Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nursery staff comforting children

208 replies

Libmama · 05/11/2023 08:21

Last week I returned to work from maternity leave. I work in a school nursery and we take children from the age of 3.

We currently have a little girl with Downs Syndrome and she loves to be carried around. She is none verbal but gestures and is beginning to learn some Makaton signs.

One of the senior leadership team came into nursery on Wednesday and observed the little girl with DS being carried across the room and two other members of staff sat doing activities with children on their knees.

We have now been told under no circumstances are we to carry any children or have them on our knee. Instead if they are upset we have to sit them next to us on the floor and comfort them.

I am appalled by this. In my opinion three year olds are still so so small and if they need a bit of adult comfort in the form on a cuddle or a carry etc then that is a basic need and us not being allowed to do that is not meeting that need.

Can anyone share how they’d feel about their children going to this nursery please. I’m trying to decide whether to kick off about it and stick to my instincts and what I believe in or to let it go.

The parents of the children haven’t been told about this new rule btw.

I AM being unreasonable- children at 3 don’t need physical contact to be comforted

I am NOT being unreasonable- children of 3 should absolutely be cuddled if they need it.

OP posts:
BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 17:02

Excellent points @MolkosTeenageAngst 🙂

Natsku · 05/11/2023 17:01

I wouldn't like my son going to a nursery that wouldn't let the teachers carry the children or sit them on their knee or discourages cuddling and other appropriate touch. Was at parents information evening last week and they told how the children love being given a piggy back to get to lunch for instance.

Plonkydonkey · 05/11/2023 16:57

My kid is 8 and he gets cuddles from his teacher. He really needs that comfort occasionally. I'm more than happy for members of staff to give him a hug if he needs it. Sometimes he just scoots across the carpet at reading time and nudges up next. That can give him a feeling of calm and then he is OK.

As humans we need touch. It's just the way we are designed.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 05/11/2023 16:47

My son is at a mainstream nursery and the girls there are really affectionate, I've seen them ruffle his hair in a lovely way as they walk past and hold hands and to the best of my knowledge do hugs. He's a very loving and affectionate boy and I'm glad he's getting this comfort in nursery. I have zero safeguarding concerns whatsoever.

clarepetal · 05/11/2023 16:46

I'd remove my child from a nursery that does that. How cold.

Reddishraddish · 05/11/2023 16:44

Once on a school camp I was disciplined for lifting a small child over a deep puddle. The child was 6, and also my daughter...

MolkosTeenageAngst · 05/11/2023 16:43

Dogdaywoes · 05/11/2023 16:09

It may be guidance, but it's harsh and unnecessary.

When DS was 4 he came down with a flu type virus. When I got to nursery to collect him I found his nursery teacher sat on the floor with him straddling her legs, head on chest asleep. Her singing to him and rubbing his back. It really really comforted me. At school, DS fell off the climbing frame - a bloody nose and 2 black eyes. When I collected him he was sat on the deputy heads knee, blood all over her and him, tear streaked face and being hugged by a teacher he loves. Again, I found it heartwarming and necessary.

I’ve had a 10-year-old child who was poorly fall asleep in my arms (special school) as it was the only way I could get her to settle whilst we waited for her parents to be available to pick her up and she was very distressed and clearly unwell. I would sit a child who was injured on my knee until parents arrived too if they needed that comfort. Even in schools with strict no-touch policies I think in most cases there will be exceptions made for when a child is unwell or injured.

The OP however doesn’t seem to be talking about these kind of situations, she seems to be referring to a culture in her setting amongst the staff where children are frequently carried or sat on laps for activities.

There are a number of reasons to discourage this kind of culture. Safeguarding is one and in extreme cases cuddling could be seen as grooming but it can also encourage staff to display favouritism and extra attention to certain children. In maintained nursery settings ratios can be 1:13 so whilst a staff member is cuddling one happy child that is time where 12 children potentially aren’t getting any adult input. Some staff members will also seek to spend more time with the children who initiate hugs and cuddles, this can spill over into favouritism and can make children who don’t have the confidence to initiate hugs from adult staff feel left out. All the children, when happy and well, are entitled to the same amount of care and attention from the nursery staff and it is difficult to maintain that when staff are spending time sat cuddling children as it tends to be the same children who will initiate this each time.

Lots of cuddling can also effect the nursery activities and can foster laziness in some staff. Obviously it is easier to sit cuddling a couple of children whilst reading a story than to run a painting activity or start an active role-play activity with a group of boisterous children. It’s unfortunate but there are staff who work in nursery settings who will try and get out of other activities by strategically placing a child on their lap to look busy or ensure they’re not the one having to get up to deal with a toileting accident or to help tidy up.

Lots of people here have said they would want their child to have a cuddle if they wanted it and that they would be sad if their child couldn’t have it, but what about the other side of it? What if your child doesn’t initiate hugs and is the one who has to engage in activities alone because the staff are always sitting cuddling the same 3 or 4 children and not spending their time equally divided around the children?

It is sad to have to initiate policies because of the potential behaviour of staff but realistically that is why safeguarding policies and policies around touch and cuddling etc exist. Unfortunately it would be great if staff who are inclined to show favouritism or to be lazy etc were never employed, but the reality is they often are and it can be very hard to manage in a setting if there aren’t policies to help navigate this. A culture of cuddling when it’s not necessary (so obviously not talking about injuries and illness) can enable favouritism as well as creating an environment which is not centred on supporting the child to learning and develop new skills and independence. It can also create difficult dynamics with some children getting extra attention and others regularly being left to their own devices and not having an adult available to teach and bring on their learning.

Timeturnerplease · 05/11/2023 16:41

There’s obviously a middle ground, in all settings. It just takes a bit of common sense - touch needs to be child initiated, never without other people present and reasonable according to developmental age.

In our (small village primary) school, hugs are commonplace because all the staff and children know each other so well. While we do follow the rules above, we mostly go with whatever a child needs to comfort/regulate themselves. I teach Y3 and have a child in my class who lost her father last year. I was off sick unexpectedly this week, and she spent most of the next day superglued to my side with her face buried in my clothes. She clearly needed to reassure herself that another familiar adult wasn’t going to die. Fine by me. The other children don’t need that level of comfort, which is also fine.

EYFS is so different to formal schooling; of course the level of contact will be different. The vast majority of NT children won’t still need carrying around or to sit on laps when they hit Y6, so I can’t see why SLT should spend too much time getting their knickers in a twist over it. If it’s an issue for staff H&S, then just get some manual handling training in place.

Our HT would laugh at other heads having time to worry about this kind of stuff.

Reddishraddish · 05/11/2023 16:34

carrying children certainly should not be happening. A friend of mine has the opposite issue - she is expected to carry a child with behaviour problems around much of the day, because it calms him down - but she refuses. Her union backs her 100%, and has specified this is inappropriate behaviour management, and unsafe - one adult has already fallen while carrying this child, and was hurt

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 16:29

WillowCraft · 05/11/2023 16:12

Not true, the child will get down when they are ready. If they want to stay there for an hour or 2 that is fine and won't stop them settling. Of course the staff member can encourage them by showing them toys etc but no need to "withdraw".

If the child has to get down to let the staff member do something else they need to do that's a different matter but don't pretend it's because that is what is best for that individual child

The staff member isn't there for the individual child. The staff member is there as part of a ratio. It's a social setting. All children should get 1:1 attention sometimes, but two hours of one child sitting on a staff member's knee is to the detriment of the rest of the organisation (and that's without my wondering why this staff member has the opportunity to sit down for two full hours).

WillowCraft · 05/11/2023 16:12

Sirzy · 05/11/2023 09:28

But by keeping him sat on her knee she is actually stopping him from being able to settle properly. She needs to be retreating from him gradually to help him settle.

the child who was otherwise happy you could have easily given a quick hug and sat her next to you.

Not true, the child will get down when they are ready. If they want to stay there for an hour or 2 that is fine and won't stop them settling. Of course the staff member can encourage them by showing them toys etc but no need to "withdraw".

If the child has to get down to let the staff member do something else they need to do that's a different matter but don't pretend it's because that is what is best for that individual child

Dogdaywoes · 05/11/2023 16:09

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 08:29

There's cuddling and cuddling. No one would deny that small children may need physical contact as comfort, but there are appropriate ways in which to do this. I was a trustee of a pre-school some years ago and recall that the Pre-School Learning Alliance used to publish guidance. iirc, for instance, hugging a child was ok, but not full-frontal. One should hug to the side with closed legs. Sitting on a knee doesn't sound appropriate any more - and the child should be in control of the position and able to leave it at any time (which would rule out carrying). This is not new guidance: I read this nearly 15 years ago.

It may be guidance, but it's harsh and unnecessary.

When DS was 4 he came down with a flu type virus. When I got to nursery to collect him I found his nursery teacher sat on the floor with him straddling her legs, head on chest asleep. Her singing to him and rubbing his back. It really really comforted me. At school, DS fell off the climbing frame - a bloody nose and 2 black eyes. When I collected him he was sat on the deputy heads knee, blood all over her and him, tear streaked face and being hugged by a teacher he loves. Again, I found it heartwarming and necessary.

LittleMooli · 05/11/2023 15:50

Giveuprobot · 05/11/2023 15:46

What a berserk world view.

There isn't. Not at a nursery.

LittleMooli · 05/11/2023 15:49

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 15:16

No one is criminalising touch.

It's a funny thing about safeguarding. Everybody wants their children to be safe, but no one wants to believe that guidelines have evolved on the back of actual situations. It never happens. We're all trustworthy. The bad people are over there and there's hardly any of them. (And hopefully they're doing it to someone else...)

Children are supposed to be kept safe on good thoughts and rainbow dust.

Exactly! People seem to just think "won't happen to my kid" all the staff seem lovely. Of course they do. A DBS check isn't some sort of magic forcefield. It's the Swiss cheese model - have the DBS check but also have rules like - not sitting on laps, no one being changed on their own.

Firebug007 · 05/11/2023 15:49

It would break my heart if my kids were upset and the nursery staff didn't give them a cuddle! I'd definitely move my kids from this nursery.

Giveuprobot · 05/11/2023 15:46

LittleMooli · 05/11/2023 15:13

There is zero need for a child of 3 to be sat on a lap.

What a berserk world view.

crostini · 05/11/2023 15:45

When I collect my 3 year old from pre school she is usually in the arms of a teacher, or sprawled across their lap. They're children! They need love and comfort in order to grow up happy and secure.

Takacupokindnessyet · 05/11/2023 15:33

I wouldn't have kept my daughter in a nursery that brought in that rule but it would also have been a question of accessibility. My daughter couldn't walk independently at 3 so needed carried to join in forest as adventures and also in the case of fire evacuations, it was written in her risk assessment that she needed to be carried.

Buttons0522 · 05/11/2023 15:25

You sound like fantastic, caring staff. I’m so sorry your management has just bulldozed you all like this.

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 15:16

Orchidgarden · 05/11/2023 15:04

All this 'safeguarding' around today. Yes there are dodgy people out there, but very few would get to work in a nursery. (I read about the Australian case, but that's extremely rare).
It's treating all staff as potential abusers, and it's sad.
If a young child needs a hug, they should get one. Touch is an important sense and we shouldn't be criminalizing it. What a sad, messed up world we live in.

No one is criminalising touch.

It's a funny thing about safeguarding. Everybody wants their children to be safe, but no one wants to believe that guidelines have evolved on the back of actual situations. It never happens. We're all trustworthy. The bad people are over there and there's hardly any of them. (And hopefully they're doing it to someone else...)

Children are supposed to be kept safe on good thoughts and rainbow dust.

LittleMooli · 05/11/2023 15:14

And again I'm really not so sure people would be so happy if it were a bloke whose lap was being sat on.

LittleMooli · 05/11/2023 15:13

There is zero need for a child of 3 to be sat on a lap.

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 15:10

MrsCuthbertson · 05/11/2023 14:42

I was a trustee of a pre-school some years ago and recall that the Pre-School Learning Alliance used to publish guidance. iirc, for instance, hugging a child was ok, but not full-frontal. One should hug to the side with closed legs. Sitting on a knee doesn't sound appropriate any more

Oh dear god!

How does an Early Years worker change them when they've had an accident? Do they have to do it from the side with child's legs closed then?

What a ridiculous post.

It is the care worker whose legs are closed and to the side, not the child's.

There are guidelines around changing - including, for instance, not keeping a changing table in a private area.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 05/11/2023 15:09

WillowCraft · 05/11/2023 14:57

If you take that attitude we may as well all go and lie in a coffin all day in preparation for being dead.

Children need to be given the appropriate care for the stage they are currently at - not "prepared" for something that is 30% of their lifetime away in the future.

A full day is a long time for a preschool child. There's plenty of time for them to be doing all this learning as well as have a cuddle now and again.

Have you got any background in teaching or early years education? So many children arrive at school in reception with none of the skills they need to actually learn effectively. There will likely not be high teacher-child ratios in a reception classroom. Children do need to start learning skills in readiness for school before they actually get there and many children will not be having opportunities to learn the skills they need at home. If you don’t think children in nursery schools (which usually do half days with the children only there for 3 hours a day/ 15 hours a week) should be taught the skills they will need for school the following September when do you think these skills should be taught?

I am not saying close touch has no place in nursery classrooms, but cuddling children during activities is usually not necessary. Child: staff ratios in maintained nurseries can be as low as 1:13 so whilst a staff member is giving one child an extended cuddle on their lap that means 12 other children may not be getting any adult input as that staff members input is on the child they are cuddling. As I said, a quick hug before moving the child to your side is reasonable but children don’t need to be sat on laps for extended cuddling sessions during activities if they are otherwise happy and regulated.

Whinge · 05/11/2023 15:06

eish · 05/11/2023 14:55

The OP did not say no cuddles. Just no sitting on knees and carrying but everyone is focusing on no cuddling.

Exactly. Nowhere has the OP said cuddles and comfort have been banned, so i'm not sure why so many are focusing on this. Confused

Swipe left for the next trending thread