Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing 'I carry all the load' posts

164 replies

ijustdontunderstanditall · 05/11/2023 12:22

Can't do a poll as on the app

It feels every other post atm is a woman being annoyed because they do everything, and their partner just goes to work, doesn't help with kids/house/life admin etc

Maybe I am just lucky that I don't have this issue, but I just don't understand why people don't just put their foot down and stop doing it all? Surely when the dinner isn't cooked/ hoover put round/ bill paid the other person will man up and help?

OP posts:
Wwwnothingdotcom · 05/11/2023 15:41

Painto · 05/11/2023 15:39

Wwwnothingdotcom

It's great if you can fix stuff but - how is it sad not to? Personally, I don't do that stuff because my DH and FIL enjoy it. My DF also is good at it.

If they weren't around, I might learn. Or just, you know, pay someone. It's not the end of the world and call it it 'sad' is way more patronising than anything anyone said to you...

I don't make my own soup because I can buy a perfectly good version at the store. I don't fix cars because I can get someone else to do it🤷‍♀️

No, it's not sadnot to.
It's sad to do "women possibly can't do that😱" charade.

And repressuring boiler really isn't "repair" tbh

Painto · 05/11/2023 15:39

Wwwnothingdotcom

It's great if you can fix stuff but - how is it sad not to? Personally, I don't do that stuff because my DH and FIL enjoy it. My DF also is good at it.

If they weren't around, I might learn. Or just, you know, pay someone. It's not the end of the world and call it it 'sad' is way more patronising than anything anyone said to you...

I don't make my own soup because I can buy a perfectly good version at the store. I don't fix cars because I can get someone else to do it🤷‍♀️

C8H10N4O2 · 05/11/2023 15:39

ijustdontunderstanditall · 05/11/2023 12:30

But surely women let this happen?

I get it to a certain extent if you are a SAHP, which i was when the kids were small, I did most of the kid stuff then, BUT DH has always done his share of house/garden/ life stuff

Why are smug posters who don't have this problem so keen to hold women responsible for the behaviour of men?

Wwwnothingdotcom · 05/11/2023 15:34

Chanelbasketballandchain · 05/11/2023 15:13

Because men change over time. Nobody knowingly marries a selfish or abusive person.

that's not strictly true. Some women are convinced they will change a man, some women decide to show off their domestic skills thinking it makes them good marriage potential.

Anyone should change and step up when they have kids, but we still live in a world where women see being house-proud as a quality, and find it cute to be useless with DIY, cars, gardening.

Yy to the "cutsue ditsy can't hadle basic DIY". DH had to leave for 4 months to take care of something back in his country 2 years ago. I am in my 30s. The number of horrified women that I am in house by myself was astounding.
"aren't you scared?!"
"Do you need shopping or anything?"
"Do you need Peter to do any DIY?"
"Oh I could never😱"
While these would normally be nice offers, the tone they were offered in was totally highpitched "damsel in distress needs help".

I was in a meeting few weeks in and mentioned about needing to change pipe leading to boiler because I realised it's ever so slightly dripping when I was repressuring boiler, so I called local firm to sort it and they might come during the meeting. Cue "omg I could never dare to try to repressure it. So brave" from few of the women while the rest raised eyebrows as I did. Nothing about that was brave or worth an amazement. I just watched youtube video when we first needed to repressure it🤷

They were nice women and smart, but some of them were fully into "haha screwdriver, I possibly couldn't know how to use it" mode. It's sad imho.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/11/2023 15:27

It does seem depressingly common. However I don't think it's as easy just to stop doing things. I'm not in this position but on threads I've read, the women don't feel like they can stop cleaning as their kids will live in a dirty house, stop tidying as their kids will live in a messy house, stop walking the dog as it will go crazy in the house and create even more mess, stop doing the laundry as their kids won't have clean clothes etc. Yes they can stop doing things for their partner, but they still have more than their share of stuff that's pretty essential in looking after themselves and their kids. They can't just go on strike and stop driving the kids to school, making their packed lunches etc as often the dads don't actually step up, they let their kids suffer then guilt the mother into taking the blame, calling her 'selfish', and saying that they will withdraw their financial support if she withdraws practical support. So I can see how women feel trapped into putting up with it

RhymesWithOrange · 05/11/2023 15:26

Chanelbasketballandchain · 05/11/2023 15:13

Because men change over time. Nobody knowingly marries a selfish or abusive person.

that's not strictly true. Some women are convinced they will change a man, some women decide to show off their domestic skills thinking it makes them good marriage potential.

Anyone should change and step up when they have kids, but we still live in a world where women see being house-proud as a quality, and find it cute to be useless with DIY, cars, gardening.

But ask yourself why this is the case (I don't actually agree with your point that women find it "cute" to be hopeless at DIY but never mind).

From before birth both men and women have different expectations set for them. They learn from the examples of their parents, from media, from society.

I think of clever, ambitious women in past generations, cut off from opportunities to achieve outside of the home, channeling all into the only outlets they had. If all you were allowed to be was a mother and a housewife you'd probably try to excel at it as well.

MargaretThursday · 05/11/2023 15:13

Two things:

  1. People who don't want to moan don't start threads. If they did go on a moaning thread and say "dh does more" then they'd get told they were smug and to get off the thread.
  2. I suspect sometimes there's a lack of seeing what the other does. When the dc were small and I was sahm I could have written that I "did all the cleaning, almost all the cooking, all the night wakings, he never hoovered, never cleaned the toilets, I did the washing and hung it out almost always, I organised any maintenance needing doing...". But looking back is easier to realise he did a lot too, as well as working full time. He almost always did the food shop (and took the dc with him which gave me a break), some DIY, sorted the accounts and bills, washing up etc. There's a point with small children where I think everyone feels exhausted and it seems relentless and it's easy to think that you're doing it all and not seeing what the other one does (I remember when dh commented that towels were normally washed annually - because he'd never done it, and normally I washed and hung them up to dry and put them away in the time he was at work).
Chanelbasketballandchain · 05/11/2023 15:13

Because men change over time. Nobody knowingly marries a selfish or abusive person.

that's not strictly true. Some women are convinced they will change a man, some women decide to show off their domestic skills thinking it makes them good marriage potential.

Anyone should change and step up when they have kids, but we still live in a world where women see being house-proud as a quality, and find it cute to be useless with DIY, cars, gardening.

Coolblur · 05/11/2023 15:09

You've clearly never been in this position OP. If just not doing things so they'll have to step up worked, there wouldn't be an issue. But instead no one does anything so the situation is worse.

What women in this position should realise is that if they work and can support their family, care for the kids, manage the housework and carry the mental load, they don't actually need their 'partner' anymore and can consider going it alone. That is truly liberating, especially once their 'partner' realises it too.

Painto · 05/11/2023 14:58

Agree that these threads are dead boring

BUT

Have you ever actually been in this situation? It's very bloody hard to put your foot down. I tried it and was accused of being an awful bully and having no empathy🙄

This was after months of cleaning up after another adult and being as accommodating as I can tolerate.

Gnomegnomegnome · 05/11/2023 14:51

I think that often things are equal until they have children. Usually the woman takes time off for maternity leave and ends up doing more of the home/child stuff simply because she’s there more and then when she returns to work they struggle to go back to doing equal shares. It shouldn’t happen but I can see how it might.

Xh was raised by sexist twats who thought that their prince shouldn’t lift a finger (they proudly used to laugh about xfil never having changed a nappy despite having 7 children). Trying to make him realise that my vagina didn’t help me to clean. I shouldn’t have married him but I was young and stupid, I thought that I could fix him.

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 05/11/2023 14:48

Maybe I am just lucky that I don't have this issue, but I just don't understand why people don't just put their foot down and stop doing it all? Surely when the dinner isn't cooked/ hoover put round/ bill paid the other person will man up and help?

They don't. I think people who are with reasonable partners don't realise how bad some partners are. And it creeps up on you - you yourself don't realise how bad your partner is, because exactly - who would do that to someone else!

As I withdrew labour (eg. not picking up his socks, asking him to cook/do the washing occasionally, put the kids to bed, buy his own car insurance or book his own flights and do his own packing) he barely did the stuff for himself, let alone start pulling his weight with the kids. He withdrew further and further, started travelling for work more, and it turned out, started seeing prostitutes and having affairs.

Some people genuinely only see relationships as a transactional agreement that should benefit them or they wander off - but they're good at pretending until they have their mug trapped.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 05/11/2023 14:48

LaurieStrode · 05/11/2023 14:41

Why do they choose these men to mate with?

Have you RTFT? There have been numerous explanations.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 05/11/2023 14:47

54isanopendoor · 05/11/2023 14:45

I'm not typical but I had 2 kids with a man who appeared to 'do his bit'
(worked full time, did DIY, cleaned, took care of car etc, whilst I did more cooking & childcare as we played to our strengths). We then had 2 ASD kids.
I became disabled. He did less & less then buggered off. I didn't 'let it happen'.

& everything @Aurasauras said upthread.

I'm so sorry this happened, the statistics for men who leave women who have been diagnosed with cancer or left disabled are shocking.

54isanopendoor · 05/11/2023 14:45

I'm not typical but I had 2 kids with a man who appeared to 'do his bit'
(worked full time, did DIY, cleaned, took care of car etc, whilst I did more cooking & childcare as we played to our strengths). We then had 2 ASD kids.
I became disabled. He did less & less then buggered off. I didn't 'let it happen'.

& everything @Aurasauras said upthread.

LaurieStrode · 05/11/2023 14:41

DustyLee123 · 05/11/2023 12:32

So you’re blaming it on females? Why should they live in a shit hole just because the man won’t lift a finger, you do it for yourself.

Why do they choose these men to mate with?

Aurasauras · 05/11/2023 14:37

Because men change over time. Nobody knowingly marries a selfish or abusive person. They generally wait until the woman is pregnant and trapped. If you do leave, your kids grow up without a dad and you still carry the load but with extra financial worries.

So, a lot of women choose to stay, let the kids have a father and a house and a “normal” childhood then simmer with rage and frustration. Marriage is for life for many. Unfortunately some people use this to leverage the perks for themselves and the burden for their partner.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 05/11/2023 14:36

Scalottia · 05/11/2023 12:42

YANBU OP.

To a certain extent - some women DO let it happen.

I am not one of those women.

I am not saying that the men in these relationships aren't to blame - they are. But for some reason the women stay with them and continue to do everything for them. Why? Where are we going wrong with raising our sons/daughters that this keeps happening?

The gender pay gap still exists and life is expensive, women feel trapped financially.

In abusive relationships you either are forced to share your children with your abuser (the court even helps continue the abuse) so you're terrified something will happen to them and you can't protect them.

Most relationships don't start off bad and society continues to the vicious cycle for our children. I got out of one of these relationships and life isn't roses now, although for it's preferable.

FannyBawz · 05/11/2023 14:36

Many women have children with arseholes. Lucky you, you didn’t. Neither did I. But I would never start such a smug thread blaming women for the fact that so many men are simply SHIT.

Maybe focus your energies into the next generation and if you have daughters teach them not to tolerate entitled male behaviour: if you have sons train them to early with domestic responsibilities and don’t let them become the selfish man babies that so many women find themselves saddled with.

PiglingQuartet · 05/11/2023 14:35

Is it not just another symptom of female dependence on men?
I will presume the man is working to contribute to their lifestyle, or else the women wouldn't marry them. Why would a woman stick around in this situation? Perhaps she needs to vent about the heavy load to distract from her choice to marry into mortgage security and a lifestyle that financially affords children.
It would make far more sense to be either A) Completely self sufficient, or B) admit to choosing this lifestyle for the financial security.

Perhaps if more women were financially secure they wouldn't end up in situations like this in the first place. Once you have had a child, you are dependent upon either the state or a man, unless your single income is sufficiently high enough to cover it all. This is possible, but less common. I suppose in this sense 'financial security' is a feminist issue.

Wwwnothingdotcom · 05/11/2023 14:31

I want him to remember to make a hair appointment, not wait to get told to make one.
Like for HIS haircut?
The only time I say anything about his hair is if he changes barber and they give him too short cut. I cannot imagine life with adult I would have to remind to get haircut.

randomusername2019 · 05/11/2023 14:30

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Heatherbell1978 · 05/11/2023 14:28

Because it's not about tasks, it's about the mental load. Two different things. It doesn't make my life easier by writing down a list of tasks DH needs to do and then spending time following up said tasks. I want to not have to write a list. I want him to remember to make a hair appointment, not wait to get told to make one.
If it was as simple as giving him jobs to do, there would be no issue.

Wwwnothingdotcom · 05/11/2023 14:27

While dynamics can change with circumstances, and we all understand that, there is frustrating number of women who say "well he was always like that since I met him,". That is so incredibly frustrating

LoneFemaleTraveller · 05/11/2023 14:26

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

This i couldnt be quiet about. It sounds like the beginnings of coercive control. He is making her have significantly less disposable income, which limits her freedom. He has her do all the housework, which limits her free time.