Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nursery staff comforting children

208 replies

Libmama · 05/11/2023 08:21

Last week I returned to work from maternity leave. I work in a school nursery and we take children from the age of 3.

We currently have a little girl with Downs Syndrome and she loves to be carried around. She is none verbal but gestures and is beginning to learn some Makaton signs.

One of the senior leadership team came into nursery on Wednesday and observed the little girl with DS being carried across the room and two other members of staff sat doing activities with children on their knees.

We have now been told under no circumstances are we to carry any children or have them on our knee. Instead if they are upset we have to sit them next to us on the floor and comfort them.

I am appalled by this. In my opinion three year olds are still so so small and if they need a bit of adult comfort in the form on a cuddle or a carry etc then that is a basic need and us not being allowed to do that is not meeting that need.

Can anyone share how they’d feel about their children going to this nursery please. I’m trying to decide whether to kick off about it and stick to my instincts and what I believe in or to let it go.

The parents of the children haven’t been told about this new rule btw.

I AM being unreasonable- children at 3 don’t need physical contact to be comforted

I am NOT being unreasonable- children of 3 should absolutely be cuddled if they need it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LatinRoyalty · 05/11/2023 21:19

The leader at the baby/toddler group we went to always cuddled my son- he ran to her with open arms every session.

his key worker at preschool was always hugging him and carrying him around- he has autism and adhd and gets extremely anxious-

his headmistresses at primary school also met him at the gate and gave him a cuddle every morning. Apparently she also hugged him every time she saw him all day (so she told me).

Natsku · 05/11/2023 20:53

Bbq1 · 05/11/2023 20:33

Dragging on a blanket?! Sounds really unsafe for children and staff and so unprofessional. They could make it fun by singing or doing different actions as they walk. Shouldn't pre schoolers be taught how to walk sensibly to the dining room in prep for school?

They keep it as safe as possible, not too many children on the blanket and not too fast. I'm glad they do more physical things like this, I think it's important for children and beneficial to their development. They learn well enough how to walk sensibly once they start school, it doesn't take years to prepare for walking down a corridor.

Crunchymum · 05/11/2023 20:49

DC3 is globally delayed and has SEN. She throws herself at her teacher every morning for a hug (year 1 / nearly 6yo). Teacher hasn't said anything but I'm trying to make DC3 more aware of appropriate boundaries. Teacher is male and I'm worried about making him feel uncomfortable 😕

All other caregivers have been female, plus DC was obviously younger so it felt more acceptable to be tactile although I think EYFS is generally more touchy feely as I used to hug the TA.

JustAMinutePleass · 05/11/2023 20:43

DS went to a nursery that was brilliant in baby and toddler rooms but refused to carry / cuddle him in preschool (official response was he’s too big - he was 50th centile for height and weight at the time) but then other mums who were able to visit said the nursery assistants were all hyperfocussed on 2-3 children with special needs: those children got all the attention and the easy going ones got nothing. I always wondered why DS would come home and latch onto me & then I realised it was because he wasn’t being held or cuddled or given any attention all day (he was fully potty trained by 2 & fed himself so minimal engagement).

I moved him to a pre-school setting in a private school and there was an immediate improvement. His teachers hug him, carry him, give him piggy backs and yet also know when to hang back to make sure they learn how to regulate themselves. I truly regret not moving him sooner

Bbq1 · 05/11/2023 20:33

Natsku · 05/11/2023 18:41

Well I'm glad they do it, its one of their methods of getting reluctant children to go to the dining hall, by making it more fun for them (another method is dragging on a blanket, which the children also love and is a favourite). Better than just telling them they have to go now whether they want to or not. These are older children though, the 4 and 5 year olds, not the under 3s - piggybacks for under 3s could be dangerous.

Dragging on a blanket?! Sounds really unsafe for children and staff and so unprofessional. They could make it fun by singing or doing different actions as they walk. Shouldn't pre schoolers be taught how to walk sensibly to the dining room in prep for school?

ThisIsntThe80sPat · 05/11/2023 19:09

Id pull my child out. My 3 year old is a sensitive wee lad and I love that his nursery teachers give him a cuddle and let him sit on their knee when he's had a fall / is upset.

Natsku · 05/11/2023 18:41

Sirzy · 05/11/2023 17:23

Personally I would find a nursery that thinks giving children piggy backs is a good idea concerning. It suggests a very lax approach to risk assessing and keeping staff and children safe!

Edited

Well I'm glad they do it, its one of their methods of getting reluctant children to go to the dining hall, by making it more fun for them (another method is dragging on a blanket, which the children also love and is a favourite). Better than just telling them they have to go now whether they want to or not. These are older children though, the 4 and 5 year olds, not the under 3s - piggybacks for under 3s could be dangerous.

Orchidgarden · 05/11/2023 18:19

Safeguarding is one and in extreme cases cuddling could be seen as grooming

Oh ffs!

lurchermummy · 05/11/2023 18:08

Omg what is the world coming to when little children can't have a cuddle or sit on a caregivers knee

BannedfromChristmas · 05/11/2023 18:00

Paediatric worker here , little ones with Downs Syndrome often have reduced muscle tone and hyper mobility the little one may rely on being carried to be able to join in with her pals. She may also have developmental need requiring more physical contact than other children of her age. It's a shit show of a day when you can't properly cuddle a child, they need it for their emotional development. I'll be damned if I have to follow guidance and a certain method on how it should be done. Each child's need is different blanket policies are also illegal when challenged in courts.

IkeaMeatballGravy · 05/11/2023 18:00

I remember picking up my DS early from school nursery because he was under the weather, he was being cuddled on his keyworker's lap. It was so lovely to see him being comforted when I wasn't there to comfort him.

Would I feel uncomfortable if it was a male member of staff? Honestly, yes because although NAMALT the male sex have earned the reputation they have. I would avoid a setting with male staff for very young DCs.

Libmama · 05/11/2023 18:00

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 17:36

I think, to be fair, you have set up the question in a way that makes it sound like the obvious thing to do is agree with you.

And many people have not engaged with the nuances of the provision of physical contact within a childcare setting.

Well I definitely didn’t mean to do that.

We can still cuddle them but whilst sat next to them.

My main concern about it was if they were upset we no longer can sit them on our knee for a cuddle and a story which is often the quickest way to settle them if they have been not wanting to leave parents in the morning.
If they hurt themselves my instinct is to pick them up and carry them to a chair whilst I sort a wet paper towel/ cold compress.

Maybe my mummy side needs to be completely left at home. That’s probably my struggle as I’m very maternal by nature. I’ll have to work on that.

OP posts:
BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 17:36

Libmama · 05/11/2023 17:31

Trust me we don’t sit down for 2 hours! They are 3&4 so we change rooms/activities quite often to keep them engaged!

The majority of you are of the same view as me anyway. So thanks.

And to those of you who think I’m unreasonable, thank you as well as I can see what SLT are thinking. I’m definitely going to go and ask WHY this new rule has been brought in next week.

I think, to be fair, you have set up the question in a way that makes it sound like the obvious thing to do is agree with you.

And many people have not engaged with the nuances of the provision of physical contact within a childcare setting.

Whinge · 05/11/2023 17:36

The majority of you are of the same view as me anyway. So thanks.

I actually think the majority are agreeing with you because they think you've been told not to cuddle or comfort the children. Which isn't the case, as all SLT have said is not to carry children and have them sat on your knee.

Libmama · 05/11/2023 17:31

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 16:29

The staff member isn't there for the individual child. The staff member is there as part of a ratio. It's a social setting. All children should get 1:1 attention sometimes, but two hours of one child sitting on a staff member's knee is to the detriment of the rest of the organisation (and that's without my wondering why this staff member has the opportunity to sit down for two full hours).

Trust me we don’t sit down for 2 hours! They are 3&4 so we change rooms/activities quite often to keep them engaged!

The majority of you are of the same view as me anyway. So thanks.

And to those of you who think I’m unreasonable, thank you as well as I can see what SLT are thinking. I’m definitely going to go and ask WHY this new rule has been brought in next week.

OP posts:
wheresmysandwich · 05/11/2023 17:31

I work in a school nursery. It's not just safeguarding rules, I wouldn't carry a child for my own safety - some of our 3 year old are quite big and carrying them would cause me a back pain. Cuddles / back rubs are OK to comfort when upset but that's it. I will only carry a child to protect them from danger (eg a child last week who tried to climb over a fence, I removed him and carried him inside to stop him doing it again)

Sirzy · 05/11/2023 17:23

Natsku · 05/11/2023 17:01

I wouldn't like my son going to a nursery that wouldn't let the teachers carry the children or sit them on their knee or discourages cuddling and other appropriate touch. Was at parents information evening last week and they told how the children love being given a piggy back to get to lunch for instance.

Personally I would find a nursery that thinks giving children piggy backs is a good idea concerning. It suggests a very lax approach to risk assessing and keeping staff and children safe!

WillowCraft · 05/11/2023 17:23

LittleMooli · 05/11/2023 15:49

Exactly! People seem to just think "won't happen to my kid" all the staff seem lovely. Of course they do. A DBS check isn't some sort of magic forcefield. It's the Swiss cheese model - have the DBS check but also have rules like - not sitting on laps, no one being changed on their own.

I see it more as a risk benefit analysis. If you choose to use a nursery you are putting your trust in those adults to care for your child. (Not just prevent harm but actually care for them). I fully support safeguarding measures such as DBs checks and not being alone with a child and staff being able to report concerns. But caring for young children and babies involves touch and intimate care. I trust them to change nappies, I trust them to cuddle my child if that's what my child needs at that time. Of course there is always a risk. There is a risk with any adult except me, even their father. But there's a huge benefit from contact with other humans too. You can't eliminate risk without eliminating benefit

Bbq1 · 05/11/2023 17:23

Thing is, some of you might not agree with it but if slt decides you can't, you can't. It's safeguarding -both child and adult .

Mariposista · 05/11/2023 17:22

A hug when upset or hurt - yes. Sit on knee for reassurance- ok
Carrying around - no. The nursery worker could trip, and also one kid does it and before you know it they all want it.

Bbq1 · 05/11/2023 17:20

This is very much the case in sen schools. A lot of teens with sen will want to hug you and often grab you in a bear hug unexpectedl . We hug side on and are trying with varying levels of success to teach the ch and yp that you must ask people before hugging and we encourage a handshake or high five instead. It's especially important to teach pupils with sen that they have agency over their own bodies as they are very vulnerable to abuse. However, i don't see an issue with carrying the little girl if she is also regularly being encouraged to walk. It's best to sit close to a child whilst working with them than have them on your knee. Comforting an upset child especially a toddler should be allowed.

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 17:18

cathcath2 · 05/11/2023 17:12

Better tell the government, NHS, schools. colleges etc then! Every safeguarding course and every safeguarding document has "trust" as a principle. Having access to a trusted adult can actually help mitigate adverse childhood experiences and lead to better resilience as an adult.

This is in the context of a child or young person knowing who they can turn to. It isn't about parents or colleagues making judgements based on little more than good feels.

cathcath2 · 05/11/2023 17:12

BrokenButNotFinished · 05/11/2023 08:48

'Trust' has no place in safeguarding.

Better tell the government, NHS, schools. colleges etc then! Every safeguarding course and every safeguarding document has "trust" as a principle. Having access to a trusted adult can actually help mitigate adverse childhood experiences and lead to better resilience as an adult.

Dinglewoop · 05/11/2023 17:05

I'd be sad if my son's nursery brought in this rule. I want him to feel a bond with the people looking after him and know people care about him if he's upset

GrannyRose15 · 05/11/2023 17:04

Errant nonsense. Ignore the advice. Except when she comes on her next visit then you can put on a good show for her.