allowed like different things. People are allowed to like cheesy films. Not every single pop culture choice someone makes needs to align with your own.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 06/11/2023 09:54

SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 09:53

Who said that? Because I certainly didn't. Confused

The OP!! 🤦🏻‍♀️

SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 09:53

DrMarshaFieldstone · 06/11/2023 09:43

Have different tastes? Absolutely.

Declare that “I would think less of anyone who told me they loved WHMS”?

Not so much. That’s where the superiority comes in.

Who said that? Because I certainly didn't. Confused

LadyBird1973 · 06/11/2023 09:52

I love pretty much all rom coms, and WHMS was one of the first and best.
I think it's a mistake to judge films from the viewpoint of where we are now - of course it isn't fresh and new anymore, it's 30+ years old. We are now used to seeing women orgasm on screen but at the time, it was groundbreaking.

I love that the characters aren't perfect people, they are not stunningly beautiful all the time and have personalities that aren't universally appealing. It's very honest and real, while still having the beautiful backdrop. The supporting cast were excellent and interesting in their own right.

Skyscrapers921 · 06/11/2023 09:50

such a dull film

LaMarschallin · 06/11/2023 09:45

Also, in response to comments from upthread, I have not been 'queuing up' to say I don't like When Harry Met Sally,

I used the phrase "queue up" but about Love Actually.
I've said very little about WHMS (and I should stop posting about LA; I don't want to derail the thread).
Maybe someone else said "people were queueing up" to say they didn't like WHMS?

SocksAndTheCity · 06/11/2023 09:44

I don't think it's aged particularly well, but I can't loathe anything with Carrie Fisher in it. I haven't seen Love Actually or Holiday though, so I don't really have a comparison there.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 06/11/2023 09:43

CesareBorgia · 06/11/2023 09:41

Are people not allowed to have different tastes without being accused of feeling superior?

Have different tastes? Absolutely.

Declare that “I would think less of anyone who told me they loved WHMS”?

Not so much. That’s where the superiority comes in.

CesareBorgia · 06/11/2023 09:41

Busephalus · 06/11/2023 08:14

Basically you're saying you have superior tastes to the people who like it

Are people not allowed to have different tastes without being accused of feeling superior?

SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 09:37

I like Love Actually, but really dislike the scenes where the young couple are making a porn film. It could have done without that and taints the film a bit IMO.

Also, in response to comments from upthread, I have not been 'queuing up' to say I don't like When Harry Met Sally, I literally just came on here just after 9am today and saw this thread. Confused I don't care if anyone thinks I am jumping on some kind of bandwagon, I'm not going to say it's great and I loved it, when I thought it was crap. I love Meg Ryan and Billy Crystal, but this was hogwash IMO.

And it's not a case of 'well, everyone else likes it' either. This thread illustrates that many people don't like it,, as many of the comments are from people who dislike it. Also, the poll result (at 9.37am today,) says that 45% of people who have voted don't like it!

No need to be offended and feel slighted, because other people don't like the film you liked. Everyone is entitled to their opinion you know. Confused

LaMarschallin · 06/11/2023 09:35

In fairness, that Jezebel article isn’t wrong. The film is a vapid love letter to misogyny wrapped up in Richard Curtis’s trademark cosy schtik.

QED

My only point was that I was surprised that someone had missed all such articles, posts etc about LA and thought people would think their taste weird.

Edit:
I am glad that everyone else has caught up with me twenty years later

Again, you'd be surprised how many people have now said how they spotted all the problems with it when it first came out.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 06/11/2023 09:35

CanIPetThatDawg · 06/11/2023 09:22

I thought this was the most common 21st century opinion of "Love Actually".
People queue up now to say how much they've never liked it, even when everyone else did etc

Absolutely. Lol at someone thinking they're going against the grain by disliking Love Actually. Anytime someone on MN says they like it they’re peppered with ‘Well actually’ responses linking them to some article that dissects all the awfulness that apparently lies within that film.

I have a very clear memory of seeing Love Actually for the first time. It came out on my birthday in my final year of uni and I planned a break from writing my dissertation to take myself to the cinema and see it on my own as a birthday treat. I was really excited about the cast (Alan Rickman! Emma Thompson! Liam Neeson!) and I was so, so disappointed. I couldn’t believe that something could be so much less than the sum of its parts.

I am glad that everyone else has caught up with me twenty years later Grin.

Slipknotted · 06/11/2023 09:29

CanIPetThatDawg · 06/11/2023 09:22

I thought this was the most common 21st century opinion of "Love Actually".
People queue up now to say how much they've never liked it, even when everyone else did etc

Absolutely. Lol at someone thinking they're going against the grain by disliking Love Actually. Anytime someone on MN says they like it they’re peppered with ‘Well actually’ responses linking them to some article that dissects all the awfulness that apparently lies within that film.

In fairness, that Jezebel article isn’t wrong. The film is a vapid love letter to misogyny wrapped up in Richard Curtis’s trademark cosy schtik.

CanIPetThatDawg · 06/11/2023 09:22

I thought this was the most common 21st century opinion of "Love Actually".
People queue up now to say how much they've never liked it, even when everyone else did etc

Absolutely. Lol at someone thinking they're going against the grain by disliking Love Actually. Anytime someone on MN says they like it they’re peppered with ‘Well actually’ responses linking them to some article that dissects all the awfulness that apparently lies within that film.

Ididivfama · 06/11/2023 09:19

So much smarter and more feminist than love actually despite being made in the 80s!

LaMarschallin · 06/11/2023 09:18

I loved the clothes in The Holiday

Lelophants · 06/11/2023 09:17

I love it because it’s funny whilst still being touching, appropriate and not full of sexist tropes like many modern romcoms. There were lots of fun bits throughout and very festive.

CanIPetThatDawg · 06/11/2023 09:17

I really didn't like The Holiday. Felt like a romcom written by a marketing team.

CanIPetThatDawg · 06/11/2023 09:16

For some reason I've never seen WHMS but keep meaning to rectify that. I enjoy that 1980s NYC vibe.

I'm not a massive romcom fan overall but really love While You Were Sleeping because Sandra Bullock and Bill Pullman have such great chemistry, and there are lots of great supporting characters.

SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 09:15

Agree @Monetm I have only watched it once and was bored stiff.

1 hour and 36 minutes of my life I will never get back. Confused Utter drivel. Only famous for 'that' scene! Greatest romcom of all time? LOL don't make me laugh! 😆

LaurieStrode · 06/11/2023 09:11

Saw it a year ago for the first time and thought it was idiotic cringe.