Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not enjoy the "Bridgertonisation" of a lot of period dramas?

56 replies

weeddigger · 05/11/2023 13:30

I Love Emily Dickinson's poetry and so I tried watching Dickinson on apple TV and its just so crap really, they turn this amazing writer into a very shallow, trope of feisty teen saying "dude" and "sick" while the women around her look on aghast and sniff their smelling salts i.e. they try to make Emily seem something by making all the other female characters nothing.

Ok so I admit I may be being unreasonable, that perhaps it isn't aimed at me but it just seems so flimsy, all style and no substance, the dialogue and so on. Sometimes mixing up time periods, using modern music and conventions can really work but other times it just seems like a lazy, formulaic way to try and appeal to the lowest common denominator.

I was looking at the new production of The Buccaneers that is going to be on Apple TV soon but that looks much the same. I suppose things like Bridgeton have influenced these things as well as Marie-Antoinette by Sophia Coppola which I enjoyed at the time but I do find myself wishing for a bit more old school BBC vibes in these productions now and again. I watched things like old productions of Middlemarch on dvd with my Mum growing up and thought they were so well done, and kept some semblance of the era.

OP posts:
whathatwhat · 05/11/2023 13:40

I did think Bridgerton when I saw the Buccaneers trailer. I quite liked the breaking of the 4th wall in Gentleman Jack. It gave a different take without having to change much else.

bombastix · 05/11/2023 13:39

I agree! also thought Bridgerton was terrible.

foreverbasil · 05/11/2023 13:39

Completely agree...Netflix version of Persuasion was woeful, Anne with an E, but I'm probably not the target audience.

ghostyslovesheets · 05/11/2023 13:38

I was so excited about The Buccaneers until I saw the trailer - I feel like you OP - I loved the book but I don't really want a modern take on it. The BBC did an adaptation that's on Britbox - I might just re watch that.

CanIPetThatDawg · 05/11/2023 13:37

I suppose so many great period dramas have been made over the past 30 years or so, they're just mixing things up a bit. And Bridgerton was such a runaway success that it's inevitable other producers are going to try and capitalise on its popularity with younger audiences. But YANBU it all feels a bit superficial. The horror that was the Netflix adaptation of Persuasion is still living rent free in my brain. Same with the most recent adaptation of Anne of Green Gables. I tell myself that my adaptations of these book already exist so what harm does it do for these to exist. I'm just not their target audience.

The Bridgerton vibe will start to feel a bit hackneyed pretty soon though if it's being replicated everywhere else.

AmiablePedant · 05/11/2023 13:35

I'm a huge fan of good historical drama but really loathe it when the script people have absolutely no ear for historical usage; I don't mean it should all be "forsooth!" and "Zounds!" but just that they should avoid having characters speak words/phrases/idioms that one glance at a good historical dictionary would reveal not to have entered the language until much later. Am still recovering from a very high budget series set in the early 16th century in which everybody was saying "Okay!"

Swipe left for the next trending thread