Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not enjoy the "Bridgertonisation" of a lot of period dramas?

56 replies

weeddigger · 05/11/2023 13:30

I Love Emily Dickinson's poetry and so I tried watching Dickinson on apple TV and its just so crap really, they turn this amazing writer into a very shallow, trope of feisty teen saying "dude" and "sick" while the women around her look on aghast and sniff their smelling salts i.e. they try to make Emily seem something by making all the other female characters nothing.

Ok so I admit I may be being unreasonable, that perhaps it isn't aimed at me but it just seems so flimsy, all style and no substance, the dialogue and so on. Sometimes mixing up time periods, using modern music and conventions can really work but other times it just seems like a lazy, formulaic way to try and appeal to the lowest common denominator.

I was looking at the new production of The Buccaneers that is going to be on Apple TV soon but that looks much the same. I suppose things like Bridgeton have influenced these things as well as Marie-Antoinette by Sophia Coppola which I enjoyed at the time but I do find myself wishing for a bit more old school BBC vibes in these productions now and again. I watched things like old productions of Middlemarch on dvd with my Mum growing up and thought they were so well done, and kept some semblance of the era.

OP posts:
CanIPetThatDawg · 05/11/2023 14:16

weeddigger · 05/11/2023 14:08

That is on Apple Tv and I haven't seen it, is it good?

I really enjoyed the first series. Great cast feat. Samantha Morton and Lesley Manville.

TheSweetEndOfTheLollipop · 05/11/2023 14:16

I thought Queen Charlotte was much better than Bridgerton to be honest.

My favourite thing about either of those is challenging race perception, and the costumes.

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 14:15

Yeah I do know that but for me I didn't like Bridgerton

Did you watch Queen Charlotte as a matter of interest. That's very different in subject and tone than the first two.

Fionaville · 05/11/2023 14:14

I agree. Although I do love Bridgeton, for what it is. But most period dramas should be an escape to a different era.
I feel the same way about Shakespeare too. I like a 'modern take' like Westside story. Usually though, if I'm going to the theatre to watch Shakespeare, I prefer it done traditionally, not in tracksuits.

TheSweetEndOfTheLollipop · 05/11/2023 14:13

Oh watching with interest! Haven't seen The Great, Essex Serpent.

I loved Wolf Hall etc.

To be honest I see Poldark/Bridgestone etc as a different category, more silly, bodice ripping fun than a good, solid, historical drama.

Never got in to Downton Abbey really. I've seen it but felt wholly unsatisfied, bar maggie smith, it was so bland.

bombastix · 05/11/2023 14:11

Most of this stuff is made for new audiences, so historical accuracy isn't important. It's also something to do with a fascination with Britain and its aristocracy by other countries.
You can write all sorts of deluded stuff in period, but will it part? No, because it is scripted for an audience of that time, and their own preoccupations. Bridgerton was said to be groundbreaking. Give it a few years and it's limitations will be more obvious than its virtues.

I am watching I Claudius again. I do not think Bridgerton will be on repeat viewing in 40 years.

weeddigger · 05/11/2023 14:08

CanIPetThatDawg · 05/11/2023 14:00

I'm annoyed Harlots isn't on the iplayer. I only got to see the first series.

That is on Apple Tv and I haven't seen it, is it good?

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 05/11/2023 14:05

SisterMichaelsHabit · 05/11/2023 13:57

What I find more bothersome is the creeping Americanisation of historical storytelling set in Britain. There was a recent period drama on Netflix (I cannot remember what it was called) and these British actors were speaking in a way that made it obvious the script had been written in American English and not properly edited or checked, and you'd think the actors would have said "this isn't British English grammar or word choice" instead of parroting this stuff and looking like idiots, but these serious errors never should have got that far.

I’d question why British entertainment isn’t creating such shows themselves.

CanIPetThatDawg · 05/11/2023 14:00

I'm annoyed Harlots isn't on the iplayer. I only got to see the first series.

aSofaNearYou · 05/11/2023 13:59

I know what you mean, but equally more straight dramas do still exist, this is just another option.

I enjoy Bridgerton well enough but it's definitely "period drama for dummies", it feels like it's explaining really basic concepts like "women can't work" to people that have never watched a historical drama before. But it can be executed well, but just like everything else, it isn't always.

The Great is really good, and Harlots was another one I really enjoyed. And I'm looking forward to the Buccaneers.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 05/11/2023 13:59

Actually even worse than that are the American ones set in "historic" Ireland. I try and forget they exist.

cheezncrackers · 05/11/2023 13:59

But Bridgerton (which I managed about four mins of before I turned it off, so simpering, awful and computer generated was it), was resoundingly popular, so now the idiots who commission things for TV think that kind of rubbish is what everyone wants to watch.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 05/11/2023 13:57

What I find more bothersome is the creeping Americanisation of historical storytelling set in Britain. There was a recent period drama on Netflix (I cannot remember what it was called) and these British actors were speaking in a way that made it obvious the script had been written in American English and not properly edited or checked, and you'd think the actors would have said "this isn't British English grammar or word choice" instead of parroting this stuff and looking like idiots, but these serious errors never should have got that far.

weeddigger · 05/11/2023 13:57

@whathatwhat Oh good! I will start on that tonight!

@TheKeatingFive Yeah I do know that but for me I didn't like Bridgerton and I think I am just a bit gutted that The Buccaneers looks to be similar as I was looking forward to that. I do like when they use a more diverse cast and innovation is fine it just feels a bit samey and without any substance at the moment. I think I did say up thread though that I did like The Great a lot.

OP posts:
BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/11/2023 13:55

YANBU. But it’s been going on for a while now - I’m thinking of Downton Abbey where characters said things like, “That’s the understatement of the century!” when people didn’t speak like that in the 1920s.

I do love a good costume drama but I wish they’d be historically accurate.

phoenixrosehere · 05/11/2023 13:55

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 05/11/2023 13:44

Completely with you OP. For me I enjoy period dramas because they do feel like a window to the past and an escape from the fast complexity of the age we live in now. I suppose it depends on the audience - some people are just after a good story and a bit of fluff. My slight concern is some people don't realise that these are very loosely based on historical times. But surely not?

On a side note, I thought Wolf Hall was a great historical adaptation, in spite of being based on a historical novel - it seemed truer to the Tudor age than many of the sexed up takes on classic novels.

My slight concern is some people don't realise that these are very loosely based on historical times.

The Great with Elle Fanning and Bridgerton’s Queen Charlotte literally say that they are very loosely based on history. It is said in the very beginning of both shows. I recall this being spoken about with Queen Charlotte and those who had actually watched the first episode pointing out the disclaimer before the show actually starts. Watching The Great, it was said during the credits every episode (at least from what I saw when I streamed it.)

If people can’t realise the difference between fact and fiction even with disclaimers, surely nothing is going to help them.

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 13:51

For me, it comes down to the quality of the production. I don't hate the concept. I loved Bridgerton, particularly Queen Charlotte. The Great is one of my favourite shows of all time. Persuasion was a bit of a dogs dinner (though I loved Mary, so not entirely a waste)

But it is just a trend and I'm sure there will be a swing back soon. There are lots and lots of faith costume dramas out there to enjoy in the meantime.

whathatwhat · 05/11/2023 13:48

Yes I’d recommend the Essex Serpent, it’s definitely not a Bridgerton type. Very atmospheric.

weeddigger · 05/11/2023 13:48

@Bernadinetta Oh yeah I quite fancy all of those shows, thanks for reminding me!

OP posts:
weeddigger · 05/11/2023 13:47

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 05/11/2023 13:44

Completely with you OP. For me I enjoy period dramas because they do feel like a window to the past and an escape from the fast complexity of the age we live in now. I suppose it depends on the audience - some people are just after a good story and a bit of fluff. My slight concern is some people don't realise that these are very loosely based on historical times. But surely not?

On a side note, I thought Wolf Hall was a great historical adaptation, in spite of being based on a historical novel - it seemed truer to the Tudor age than many of the sexed up takes on classic novels.

@FortheBeautyoftheEarth Wolf Hall was epic! I may have to rewatch that myself. Will we ever see a production of the other books I wonder, I hope so!

Has anyone watch the Essex Serpent on Apple TV was that any good? It might be my last ditch attempt before I bin my subscription!

OP posts:
Bernadinetta · 05/11/2023 13:44

Recommend Lark Rise to Candleford, Cranford and North & South for the vibes you’re after (sorry for use of “vibes” 😆). And can’t go wrong with Emma Thompson’s Sense and Sensibility.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 05/11/2023 13:44

Completely with you OP. For me I enjoy period dramas because they do feel like a window to the past and an escape from the fast complexity of the age we live in now. I suppose it depends on the audience - some people are just after a good story and a bit of fluff. My slight concern is some people don't realise that these are very loosely based on historical times. But surely not?

On a side note, I thought Wolf Hall was a great historical adaptation, in spite of being based on a historical novel - it seemed truer to the Tudor age than many of the sexed up takes on classic novels.

weeddigger · 05/11/2023 13:44

whathatwhat · 05/11/2023 13:40

I did think Bridgerton when I saw the Buccaneers trailer. I quite liked the breaking of the 4th wall in Gentleman Jack. It gave a different take without having to change much else.

Gentleman Jack was soooo good! So I really don't think I am being a fuddy duddy about it its just it so often comes out a bit crap. I think I read that Gentleman Jack has been scrapped too for some unknown reason. Perhaps the BBC just do these things much better than anyone else?

OP posts:
weeddigger · 05/11/2023 13:42

@CanIPetThatDawg I do know what you mean and I love The Favourite for example and The Great but it is the superficiality that really bothers me. Of course I accept that they probably aren't aimed at me even if I am still kind of in their demographic but even then don't these new views deserve better also?

OP posts:
AmiablePedant · 05/11/2023 13:41

I got 5 minutes into the recent Netflix Persuasion (it happens to be my much cherished favorite Austen novel) and ran screaming for the hills. Or rather for my DVD of the movie version with Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds and Corin Redgrave and Sophie Thompson (1995) which is beautifully done and very moving.