Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing 'I carry all the load' posts

164 replies

ijustdontunderstanditall · 05/11/2023 12:22

Can't do a poll as on the app

It feels every other post atm is a woman being annoyed because they do everything, and their partner just goes to work, doesn't help with kids/house/life admin etc

Maybe I am just lucky that I don't have this issue, but I just don't understand why people don't just put their foot down and stop doing it all? Surely when the dinner isn't cooked/ hoover put round/ bill paid the other person will man up and help?

OP posts:
Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 05/11/2023 14:25

disappearingfish · 05/11/2023 12:25

The people in happy, equal relationships are not starting threads!

Relationships don't always start off unequal, it often comes when women are on maternity leave and they start to do more at home. Then add in societal expectations after 3000 years of patriarchy and there we are!

This.
Dynamics can totally change when a baby is born - l got made redindant when on mat leave so had no job to go back to - apart from losing confidence in my ability to work, l also felt like my contribution was keeping the home nice etc.
I feel like the op is a bit tone deaf - almost like saying l have never lived in a council house/been camping/insert whatever - so why would anyone want to?

randomusername2019 · 05/11/2023 14:25

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

randomusername2019 · 05/11/2023 14:22

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Chanelbasketballandchain · 05/11/2023 14:21

there is an element of martyrdom.

Taking care of children, not optional.

Spring cleaning the house before going away? Not a necessity but a logical choice to make the return home less painful.

The concept of "visitor-ready house"? Never once have I heard it from a man. It's disingenuous to add it to the mental load when it's purely self-inflicted and frankly unnecessary.

How many men are described as "house proud"? you can have lovely men, with a strong preference for a tidy and clean house who do it themselves, or pay a cleaner, but they don't define themselves by it.

The enormous Christmas or people's birthday mental load? Most of it is self-inflicted. If your husband doesn't care about sending a million christmas cards or birthday cards, you are not doing him a favour by doing it for him.

It's like the caricature of a man being obsessed with washing his car every Sunday. If you don't care, would be more than happy to bring it to the car wash yourself once in a blue moon, the car washer is not doing you a favour. If nothing else, he's an irritant.

JamSandle · 05/11/2023 14:17

Don't look at threads you aren't interested in. Simple.

PonyPatter44 · 05/11/2023 14:13

Those posts can be a bit annoying, I agree, but in 9 out of 10 cases posters ask a few more questions, and suddenly there's a whole lot more problematic or downright abusive behaviour... and THEN the OP starts to get constructive advice.

shams05 · 05/11/2023 14:12

Cosywintertime · 05/11/2023 13:52

I think there is some defensiveness on this thread op. Like you have hit a nerve. My husband does equal amounts, and if he’s occasionally lax I will say your turn for the dishwasher, or can you get the hoovering done now before we sit down. And if required I will keep saying it. It’s seldom required though. I certainly won’t do it. It will keep being said till it’s done. That’s incredibly rare though. He usually just does it.

he’s a grown up and perfectly capable. I’m not his mother. This isn’t the 1950s and we will equally contribute to the upkeep of our home.

I've tried this, he'll even do it but at a later date will berate me for it.
What really hurts is for years he acted like a clux in the kitchen and I love cooking so I took on all food related jobs but now he's on a serious health kick he's suddenly learned to chop and sauté and cook solely for himself. My heart's in my mouth as I type this because although it's been around 2 months of this sudden change it still upsets me.
I did bring it up but his response was surly and abrupt.
Thankfully my boys are totally different, they have great role models in my brother, my dad and my brother in law.

ColleenDonaghy · 05/11/2023 14:10

I hate those threads too, and there are so many. I'm sick of seeing them, and seeing them play out in real life too.

I'm sick of my DH who pulls his weight with half the childcare, half the housework (but nowhere near half the mental load) and half the salary being declared AMAZING, a god amongst men, told I'm SOOOOOO lucky. Needless to say he's never told he's soooo lucky because his wife does the school run and knows what day PE is.

But I think blaming women for men being awful might be even worse than the ridiculously low bar set for husbands and fathers that so many still fail to clear.

shams05 · 05/11/2023 14:06

Octavia64 · 05/11/2023 12:39

I stopped doing (some stuff). It was eight months before he noticed his bathroom hadn't been cleaned.

If I didn't cook he just ordered takeaway (only for him as he was usually back late).

If someone is not in the mentality of we're a family and the kids are my responsibility too then just stopping doing stuff doesn't get them into that mentality.

It does mean you do a bit less though, and it makes it clear to you they don't think if themselves as a parent or even a couple.

This is me.
There's some things I've just stopped doing, they get left but other than some irritation it doesn't affect me.
Everything else I'll do but I drew a line and refuse to shift.

LoneFemaleTraveller · 05/11/2023 14:05

DustyLee123 · 05/11/2023 12:35

And why ‘man up’?

Because it is men whose behaviour that is on the floor.

women are already up.

Blinkityblonk · 05/11/2023 14:04

There's research on this.

Those saying, you chose them, often people are equally matched up in terms of contributing to the house until they have children.

After children (not if they don't have them) is where the disparity opens up, possibly due to maternity leave setting the standard of women being responsible for the house and for childcare.

We know it is a gender thing because all the research shows that women consistently do more housework and more childcare/time with children even in very equal countries (like Nordic countries). So, it's not in anyone's imagination and individual women may be very disinterested in housework or cooking or reading bedtime stories to the kids but in general, they still do more of it.

gannett · 05/11/2023 14:00

TedMullins · 05/11/2023 13:50

I also think many people make work for themselves - when I see “running the house and doing the finances” I just think what exactly does that involve in this day and age? Set up automatic direct debits and you don’t have to think about it until contracts are up for renewal which you get a reminder for anyway on email usually. No idea what “running a house” means if it’s something different to laundry and cleaning and food shopping (which yes, of course men should play an equal part in, but also are things literally everyone has to do whether they’re single, married, a parent, childfree, have a job, are a SAHP)

I sometimes see references to daily hoovering, dusting, mopping etc and it boggles my mind. Hoovering is my job and I do it once a week at the absolute most and frequently that slips. In between I don't think about it at all. There are definitely some MNers out there who have pristine show home standards. I don't get it; life should be geared towards minimising domestic drudgery for everyone, not creating more than is necessary.

And re: "my job" - as the messy one in the relationship it works out best if DP and I divvy it up and let the other person get on with their allotted chores. We worked that out within days of moving in with each other.

JCWiatt · 05/11/2023 13:53

I'm lucky that my DH is 50/50 with me, but I did make my boundaries clear early on and do bring up any issues quickly. He is under no illusions that I'll put up with lazy behaviour. The key thing is to teach the next generation what an equal relationship looks like. It's little things like this morning when my DS age 8 put his plate next to the dishwasher...I asked who he thought was going to put it inside? He quickly got the point and did it himself. I'd like to raise boys that will one day be excellent partners and look after their own homes successfully.

Cosywintertime · 05/11/2023 13:52

I think there is some defensiveness on this thread op. Like you have hit a nerve. My husband does equal amounts, and if he’s occasionally lax I will say your turn for the dishwasher, or can you get the hoovering done now before we sit down. And if required I will keep saying it. It’s seldom required though. I certainly won’t do it. It will keep being said till it’s done. That’s incredibly rare though. He usually just does it.

he’s a grown up and perfectly capable. I’m not his mother. This isn’t the 1950s and we will equally contribute to the upkeep of our home.

TedMullins · 05/11/2023 13:50

I also think many people make work for themselves - when I see “running the house and doing the finances” I just think what exactly does that involve in this day and age? Set up automatic direct debits and you don’t have to think about it until contracts are up for renewal which you get a reminder for anyway on email usually. No idea what “running a house” means if it’s something different to laundry and cleaning and food shopping (which yes, of course men should play an equal part in, but also are things literally everyone has to do whether they’re single, married, a parent, childfree, have a job, are a SAHP)

Melodysmum12 · 05/11/2023 13:41

Totally agree. My husband is amazing and does everything equally. He works full time and me 25 hours around school runs. I feel very lucky but if he didn’t help out, I’d not tolerate it.

Burnoutwhat · 05/11/2023 13:39

It's not my situation but I'm sick of seeing posts like this where people can't even do basic thinking about others situation. Can you really not think about why others may not put their foot down? Really?

alwaysmovingforwards · 05/11/2023 13:38

gannett · 05/11/2023 13:18

I don't personally identify with those posts either, and I'm not convinced the behaviour is really that gendered - as a woman who's very much on the slatternly, messy side. I pull my weight but I don't care about tidiness anywhere near as much as DP does, and I have no desire to spend any more than the bare minimum of time thinking about domestic crap. I'm always astonished at how much people willingly put on their own plates that they don't need to. But then I'm also child-free and not maternal, which I suspect is linked.

The other pattern I notice on MN though is on dating threads where women pretty much exclusively want to find "traditional", stereotypically manly men. Most MNers seem to want to find tall, burly rugby-playing men who look like good "protectors" and earn enough to be good "providers" (and presumably who want to play those roles too). Short men are talked about with disdain, men on low salaries are cocklodgers, and generally any man who deviates from traditional masculinity gives you the ick.

It shouldn't take a genius to work out that if you look for traditional masculinity, well then that's what you get down the line as well - a man who thinks his job is more important than your career, and who thinks it's your role to run the house by yourself. Even if he doesn't say so out loud at first.

Really good points raised.

Whenever I read those posts about how hard their lives are I often think:

a) just leave then, judging by the post they bring nothing to the table so just go and you'll no doubt be absolutely fine running the life you want and laying all those bills as a singleton...

b) if he's a bit shit and you're not going to leave... you picked him! Sorry to sound harsh but if having done the checks & balances during courtship to assess relationship suitability and he's the best you could find (because your 'perfect partner' errrr didn't cross paths with you?shall we say or lives in your imagination), then welcome to your chosen life.

c) I often wonder how much 'mental load' could be attributed to just not being better organised & getting stuff done. I mean, the length of some posts going into extreme but uncoordinated detail from people who are supposedly completely overwhelmed with organising kids dentals appointments and navigating the social dynamics of the school gate collection area... staggering.

TedMullins · 05/11/2023 13:38

gannett · 05/11/2023 13:18

I don't personally identify with those posts either, and I'm not convinced the behaviour is really that gendered - as a woman who's very much on the slatternly, messy side. I pull my weight but I don't care about tidiness anywhere near as much as DP does, and I have no desire to spend any more than the bare minimum of time thinking about domestic crap. I'm always astonished at how much people willingly put on their own plates that they don't need to. But then I'm also child-free and not maternal, which I suspect is linked.

The other pattern I notice on MN though is on dating threads where women pretty much exclusively want to find "traditional", stereotypically manly men. Most MNers seem to want to find tall, burly rugby-playing men who look like good "protectors" and earn enough to be good "providers" (and presumably who want to play those roles too). Short men are talked about with disdain, men on low salaries are cocklodgers, and generally any man who deviates from traditional masculinity gives you the ick.

It shouldn't take a genius to work out that if you look for traditional masculinity, well then that's what you get down the line as well - a man who thinks his job is more important than your career, and who thinks it's your role to run the house by yourself. Even if he doesn't say so out loud at first.

Agree with all of this and I’m also like you - I’m a lazy slob who can’t cook basically. I do as little domestic drudgery as I can get away with simply because I don’t like it and don’t have very high standards of cleanliness, it certainly isn’t ingrained in me as a woman.

Tessisme · 05/11/2023 13:36

But surely women let this happen?

Oh dear. Apart from the victim blaming aspect of this question/statement, there is also the fact that males and females have already been exposed to gender stereotyping long before they reach adulthood. And I think we all know who generally benefits from such stereotyping.

BogHag · 05/11/2023 13:33

If it was that simple it wouldn’t be a problem, would it?

Thelnebriati · 05/11/2023 13:31

No, women don't 'let this happen'. Its a deliberate abuse tactic designed to take up all of your time and energy.I think you imagine that if she stops doing the housework, it means he'll 'have' to do it. He won't, and he won't pay a cleaner either; he'll just ignore it, and if she complains about the mess he'll say her standards are 'too high'.

Ollifer · 05/11/2023 13:24

Forgot to add onto my post - i do find it unacceptable that a lot of men still think it's woman's work to do the housework and childcare (and is a lot of the reason I am now a single parent and plan to remain one!!!)

Younghearts · 05/11/2023 13:23

I understand what you mean. I guess it’s one of them things where it’s easier said than done to put your foot down.

I’m quite lucky that my DH does a lot (sometimes more than me tbh) round the house and is a great dad to our son from the minute he gets home from work. It upsets me when I see woman complain about how lazy their DH’s are when it comes to house work and looking after the children. A friend of mine constantly was upset her DH didn’t even change a nappy or feed the baby. I mean I just couldn’t put up with it

NewMum0305 · 05/11/2023 13:23

dameofdilemma · 05/11/2023 13:08

Pre kids it's easy to share the load equally.

Post kids it becomes a game of chicken to see if you're prepared to let your kid go to school without lunch money to make a point.

Spot on. Should I not buy my children new clothes when they grow out of them, or book their vaccinations, to make the point to my husband that he needs to take on the mental load.

How does “just stop doing things” work when it’s your children who will feel the consequences?

Swipe left for the next trending thread