Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School wrap-around - what do we do ?

414 replies

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 09:52

Hi,
DD (4) just started reception. I chose the school based on local reputation plus the availability of breakfast club and after school club to facilitate us still working. The school explained to us in a meeting that the after school club runs daily.
Fast forward to a week before term in September and the club (who are a private company hired by the school), says they aren't running due to a lack of staff.
Panic stations as we have no local family and not huge flexibility with our jobs. Partner WFH twice a week so collects then and I work 4 days. So we needed after school club for two afternoons.
The schools response was 'that's a shame but nothing we do'.
We've had to juggle it with another local parent who collects on the two days we needed and we take her DS to school every day. Workable in the very short term but not long term as she is having to leave work super early those days and meet important meetings.
I've emailed the school a few times asking for updates and it's all very 'no nothing sorry '.

I'm at the point where I'm wondering do we move schools to one where they have nursery wraparound.
Also one childminder serves the school we chose, and she's full with a waiting list.

What has also annoyed me is that when we went to info afternoon with the school where they told us the club runs daily , that it wasn't even true. The after-school club told us they ran for two days a week last academic year , and not even the days we needed.

Has anyone else experienced similar before? I feel very stressed. I changed my job of 12 years due to DD starting school and wonder now why I bothered as we're in a worse logistical situation thanks to this.

There's nothing from the club or school about when this is going to be resolved.

OP posts:
margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:39

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 11:37

Wakeywake, the school's first priority is the children, not working parents

These are, however, one and the same. If parents are unable to pay bills, of course that will impact the children.

OP, I would move without delay. They've misled you on this, how do you know they won't do similar again.

The thing is, though, any school could suddenly decide to stop offering childcare as it's not something they have a legal obligation to provide.

OP could move schools and find herself in the same situation next September.

Saschka · 05/11/2023 11:38

arintingly · 05/11/2023 11:04

Well exactly. On Mumsnet it's this huge problem and impossible to solve.

All of our local schools have wraparound care and have no difficulty in finding staff to run it.

Ours is run by TAs who are very happy to have a full day's work and salary not just school hours

Same here - every school locally offers breakfast club and ASC. The idea that this is a huge imposition on the school, and women should just give up their silly little pin money jobs and be SAHMs because it’s just far too hard for the school to organise, is frankly bizarre.

And no, a nanny is not a realistic option - they want FT hours, and that would cost me about £50k per year including NICs, pension contributions etc, which is more than I earn after tax as a hospital consultant. A childminder would work, but OP says there aren’t any with spaces locally. Presumably because there are no ASCs running.

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 11:37

Wakeywake, the school's first priority is the children, not working parents

These are, however, one and the same. If parents are unable to pay bills, of course that will impact the children.

OP, I would move without delay. They've misled you on this, how do you know they won't do similar again.

spanieleyes · 05/11/2023 11:37

Hang on! There was certainly some confusion over the days the AS provision was available ( but the fact is that when the OP enquired about the days available , the provider was happy to say there would be provision on the days they needed) but why is the school to blame for the providers later decision not to continue? the OP said the decision to choose the school was because AS provision was in place. Unless the school was aware that the provider was going to close some 10 months later ( the time between application for school places and starting Reception) it's hardly misleading to say it's available when it was at the time!

Rubyupbeat · 05/11/2023 11:35

Gymmum82 · 05/11/2023 09:57

That’s really crap and honestly I think it is the school’s responsibility to source a wrap around provider. Parents work. They don’t work school hours. If the school isn’t going to provide wrap around care then it’s not a viable option for most children.
I would move schools personally. They clearly aren’t going to help with a solution so you have no choice

How the hell is the school responsible for childcare?, they provide an educational setting and that's it. After school and breakfast clubs are a bonus, but, as in this case, if it becomes a problem because the provider are short staffed, then it is what it is. It's the parents responsibility to provide childcare, as it should be.
Hire an Au pair or nanny.

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 05/11/2023 11:35

arintingly · 05/11/2023 11:04

Well exactly. On Mumsnet it's this huge problem and impossible to solve.

All of our local schools have wraparound care and have no difficulty in finding staff to run it.

Ours is run by TAs who are very happy to have a full day's work and salary not just school hours

We struggle to get TAs, let alone TAs who don't have their own family commitments after school hours. That doesn't work everywhere, especially now that salaries are higher in the local superstores than TA packets.

margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:35

DarkDarkNight · 05/11/2023 11:30

Not everyone can afford a nanny or even a nanny share.

The OP chose the school (as others may have too) specifically because of the wraparound childcare the school said they had.

I have family help so don’t rely on wraparound care but have colleagues who do and it is really stressful for them when schools decide often at very short notice that clubs won’t be running. This country is ridiculous, there is such pressure for parents to be working full time but not much help is provided.

But it wasn't the school cancelling the childcare. It was run by a private company who decided it was no longer viable. That could happen to anyone.

I do agree there should be more/better childcare but it's not the schools' fault that that childcare doesn't exist.

Busephalus · 05/11/2023 11:35

Wakeywake, the school's first priority is the children, not working parents

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/11/2023 11:33

modgepodge · 05/11/2023 11:15

Yes there are expenses for running childcare of course. But surely lots of these are reduced if the school runs it themself? Schools offer free after school clubs for football, chess etc and these don’t cost the school anything (except staff goodwill/cost depending on if they’re paying staff for it). What additional expenses would the school running their own ACS using their own staff (TAs for example) incur? They own the building so no hire cost, I’ve already mentioned staffing and cost for food, not sure if additional insurance would be required if it was run on site by TAs or whoever. What else? Not trying to be difficult, genuinely interested.

(I’m a teacher at a school which runs its own ASC on site at much lower cost than I pay for my own daughter’s ASC which is run by a private company!)

They'd need to pay somebody a significantly higher salary to be in charge - somebody with DSL training/a senior member of staff. Probably somebody to train school leavers as they're the most likely to be available at that time of day.

There's paying site staff to stay later.

It's not standard educational activity. There would need to be ways of keeping kids and parents away from the majority of the school premises. Somebody controlling the gate when the office staff have finished for the day. Working around parents' evenings, open evenings, parts used as polling stations, INSET days.

Depending upon the school itself (maintained or academy), the financial procedures could require it to be run as a separate entity, at which point the law requires them to not provide use for free or at a reduced cost.

Separate insurance. Variations to contracts and the associated increase in employer's contributions.

The implications for somebody expected to do breakfast club, lunch cover and after school on their maximum working periods, especially if they're also working throughout lesson time, as they would then require mandatory breaks, taking them away from children in school hours.

Separate accounting for the ASC, increasing the cost of finance staff, bank account administration, different legal requirements.

Credit control - as parents can and do omit to pay and then don't turn up to collect their children, thinking 'it's just the school, they're already there, why should I pay for this?'.

And if nobody wants to work 11 hour days with no break for a fraction over minimum wage, they're in the same position of having to close the ASC if they can't find random teenagers prepared to be there just when older women would need to look after their own children.

Add in holiday clubs with a whole other world of issues on top.

It's very complex and fraught with difficulties - which is why it's been something that external providers do.

Wakeywake · 05/11/2023 11:31

I'd change school. They misled you and don't give a damn about working parents. You can bet this will be reflected in other aspects of the school life.

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 05/11/2023 11:31

TheYearOfSmallThings · 05/11/2023 10:03

I would move school without delay. You need wraparound childcare, and you need a school that takes this need seriously - some do (and working parents choose these) and some don't (and attract the SAHP market).

Even if they patch something together now, you know they don't see it as any of their remit, and you will have more problems in the future.

This

Plus the school wasn't honest. There was no need to lie, and yet they did. Probably in a quest to fill classes for funding purposes, but that isn't your issue. It's theirs. And you can't trust them going forward.

I'd contact your local authority as well. Tell them the school deliberately misled you, and likely other parents, and that after school care is needed. Some local authorities will help try to get provision into schools where there is need.

Helpdontknowwhattosay · 05/11/2023 11:31

Ahh I know how you feel OP. DS's school cancelled their after school club, this year and it's been really difficult. Thankfully my DM doesn't work so she has been able to help, but she's often unwell so it's not always a given. DHs work have been really resistant to offering the flexibility to WFH that they promised when he first started and I can't WFH doing my job.

I know some of the local nurseries do offer pick up from the school, but DS is a flight risk so they aren't much help to us.

We've considered changing schools but due to DSs additional needs it would be difficult. He's due to start junior school next year and DS2 is due to start reception so I'll definitely be looking at another school that offers breakfast and after school clubs.

Sorry I don't have any helpful suggestions, just offering solidarity in what is an utterly shit situation.

DarkDarkNight · 05/11/2023 11:30

PussyGalore1 · 05/11/2023 09:55

To be fair, it’s not the schools responsibility to look after your child after hours.
sorry to be so blunt but can you look at nanny share ?

Not everyone can afford a nanny or even a nanny share.

The OP chose the school (as others may have too) specifically because of the wraparound childcare the school said they had.

I have family help so don’t rely on wraparound care but have colleagues who do and it is really stressful for them when schools decide often at very short notice that clubs won’t be running. This country is ridiculous, there is such pressure for parents to be working full time but not much help is provided.

GRex · 05/11/2023 11:29

It's really shit that you were given incorrect information, obviously you need additional out of hours cover. I would be worried you'll have 6 years sourcing extra childcare, so would move schools rather than face that constant challenge.

spanieleyes · 05/11/2023 11:28

If the school believed they had the staff to run an after school provision ( as opposed to after school clubs which are generally run by teachers for free) and could make a profit from it, they would be doing so. The fact that they aren't means either that they don't have the staff available or it's not financially viable. As the private provider has ceased, presumably they had similar issues.

sollenwir · 05/11/2023 11:28

Gymmum82 · 05/11/2023 09:57

That’s really crap and honestly I think it is the school’s responsibility to source a wrap around provider. Parents work. They don’t work school hours. If the school isn’t going to provide wrap around care then it’s not a viable option for most children.
I would move schools personally. They clearly aren’t going to help with a solution so you have no choice

No, it's not the school's responsibility to sort out wraparound childcare, much as it might make parent's lives easier.

In this case the school did misrepresent both the level and reliability of the wraparound care, which they should not have done.

margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:27

arintingly · 05/11/2023 11:04

Well exactly. On Mumsnet it's this huge problem and impossible to solve.

All of our local schools have wraparound care and have no difficulty in finding staff to run it.

Ours is run by TAs who are very happy to have a full day's work and salary not just school hours

Whereas in our area, the TA's don't work to work longer days for shit pay. In 99% of cases, their extra wages would just be going on childcare for their own children so it would be a total waste of time.

A friend of mine is a TA and also runs her own business - she earns more working for herself after school for a couple of hours than she'd ever earn doing ASC.

Floooooof · 05/11/2023 11:26

It's a bloody nightmare isn't it? Our school suddenly decided at the beginning of term that they were only going to offer after school clubs to key stage 2. I was planning on looking for a new job but not sure it will be possible now. We also have a private company available but it costs £££ compared to the school run clubs

margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:23

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 11:00

@margotrose no, they ran Monday and Wednesday, but we need Tues and Thurs .
Fortunately they then said they could accommodate us , and then a week before term said they didn't have staff

Ah, I got you.

Unfortunately if you rely on someone else for childcare there is always the risk that they'll stop providing it. It sucks but I'm not sure there's a solution really!

MintJulia · 05/11/2023 11:19

The last year DS was at primary, the afterschool club stopped operating on Fridays because there wasn't enough demand.

I had no help, but I did a deal with my boss, that I took my lunch hour between 2.45 and 3.45. There was just enough time for me to pick ds up, drop him home and go back to work for another 2 hours.

Obviously your dc is tiny so not an option for you but there will be a way around this. Is there a class Whatsapp group? Have you posted saying you need to share pickups and drop offs? You have some flexibility. You need to find someone who can cover the other days. Others will be in the same situation.

StillWantingADog · 05/11/2023 11:17

You were misled and it’s shit but I don’t know what you can do
when I was in a similar situation I spoke to the provider directly which was reassuring. We’ve had all kinds of issues with our provider but Tbf to the school they did their best to ensure it continued when they eventually kicked them out, basically temporarily organising it themselves before a new provider started. This is going above and beyond however. Bottom line is though that the school knows how important it is. It’s not a large school but big enough to make it viable. Perhaps yours isnt

our school does offer extra curricular activities once a week for an hour after school which helps on that day. Presume there is none of those?

before you move schools I would try and set up an arrangement with a parent who doesn’t work. Offer to pay them by all means if you can’t reciprocate.

modgepodge · 05/11/2023 11:15

KateyCuckoo · 05/11/2023 10:54

My goodness there's a hell of a lot of expenses with providing childcare. It's nothing like you imagine!

Yes there are expenses for running childcare of course. But surely lots of these are reduced if the school runs it themself? Schools offer free after school clubs for football, chess etc and these don’t cost the school anything (except staff goodwill/cost depending on if they’re paying staff for it). What additional expenses would the school running their own ACS using their own staff (TAs for example) incur? They own the building so no hire cost, I’ve already mentioned staffing and cost for food, not sure if additional insurance would be required if it was run on site by TAs or whoever. What else? Not trying to be difficult, genuinely interested.

(I’m a teacher at a school which runs its own ASC on site at much lower cost than I pay for my own daughter’s ASC which is run by a private company!)

Thisisreallyme · 05/11/2023 11:15

Sounds like they mislead you to get you on their books. Unless the school is amazing in every other respect, I’d be looking for a school that fits your requirements. Better to do it now while your lo is young and in the early stages of friendships.

JADS · 05/11/2023 11:14

I get your frustration. My Ds had a childminder who looked after him since he was 1 year old and she covered his school. After Covid, she initially moved school and then quit childminding completely.

I got a place at before school club, but after school was a bit hit and miss and couldn't give me all the days I needed. DS also hated it. We now have an after school nanny who works at a pre school and wanted to top up her wages 2 days a week. She is brilliant, expensive but worth every penny.

Keepitrealnomists · 05/11/2023 11:12

While it's not the school responsibility to provide wrap around care if you base your decision on a school on the wraparound care then its removed its hard to then work around it. Change schools if you need that wraparound care.