Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School wrap-around - what do we do ?

414 replies

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 09:52

Hi,
DD (4) just started reception. I chose the school based on local reputation plus the availability of breakfast club and after school club to facilitate us still working. The school explained to us in a meeting that the after school club runs daily.
Fast forward to a week before term in September and the club (who are a private company hired by the school), says they aren't running due to a lack of staff.
Panic stations as we have no local family and not huge flexibility with our jobs. Partner WFH twice a week so collects then and I work 4 days. So we needed after school club for two afternoons.
The schools response was 'that's a shame but nothing we do'.
We've had to juggle it with another local parent who collects on the two days we needed and we take her DS to school every day. Workable in the very short term but not long term as she is having to leave work super early those days and meet important meetings.
I've emailed the school a few times asking for updates and it's all very 'no nothing sorry '.

I'm at the point where I'm wondering do we move schools to one where they have nursery wraparound.
Also one childminder serves the school we chose, and she's full with a waiting list.

What has also annoyed me is that when we went to info afternoon with the school where they told us the club runs daily , that it wasn't even true. The after-school club told us they ran for two days a week last academic year , and not even the days we needed.

Has anyone else experienced similar before? I feel very stressed. I changed my job of 12 years due to DD starting school and wonder now why I bothered as we're in a worse logistical situation thanks to this.

There's nothing from the club or school about when this is going to be resolved.

OP posts:
itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 05/11/2023 12:26

Our local authority got involved in our local primary school when the after school provision and the preschool collapsed due to more management.

A private provider was brought in for the WAC and the school was funded to provided a preschool.

A lot of social housing in the area, so possibly a factor, but the pressure was on to provide services and they got them sorted almost immediately.

Sugarfree23 · 05/11/2023 12:23

Perk of the job is free childcare for afterschool staff. That's how ours operates anyway. And it's a way to recruit.

Op I'm wondering if you picked school up wrong. Our school operates occasional afterschool activities which the school put on with teachers. They maybe run one or two days for different year groups. Art class, football club for a term or so.

The afterschool is completely separate and paid for.

margotrose · 05/11/2023 12:20

arintingly · 05/11/2023 12:18

At our school it's not for all staff - just the ones running the club. So it costs very little given the big ratios at this age group. It's like 2 children every day.. and makes the staff happy to do it. Seems win win to me.

I'm glad it works in your area! It's a shame it's not the same everywhere but I can see why it doesn't - the hours aren't appealing and the pay is poor, even when you include benefits like free spaces and a good pension.

arintingly · 05/11/2023 12:18

margotrose · 05/11/2023 12:16

Lots of places can't afford to hand out free childcare to staff - especially if they have multiple children needing a space.

I have to be honest and say that pension wouldn't even be a factor for me when it came to choosing a job. Hours, annual leave entitlement and flexibility would all be much higher up the list of necessities.

At our school it's not for all staff - just the ones running the club. So it costs very little given the big ratios at this age group. It's like 2 children every day.. and makes the staff happy to do it. Seems win win to me.

margotrose · 05/11/2023 12:17

howshouldibehave · 05/11/2023 12:15

Our TAs work school hours because they wanted a job where they didn’t have to put their kids in childcare whilst they work.

Yep, there's this too. They want to work 9-3 so they can be around for their kids after school, so they can take them to activities etc.

They wouldn't want to take on extra hours just to stick them in childcare, even if it is free.

margotrose · 05/11/2023 12:16

arintingly · 05/11/2023 12:10

It's a pretty obvious perk to offer free childcare for the children of staff surely?

The other thing you're missing is pension - usually a much better deal than something like Tesco

Lots of places can't afford to hand out free childcare to staff - especially if they have multiple children needing a space.

I have to be honest and say that pension wouldn't even be a factor for me when it came to choosing a job. Hours, annual leave entitlement and flexibility would all be much higher up the list of necessities.

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 12:15

arintingly · 05/11/2023 12:10

It's a pretty obvious perk to offer free childcare for the children of staff surely?

The other thing you're missing is pension - usually a much better deal than something like Tesco

The thing is that if you're in an area where TA vacancies are filled and the demand for roles in schools actually exceeds supply, your local microclimate is different to the picture nationally. The school sector has significant recruitment problems. You're not going to be able to draw any sensible conclusions if your starting point is an unrepresentative locality.

howshouldibehave · 05/11/2023 12:15

Our TAs work school hours because they wanted a job where they didn’t have to put their kids in childcare whilst they work.

spanieleyes · 05/11/2023 12:14

@TrashedSofa

I'll have a quick look!
Nope, nothing there!

We don't run an after school provision. A local nursery does and collects from my school. They have a maximum of six-eight children attending per night. Even if I could persuade my staff to work extra hours, I couldn't run a school based provision for just six children without charging a fortune. It is not economically viable.

curaçao · 05/11/2023 12:12

Darhon · 05/11/2023 10:59

Lots of schools have separate after school provision with staff employed just for this. Often staff who cycle through breakfast club, lunchtime supervision and after school. It’s not some strange, untested idea that can’t happen. It does happen and should be standard.

That sounds as though it woukd be even more 'bitty' and difficult to staff!

arintingly · 05/11/2023 12:10

margotrose · 05/11/2023 12:09

If they're offered free childcare for their own children then that's a bit different.

However in general, working term-time only isn't really an appealing option to anyone who isn't a parent. It limits when you can take your annual leave, it means you pay over the odds for your holidays and it limits your earning potential.

If I was looking for a part-time job with set hours, I would go and work on the checkouts in Tesco - not spend three hours looking after someone else's kids for minimum wage.

It's a pretty obvious perk to offer free childcare for the children of staff surely?

The other thing you're missing is pension - usually a much better deal than something like Tesco

margotrose · 05/11/2023 12:09

arintingly · 05/11/2023 11:48

At ours most of the TAs have grown up children but those that have children at the school get a free place if they work the extra hours - as I understand it from chatting to them recently, they actually have trouble deciding fairly who gets the extra hours because everyone wants them.

If they're offered free childcare for their own children then that's a bit different.

However in general, working term-time only isn't really an appealing option to anyone who isn't a parent. It limits when you can take your annual leave, it means you pay over the odds for your holidays and it limits your earning potential.

If I was looking for a part-time job with set hours, I would go and work on the checkouts in Tesco - not spend three hours looking after someone else's kids for minimum wage.

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 12:08

spanieleyes · 05/11/2023 12:05

I would love to find a " creative solution" but I cannot put the core funding of my school at risk to run a commercially unviable after school provision when

  1. I don't have the staff who want to run it ( I have asked!)
  2. there is no way it would break even without charging an extortionate amount that very few of my families could afford!

Come now, you can just creatively pull as many staff as needed right out of your arse. If people who'll do a job exist in one area, they must exist in all areas, and it's your fault if they don't.

howshouldibehave · 05/11/2023 12:06

arintingly · 05/11/2023 12:01

There are clearly some schools staffed by some of the posters on here who are just "not my job" about wraparound care and some school which take a more holistic view of children's lives and realise it may not be technically their job but that it's important and try to find creative solutions

If you can’t get the staff, then it’s unviable.

stillplentyofjunkinthetrunk · 05/11/2023 12:06

Oneanddone88 · 05/11/2023 10:12

I think the main issue is that we've been misled
I don't need people to explain the responsibility of AFC, I'm a teacher myself so I get that.

You are entitled to be annoyed for sure. Your mistake, purely so you don't repeat it was asking the wrong people the wrong questions.

From the school's pov you might as well have been asking about a private drama club which rents space after hours.

What you CAN DO NOW google make some calls are there any after school clubs in your area which do have spaces. Would they be allowed to take someone from another school (ours did).

If yes, can the parent or someone with flexi-time rock up collect kid(s) take them to the other location. If not you might need to pay someone to accompany kid to the other club as a private arrangement.

morechocolateneededtoday · 05/11/2023 12:06

Whilst I do agree the school is not responsible for providing wraparound, it should be held responsible for providing accurate information to prospective parents - at the bare minimum, it should reflect the situation at the time of viewing. In this case, the school said they provide full wrap around when they only had it running for 2 days each week. Parents make their choices based on information like this so of course it should be accurate.

This is exactly the reason we went private instead of moving into catchment of the outstanding state option - their wraparound was also variable and demand was low. We may pay a premium but wraparound is guaranteed all 5 days of the week and no waiting lists or notice required for it. I’m sorry this isn’t an option for you. I would be looking at alternative schools with a busy wraparound so you know it’s not at risk of closing and that your child isn’t one of very few attending

BeReet · 05/11/2023 12:06

Our school offers a breakfast club and an After school Club, both of which are staffed by school employees. I am a TA and work the ASC as my children are all teenagers and I am able now to work extra hours.

Our ASC used to be well attended and covered its costs. With the massive rise in WFH our numbers have plummeted and we now make a considerable loss on it. This is not sustainable and soon our offer will be withdrawn. If there isn't the numbers it can't be done, it's as simple as that

margotrose · 05/11/2023 12:05

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 11:59

But she can't predict the future.

No, she can't.

However given that her current school has no provision now, a school with provision is a better option, based on the information available. She's not risking her provision now because she doesn't have any.

Absolutely. I'm not saying she shouldn't change school, just that relying on any form of childcare is tricky for working parents - especially private childcare - as it can be withdrawn with very little/no notice whatsoever.

spanieleyes · 05/11/2023 12:05

I would love to find a " creative solution" but I cannot put the core funding of my school at risk to run a commercially unviable after school provision when

  1. I don't have the staff who want to run it ( I have asked!)
  2. there is no way it would break even without charging an extortionate amount that very few of my families could afford!
curaçao · 05/11/2023 12:04

modgepodge · 05/11/2023 11:15

Yes there are expenses for running childcare of course. But surely lots of these are reduced if the school runs it themself? Schools offer free after school clubs for football, chess etc and these don’t cost the school anything (except staff goodwill/cost depending on if they’re paying staff for it). What additional expenses would the school running their own ACS using their own staff (TAs for example) incur? They own the building so no hire cost, I’ve already mentioned staffing and cost for food, not sure if additional insurance would be required if it was run on site by TAs or whoever. What else? Not trying to be difficult, genuinely interested.

(I’m a teacher at a school which runs its own ASC on site at much lower cost than I pay for my own daughter’s ASC which is run by a private company!)

But you are missing tge point.It is not a financial issue, it us a staffing issue.No-one wants to do it!
TAs are mostly only TAs because of tge hours!

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 12:01

Pp are correct that I could have issues with any school but I think less likely with those that have the private nursery wraparound.

That sounds sensible

arintingly · 05/11/2023 12:01

There are clearly some schools staffed by some of the posters on here who are just "not my job" about wraparound care and some school which take a more holistic view of children's lives and realise it may not be technically their job but that it's important and try to find creative solutions

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 12:00

margotrose · 05/11/2023 11:57

But she can't predict the future. There's a recruitment crisis in education for a good reason and it's only getting worse - schools that happily provide ASC now may well have no choice but to stop in the future.

This is a good point.

It's one of the reasons it's so annoying when people post stuff about doing their research in response to threads from OPs who can't get childcare. Nobody knows what's going to keep being offered.

TheKeatingFive · 05/11/2023 11:59

But she can't predict the future.

No, she can't.

However given that her current school has no provision now, a school with provision is a better option, based on the information available. She's not risking her provision now because she doesn't have any.

1990thatsme · 05/11/2023 11:57

I appreciate it’s annoying but any childcare provider could close down at any point.

If there really aren’t any other childminders in the area, I guess you will have to change schools. I can’t see why it’s the schools fault.