Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Layton Williams in Strictly

337 replies

Char65 · 05/11/2023 19:23

I am a big fan of Strictly but I have lost interest in it this year because of Layton Williams as he is a professional dance. His CV reads

2007–2008: Billy Elliot the Musical
2008–2009: Beautiful People
2016: Hairspray the Musical UK Tour - playing Duane
2016-2017: Rent UK Tour - playing Angel
2017-2018: Hairspray the Musical UK Tour - playing Seaweed J. Stubbs
2018-2019: Kiss Me Kate - playing Bill Calhoun/Luciento
2019-2022: Everyone's Talking About Jamie - playing Jamie New

He was also in a Michael Jackson show - and I believe Jackson could dance a bit!

To me its no fair to pitch a pro against amateurs though I accept a lot of actors have also done dance at stage school but not appeared in the West End like this guy! What do others think?

OP posts:
Samcro · 15/11/2023 16:24

he won't win. if he ends up in the DO the judges will say that they don't understand why he is there. happens every time. I wish they would be honest and accept that obvious ringers don't win.
I enjoy watching him and he seems nice.

peakedatseven · 15/11/2023 16:11

I keep seeing claims that Layton is more of a ringer than anybody else they’ve ever had on but is he actually more of a ringer than Ashley from Pussycat Dolls? I would put them on the same level of dance experience.

I like watching Layton and Nikita dance together and think he has actually been improving. Not on the level of improvement as some of the others given his starting point, but still improving. He won’t win (I think Ellie will) but I’ll enjoy watching him when he’s dancing.

JoanThursday1972 · 15/11/2023 15:55

Would you like to see a whole cohort of Krishnans?

LizzBurg · 15/11/2023 15:44

Char65 · 15/11/2023 07:48

It doesn't matter how nice Layton is the question was should a professional dancer be allowed to compete on Strictly? and 82% of voters said "no".

I think what annoys me and I guess a lot of people is the BBC trying to 'pretend' he is a 'celebrity' and not a pro dancer. I was never keen on Krishnan but was impressed by how he improved as a dancer (with little or no dance knowledge) from week one until Sunday when he was voted out and too me that's what its all about. Its the same with the results show and the BBC pretending its 'live' - which is a another whole topic!

the question was should a professional dancer be allowed to compete on Strictly? and 82% of voters said "no".

well if 82% of MN voters say so bin him off. I think you’ll find that nowhere does it say that a dancer cannot participate in the show. Krishnan was great, he said it was life changing. Yes life changing so having Layton dance hasn’t ruined the whole experience. And do you know why that is? Because Layton’s involvement has no bearing on the other contestants experience on Strictly.

LizzBurg · 15/11/2023 15:25

Comefromaway · 15/11/2023 11:49

I expect the correct thing to say is that in 2015 he was working as a professional dancer in one of the UK's leading dance companies.

My daughter is a professional dancer but she also works in panto, theatre in education, teaching and front of house in a theatre. The other jobs don't make her any less of a professional dancer though.

And if a tiktok or something went viral and she became known to some of the audience, like Joe Sugg for example and she was asked to compete on Strictly…….would she do it?

Trina90 · 15/11/2023 13:55

KingsleyBorder · 15/11/2023 11:19

As someone said, it’s a TV show, not the Olympics. They only get a trophy for winning! Just chill and enjoy it?

Yeah.

Cant wait to see him and Nikita dance again on Saturday. 😆

Comefromaway · 15/11/2023 11:49

I expect the correct thing to say is that in 2015 he was working as a professional dancer in one of the UK's leading dance companies.

My daughter is a professional dancer but she also works in panto, theatre in education, teaching and front of house in a theatre. The other jobs don't make her any less of a professional dancer though.

CatOnTheCludgy · 15/11/2023 11:35

I don't think he should be a contestant. However HOWEVER he sure can dance! That Argentine Tango was beautiful. Just wow.
But it's not exactly much of a 'journey' for him is it

Comefromaway · 15/11/2023 11:33

A performer with a leading dance company is a professional dancer. yes, he can do other stuff. You often get dancers branching out into other genres such as musicals or TV acting. But he is a professional dancer.

KingsleyBorder · 15/11/2023 11:19

As someone said, it’s a TV show, not the Olympics. They only get a trophy for winning! Just chill and enjoy it?

KingsleyBorder · 15/11/2023 11:17

I’m not disputing that he is someone who gets paid to dance. But his job is performer, not dancer. He’s a GP not a surgeon.

cathyandclaire · 15/11/2023 11:07

He’s a triple threat, like Nigel/ Danny Mac/ Denise Van Outen/ Tom Chambers/ many many others. He is an excellent dancer but he’s not just a dancer- unlike Ashley for example who really only danced and judged dancing, in the PCD they didn’t even sing usually.

Many many MT performers do masterclasses, it helps pay the bills during down time, at DDs’ dance school loads of MT ‘stars’ come and do sessions. they would not define themselves as dancers, they’re singers/actors/ dancers.

Comefromaway · 15/11/2023 10:54

He IS a professional dancer. He toured with leading dance company New Adventures (the company made famous by Matthew Bourne's all male Swan Lake) in their production of The Car Man a production that incorporates several different dance styles.

KingsleyBorder · 15/11/2023 10:50

He’s not a professional dancer though, he’s an actor who dances well and performs in some roles that require acting, singing and dancing. He is known to some people through roles that don’t involve dance- there wasn’t much in Bad Education albeit his character was a wannabe musical theatre star. I suspect that he would not make it to “the top” in the world of performers who specialise in dance only.

Char65 · 15/11/2023 07:48

It doesn't matter how nice Layton is the question was should a professional dancer be allowed to compete on Strictly? and 82% of voters said "no".

I think what annoys me and I guess a lot of people is the BBC trying to 'pretend' he is a 'celebrity' and not a pro dancer. I was never keen on Krishnan but was impressed by how he improved as a dancer (with little or no dance knowledge) from week one until Sunday when he was voted out and too me that's what its all about. Its the same with the results show and the BBC pretending its 'live' - which is a another whole topic!

OP posts:
LizzBurg · 14/11/2023 22:18

SoupDragon · 14/11/2023 22:03

Yes Layton has extensive dance training

you mean "is a professional dancer"

He could be the love child of Motsi and Anton for all I care. It’s a dance show, and he’s doing just that, dancing and in return they all get paid, it’s a job. Do you think the talent bookers were oblivious to his career? There’s no reason why he shouldn’t be on the show.

SoupDragon · 14/11/2023 22:03

Yes Layton has extensive dance training

you mean "is a professional dancer"

LizzBurg · 14/11/2023 20:37

Eleganz · 14/11/2023 14:36

This is page 11 of one of many threads on this topic. Like many other people Layton's inclusion has reduced my enjoyment and the entertainment value of the show to me because it is so obviously unfair.

Yes, it isn't the Olympics, but the BBC should be making entertaining quality programmes not putting professional west-end dancers against paralympians and journalists with no prior dance experience and pretending like it is a fair competition. The judges gave Jody absolutely no quarter when he was pitted against the likes of Layton, pretty disrespectful and manifestly unfair and largely unnecessary. There are limits to this and I think the BBC has pushed it too far this year.

And yes I am someone who would find the show more enjoyable if it was restricted to celebrities with little dance experience.

Edited

I came back to this post to say how well Layton came across on It Takes Two tonight but reading
The judges gave Jody absolutely no quarter when he was pitted against the likes of Layton, pretty disrespectful and manifestly unfair and largely unnecessary. There are limits to this and I think the BBC has pushed it too far this year.
The judge’s treatment of Jody was no different to that of Johnny Peacock when he competed or any other competitor with a disability, it was hardly Jody vs Layton in a dance off. Jody was competing against practically everyone. How does your theory work out when you have someone like Rose Ayling-Ellis? Had she been dancing this year she still would have had the journey and performed as amazingly as she did because she had the ability to learn and as an actor has the skills to perform. Shouldn’t Ellie, Nigel or Amanda have competed against Jody because they can act and have some dance experience too? Yes Layton has extensive dance training but why a whole section of people who claim to enjoy Strictly can’t just enjoy the dancing for what it is - a competition to win a glitterball trophy, nothing more. And if past series have shown us anything you’ll get your moment to gloat when he is the runner up. He’s in the competition, get over it because unless you’re one of the other dancers it should have no effect whatsoever on your life.

Eleganz · 14/11/2023 14:36

CroccyWoccy · 13/11/2023 16:48

Crikey, it's a light entertainment show not the Olympics!

I guess some people would prefer that they picked a bunch of entirely "average" celebs with no prior dance skills. But in more recent seasons at least they've gone for diversity - it's never really going to be "fair" to pit a paralympian who has never danced before against someone who has danced in a professional capacity but they do that every year. Does it actually matter? Celebs go into it with an understanding of how it works, the technically best dancer is rarely the winner and the people get the most from it either in the short or longer term are often not the winners.

Most recent previous series have included a ringer who gets to the final but doesn't go on to win - the fact Layton is an uber-ringer doesn't really change that. If he were 50% less outstanding he'd probably still be in the final and if anything probably MORE likely to win than he is now!

This is page 11 of one of many threads on this topic. Like many other people Layton's inclusion has reduced my enjoyment and the entertainment value of the show to me because it is so obviously unfair.

Yes, it isn't the Olympics, but the BBC should be making entertaining quality programmes not putting professional west-end dancers against paralympians and journalists with no prior dance experience and pretending like it is a fair competition. The judges gave Jody absolutely no quarter when he was pitted against the likes of Layton, pretty disrespectful and manifestly unfair and largely unnecessary. There are limits to this and I think the BBC has pushed it too far this year.

And yes I am someone who would find the show more enjoyable if it was restricted to celebrities with little dance experience.

CroccyWoccy · 13/11/2023 16:48

Crikey, it's a light entertainment show not the Olympics!

I guess some people would prefer that they picked a bunch of entirely "average" celebs with no prior dance skills. But in more recent seasons at least they've gone for diversity - it's never really going to be "fair" to pit a paralympian who has never danced before against someone who has danced in a professional capacity but they do that every year. Does it actually matter? Celebs go into it with an understanding of how it works, the technically best dancer is rarely the winner and the people get the most from it either in the short or longer term are often not the winners.

Most recent previous series have included a ringer who gets to the final but doesn't go on to win - the fact Layton is an uber-ringer doesn't really change that. If he were 50% less outstanding he'd probably still be in the final and if anything probably MORE likely to win than he is now!

Comefromaway · 13/11/2023 15:15

Nigel Harman trained as a singer/actor who was given enough dance classes in college to get by. We said several pages ago that the roles he has played in musical theatre were not dance roles. Heck, in Shrek he spent the entire show on his knees!

Layton trained as a dancer/singer who then moved into acting as a triple threat.

SoupDragon · 13/11/2023 15:09

Georgeandzippyzoo · 13/11/2023 15:07

I think YABU purely cos you're not also complaining about Nigel Harman who has also had many main roles in West end shows requiring dancing skills!

He is not a professional dancer who teaches dance.

he's only a standard level ringer.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 13/11/2023 15:07

I think YABU purely cos you're not also complaining about Nigel Harman who has also had many main roles in West end shows requiring dancing skills!

MissFancyDay · 13/11/2023 14:56

I agree, I love watching him and it's a great partnership, but it's unfair on the others. And I do think that he takes criticism quite badly, although he is getting better in that regard.

Saying that though I do look forward to his dance every week.

Swipe left for the next trending thread