Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never got the fuss about ‘When Harry Met Sally’

207 replies

Monetm · 05/11/2023 21:20

Just reading a review of Meg Ryan’s new romcom which compares it to When Harry Met Sally as if the latter was some kind of holy grail of filmmaking. AIBU to remember it as a pretty white bread and basic film that has some decent performances and doesn’t actively insult your intelligence, but really isn’t anything special? The speech Billy Crystal gives her at the end about how he loves the little crease in her forehead, or whatever it is, I honestly find really cheesy and cringe. I don’t particularly think they have chemistry. I liked Meg Ryan better in ‘In the Cut’. I would think less of anyone who told me they loved WHMS.

AIBU?

OP posts:
LaLaLouella · 08/11/2023 19:40

When Harry Met Sally is a wonderful film - the writing, acting, music are all just fabulous!

I probably find myself quoting a line from it at least once a week... Smile

BeaLola · 08/11/2023 19:36

I have already commented earlier about how much I like it but reading sone of these comments has reminded me just how good it is - I think every time I watch it I see something new/recall why I like something etc and yes the vignettes and he music - just lovely

Monetm · 08/11/2023 19:33

I’m not a massive fan of romcoms in general, but I find both of those fresh, original and funny

OP posts:
Monetm · 08/11/2023 19:31

LarkspurLane · 08/11/2023 18:35

OP, can you list some better romcoms?

There are films out there that I think are better than WHMS but I think it rules the romcom genre quite easily.

It Happened One Night

Four Weddings and a Funeral

OP posts:
Aydel · 08/11/2023 19:19

I love it, it’s one of my favourite films.

GarethSouthgatesWaistcoat · 08/11/2023 19:05

RedSuedePump · 06/11/2023 06:35

it’s one of my favourite films - Nora Ephron is such a brilliant writer, the dialogue and the way it’s delivered is really special. i love how it shows mature adults with all their foibles and flaws but still makes them likeable. great supporting characters in Bruno Kirby and Carrie Fisher (‘you’re right you’re right i know you’re right”). plus stunning NYC locations through the seasons. great kate 80s clothes. it’s festive too. and has a great soundtrack. Billy Crystal being Billy Crystal. And Meg Ryan at the height of her rom com powers. I love it.

Agreed!

GarethSouthgatesWaistcoat · 08/11/2023 18:53

I feel like it was of its time? I was only 7 when it came out so it passed me by but I remember the hype. I love watching 70s and 80s movies for the nostalgia and storytelling 🙂

Was it a sort of 'revolutionary' anti-romcom of the era? I only actually watched it a couple of years ago and didn't love Billy Crystal as a romantic lead but appreciate he was a big deal at the time with his fast talking/self deprecating humour.

LarkspurLane · 08/11/2023 18:35

OP, can you list some better romcoms?

There are films out there that I think are better than WHMS but I think it rules the romcom genre quite easily.

EarthlyNightshade · 08/11/2023 18:32

Love it, especially Carrie Fisher.
When she finds out someone in her box of files is married, she turns down the corner of the file.

I am interested in those who don't think it's a great romcom, which ones are better?

DrMarshaFieldstone · 08/11/2023 18:22

threecupsofteaminimum · 08/11/2023 18:06

Never seen it, doesn't appeal to me at all.

Exactly the sort of sparkling content that keeps me coming back to MN.

Justleaveitblankthen · 08/11/2023 18:21

Yes, Carrie Fisher was brilliant in everything and a very talented and funny writer.
Postcards From The Edge was superb.
Also great as a cameo in SATC.

Zebedee55 · 08/11/2023 18:10

The film was of its day. Funny then, probably not now.

threecupsofteaminimum · 08/11/2023 18:06

Never seen it, doesn't appeal to me at all.

SheerLucks · 08/11/2023 16:22

I watched WHMS last night with my DD16.

It actually seemed very low key and ordinary, but with massive sexual content in the dialogue all the way through!

My DD said it was more sexcom than romcom.

MasterBeth · 08/11/2023 13:22

Children don't have to be young children.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 07/11/2023 20:16

SheerLucks · 07/11/2023 19:56

I thought Love Actually was one of the most cynical and patronising films I've ever seen. I literally felt soiled when I left the cinema.

But I know many people in their 20s and 30s who rate it as one of their all time favourites - I think it's because they saw it as children at Christmas with their parents, and it gives them a warm, fuzzy feeling that has very little to do with the quality of the film.

People show Love Actually to their children?!

SheerLucks · 07/11/2023 19:56

CanIPetThatDawg · 06/11/2023 09:22

I thought this was the most common 21st century opinion of "Love Actually".
People queue up now to say how much they've never liked it, even when everyone else did etc

Absolutely. Lol at someone thinking they're going against the grain by disliking Love Actually. Anytime someone on MN says they like it they’re peppered with ‘Well actually’ responses linking them to some article that dissects all the awfulness that apparently lies within that film.

I thought Love Actually was one of the most cynical and patronising films I've ever seen. I literally felt soiled when I left the cinema.

But I know many people in their 20s and 30s who rate it as one of their all time favourites - I think it's because they saw it as children at Christmas with their parents, and it gives them a warm, fuzzy feeling that has very little to do with the quality of the film.

LizzieW1969 · 07/11/2023 19:33

HeavenCANTwait · 07/11/2023 17:31

Incredibly original

Anyone watching it now would shrug - and that's because almost Rom coms copy it!

It's so funny, the characters are beautifully drawn and there's loads of chemistry between them

Carrie Fisher staying with that twat - "He's NEVER going to leave her"

"OF COURSE HE ISNT"

Lol, yes I loved that line. Another line of hers I really like comes when Jess and Marie are buying furniture for their new home and Jess wanted to buy a coffee table that she hated. Harry said cynically, ‘In 10 years time you’ll be fighting over who keeps that coffee table.’ Marie then says to Jess, ‘Don’t worry, I’ll never fight you for that coffee table.’

Yes, Carrie Fisher was perfect for that role.

NCGrandParent · 07/11/2023 19:28

@WitcheryDivine I feel like you maybe have t watched the film! It's the absolute opposite of the "pick me" genre of rom com. She thinks he's a twat for most of the movie. He IS a twat for most of the movie! I beg any cynics about it but have a love of writing and film to listen to the podcast recommended above. It beautifully highlights all the ways it is a very smart deconstruction of the genre

mathanxiety · 07/11/2023 17:51

I agree with @Crikeyalmighty - yy, it has a feel of Woody Allen films. It's the neurotic NY feel, and the love for the city itself that shines through.

Needhelp101 · 07/11/2023 17:51

So many good lines!

"She doesn't have a problem with chins"

Also that wonderful scene where Sally takes him to task about his attitude to women, "And I will make love with someone when it is making love, not like you, like I'm out for revenge or something!"

And then he asks if he can say something, and apologises ❤️

mathanxiety · 07/11/2023 17:50

It's a really funny comedy and an ode to NYC.

You don't have to think it's the greatest rom com ever, but it is really memorable, with characters and relationships amongst them really well fleshed out in ways very few rom coms do, wit everywhere, and timing really nailed.

HeavenCANTwait · 07/11/2023 17:31

Incredibly original

Anyone watching it now would shrug - and that's because almost Rom coms copy it!

It's so funny, the characters are beautifully drawn and there's loads of chemistry between them

Carrie Fisher staying with that twat - "He's NEVER going to leave her"

"OF COURSE HE ISNT"

WitcheryDivine · 07/11/2023 16:58

I agree OP I think it's ok at best. I do hate the kind of romcoms that are mainly about a woman being kind of emotional and hopeless and waiting for a (usually dead ordinary, not exciting, not especially good looking) man to "choose" her. Don't get the charm of the story at all.

This one was particularly weird because Billy Crystal was so obviously quite a lot older than Meg Ryan.

I also HATE You've Got Mail, but for different reasons.

There are loads of romcoms I love though.

LadyBird1973 · 07/11/2023 16:36

In the spirit of this thread I rented WHMS from Sky this morning and rewatched. It's still so funny and sweet. I think Billy Crystal was perfect and agree that Tom Hank's would have been all wrong for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread