Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Layton Williams in Strictly

337 replies

Char65 · 05/11/2023 19:23

I am a big fan of Strictly but I have lost interest in it this year because of Layton Williams as he is a professional dance. His CV reads

2007–2008: Billy Elliot the Musical
2008–2009: Beautiful People
2016: Hairspray the Musical UK Tour - playing Duane
2016-2017: Rent UK Tour - playing Angel
2017-2018: Hairspray the Musical UK Tour - playing Seaweed J. Stubbs
2018-2019: Kiss Me Kate - playing Bill Calhoun/Luciento
2019-2022: Everyone's Talking About Jamie - playing Jamie New

He was also in a Michael Jackson show - and I believe Jackson could dance a bit!

To me its no fair to pitch a pro against amateurs though I accept a lot of actors have also done dance at stage school but not appeared in the West End like this guy! What do others think?

OP posts:
stardust40 · 05/11/2023 21:48

I've normally given up watching as it gets boring but am actually in to it this year just to watch him and Nikita dance....bloody brilliant!! I'm not bothered about the competition he just gives awesome Saturday night tv!

HoopLaLah · 05/11/2023 21:38

PosyPrettyToes · 05/11/2023 20:16

Amanda trained to be a professional dancer prior to becoming an actor.

Angela S was in a professional Irish dancing troupe.

Nigel has the same training and a similar CV to Layton‘s, with numerous west end musicals.

Ellie trained in tap, ballet, street and modern.

So why just Layton?

“Ellie trained in tap, ballet, street and modern.”

Did she? They’ve been keeping that quiet.

Bit like when they glossed over Karim having dance training experience.

I thought it seemed unlikely that she’d never danced before looking at her ability level.

Projectme · 05/11/2023 21:36

C8H10N4O2 · 05/11/2023 21:24

Pretty much anyone in theatre/acting will have done dance training and singing as part of their training. That doesn't mean they were good at it or have continued to train and practice with dance as a key part of their profession. Their main advantage is in being experienced performers and able to "act" the parts.

Layton is on another level to that - not only highly trained but working as a dance and music performer at a high level for the last 15 years and teaching the subject.

I love watching him dance and have seen him in the theatre more than once, but pitching him against people with no professional dance experience in recent decades or at all is just silly. As pp say - no journey or improvement to enjoy. He is just too far ahead of the pack from day one.

In his late 60s Vince Cable was considered ineligible for the main Strictly contest on account of having done some amateur ballroom dancing in his youth and yet now a successful and practicing professional dancer is fine from day one.

Edited

Agree with this. Great dancer but so he should be. He's maintained his ability to dance because uts his profession. The others may have a qualification/degree etc in the subject but they've gone on to acting rather than dancing.

And I know I'm going to be slated for saying this and it's probably a really unpopular opinion but I can't stand Angela Rippon in SCD. As a presenter she's good but she comes across so smug I'm SCD! (And I know! So she should be smug, as she's knocking on 80 and I'll probably be pushing up daisy's when I'm her age, not doing the splits on the dance floor but she just sets my teeth on edge.)

HoopLaLah · 05/11/2023 21:35

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 05/11/2023 19:52

John Waite (who I assume had no previous dance experience, since he's a chef) got to the final with Johannes I think.

They've only had a few same sex couples - it's not like only one of them getting to the final is a bad track record.

John Waite did have previous dance expertise - he’d done ballet and jazz as a child/youth. It was obvious watching him.

Oganesson118 · 05/11/2023 21:33

I think there's a huge difference between someone doing some dance as a youngster and dancing being the bulk of your career for the last however many years. There's even a gulf between Nigel who did a MT degree and someone like Layton when you consider Nigel's training was over 25 years ago and he has concentrated largely on acting for the bulk of that time. Arts Ed's MT degree contains dance but is not dance intensive (based on testimonies of friends who went)

For me though, it's not solely his experience but the fact he seems incredibly cocky with it and that over exaggerated campness annoys me. The dances he and Nikita do seem every week to be "look at me!" opportunities to show off with a little bit of whatever they've been assigned shoehorned in. The bloody cartwheel made me long for the days when you'd get docked points for such shenanigans. I'm not a fan of Nikita at all either - but I'm not sure why.

LizzBurg · 05/11/2023 21:32

TheMarzipanDildo · 05/11/2023 21:13

Tbf they undermark him to take this into account so he’s rarely top of the leaderboard.

Exactly, out of 7 weeks he’s only topped the leaderboard 3 times. Even I spotted his turned in feet during his jive this week. He’s a great dancer but as Shirley says he’s still got to master the fundamentals.

SpacePotato · 05/11/2023 21:27

Hamza Yassin made me smile from ear to ear every time he danced, and that’s what I want. His dancing was just such a joy

Same. He really was a joy to watch. Javita? was fantastic with him. I think it was because it was just so unexpected. Such a shy man with a stocky build able to move so well and throw her about with such ease.

My DD preferred molly and Carlos but I found her so irritating and very stage school. It wasn't that she couldn't dance.
I feel the same about Bobby this year.

Bill Bailey was great too.

I love watching Angela Rippon dance though. Old school natural elegance and grace.

With Layton, he seems to struggle with not being front and centre so not good when Nikita needs to lead.
I liked their dance this week though.

C8H10N4O2 · 05/11/2023 21:24

PosyPrettyToes · 05/11/2023 20:16

Amanda trained to be a professional dancer prior to becoming an actor.

Angela S was in a professional Irish dancing troupe.

Nigel has the same training and a similar CV to Layton‘s, with numerous west end musicals.

Ellie trained in tap, ballet, street and modern.

So why just Layton?

Pretty much anyone in theatre/acting will have done dance training and singing as part of their training. That doesn't mean they were good at it or have continued to train and practice with dance as a key part of their profession. Their main advantage is in being experienced performers and able to "act" the parts.

Layton is on another level to that - not only highly trained but working as a dance and music performer at a high level for the last 15 years and teaching the subject.

I love watching him dance and have seen him in the theatre more than once, but pitching him against people with no professional dance experience in recent decades or at all is just silly. As pp say - no journey or improvement to enjoy. He is just too far ahead of the pack from day one.

In his late 60s Vince Cable was considered ineligible for the main Strictly contest on account of having done some amateur ballroom dancing in his youth and yet now a successful and practicing professional dancer is fine from day one.

TheMarzipanDildo · 05/11/2023 21:13

Tbf they undermark him to take this into account so he’s rarely top of the leaderboard.

Bluevelvetsofa · 05/11/2023 21:11

Jojo and John Waite were excellent and got to the final. Might have won in a different year, but no one was ever going to beat Rose.

Jayde and Karen and Gio and Richie were awful.

Nikita is really being tested this year.

I think Layton has dealt with a lot of trolling, so well done to him for keeping going. It would be difficult to find a group of slebs with no training or experience, because the fact that they mostly come from TV and theatre means they will have had some experience at stage school as a minimum.

megletthesecond · 05/11/2023 21:07

yy midnight Hamza was adorable and worked his backside off.
Layton is already an excellent dancer. No "journey".

ExtraOnions · 05/11/2023 21:07

He’s not only a trained dancer, he had led classes teaching other people how to dance.

There is a huge difference between learning some generic dancing at Drama School, and, the level of experience he has.

What gets my goat is this notion (peddled by SCD), that he’s not at an advantage. At least be honest

Mrsjayy · 05/11/2023 21:04

Can you imagine 13 Les Dennis's !

SaySomethingMan · 05/11/2023 21:04

So much hate.
He’s not the first ‘professional dancer’ to be on strictly.
I love watching him and Nikita pushing themselves week after week. They’re both very talented and it’s great they get to show it.
Nigel Harman is a trained dancer. No one is talking about his ‘advantage’.

There have been several performers from boy bands and girl bands, who usually have trained to dance and no one says anything.

“He was in a Michael Jackson show”? Come on! 🙄

Yikes101 · 05/11/2023 21:03

YABU who wants to watch a cast of duffers?

Mrsjayy · 05/11/2023 21:01

Simonjt · 05/11/2023 20:59

Yep

Flamboyant gay man maybe ?

theriseandfallofFranklinSaint · 05/11/2023 21:01

I loved hamza last year but I love watching Layton and could watch him and Nikita dance all night. He's amazing and I love the fact that Nikita has to work harder than ever for them to keep up with each other. Unfortunately I don't think they'll win as so many people are pissed off that he has a theatrical background but in the meantime, bring it on!!!

Simonjt · 05/11/2023 20:59

PosyPrettyToes · 05/11/2023 20:16

Amanda trained to be a professional dancer prior to becoming an actor.

Angela S was in a professional Irish dancing troupe.

Nigel has the same training and a similar CV to Layton‘s, with numerous west end musicals.

Ellie trained in tap, ballet, street and modern.

So why just Layton?

Yep

Sunshineismyfavourite · 05/11/2023 20:57

I think people miss the point when they moan about 'pro dancer' celebs on the show. Strictly is, first and foremost an entertainment show. Producers deliberately get a mix of celebs so there is something for everyone. I love watching the great dancers like Layton - I'd much rather watch someone like him than someone like Les Dennis who was pretty dreadful to watch. As a nation we bloody love an underdog which gets in the way of common sense sometimes. Even a couple of weeks appearing on the show must boost each celebs worth by a few million I'd guess?! They can't complain. It's not about being fair or unfair - it's a TV show not the Olympic Games!

Mrsjayy · 05/11/2023 20:47

I think Masie Smith also had a MT degree.

Mrsjayy · 05/11/2023 20:44

CrystalMaisie · 05/11/2023 19:46

i like Layton, I like watching good performers. This week the feedback on his jive was spot on; really good performance but not very much jive content. So being a pro dancer still doesn’t make him a good latin dancer. His feet were still not in the right position.
Ultimately it’s the public voting them through.

I agree this weeks dance was fine and he had his tricks but i think it was lacking Jive, I do sometimes forward him as it can be too much the jazz hands bug me .

TheMidnightLibrary · 05/11/2023 20:43

Thinking back to last year, someone with no formal dance training won. Hamza Yassin made me smile from ear to ear every time he danced, and that’s what I want. His dancing was just such a joy.

MumofSpud · 05/11/2023 20:27

YANBU - I am a fan of Layton - loved him in 'Jamie' and Bad Education but....
It is ridiculous, I agree, that he is being judged against non dancers when he IS a dancer!
I imagine that it will get harder for Strictly to find younger celebs with no dance experience as they all seem to have had some
But to have an actual dancer on the show - that was a bad call

cathyandclaire · 05/11/2023 20:22

I think with Layton it's more about ability than training.

He was cast as Billy Elliot with only a year or two of street dance experience and no ballet or tap training- he was coached up to playing the role in a year. It's a very challenging part and he was unbelievably good ( as seen on the one show or something similar) after a few months. That shows a huge natural aptitude.

He has a degree in MT from Arts Ed, the same as Nigel Harman, Will Young and Danny Mac.

GoodOldEmmaNess · 05/11/2023 20:21

Wotchaz · 05/11/2023 19:34

I reckon they’ve done it deliberately because the previous same sex couples have been a bit “meh”. So they’ve brought in someone who’s guaranteed to stay in for longer and show what a same sex couple can do. Doesn’t stop me finding him irritating, but maybe worth it to see Nikita each week!

That's a good point, about having a strong and successful same-sex couple that's a joy to watch. I'm glad to have a reason to feel positive about Layton's presence because it was making me feel v v angry and the WHOLE POINT of Strictly for me is to have an hour or so each week when I just feel cheesily positive about EVERYONE.

Swipe left for the next trending thread