Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing 'I carry all the load' posts

164 replies

ijustdontunderstanditall · 05/11/2023 12:22

Can't do a poll as on the app

It feels every other post atm is a woman being annoyed because they do everything, and their partner just goes to work, doesn't help with kids/house/life admin etc

Maybe I am just lucky that I don't have this issue, but I just don't understand why people don't just put their foot down and stop doing it all? Surely when the dinner isn't cooked/ hoover put round/ bill paid the other person will man up and help?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TwinklyWinkly · 07/11/2023 20:13

TheClitterati · 07/11/2023 20:10

This is why I will no longer live with men.

Yes.

TheClitterati · 07/11/2023 20:10

This is why I will no longer live with men.

Goldbar · 07/11/2023 20:03

@Resilience. I agree with you.

It's interesting that women are refusing to have children (or not having "enough") and a lot of people are very worried about this. So while having children and caring for them is seen as an individual matter (with the burden disproportionately falling on women), not having them is seen as a societal issue.

Resilience · 07/11/2023 19:04

Society fundamentally relies on people having children to fill skills gaps, fund pensions, etc. This benefits everyone, not just mothers. But mothers pay a disproportionate price for that. Granted, most mothers aren't having children for society but for themselves, but so do fathers yet it doesn't have the same impact on them.

Women end up mostly being the ones who step back from working because they're the only ones who can gestate and lactate. Many, like me, would have loved to have had DC without that but (like men do) but biology got in the way. Once that stage has happened, the precedent is set for all the reasons I gave in my earlier post.

I was a single parent so both breadwinner and primary carer. Fortunately, also a professional so able to buy in child care (although it left me skint). For those not earning that kind of money, the costs are prohibitive. And so the inequality starts.

If women refused to have children, society would collapse. Yet we don't protect women who have children. That's not fair.

Chanelbasketballandchain · 07/11/2023 09:56

Painto · 07/11/2023 09:34

Allen shouldn't be disadvantaged for having a family but on can't really expect to be given a promotion or pay rise when you're not there or doing reduced hours.

that would be unfair on women just as much as men.

Child-free workers, or people who organise childcare in such a way the children don't impact on their work schedule should not be penalised or discriminated against parents.

And I said that as a mum!

Painto · 07/11/2023 09:34

Allen shouldn't be disadvantaged for having a family but on can't really expect to be given a promotion or pay rise when you're not there or doing reduced hours.

SomersetBrie · 07/11/2023 08:47

LaurieStrode · 06/11/2023 23:17

We have a gender earnings gap, not pay gap.

Of course people who choose to exit the workforce to focus on other lifestyle choices are going to earn less than those who keep noses to the grindstone. As they should. Can't have it all.

There are tradeoffs to having children. Expecting otherwise is rather naive. Presumably the upside of having one's offspring compensates for any losses or downsides.

People doing the same job should be paid the same. It's not about years of service.
I agree the obviously better jobs might go to more experienced people and that is a whole other issue, but there are still businesses where men are paid more because they are men and not because they didn't take time off to raise their family.

LaurieStrode · 06/11/2023 23:17

We have a gender earnings gap, not pay gap.

Of course people who choose to exit the workforce to focus on other lifestyle choices are going to earn less than those who keep noses to the grindstone. As they should. Can't have it all.

There are tradeoffs to having children. Expecting otherwise is rather naive. Presumably the upside of having one's offspring compensates for any losses or downsides.

Resilience · 06/11/2023 15:14

Interesting, if slightly goady, thread.

I'm in one of those equal relationships. I have a very low tolerance for doing more than my fair share of housework. DC have been brought up to do their own laundry, make their own packed lunches etc since they started secondary school. Everyone cleans the toilet after they've used it. Other cleaning/cooking is done by rota.

I'm the same person who, in a different relationship, found myself doing way more than my fair share having had DC despite never noticing it before. When I tackled him on it, he became psychologically abusive. I left shortly afterwards when the increasing rows turned physical.

I've done a lot of thinking about this and laud the post above which explains that not pulling your weight domestically can be a form of domestic abuse.

I think it's really important to understand that none of this happens in a vacuum.

Humans are a social species and we're status driven. Our home and belongings are not just seen as our safe places but also as representative of ourselves . Across many cultures it's desirable to have a warm, welcoming home and to be hospitable. Men want this too! We all want to live somewhere safe and pleasant and to feel pride when someone comes to see us in it. It's natural, therefore, to make an effort to keep our homes pleasant. No one should feel dismissed for taking pride in making a nice home. Barring OCD-levels of cleaning, this is a natural behaviour IMO. The problem is not what some (mainly women) are doing. It's what some (mainly men) are not doing.

We also have a persistent gender pay gap that, funnily enough, is largely explained by the fact that women have children, since it largely doesn't exists until that point. The biggest way to reduce the gender pay gap would be that women stop having DC, but no one suggests that.

We also happen to live in a society where home making and child care doesn't count towards GDP. It has no 'real' economic value (unless you have to buy it, of course).

Our social set up actually encourage this division of labour since someone has to have the children and raise them but the state doesn't want to subsidise that, placing the responsibility on individual families. Since few families will earn enough to comfortably pay for a full time nanny, one parent nearly always ends up scaling back or giving up work completely and it's usually the mother because of things like breastfeeding and social expectations.

So, even for many women who have maintained independence until having children, it's not uncommon to find themselves on a lesser salary (or devoid of one completely) having children. In a society that says there is only a moral value to being a good mum, not a financial one. Many respond by trying to "pull their weight" in other ways, even if their DH doesn't actually expect that of them. And our patriarchal society encourages this.

Chanelbasketballandchain · 06/11/2023 14:40

It tells you all you need to know when a woman can only be accused of "misogyny" because you don't agree with her.😂

You kind of prove my point, relying on the same excuses to justify a lack of ambition and the need to be a constant victim.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 06/11/2023 14:27

Chanelbasketballandchain · 06/11/2023 13:19

I've never seen a murder so murder doesn't happen.
what a stupid thing to say.

I am talking about opportunities, real life examples and real life workplace.

A lot of the complaints against the "gender gap" compare different things (a lot ,not all...SOME women complaining that they don't get the same or higher when they refuse to work the same hours and show the same commitments

I think you'll be surprised at the mediocre men earning more than fantastic women. Women calling themselves "fantastic" when they are just as mediocre you mean 😂or when they don't negotiate their contract, or when they don't fight for higher pay rises.

It's this stupid attitude that makes it harder for the rest of us!

And I am saying, just because you haven't seen/experienced the discrimination in your workplace that doesn't mean it doesn't happen. Your anecdote doesn't supercede statistics.

Yes, some of the gender pay gap does cover similar roles not the exact same roles but a lot cover the exact same roles where men are still being paid more. Women generally can't work the same hours or show commitment because of the reasons discussed here - they are expected to parent like they don't work and work like they don't parent, whilst SOME men just abdicate their family commitments to women because society perpetuates this. This is the whole purpose of the thread.

Your internal misogyny is on full display on your last paragraph and it makes you look a bit silly.

drspouse · 06/11/2023 14:00

I've been married 20 years and didn't "audition" as a wife, but rather checked that DH was up to scratch. He'd moved 6 months earlier into a new flat and hadn't got a washing machine yet but was taking his washing home to Mum. He realised this was out of order and sorted it.

Chanelbasketballandchain · 06/11/2023 13:49

SomersetBrie · 06/11/2023 13:30

Your attitude towards women is quite depressing and it is somewhat understandable why you are working in a male environment.

I've been lucky enough not to be discriminated against because I am a woman but I have talked to other people who have, and I believe them.

well, quite. If you just get on with things, "male environments" are not a menace or something to avoid, it's just that.. a work environment.

Of course discrimination exists, so does racism, and any illegal or abusive attitude.

It's not enough of an excuse in this country not to achieve whatever you want to achieve, it's the exception rather than the norm. You meet a dickhead, a racist, or a misogynist, you deal with it, you don't let one individual hold back your entire career

SomersetBrie · 06/11/2023 13:30

Chanelbasketballandchain · 06/11/2023 10:59

Yes, I blame women who use excuses when nothing really stopped them.

I am not talking about countries abusing women, I am talking about my country, where we have exactly the same rights and opportunities. I have never witnessed or heard of a Maths teacher prioritising male students over female, I have never heard of a university discouraging female students.

I have always ended up working in a so-called "male environment", nothing stopped women to join in, they just.. were not there. Men were recruited because we had male applicants. I have never felt inferior let alone worst paid than a male.

If young women struggle to juggle work and family, it's a personal issue. Sort it out before having kids, don't blame "society" for it.

Your attitude towards women is quite depressing and it is somewhat understandable why you are working in a male environment.

I've been lucky enough not to be discriminated against because I am a woman but I have talked to other people who have, and I believe them.

Chanelbasketballandchain · 06/11/2023 13:19

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 06/11/2023 12:48

The 'im alright Jack's attitude is honestly vile and does nothing but make people who say it look ridiculous. I've never seen a murder so murder doesn't happen.

If you can't see why and how society perpetuates women's struggles then I can't help you.

You only have to see the gender pay gap reporting to see that women are worse off than men. I think you'll be surprised at the mediocre men earning more than fantastic women.

I've never seen a murder so murder doesn't happen.
what a stupid thing to say.

I am talking about opportunities, real life examples and real life workplace.

A lot of the complaints against the "gender gap" compare different things (a lot ,not all...SOME women complaining that they don't get the same or higher when they refuse to work the same hours and show the same commitments

I think you'll be surprised at the mediocre men earning more than fantastic women. Women calling themselves "fantastic" when they are just as mediocre you mean 😂or when they don't negotiate their contract, or when they don't fight for higher pay rises.

It's this stupid attitude that makes it harder for the rest of us!

Chanelbasketballandchain · 06/11/2023 13:15

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 06/11/2023 11:30

I am not talking about countries abusing women, I am talking about my country, where we have exactly the same rights and opportunities. I have never witnessed or heard of a Maths teacher prioritising male students over female, I have never heard of a university discouraging female students.

ROFL - I was hounded out of Physics A-level nearly 30 years ago - and let me tell you, as one of only 2 women on my particular Uni course, and one of 4 or 5 max in the lectures shared with other courses, it takes a bit of bottle walking into a room filled with 100 blokes at 18 and standing your ground in discussions.

oh please.

I work with in a "male environment"because I fell into it more than anything, I am not especially bothered one way or another.

It makes 0 difference to be at uni or walk into a conference room with 200 blokes or 200 women, they are people. That coy attitude from SOME women really annoys me, you are a big girl, behave like an adult. Do you walk out of a supermarket if there's a majority of male shoppers there too? Ridiculous.

That's what brings us down, not the men who happened to be there.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 06/11/2023 12:48

Chanelbasketballandchain · 06/11/2023 10:59

Yes, I blame women who use excuses when nothing really stopped them.

I am not talking about countries abusing women, I am talking about my country, where we have exactly the same rights and opportunities. I have never witnessed or heard of a Maths teacher prioritising male students over female, I have never heard of a university discouraging female students.

I have always ended up working in a so-called "male environment", nothing stopped women to join in, they just.. were not there. Men were recruited because we had male applicants. I have never felt inferior let alone worst paid than a male.

If young women struggle to juggle work and family, it's a personal issue. Sort it out before having kids, don't blame "society" for it.

The 'im alright Jack's attitude is honestly vile and does nothing but make people who say it look ridiculous. I've never seen a murder so murder doesn't happen.

If you can't see why and how society perpetuates women's struggles then I can't help you.

You only have to see the gender pay gap reporting to see that women are worse off than men. I think you'll be surprised at the mediocre men earning more than fantastic women.

Goldbar · 06/11/2023 12:09

dameofdilemma · 05/11/2023 13:08

Pre kids it's easy to share the load equally.

Post kids it becomes a game of chicken to see if you're prepared to let your kid go to school without lunch money to make a point.

This. It's very easy to function as adults with no children in the picture if you're not house proud. DH and I managed it for years doing practically nothing:

  • We both ate lunch and breakfast at work - no cooking or cleaning up. We also ate out once or twice a week in the evening, ate 'posh' microwave meals a few times a week, snacked most of the rest of the time and cooked properly maybe a couple of times of week.
  • We did our own laundry.
  • We wiped up any kitchen mess we made and put our dirty plates in the dishwasher.
  • I ran the hoover round the alternate week from the cleaner.

We'd each of us spend less than 10 minutes a day on chores really. The only real points of contention were taking turns over emptying the dishwasher and taking out the bins/recycling.

Compare that to now:

  • Children need 3 healthy meals a day. Packed lunch for the older one if it's a school day. Youngest is 1, so a lot of food ends up on them/the floor. So the floor needs hoovered and the highchair wiped down 3 times a day.
  • School mornings are a nightmare - getting everyone washed, breakfasted, dressed, baby fed, bags packed and out of the house by 7.45am.
  • The older one has guided reading to do every night and homework once a week, so this needs to be supervised. There's often some school project/dress-up day/school trip that needs to be planned for, some line that needs to be learned for a play or assembly or something to take in. PE kit for PE days etc. and making sure we have everything.
  • School run takes up to 2 hours every day.
  • Evenings are an endless round of homework, dinner, bath, bed.
  • Baby still wakes 2-3 times a night.
  • The workload is the same on weekends/holidays - children still need to be fed/washed/exercised/played with/generally loved and cared for.
  • There is endless mess to be cleared up - food mess, dirt from outside, craft mess, toys etc. It is amazing how much mess children can make in a short period of time.

But there is no part of this that I would ignore or just stop doing if my DH didn't pull his weight, because I wouldn't want my children missing out, not being properly cared for or living in an unpleasant home environment.

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 06/11/2023 11:30

I am not talking about countries abusing women, I am talking about my country, where we have exactly the same rights and opportunities. I have never witnessed or heard of a Maths teacher prioritising male students over female, I have never heard of a university discouraging female students.

ROFL - I was hounded out of Physics A-level nearly 30 years ago - and let me tell you, as one of only 2 women on my particular Uni course, and one of 4 or 5 max in the lectures shared with other courses, it takes a bit of bottle walking into a room filled with 100 blokes at 18 and standing your ground in discussions.

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/11/2023 11:24

I agree with you.

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 06/11/2023 11:24

eg. not picking up his socks

Also this. Why would I pick up his socks for him?! If he leaves them on the floor, so what? They're his socks!

(The laundry is my job so if they are next to the laundry basket I'll pick them up but if he leaves them on the other side of the bed that's his problem. Though tbh my socks are the ones that are strewn all over the floor. He doesn't have to pick them up. It's a non-issue. If that's your mental load just get rid of it!)

OK - that's what I did, he just bought more, eventually every table and chair had his socks underneath them, collecting dust, stopping the robohoover going round (bought because I was the only one who ever hoovered or swept), some cases just looking bad and embarrassing if I had a guest, in some cases actually smelling. I either had the work of picking them up, or the mental drag of seeing them everywhere I looked.

My half-way house was chucking them all in a box, with everything else he left lying around that was in my or the children's way - but that's no solution either, that was just another illustrates the issues with the relationship.

Chanelbasketballandchain · 06/11/2023 10:59

RhymesWithOrange · 05/11/2023 15:54

@Chanelbasketballandchain there's still a massive gap between high flying men and women, and misogyny/patriarchy is just as strong even if the law has moved on (in most, not all countries. Women do not have equal access to professional/public roles. Young women today are still facing really difficult choices about how to afford/juggle career and family and still have time/money left over for themselves.

Men are just using different methods to control women's participation in work and society now. They can't outright discriminate but they still use coercive control in relationships, ugly trolling on SM against women in the public eye (see Caroline Criado Perez) etc., deprioritisation of issues affecting women in public policy. There's still a long way to go.

But yeah, let's blame women for their predicament 🤔

Yes, I blame women who use excuses when nothing really stopped them.

I am not talking about countries abusing women, I am talking about my country, where we have exactly the same rights and opportunities. I have never witnessed or heard of a Maths teacher prioritising male students over female, I have never heard of a university discouraging female students.

I have always ended up working in a so-called "male environment", nothing stopped women to join in, they just.. were not there. Men were recruited because we had male applicants. I have never felt inferior let alone worst paid than a male.

If young women struggle to juggle work and family, it's a personal issue. Sort it out before having kids, don't blame "society" for it.

CliantheLang · 05/11/2023 22:34

So from his perspective, he was working longer hours than you (to put food on the table), and perhaps thought that you would reciprocate by cooking dinner.

Except...

he wasn't working longer hours.

I hate to burst any bubbles but keeping house and caring for family members IS work. Which is why we pay cooks, teachers, nurses, cleaners and carers to do everything that wives, mothers and daughters are expected to do for free.

I suppose all the posters blaming women for their own oppression think women should just walk away and leave their kids and elderly parents to make do without them.

I have other suggestions but I don't want to get banned.

TedMullins · 05/11/2023 22:08

gannett · 05/11/2023 21:46

Same here, except it wasn't so much a persona as the real thing. And when I met DP, becoming slightly less of a slattern was my compromise - his was to let some of his standards drop. I'm pretty happy that a tiny amount of his cooking skills have rubbed off on me, though he still does almost all of it.

It wasn't a deliberate tactic but who knew that being a fun-times party girl who stayed out clubbing every weekend would weed out so many shit men.

Same. I remember years ago dating an older guy who it turned out was a massive misogynist and subscriber to the notion of traditional gender roles. Didn’t stop me lying in bed til gone lunchtime every weekend and never doing any cleaning or cooking. Well, I would occasionally but not near as often as he wanted and my cooking is terrible. He actually did start doing all that stuff himself but he did berate me about my slovenliness and complain he didn’t have any clean work shirts, I told him to just take care of his own laundry and I’d do mine because his work shirts weren’t any of my concern. So he ended up doing most of the domestic stuff and being the higher earner. I’m now the higher earner with my current partner and he does all the cooking and I’d say we’re 50/50 on cleaning because we’re both slobs and happy to do it once a week or less, so it’s easy to share. He will do more laundry than me during the week. It’s just never occurred to me to want to be a homemaker or give out the persona of a domestic goddess. I don’t care what men or wider society think of me and I’d rather not conform to a traditional idea of femininity. How did I (and @gannett) miss out on that part of socialisation that apparently all women get that makes them do it?

TedMullins · 05/11/2023 22:07

gannett · 05/11/2023 21:46

Same here, except it wasn't so much a persona as the real thing. And when I met DP, becoming slightly less of a slattern was my compromise - his was to let some of his standards drop. I'm pretty happy that a tiny amount of his cooking skills have rubbed off on me, though he still does almost all of it.

It wasn't a deliberate tactic but who knew that being a fun-times party girl who stayed out clubbing every weekend would weed out so many shit men.

Same. I remember years ago dating an older guy who it turned out was a massive misogynist and subscriber to the notion of traditional gender roles. Didn’t stop me lying in bed til gone lunchtime every weekend and never doing any cleaning or cooking. Well, I would occasionally but not near as often as he wanted and my cooking is terrible. He actually did start doing all that stuff himself but he did berate me about my slovenliness and complain he didn’t have any clean work shirts, I told him to just take care of his own laundry and I’d do mine because his work shirts weren’t any of my concern. So he ended up doing most of the domestic stuff and being the higher earner. I’m now the higher earner with my current partner and he does all the cooking and I’d say we’re 50/50 on cleaning because we’re both slobs and happy to do it once a week or less, so it’s easy to share. He will do more laundry than me during the week. It’s just never occurred to me to want to be a homemaker or give out the persona of a domestic goddess. I don’t care what men or wider society think of me and I’d rather not conform to a traditional idea of femininity. How did I (and @gannett) miss out on that part of socialisation that apparently all women get that makes them do it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread