Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing 'I carry all the load' posts

164 replies

ijustdontunderstanditall · 05/11/2023 12:22

Can't do a poll as on the app

It feels every other post atm is a woman being annoyed because they do everything, and their partner just goes to work, doesn't help with kids/house/life admin etc

Maybe I am just lucky that I don't have this issue, but I just don't understand why people don't just put their foot down and stop doing it all? Surely when the dinner isn't cooked/ hoover put round/ bill paid the other person will man up and help?

OP posts:
Ollifer · 05/11/2023 13:22

Although I now don't live with a man for me personally the situation was this - you can't have someone who has everything you desire - some things you need to prioritise, so for me that's someone who is kind, has a job, good sense of humour, interesting etc. So if I found someone who ticked all my boxes but is a bit shit round the house it would be something I'd have a whinge at but wouldn't be enough to actually leave them (if that makes sense). So I think a lot of the time these posts are people who are on the whole generally quite happy in their relationship but have certain things they get frustrated with which is totally normal. It would be unusual to live with someone and not have anything you wished they did differently, whether it's being shit with money, in the house, sleeping habits, eating drinking whatever.

niadainud · 05/11/2023 13:21

DustyLee123 · 05/11/2023 12:29

My DH will cook and do washing, but he doesn’t clean. He says he can’t see it.
The one time I asked him to dust and hoover the lounge, I could see a layer of dust on the TV stand. I assume he just hoovered where he could see.

I hope you told him to make an appointment with the optician.

Malarandras · 05/11/2023 13:20

If you cannot understand other peoples lives because they are so different from your own, then maybe don’t read threads where the title indicates as much? That’ll save you the trouble of not understanding won’t it?

gannett · 05/11/2023 13:18

I don't personally identify with those posts either, and I'm not convinced the behaviour is really that gendered - as a woman who's very much on the slatternly, messy side. I pull my weight but I don't care about tidiness anywhere near as much as DP does, and I have no desire to spend any more than the bare minimum of time thinking about domestic crap. I'm always astonished at how much people willingly put on their own plates that they don't need to. But then I'm also child-free and not maternal, which I suspect is linked.

The other pattern I notice on MN though is on dating threads where women pretty much exclusively want to find "traditional", stereotypically manly men. Most MNers seem to want to find tall, burly rugby-playing men who look like good "protectors" and earn enough to be good "providers" (and presumably who want to play those roles too). Short men are talked about with disdain, men on low salaries are cocklodgers, and generally any man who deviates from traditional masculinity gives you the ick.

It shouldn't take a genius to work out that if you look for traditional masculinity, well then that's what you get down the line as well - a man who thinks his job is more important than your career, and who thinks it's your role to run the house by yourself. Even if he doesn't say so out loud at first.

SublimeLime99 · 05/11/2023 13:14

I think you're being deliberately obtuse OP.

Of course you're objectively correct that there's an epidemic of women doing a double (or triple) shift, doing FT jobs, doing all or most childcare and all or most domestic work and mental load. Very few people would dispute that that's a bad thing.

But you're glossing over millennia of baggage and institutional discrimination which enables this. For millions of women it's just not as simple as "put your foot down".

There may be physical or psychological abuse. There often is financial dependency which is such that the woman can't function without the man's input and is therefore loathe to push too far. It's very hard to run a household with multiple children solo. Plenty of women do it (I do it) but you can't blame people for wanting to avoid this.

And that's before you get to the societal baggage which dictates that women are the default provider of these services. Many if not most men take as read that their spouse or partner is the person responsible for most domestic stuff. Even the ones who recognise they have a part to play usually don't do as much as they should. Challenging this is necessary, but it's stressful and leads to constant friction and many people don't have the stomach or the emotional energy for this. Many women are not backed up by their families, who put pressure on them to remain in situations where they are the default carer/domestic helper because that's what their families think is the natural way of things.

I'm not saying you're not right: you are. But I think you're minimising the difficulty of challenging it. It's a long, hard slog to challenge it and there's no guarantee you will be successful at the end of it.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 05/11/2023 13:14

I tried leaving ex husband's shirts (that he would take off and dump on the floor randomly). I'd tried asking him to at least put them in the laundry basket - no result. So I just stopped picking them up.

He didn't even realise until he ran out of shirts. And then I got a bollocking from him for leaving them. I tried speaking up, pointing out that I'd asked him to put his shirts in the basket but, no. It was all my fault. I've never seen a man so enraged - I think it was because I'd been compliant (in his view) up until then. He grew up in a family where Mother did absolutely everything, I grew up in a family with both parents doing housework equally. So, in his eyes, I was supposed to do everything, and in mine he should have been doing half.

TwinklyWinkly · 05/11/2023 13:13

I have in the past chosen being poor as a church mouse on benefits and single and alone in the world, over being with an entitled slob who thinks housework should be done by mothers and wives.

Was never happier! The peace, airiness, and lack of clutter, was bliss!

Sometimes I was lonely, sometimes I didn’t have enough money to pay all the bills on my own… but never once did I regret my decision.
Living with frustration and resentment was making me emotionally and physically ill.

Turns out exs small-mindedness, and dependency was holding me back…
My independence has been me so strong, I’ve travelled so far, and seen and learned so much.

A life of drudgery with a selfish person, awful. Better to be alone. Thank goodness we live in a country that facilitates this.

Ex wasn’t even providing that well, I don’t know what I was thinking! I was young, naive, romantic and innocent. There are some people who will take advantage.

AngelAurora · 05/11/2023 13:08

I agree OP yet these posters complaining still put up with it.

dameofdilemma · 05/11/2023 13:08

Pre kids it's easy to share the load equally.

Post kids it becomes a game of chicken to see if you're prepared to let your kid go to school without lunch money to make a point.

Reugny · 05/11/2023 13:05

There is also conditioning from childhood.

For example in my extended family everyone does their own washing and ironing from being a teen. So if you don't have clean school uniform or an ironed top then it's on you. However on many threads posters are surprised by this attitude claiming it simply easier for them to do all their family's washing and ironing. (The one SIL who offered to do it for my brother at the beginning of their relationship soon found out she was doing his washing "incorrectly".)

Yes it's easier in terms of time and negotiating who uses what when, but it isn't easier in conditioning children particularly boys in the fact looking after yourself is your own responsibility.

Sparklesocks · 05/11/2023 13:05

There are men who won’t ‘see’ the mess even if left, they will squeeze rubbish into a clearly full kitchen bin without thinking to empty it, or step over the dirty laundry on the floor to get into bed without popping it in the hamper or even doing a wash.

Yes their wives/partners can point it all out, and ask them to do it, or make a list for them - and yes, it will probably be done then… unless he’s completely useless.

But a lot of women are tired of having to ask, to show what needs to be done, every single time. That becomes a chore in itself I’m sure you can imagine how tiring if must be having to ask the same things over and over of an adult without them having the initiative to do it without being asked.

bellac11 · 05/11/2023 12:48

I think that some people/men dont see detail, they dont see what we might see

OH can drop stuff on the floor, on the table, all over the worktops, he isnt bothered, he wouldnt be bothered if it stayed there for eternity. He isnt bothered if the sheets arent changed for weeks on end, isnt bothered if the floor isnt hoovered, isnt bothered if the bathroom isnt clean.

Some people just arent.

We have a cleaner so I dont do anything anyway.

Renamed · 05/11/2023 12:48

It’s sickening that it seems such a common circumstance, but what I think is that the outlet of a forum like this one will help. People often don’t want to talk about their partner with friends or family who also know them and may have their own axe to grind. It’s helpful for women to work out how they are feeling and other posters may have ideas and strategies which have worked. And sadly, sometimes it does come down to seeing that the partner is not interested in an equal relationship. I think it would be great if young women could take from these experiences and be clear about what their idea of love and partnership is. May be this should be part of citizenship classes. Young men to be taught that partnership doesn’t mean that they will get all their needs provided for, always put first, and sex on tap.

burnoutbabe · 05/11/2023 12:47

generally women want things cleaned and tidied far more than men (exceptions obviously)

how many threads here about washing towels after each use? tons.

Do you imagine most men would choose to wash a towel that often - they'd just wash it at the point they felt it needed washing. Same with bedding or cleaning bathroom/kitchen.

So living up to someone else's standards is part of the issue.

I mean i don't cook - i am happy with ready meals/takeaways and beige food. So partner cooks sometimes and the rest of the time i provide a meal from the freezer. if he doesn't like that he can just find someone to cook for him. not demand i cook properly more often.

(and we just pay for a cleaner to come every fortnight to avoid that discussion - to be fair they come probably more than either of us woukd bother if we lived alone)

Fionaville · 05/11/2023 12:45

On MN, I'm more concerned at the amount of couples who don't communicate openly. The amount of posts that have "DH did/does/said this, how do I ask him to.." Most of them would be easily solved if they would just talk to their DH or react to the thing at the time. I've never hesitated to have a conversation or react to something with my DH.
It leads me to believe that lots of these women are either in an abusive relationship or they are just severely lacking in self worth and have no confidence. Either way, it's not a good relationship if you can't communicate with your other half openly.

Midnightkittycat · 05/11/2023 12:45

I tried not doing stuff. End result was stuff didn't get done, there were constant arguments and the dcs suffered. It took me 20 years to recognise it was because it was an extremely abusive relationship, and a further 2 years of counselling to find the strength to leave.

If you haven't been in that position, you can't imagine how hard it is.

theduchessofspork · 05/11/2023 12:44

@ijustdontunderstanditall Life isn’t always as simple as putting your food down, people carry all sorts of behavioural baggage into relationships, and once they are in them all sorts of complex power balances come into play, and all sorts of reasons why it’s hard to push back. If you haven’t understood that out by now, there’s nothing useful anyone can say to you.

But what is simple is not opening a thread that you know will annoy you, so why don’t you just do that?

SweetBirdsong · 05/11/2023 12:43

You're right @ijustdontunderstanditall Women (many women) are their own worst enemy. I'm the same. Always pretty much done everything - domestic duties, childcare, shopping, cooking, home admin. Done it since the kids were little, and I was part time and DH was full time.

Kids are grown now, and I just can't make myself stop it, and I annoy myself. Many girls are conditioned to be polite and helpful, and women are expected to be the main child nurturer, and many women fall into the trap of 'carrying all the load.'

So YANBU.

Scalottia · 05/11/2023 12:42

YANBU OP.

To a certain extent - some women DO let it happen.

I am not one of those women.

I am not saying that the men in these relationships aren't to blame - they are. But for some reason the women stay with them and continue to do everything for them. Why? Where are we going wrong with raising our sons/daughters that this keeps happening?

haribosmarties · 05/11/2023 12:41

Tbf you have to massively lower your standards if you expect the men to do it just coz you've stopped doing it. They won't. There are some very clean house proud men out there sure.. but they are rare. I swear most men will literally live doing the bare minimum and won't even care it won't even register on them.
And then you enter the world of having to ask and feeling like a nag and like the most boring person in the world.
Or you just end up living in a filthy home that you are embarrassed to bring anyone back to because guess who will get judged for it? Not the man.

TedMullins · 05/11/2023 12:41

I do agree with you up to a point - obviously women are not responsible for men’s shitty behaviour, but we do have to take some responsibility for tolerating and allowing it. In that respect yes I do think there is truth in saying many women allow this to happen to themselves by not laying down firm boundaries sooner. But it’s also a lot bigger than that.

Society is still structured to encourage this, and many people on here have explained their upbringings modelled it and they subconsciously absorbed it. The values you’re taught by your parents, your self esteem, your financial power, your culture, education level all have an impact on your ability to challenge inequality. Many cultures that aren’t white British for example still have much more defined gender roles so women of different ethnicities may feel pressure to conform to that dynamic differently to white women.

So while on a basic level I do agree that women should have good strong boundaries and expect more from the men in their lives (or not get involved with feckless twats in the first place) it isn’t that simple. A lot of women also have said that their male partners did share all this until children came along and unexpectedly reverted to sexist pigs once they became fathers, which I can understand as it’s still not the norm for men to do 50/50 parenting (which is should be) so these men might have felt pushback from their work, social circle etc. not that that’s an excuse of course. But as well as women looking after themselves it would be nice to see men speaking out about the need for them to partake equally in domestic work. I actually know a couple of SAHDs who do this but there’s no organised campaigns on it like there is about feminist issues.

LightSpeeds · 05/11/2023 12:41

For centuries, men have been leaving all the household stuff, drudgery and child rearing to women.

This hasn't entirely changed, obviously. A lot of men would just clear off and find someone else to look after them and put up with their entitled laziness if challenged.

Moreempatheticmyarse · 05/11/2023 12:41

This reminds me of a post I have quoted before that someone else put up on MN ages ago and stuck with me:

*Household chore inequity and child care inequality is a form of domestic abuse. It forces women to work themselves into exhaustion and illness, whilst men buy their free time with female exhaustion.

No one wants to see themselves as being in an abusive relationship. It means acknowledging that someone you love, someone you married or committed to, someone you chose to have children with is taking advantage of you and that hurts on so many levels.

it's heartbreaking to acknowledge, but acknowledge it we must.

If your husband or partner is capable of working at their job without being micromanaged and given extremely explicit instructions, then they are capable of contributing fairly at home without being given extremely explicit instructions and micromanaged. If they act like they are incapable they are gaslighting you.

If they were capable of living independently without living in a rat-infested pigsty without any clean clothes and living off pizza, then they are capable of ensuring children are fed and clothed, groceries are done, and household chores are shared equally. If they act like they are incapable they are gaslighting you.

If they claim they love you and yet your health comes secondary to their leisure, they're gaslighting you.

If they claim they can't possibly function and it would be unsafe for them to work with broken sleep, but it's totally fine for you to have to work, drive and do all the household chores and childcare on broken sleep, they're taking advantage of you.

If they say they are going to get up in the night and help but when the time comes the pretend to be asleep/complain, they're gaslighting you.

If they don't even actually try to settle the baby and had bub back almost immediately with "they just want you:", they're gaslighting you.

If your health, sanity, sleep, work, or self-esteem are suffering because you are the one doing everything, whilst they leverage your exhaustion into their free time, they're abusing you.
Like other forms of abuse, it will not get better on its own. It's not an accident.*

When you blame women for men's abuse you make it a woman's fault for not fixing it. The blame should be with the abuser not the victim

(and before someone jumps out and points put this happens to men too, I know, but the OPs post seems to be specifically about women in this situation so thats what I'm responding to)

DeeCeeCherry · 05/11/2023 12:40

It doesn't annoy me seeing them. I just wonder why still, in this day and age, women 'audition' for a wife role. Namely, doing everything for a man so as to appear the perfect partner in his eyes. Then expecting that miraculously after marriage and children he will suddenly become a great help around the house, when said woman has been doing his cooking cleaning washing for years/in the lead up. Pampered men don't really change whether their pampering started from their parental home, or via a woman encouraging ineffectiveness. I guess the thought is they SHOULD change. Yes, they should. But real life isnt a story book. Better to take off the love goggles in the 1st place and see a man for who he truly is. If he's never seen to cook and tidy up, can't cook, doesn't care about living in chaos etc, then he's to be avoided unless one wants to create a life of stress and mess.

teenysaladandsniffofarose · 05/11/2023 12:39

I think you're being extremely ignorant.

I'm lucky that my partner is great and does his share however I understand some womens circumstances are different and it's not always a simple "just stop doing it or leave".