Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep my kid in their state school now I'm a millionaire?

66 replies

evinalina · 05/11/2023 19:51

Sorry, I'm not a millionaire, but I'm having my "if I were a millionaire" daydream.

My DC goes to a state school, nothing special, one form entry, but we like it, he likes it, he has nice friends . I always think if we won the lottery then we would definitely move house , a probably further away from the school and in an area where the houses are much bigger than ours, and the area is a bit "posher"

Would it be weird to transition in to a rich persons "lifestyle" (by means of where we live and what we could afford to do) and leave my child in their happy school, who would then probably want to join the now local state school with his friends???

I'll wake up soon.

OP posts:
Skyscrapers921 · 06/11/2023 09:28

I went to a rich person's private school. It was miserable.

SoGladofYou · 06/11/2023 08:58

But becoming a millionaire won’t fundamentally change who you are, and so transferring to a rich person’s lifestyle doesn’t mean that you would simply take on that persona. And as other posters have said, private education isn’t necessarily better. So if you found yourself in that position, do your homework and then decide what the intrinsic ‘you’ would feel most comfortable with.

PuttingDownRoots · 06/11/2023 08:51

Money gets you choice. A better catchment area, extra curricular, tutors, private school...
You get the luxury of choosing the better option for you.

WhatsCookingFlora · 06/11/2023 08:44

Not at all! I think we'd stay up north rather than moving back down south, even if we could suddenly afford the houses and private school too!

Shopkinsprincess1986 · 06/11/2023 08:00

As a teacher in the state sector, if I could possibly afford it I’d get my child into the private sector and never look back. I always look at these threads praising the local state schools and chortle. You’d be horrified knowing what goes on day in day out- not on an open afternoon or on a website but walking into yet another disrupted lesson on any given day. Lack of money, hardly any decent qualified teachers, classrooms falling to bits, behaviour disrupting most lessons. Big standard teachers dealing with severe SEN due to lack of specialist places and a drive for “inclusivity” - most teachers can’t meet their needs (reality) and the amount of time on that 1:1 severely affects your standard NT child. Your bright state pupil, if they are keeping up and making standard will be looked over. They won’t be pushed. You’ll never hear it from the school. Your GCSE maths pupil is prob being taught by a teacher who has no expertise in the subject due to teacher shortage. As for “you can’t buy brains” - if you only knew. You certainly can buy opportunity, expertise and life chances. I’d go private and never look back. Sorry if that bites, but it’s the reality.

Saschka · 06/11/2023 07:49

rockinginarockingchair · 05/11/2023 22:16

I dont know why we have schools when kids can learn the same thing at home with the click of a button.
It's like its a place to send children to see other children like a large day care center.

Social contact is an important part of a child’s education! As well as games, art, music etc, which they can’t learn online.

I think lockdown demonstrated clearly that homeschooling large swathes of children doesn’t work especially well. You need a very motivated parent supervising, and they need to know what they are doing, and that is not the case for the majority.

Saschka · 06/11/2023 07:42

SallyWD · 06/11/2023 07:32

Who knows, she might have been bullied at private school too. Most kids at private school have "normal" parents rather than world superstar parents so she would still have stuck out like a sore thumb. It's not like bullying doesn't happen at private schools!

Oh agreed, I was thinking of the kind of exclusive private school where the other children are literal princesses, or children of Russian oligarchs! Not just the local prep.

PoloMintRoll · 06/11/2023 07:41

Plenty of wealthy and successful people send their children to state schools. Probably because they themselves were state educated and have done well in life.

Busephalus · 06/11/2023 07:41

Jayjayel - completely agree

x2boys · 06/11/2023 07:38

I bet you wouldd,nt if the local school was a shit hole....

SallyWD · 06/11/2023 07:32

Saschka · 05/11/2023 21:07

Stella McCartney claims she was horribly bullied though, and would never send her own children to state! So not sure that is a success story.

There comes a point where having famous millionaire parents does paint a bit of a target on your back. Fortunately not something either I or DS will ever need to worry about.

Who knows, she might have been bullied at private school too. Most kids at private school have "normal" parents rather than world superstar parents so she would still have stuck out like a sore thumb. It's not like bullying doesn't happen at private schools!

rockinginarockingchair · 05/11/2023 22:16

I dont know why we have schools when kids can learn the same thing at home with the click of a button.
It's like its a place to send children to see other children like a large day care center.

JayJayEl · 05/11/2023 21:36

evinalina · 05/11/2023 19:54

Not even necessary a private school, but to move to the school in the catchment area where the majority of families would be in the same financial position?

As a former primary school teacher, I worked in inner-city schools all over England and Wales at the polar opposite ends of community demographics - some in well off areas (think doctor and lawyer parents) and some in very, very poor areas (think children being exposed to gun violence - yes, really!), and everything in between.

I can tell you that the absolute best schools are in the poorer areas. Schools receive more money per head of pupil, and much more easily get accepted for grants so there is more money to work with. The teaching staff are often the best of the best because they are there to truly make a difference and need to tackle many more issues, not just to do the work and pay the bills. Parents are usually grateful for what you are doing for their children, rather than having increasingly more unreasonable expectations and demands. (Obviously these are stereotypes, but stereotypes usually exist because of some sort of truth.) In short, people in working class areas are just much nicer - proper communities!

Also, city schools in affluent areas tend to made up of majority white, Christian families. Where most of the children have cookie-cutter lives, backgrounds and experiences. Given the choice, I would pick a school with a more multicultural population so that my children's education and life experience will be much more diverse!

So, if money were no object, would I send my child to a private school over a state school? No. And I also (probably) wouldn't send them to a school in an incredibly affluent area, for the above reasons! Goes without saying it would depend on the school (probs would avoid the extreme end of my experience where there was gun violence exposure!) but the above is my personal experience.

Wow - that was a long answer to a completely hypothetical question. 🙈

PrinnyPree · 05/11/2023 21:24

I wouldn't, especially if my child was happy and had good friends. In fact if they were secondary school aged I would be asking what they wanted.

I don't really believe in private schools though as I don't think some children should have a leg up because of the wealth of their parents rather than merit or need. Having said that I am privileged to live in an area with really good state schools (and I'm sure a few millionaires just send to local state, especially to the primary schools) so maybe if the locals schools were shite, with overwhelmed and overworked teaching staff and high levels of bullying my principals would change if I became a lottery winner...

Saschka · 05/11/2023 21:07

SallyWD · 05/11/2023 20:22

I grew up near Paul McCartney. His kids went to the local state school. I'd do the same if I was a millionaire.

Stella McCartney claims she was horribly bullied though, and would never send her own children to state! So not sure that is a success story.

There comes a point where having famous millionaire parents does paint a bit of a target on your back. Fortunately not something either I or DS will ever need to worry about.

Saschka · 05/11/2023 21:00

evinalina · 05/11/2023 19:57

@ConsuelaHammock well exactly! My DC is completely average, and I'd much rather him stay happy and content than try to buy brains .

To be honest, average kids are probably the ones who most benefit from private school, as they get the most benefit from 1:1 personalised tuition. A super-brainy kid can only improve so much! If they were likely to get an A* anyway, private school just smooths the way. Whereas a B/C kid could be lifted up into getting As with the right teaching.

Anyway, no if you won the lottery I’d keep your child where you think they will be happiest. I moved primary schools (and houses) 5 times due to my dad’s job, and it was hugely disruptive - I had some great experiences, but I’m determined DS is not going to move schools unless it is essential.

You don’t want your child to stick out as “the posh kid” if they currently go to school in a really deprived area, but in an average town, there will be a mix of rich and poor in most state secondaries.

Chromium24 · 05/11/2023 20:50

quite a few mumsnetters will congrat you on this perspective,

fyn · 05/11/2023 20:49

We intended to send our children to a state school, we moved into a catchment of a primary school ranked by the Times in the top 100 state primaries. Went to the open day and there was just absolutely no way I was leaving my DC there. It was a chaotic two form entry, the open day was entirely conducted by children and we didn’t once speak to an adult, children kicking off in the classes we observed and parents swearing at the school gates.

We went to the local private school and the atmosphere couldn’t have been nicer, polite children, no swearing, ability to talk to adults, great facilities. If it was a lovely little one form village school then maybe but that isn’t an option for us at present!

mondaytosunday · 05/11/2023 20:47

My kids went to private school. They came from all over and parents were from 'just about affording it' to 'could have bankrolled the whole school'.
'Rich kids' don't just hang out with rich kids.
As for state, I imagine as they have to be local and you lived in an upmarket area they would be of similar affluence, but would you take your child away from where he's happy?

AllstarFacilier · 05/11/2023 20:38

After seeing some of the staff leave the school I work at to work in the public schools nearby, I wouldn’t pay for my kids to be taught by them.

Xenia · 05/11/2023 20:34

The good academic private schools choose the pupils not vice versa. Most who sit the exams fail to get in even if the parents are worth millions. So it would depend on his IQ if he got into a good one.

gotomomo · 05/11/2023 20:30

It's quite location dependent, here all kids go to the local primary school even the genuine Hollywood stars kid, it's 45 mins through heavy traffic to the nearest private primary so you have to seriously consider if that is in your child's interest. A few go fir secondary but it's 30 minutes on the bus then a 25 minute walk

mrsmalcolmreynolds · 05/11/2023 20:27

DH and I are millionaires I guess in that we have over £2m of assets between us (excluding pension savings). This is partly from our savings and property appreciation and also my (middle class professional) parents both died in their early 70s before they got to spend a lot of their own savings.

We could afford to send DC to private school but don't - our local state schools are good and also we live in a v naice area swimming in privilege already and we want our kids to have at least some sense of what real life is like. We see a lot of private school kids at their sports clubs etc and lots (not all) are entitled little so and sos.

Echobelly · 05/11/2023 20:26

I don't think I'd move my kids if I suddenly came into loads of money, they're happy at their state school and it's a very good one and I don't think we'd move to a wildly different area.

WrongSwanson · 05/11/2023 20:26

All the private schools round here get worse results than the state so I wouldn't move mine. I don't know what the parents are paying for but they aren't "buying brains"