Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never got the fuss about ‘When Harry Met Sally’

207 replies

Monetm · 05/11/2023 21:20

Just reading a review of Meg Ryan’s new romcom which compares it to When Harry Met Sally as if the latter was some kind of holy grail of filmmaking. AIBU to remember it as a pretty white bread and basic film that has some decent performances and doesn’t actively insult your intelligence, but really isn’t anything special? The speech Billy Crystal gives her at the end about how he loves the little crease in her forehead, or whatever it is, I honestly find really cheesy and cringe. I don’t particularly think they have chemistry. I liked Meg Ryan better in ‘In the Cut’. I would think less of anyone who told me they loved WHMS.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Ktime · 06/11/2023 15:03

the80sweregreat · 06/11/2023 12:56

I've never seen ' the holiday ' the whole way through , but Jude law is so hammy in it , it put me off watching all of it.
I do like ' leap year' as the two leads are endearing and although it's predictable and has many plot holes and tropes , it is just watchable nonsense. Not as good as 'when Harry met Sally ' or even 'sleepless in Seattle' but still one of my favourites ( along with Muriel's wedding , which is utterly brilliant , but not a rom com)

Yes Jude was hammy in it. I think we were supposed to be bowled over by the fact that his character cries 🙄

DrMarshaFieldstone · 06/11/2023 14:16

AgingDisgracefullyHere · 06/11/2023 14:08

Has anyone seen the original version of You've Got Mail? It's called The Little Shop Around the Corner. It's an American movie with American actors, but it is clearly set in Eastern Europe. It's a good film.

That's why Kathleen's bookshop in YGM is called The Shop Around the Corner! It's a deliberate homage.

Notonthestairs · 06/11/2023 14:11

MasterBeth · 06/11/2023 11:16

This is a brilliant explanation of why When Harry Met Sally is glorious:

https://shows.acast.com/a18c2026-fb61-4cb6-a153-32d529de0a07/eb6b4407-202a-464f-91d3-3fc04a633d17

Loved this! Thank you.

AgingDisgracefullyHere · 06/11/2023 14:08

Has anyone seen the original version of You've Got Mail? It's called The Little Shop Around the Corner. It's an American movie with American actors, but it is clearly set in Eastern Europe. It's a good film.

ButterMyParsnip · 06/11/2023 13:46

I can't even remember watching When Harry Met Sally. I did like You've Got Mail though. A nice bit of easy watching on a dreary day when I can't be arse to go out or think.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 06/11/2023 13:11

I never got it either!
And lets be honest if you ask, most people only remember the 'I'll have what she's having!' Scene, which i found cringy.

ABetterBitOfButter · 06/11/2023 13:01

I absolutely love WHMS. The dialogue is fabulous. Nora Ephron was an incredibly witty writer.

Someone upthread mentioned the couples talking about their relationships. I always quote the woman who says, 'And I knew. I knew the way you know about a good melon' when people ask me about when I met DH for the first time.

It's full of great lines. 'You are a human affront to all women, and I am a woman.'

And,

<whispered> 'Someone is staring at you in Personal Growth.'

It's fab.

the80sweregreat · 06/11/2023 12:56

I've never seen ' the holiday ' the whole way through , but Jude law is so hammy in it , it put me off watching all of it.
I do like ' leap year' as the two leads are endearing and although it's predictable and has many plot holes and tropes , it is just watchable nonsense. Not as good as 'when Harry met Sally ' or even 'sleepless in Seattle' but still one of my favourites ( along with Muriel's wedding , which is utterly brilliant , but not a rom com)

Ktime · 06/11/2023 12:51

beguilingeyes · 06/11/2023 11:47

I didn't like WHMS the first time I saw it. It bears repeated watching, possibly when a bit older, because I bloody love it now. It's a great NYE film.
Norah Efron is a stone cold genius and I doubt she needs to rip off Woody Allen, or indeed anyone else.
We went to see Oklahoma in the theatre recently and giggled all the way through Surrey With The Fringe On Top.
I hated The Holiday, mostly because Jack Black. Talk about unfanciable.leads. Kate Winslet really drew the short straw with that one...and.really.annoyingly for a Bristolian...Cary Grant was born in BRISTOL!

I hate The Holiday, I agree, Jack Black was bad casting. I’m also not a Jude Law fan.

Ktime · 06/11/2023 12:49

1975wasthebest · 06/11/2023 11:38

That's a big problem. It's too much of a leap for me to think that the gorgeous Sally would ever be interested in Harry. He was totally wrong for the part, and ridiculous he could pass for being in the scenes set in 1977. Tom Hanks was offered the role and would have been so much better.

The film itself is funny at times but not often. Let's face it, if it wasn't for the fake orgasm scene, the film wouldn't be remembered as much as it is. Some elements are more enjoyable and compelling than the central relationship and script (the score, locations and Carrie Fisher's performance).

Totally agree. Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan were a great on screen couple to boot.

I feel like we’ve missed out now, I wish he’s accepted the role.

m I’m sad Nora is gone, wish she’d given us more films.

NCGrandParent · 06/11/2023 12:37

That podcast is an excellent description of why it's considered the ultimate. So many points I hadn't considered before. So if OP genuinely wants a description of reasons why it's considered so highly, recommend a listen!

1975wasthebest · 06/11/2023 12:03

I was too late to edit...

He was totally wrong for the part, and ridiculous he could pass for being in his early 20s in the scenes set in 1977.

DaggerIsle · 06/11/2023 12:02

I like the film but find the love story ultimately quite disappointing.
Harry is very smug and quite pass agg/dismissive about Sally.
He spends decades mocking her and leads her on, then decides to go for it and she falls in his arms? Meh.

Carrie Fisher makes the film.

NCGrandParent · 06/11/2023 11:57

Judge it on its own terms OP! It's a very classy and classic romantic comedy of its time. Written by an absolute giant of writing about middle class middle aged (white) New Yorkers (Nora Ephron) and with genius dialogue. As a PP has said, the "side characters" are better drawn and acted than most main characters in a room com of the last 20 years. And the character development of Harry and Sally is plausible and charming.

If that type of film isn't your thing then fine. You're not going to like it. But if rom coms are your thing, what bugs you about it? And which other films of that type do you prefer?

beguilingeyes · 06/11/2023 11:47

Also,.the Reuben at Katz's Deli is the best sandwich in the world.

beguilingeyes · 06/11/2023 11:47

I didn't like WHMS the first time I saw it. It bears repeated watching, possibly when a bit older, because I bloody love it now. It's a great NYE film.
Norah Efron is a stone cold genius and I doubt she needs to rip off Woody Allen, or indeed anyone else.
We went to see Oklahoma in the theatre recently and giggled all the way through Surrey With The Fringe On Top.
I hated The Holiday, mostly because Jack Black. Talk about unfanciable.leads. Kate Winslet really drew the short straw with that one...and.really.annoyingly for a Bristolian...Cary Grant was born in BRISTOL!

1975wasthebest · 06/11/2023 11:38

Ktime · 06/11/2023 10:01

I think the problem with WHMS is Billy Crystal. He is just not fanciable, and a romcom lead should be.

That's a big problem. It's too much of a leap for me to think that the gorgeous Sally would ever be interested in Harry. He was totally wrong for the part, and ridiculous he could pass for being in the scenes set in 1977. Tom Hanks was offered the role and would have been so much better.

The film itself is funny at times but not often. Let's face it, if it wasn't for the fake orgasm scene, the film wouldn't be remembered as much as it is. Some elements are more enjoyable and compelling than the central relationship and script (the score, locations and Carrie Fisher's performance).

the80sweregreat · 06/11/2023 11:14

Duckie would have been better boyfriend material , but Andrew McCarthy's eyes .,
Love When Harry met Sally
I agree that Carrie fisher is brilliant, the music , the way Harry kind of grows up so much, but never loses his cynicism!

tothesea · 06/11/2023 11:08

Team Duckie here!

LadyBird1973 · 06/11/2023 10:24

That dress was a monstrosity in Pretty in Pink! Also she chose the wrong boy - as beautiful as Andrew McCarthy is, she would have been better off with Duckie

CanIPetThatDawg · 06/11/2023 10:09

SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 09:57

@LadyBird1973 Thing is I am not 'judging it' as of now, I saw it about 33 years ago and thought it was crap then. There were much better 'rom com' type films about at the time, like Working Girl, Dirty Dancing, Pretty In Pink, and Pretty Woman. This was just boring and a bit crap. (IMO.)

I am sure some people will think the 4 films I named here are boring/crap. That is their right, and I don't care. I'm not going to mock them or accuse them of jumping on any bandwagon.

I love Working Girl. So 80s.loved Pretty in Pink (aside from when she commits fashion crimes against the dress). Haven't seen either in an age.

Never got the fuss with Dirty Dancing.

SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 10:06

LadyBird1973 · 06/11/2023 10:03

@SweetBirdsong I adored Dirty Dancing, but the older I get, the more I identify with the dad and think no way would I be happy if my teenage daughter was hanging around with an older, failed dancer who had no prospects and made money by shagging bored rich housewives! But as a teen I was sooo jealous of Baby!

Yeah I have thought that too recently! After seeing Martin and Katy on Classi Corrie! Shock A man of 35 and a girl of 16. I think Baby in DD is meant to be 16, but I am never sure of Johnny's age. (Late 20s or so?) (off to google...)

EDIT!

Johnny is meant to be 25! But Patrick Swayze was 35 when the film was released (so probably 34 when it was filmed!) He was old enough to be her dad (In real life.) Jennifer Grey who played Baby was actually only 17 when the film was released.) So probably actually 16 when it was made.

SweetBirdsong · 06/11/2023 10:04

@LadyBird1973 Oooh I forgot about Notting Hill, yep great film. And yes to Love Actually. I enjoy this every Christmas! 🎄 (As I said, the only bit(s) I dislike in it are the couple making the porn film.)

LadyBird1973 · 06/11/2023 10:03

@SweetBirdsong I adored Dirty Dancing, but the older I get, the more I identify with the dad and think no way would I be happy if my teenage daughter was hanging around with an older, failed dancer who had no prospects and made money by shagging bored rich housewives! But as a teen I was sooo jealous of Baby!

Swipe left for the next trending thread