Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School wrap-around - what do we do ?

414 replies

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 09:52

Hi,
DD (4) just started reception. I chose the school based on local reputation plus the availability of breakfast club and after school club to facilitate us still working. The school explained to us in a meeting that the after school club runs daily.
Fast forward to a week before term in September and the club (who are a private company hired by the school), says they aren't running due to a lack of staff.
Panic stations as we have no local family and not huge flexibility with our jobs. Partner WFH twice a week so collects then and I work 4 days. So we needed after school club for two afternoons.
The schools response was 'that's a shame but nothing we do'.
We've had to juggle it with another local parent who collects on the two days we needed and we take her DS to school every day. Workable in the very short term but not long term as she is having to leave work super early those days and meet important meetings.
I've emailed the school a few times asking for updates and it's all very 'no nothing sorry '.

I'm at the point where I'm wondering do we move schools to one where they have nursery wraparound.
Also one childminder serves the school we chose, and she's full with a waiting list.

What has also annoyed me is that when we went to info afternoon with the school where they told us the club runs daily , that it wasn't even true. The after-school club told us they ran for two days a week last academic year , and not even the days we needed.

Has anyone else experienced similar before? I feel very stressed. I changed my job of 12 years due to DD starting school and wonder now why I bothered as we're in a worse logistical situation thanks to this.

There's nothing from the club or school about when this is going to be resolved.

OP posts:
margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:57

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 11:56

But it doesn't matter how seriously the school takes it - if there's no staff, there's no staff.

There are always going to be people out there better equipped to foresee problems, solve problems and be innovative about solutions. In every single field of life. Or simply be in a better position in the first place. The OP is now in a better place to identify such a school.

But she can't predict the future. There's a recruitment crisis in education for a good reason and it's only getting worse - schools that happily provide ASC now may well have no choice but to stop in the future.

CharlotteBog · 05/11/2023 11:57

The school should do some sort of parent questionnaire at some point, which I think will be fed back to governors and OFSTED. In this you can mention how you were misled about the after school provision by the school.
They can't throw their hands in the air stating they have nothing to do with it, while they are putting false information on the school website.

Saschka · 05/11/2023 11:57

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 11:53

What's bizarre is people thinking that because something can be staffed in their own local area, that must be true for everywhere else in the country. A country which currently has a very tight labour market, in a sector where the recruitment and retention problems are very well known.

If the schools have tried and can’t recruit, fair enough. I’m talking about the posters on here saying “look after your own children!” like that is a realistic option for the vast majority of parents.

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 11:56

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 11:55

Fundamentally for me, I wouldn't have chosen this school if we'd have been informed correctly that ASC was running twice per week last year. I would have chosen the other school on my list that is slightly further away but has full wraparound via a nursery.
I am going to contact the family information service tomorrow and let them know and to see if there are any local providers they know of that might help.
Pp are correct that I could have issues with any school but I think less likely with those that have the private nursery wraparound.

I think that's completely fair enough. Strikes me as unwise behaviour from the school to be drawn on the ASC issue at all if it's all done separately. I'd be irritated.

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 11:56

But it doesn't matter how seriously the school takes it - if there's no staff, there's no staff.

There are always going to be people out there better equipped to foresee problems, solve problems and be innovative about solutions. In every single field of life. Or simply be in a better position in the first place. The OP is now in a better place to identify such a school.

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 11:55

Fundamentally for me, I wouldn't have chosen this school if we'd have been informed correctly that ASC was running twice per week last year. I would have chosen the other school on my list that is slightly further away but has full wraparound via a nursery.
I am going to contact the family information service tomorrow and let them know and to see if there are any local providers they know of that might help.
Pp are correct that I could have issues with any school but I think less likely with those that have the private nursery wraparound.

OP posts:
margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:54

And while the low wages don't help, and the childcare sector does need money throwing at it, there are just substantial logistical difficulties with staffing something like this. The hours themselves are unattractive.

Precisely. Anyone looking for part-time work would be better off getting a job at Tesco - the hours would be better, they'd be able to work year-round and they wouldn't be restricted to school holidays when it comes to taking annual leave.

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 11:53

Saschka · 05/11/2023 11:38

Same here - every school locally offers breakfast club and ASC. The idea that this is a huge imposition on the school, and women should just give up their silly little pin money jobs and be SAHMs because it’s just far too hard for the school to organise, is frankly bizarre.

And no, a nanny is not a realistic option - they want FT hours, and that would cost me about £50k per year including NICs, pension contributions etc, which is more than I earn after tax as a hospital consultant. A childminder would work, but OP says there aren’t any with spaces locally. Presumably because there are no ASCs running.

What's bizarre is people thinking that because something can be staffed in their own local area, that must be true for everywhere else in the country. A country which currently has a very tight labour market, in a sector where the recruitment and retention problems are very well known.

margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:52

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 11:49

OP could move schools and find herself in the same situation next September.

I expect the OP is better equipped now to ask the right questions and do the right research to understand how seriously any new school takes after school provision

But it doesn't matter how seriously the school takes it - if there's no staff, there's no staff. They can't just magic childcare out of thin air.

howshouldibehave · 05/11/2023 11:49

It means that I think all schools should be providing an offering from 3-6 for children to do extra curricular activities (with funding from the government).

*adequate funding.

At the moment, most schools are running at a loss when providing universal free school meals for KS1/EYFS. If the government want all schools to provide after school clubs, then the funding has to be adequate. As they haven’t managed that with loads of other services-such as nurseries, it’s unlikely this will happen to after school clubs any time soon.

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 11:49

OP could move schools and find herself in the same situation next September.

I expect the OP is better equipped now to ask the right questions and do the right research to understand how seriously any new school takes after school provision

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 11:48

margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:40

No one is suggesting that these staff be paid a pittance! Most ASC charge about £15 a session - which at a 1:15 ratio (with government funding on top) should be enough to pay staff a decent wage. Supply and demand - if you pay a decent and give guaranteed hours wage you will get staff.

But who is going to be available (and willing) to work for three hours a day, term-time only? Very few people, unfortunately, which is why so many ASC providers close down or only offer very restricted hours and availability.

Exactly.

Posters on here often have bright ideas about services that should be funded, with no thought of where the actual boots on the ground are going to come from in this very tight labour market. And while the low wages don't help, and the childcare sector does need money throwing at it, there are just substantial logistical difficulties with staffing something like this. The hours themselves are unattractive.

There'll come a point when throwing enough money at it will get people in the jobs, for example if ASC work paid a full time wage for 3 hours work a day then I don't doubt there'd be plenty of candidates. But it might need to be a lot more than the £15 stated, or even £20 really.

arintingly · 05/11/2023 11:48

margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:27

Whereas in our area, the TA's don't work to work longer days for shit pay. In 99% of cases, their extra wages would just be going on childcare for their own children so it would be a total waste of time.

A friend of mine is a TA and also runs her own business - she earns more working for herself after school for a couple of hours than she'd ever earn doing ASC.

At ours most of the TAs have grown up children but those that have children at the school get a free place if they work the extra hours - as I understand it from chatting to them recently, they actually have trouble deciding fairly who gets the extra hours because everyone wants them.

BungleandGeorge · 05/11/2023 11:47

I thought at one stage schools were expected to provide wrap around care and were lent on to provide it but that seems to have changed and there’s not much you can do. I would either alter working hours permanently if you can or move schools

stillplentyofjunkinthetrunk · 05/11/2023 11:47

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 10:05

When we told it was running daily , it was at that time running twice per week

You are totally allowed to be annoyed by this. But you have fundamentally misunderstood the nature of the schools responsibility / role in providing care outside of school hours.

My kids were lucky enough to eventually get a place at the before and after schools clubs at our local primary (though we had a very awkward and expensive term waiting for places).

There were 30 places at a school of over 400 kids. You do have the right to try and change school(to a school which has a place available), you have no g'tee whatsoever of a place at the after school club of a different school.

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 11:46

@LadyLapsang good thinking . It still says they have daily wraparound on their website.my next door neighbour is in the process of applying so I've told her the situation and she's now not applying as she and her husband work full-time .

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 05/11/2023 11:45

FlippityFlippityFlop · 05/11/2023 10:51

For all those saying ASC is not the schools responsibility - we know it isn't - but it should be!
Let's be honest - most if not all working families (single parent and 2 parent) need it.

The 9-3 provision doesn't work for the modern day set up. And no, that doesn't mean that I think teachers should be doing it. It means that I think all schools should be providing an offering from 3-6 for children to do extra curricular activities (with funding from the government).

The pertinent part of that is "with funding from the government".

Legomania · 05/11/2023 11:45

As a sidebar, we chose a school that wasn't the glamorous choice partly based on the wraparound care. It was a bit of a leap of faith as the school was that year bringing it in house.

We also thought it was likely to reflect the school's attitude to working parents, which was happily true.

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 11:43

Darhon · 05/11/2023 10:59

Lots of schools have separate after school provision with staff employed just for this. Often staff who cycle through breakfast club, lunchtime supervision and after school. It’s not some strange, untested idea that can’t happen. It does happen and should be standard.

Statements like this in the labour market we have are just pointless. Your 'shoulds' don't conjure up sufficient people who actually want the work.

Beautiful3 · 05/11/2023 11:43

Could you move your child to another school who have wrap around care, and has a space? That's rubbish what has happened to you. You cannot trust that private club, even if they said they'd run it again. For them to shut down without notice, isn't great.

spanieleyes · 05/11/2023 11:41

If the provision was viable, the private provider would still be running it!

LadyLapsang · 05/11/2023 11:41

Hi OP, has the school and LA updated all their information to show there is now no wrap around childcare? If they haven’t, I would push for them to do so, so parents making choices for Yr. R in September 2024 can make an informed decision before the January 24 on time application deadline. This in itself could push them to act as depending on local picture, this could nudge parents towards alternative schools.

margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:40

No one is suggesting that these staff be paid a pittance! Most ASC charge about £15 a session - which at a 1:15 ratio (with government funding on top) should be enough to pay staff a decent wage. Supply and demand - if you pay a decent and give guaranteed hours wage you will get staff.

But who is going to be available (and willing) to work for three hours a day, term-time only? Very few people, unfortunately, which is why so many ASC providers close down or only offer very restricted hours and availability.

DahliaJ · 05/11/2023 11:40

If the provider can’t find staff, I don't know what you expect to happen. No staff no WRAC.

Unfortunately, as you will know, there is a crisis in staffing in schools (TA’s, admin) and in providers, EY staff, WRAC staff. Pay is poor, often jobs with WRAC providers are poor hours - at the start and end of a day.

I have been there so understand. As a SP I had to find a school nearer to my own so that the hours for WRAC fit needs.

FlippityFlippityFlop · 05/11/2023 11:39

It doesn't have to be TAs. As @Darhon and @Legomania pointed out it could be provisioned by staff explicitly doing Wraparound/ASC.

No one is suggesting that these staff be paid a pittance! Most ASC charge about £15 a session - which at a 1:15 ratio (with government funding on top) should be enough to pay staff a decent wage. Supply and demand - if you pay a decent and give guaranteed hours wage you will get staff.

The current set up doesn't work for working families. Even the provision that does run finishes at 5 - how are most workers ment to get to pick up when most jobs don't finish until 5!

There must be a better way.