Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Layton Williams in Strictly

337 replies

Char65 · 05/11/2023 19:23

I am a big fan of Strictly but I have lost interest in it this year because of Layton Williams as he is a professional dance. His CV reads

2007–2008: Billy Elliot the Musical
2008–2009: Beautiful People
2016: Hairspray the Musical UK Tour - playing Duane
2016-2017: Rent UK Tour - playing Angel
2017-2018: Hairspray the Musical UK Tour - playing Seaweed J. Stubbs
2018-2019: Kiss Me Kate - playing Bill Calhoun/Luciento
2019-2022: Everyone's Talking About Jamie - playing Jamie New

He was also in a Michael Jackson show - and I believe Jackson could dance a bit!

To me its no fair to pitch a pro against amateurs though I accept a lot of actors have also done dance at stage school but not appeared in the West End like this guy! What do others think?

OP posts:
Paradeofrain · 06/11/2023 07:59

To be honest it bothers me more that there's one dancer who makes consistent mistakes and is frequently scored far higher than dancers with more content and smoother performances.

Strepsils · 06/11/2023 07:56

It does irritate me as he is obviously a dancer. And then recently I found out that Angela has toured with an Irish dance company. It was interesting this week that Craig commented that her her legs were fine, but the top half of her body was all over the place. I guess in Irish dancing a lot of it is just based on the legs moving with the arms and body still and straight?

However, I am getting slightly less irritated now, because I am finding some of the other dancers, very unmemorable. I don’t know if it is my memory playing tricks with me, but I’m sure the standard at this stage of the competition has been higher in previous series? For that reason, it is actually quite nice to watch some good dances as I’m getting bored of the rubbish ones who don’t seem to be improving or fulfilling their initial potential. Too many 6s and 7s at this stage still I think.

I can’t warm to Angela R for some reason. And I just want to give Bobby a hug as he reminds me of my son!

WatchOutMissMarpleIsAbout · 06/11/2023 07:50

And I actually forgotten that I disliked Ashley Robert for ringerness as well. I also had an irrational dislike for Peter Andre on strictly and he’s lovely in person (I’ve met him several times).

I actually think if Angela R was 20 years younger she’d be getting equally scathing comments as Layton tbh.

Fizbosshoes · 06/11/2023 07:48

I enjoy watching Layton and Nikita, his dancing is amazing (although I said when watching that Craig would comment his feet turned in) but of course he has an advantage over some of the others.
But there's always been ringers in it, and there's always a variety of abilities (part of which might be due to who agrees and is available to be on the show) It's exciting to see people improve but it's also good to see some incredible dancing.

I did see a Guardian article on Layton though, and he said it wasn't easy and the headline talked about "the myth of his unfair advantage" ....but nothing in it explained how it was, in any way a myth. Any of them with dance training will have an advantage over someone with none, and he has an awful lot of dance experience both from stage school and performing in the West End.

My main complaints from this series are that almost everyone seems to be able to do the splits or lift their leg over their head - and that makes me feel unbelievably inflexible!! 🤣🤣

And the constant overmarking of the "cooples choice" dances. I think most of them seem pretty meh. A few of them this year have done contemporary/Street dance style ones where you can see the professional is "bouncy" with lots of energy and the star is nowhere near matching them and looks a bit flat-footed. Last year Molly and Carlos did a dance to Grange Hill music she definitely had all the energy but it just seemed a bit basic and underwhelming imo.

RedSuedePump · 06/11/2023 07:44

I agree with your last sentance @icelollycraving

NashvilleQueen · 06/11/2023 07:44

Krishnan is my second favourite

NashvilleQueen · 06/11/2023 07:43

I'd never heard of or seen Ellie until Strictly and she's been my favourite since week one. She seems happy, keen to learn and well adjusted. And I like Vito.

Paradeofrain · 06/11/2023 07:41

I do think some of the other contestants aren't getting the same level of scrutiny

Nigel has a fairly similar back ground degree wise, his own bio says he also was cast simply as a dancer in the original stage show of mamma Mia then given a named character, he's been in guys and dolls in a dance heavy role, danced on cruise ships and even won an olivier for a role that included dancing on his knees. I saw him in some west end shows in which he was most definitely dancing the majority

Angela Rippon was chosen as a guest judge for dancing on ice because of her experience, she has also competed in that and one off strictly before

Angela s trained and competed internationally in another form of dance.

I don't think West end dance is at all comparable though...
I've seen les Dennis in many musicals. He's been in 42nd street this year, he's been in everything from legally blonde to hms pinafore. I've also seen him in hair spray, and the Adams family!

GunboatDiplomacy · 06/11/2023 07:39

VeniVidiWeeWee · 05/11/2023 22:37

And your source for this is?

None of these are controversial claims. Caroline did a three year full time Danone course at Bodyworks (not sure if it counts as an actual degree, but essentially the same) Denise van Outen had been in Chicago and Ashley Roberts was a Pussycat Doll at the time when they were transitioning from dance troupe to girl group. Jay McGuiness also did a dance-focussed degree.

IMO Layton (and Ashley) are a step too far in that he's worked primarily as a dancer, including teaching dance, and is still at his physical peak unless Debbie McGee. But he's doing great routines, Nikita seems lovely, and he won't win so it's no big deal.

Princessfluffy · 06/11/2023 07:39

Layton is fun to watch unlike Ellie who I find completely unengaging and usually don't bother watching. Clearly I'm on my own about Ellie though as she tops the leader board and is widely tipped to win it.

thebellagio · 06/11/2023 07:38

I’m not a fan of him - I find him too cocky.

my issue is with the producers. They saw how the public reacted to Ashley Roberts who was also a pro dancer, and they KNEW that Layton would get the same reaction.

I think people comparing his level of dance experience to other people like Nigel are deliberately being obtuse. If Layton had come in as a new pro dancer everyone would be saying “yeah, he’s got the pedigree for it” whereas if they said Nigel (for example) was being a new pro dancer people would rightly say wtf. And that’s the issue for me.

I quite like his performances with Nikita but in my head they aren’t in the competition, they are just randomly doing a pro dance in the middle of the show.

also most people do strictly for the profile boost with many of them going into the west end - Layton is already getting the starring roles in the west end.

And quite frankly whatever he does I personally think he could do and had the capabilities of before the show - for me, I like the journey contestant.

but what really fucking pisses me off is the constant claims that his experience isn’t an advantage. Admit your privilege here mate!

Dogmatix34 · 06/11/2023 07:34

I agree @icelollycraving . The hatred against him is unfair and seems very personal. I loved him in Beautiful People so was pleased to see he was in it but expected him to be a bit annoying but I’ve found him to be quite sweet.

icelollycraving · 06/11/2023 07:26

Every year there is someone with really strong experience. I love watching him perform. He still has feet that turn in and I think they score him appropriately. Most of them have some dance training. People are voting for him to stay, just like the others. I think this year is a really good mix from the ones with training, to Krishnan who is simply loving strictly life.
I think a lot of people don’t want to admit, perhaps even to themselves, why they dislike him so much.

WatchOutMissMarpleIsAbout · 06/11/2023 07:24

John Waite and Johannes were fabulous!

There are ringers and then there is Layton. He’s been paid to teach dance previously. . Step too far imo. If it’s the same for Angela S then same to her. Step too far.

It’s hard to get people without any dance experience completely but a professional dancer. Not right.

chocolateisavegetable · 06/11/2023 07:23

I absolutely love watching him and Nikita. They are the only reason I’m watching this year because I knew who Layton is. He was invited on the show by the BBC, so those that don’t like it should complain to them rather than pour hate on someone who’s suffered with quite enough hatred already.

Mrsjayy · 06/11/2023 07:23

VeniVidiWeeWee · 05/11/2023 22:37

And your source for this is?

what ? Do you want me to do your Google search for you I mean I can if you like 👍

BrendaMcPherson · 06/11/2023 07:16

Wotchaz · 05/11/2023 19:34

I reckon they’ve done it deliberately because the previous same sex couples have been a bit “meh”. So they’ve brought in someone who’s guaranteed to stay in for longer and show what a same sex couple can do. Doesn’t stop me finding him irritating, but maybe worth it to see Nikita each week!

John Whaite was anything but 'Meh'. He got to the final! You cant stay in any longer than that. Did you even watch his Pirates Paso?!

RedRiverShore4 · 06/11/2023 07:16

I shall vote for him each week as I enjoy watching him

RedSuedePump · 06/11/2023 07:01

Layton definitely has dance skills above what some of the other “stage school trained” competitors have and some of his stage roles have had dance elements as an integral part of it. however he was offered a place by the BBC and was well within his rights to accept it and then compete to the best of his ability. any nasty trolling is out of order. ultimately there’s been loads of people over the years who have been in musicals/bands etc and they always have an advantage over the likes of the sports starts/ presenters etc it’s a light hearted saturday night family tv show - just enjoy it.

LizzBurg · 06/11/2023 06:52

For me though, it's not solely his experience but the fact he seems incredibly cocky with it and that over exaggerated campness annoys me.

Seeing Layton after each dance talking to Claudia and also interviews with him on It Takes Two, cocky is the last thing I would call him. He comes across as a pleasant guy learning the complexities of a new skill, just like the other competitors.
Is it just Layton or do all displays of campness annoy you? If so @Oganesson118 then Strictly really isn’t for you.

pink1173 · 06/11/2023 06:46

I absolutely love him! I would rather watch him than all the ones who can’t dance. The hatred online for him has been obscene. And it’s not as if he has lobbied to be on the show. The BBC have deemed him suitable to be part of the competition so I think if people have a problem
they need to direct their comments to the BBC and not the actual person. You can tell all the comments are weighing him down when he speaks on his Instagram stories. People are truly vile nowadays.

Magicshoppingtrolley · 06/11/2023 06:38

So many of them have dance experience, as have so many over the years, but I can’t remember so much hate and trolling being spewed for a contestant. But then have the others been openly gay men……?

It’s an entertainment show. And as such I expect to be entertained by a variety of dancers; enjoying watching those who have really come on, those who aren’t that great and those who have dance experience - but are still learning as Latin and Ballroom are so different.

I can’t comprehend why people feel the need to hate on someone so much.

Friendfoe1 · 06/11/2023 05:06

bridgetreilly · 05/11/2023 23:49

I find him unbearable to watch, frankly. He is more up himself than Johannes, and that is saying something.

Agreed 🤣

Friendfoe1 · 06/11/2023 05:04

HarrietSpying · 05/11/2023 19:43

Totally agree. Can’t bear him. I don’t watch him now. Much prefer the others. I hope he doesn’t make it much further but I suspect he will.

I think he will be in the final, I doubt anyone could beat him in the dance off. 😏