Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much will you receive from your Pension?

213 replies

WinteryWonderland · 04/11/2023 23:46

I'm on track for full state pension after checking recently, so that's something. DH is also on track and has a private pension, but we've been advised to up the payments by £500 month 😬 like we have that surplus floating around!
I just wondered what other people have in place and how much that will provide yearly when you retire?

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 06/11/2023 14:05

Syrupycake · 05/11/2023 11:03

My bil retired early at 63 he was shocked to find out that his state pension would be reduced because he hadn’t been paying national insurance after he retired, even though he’d accumulated the correct number of years, he had to pay a few thousand £ to reinstate the gap. We thought it was a scam when he mentioned it. It’s worth checking what happens to your state pension entitlement if you retire early. It’s really complex

I don't understand this. Surely "accumulating the correct number of years" means "paying the correct number of years"?

I assumed that you need to just check your NI account on the gov website and check how many more years you need to pay for. eg I think I need to pay 5 more years until I'm 55 and then I will have paid the correct number of years to give me my full state pension entitlement which I can draw at age 67. My understanding was that I could "retire" early from my job, then, at any time after age 55, if I had the means to support myself in other ways eg living off savings, or DH's salary, until I reach 67 when I can draw the full state pension?

Are you saying that's not the case? I can't work out your BIL's working situation at all.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 06/11/2023 14:03

HeavenKnowsIamMiserableNow · 06/11/2023 13:43

Yes I did mean to @ you, @Mia85

No point in telling OP that these threads are worrying, because private pensions are now sadly a part of life, because as we all know the state pension is not very generous.

I thought @Mia85 's advice was well-intentioned and supportive, trying to point people towards independent research and not bury their heads in the sand 🤷🏻‍♀️ (despite my criticisms of said research!).

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 06/11/2023 14:01

Pooooochi · 05/11/2023 16:06

IBlinkThereforeIAm
Dh (economist) and I (tax expert) would say sadly you are right, and my parents are classic examples. University 100% funded with generous grants. Large family (4 kids). Property much cheaper relative to wages, even factoring in interest rates. My DSis and DBil coincidentally do the same jobs as my parents, with same employers, have 2 fewer kids and are much worse off despite more careful budgeting than my parents.

But pensions were the real swindle. There was an era when british DB pensions did not predict life expectancy well, they were over optimistic about performance and gave payment holidays and all sorts, its why so many private schemes either went bust or are still being heavily shored up today. A huge swathe of people are benefitting from generous pensions now who simply did not contribute anything like enough. So essentially, the real value of their salary packages including those pensions is very high relative to what people in the same jobs today.

Absolutely agree. And what is worse is that current salaries are being suppressed in many industries in order to pay historic defined benefit pension obligations of retirees who did not make sufficient contributions to fund the benefits they receive. And then everyone gets taxed more to fund the public sector ones that are unfunded which - despite reforms - still have outstanding promises which are completely impossible to be fulfilled into the future. To even things up a bit legislation should be updated to gradually raise both employer and employee mandatory contributions to DC schemes to at least double what they are now, and mandate similarly for the self-employed, but that would likely depress current salarieseven further as well. On top of the demographic shifts and the starvation of infrastructure investment and flatlining productivity it's not a pretty picture at all. 😕 So sad that the country has been run into the ground in this way in every respect, and there is no way out without significant productivity growth but we have no policiticans who seem capable of understanding that.

From a personal perspective, my children are young and once I get past the most gruelling years of childcare expenses that are hard to contend with as a lone parent I intend to open SIPPS for them so that they can benefit from growth over the longest period possible, even if I can't add large lump sums, but to get a pot started for each before they're old enough to work and contribute to it themselves. I hope it'll also help with financial education, to show them this is what was added and this is how it has grown and encourage them having seen that to contribute to it themselves as much as possible throughout working life. In a different life where I'd not been a lone parent I would have wanted to save £10k per child to put into a pension for them before they started school because timing makes so much difference with outcome when it comes to pensions. I guess we all need to drill into our children about saving from as early as possible, not playing catch up in middle age, as it's so much harder. And I suppose that at least - given I am not well and my life expectancy is not high - my children should inherit a decent chunk of what is in my own pension pot. I just hope I can at least provide for them and be here for them physically until they are adults first.

Mia85 · 06/11/2023 13:54

HeavenKnowsIamMiserableNow · 06/11/2023 13:43

Yes I did mean to @ you, @Mia85

No point in telling OP that these threads are worrying, because private pensions are now sadly a part of life, because as we all know the state pension is not very generous.

I think you might have misunderstood my post. The OP sounds quite worried about her plans for the future and sounds as if she has little to no private pension and is concerned that she can't afford the amounts she has been advised to put in. Her question was not about her own situation but about the situation others are in and unsurpringly she's got a range of responses including some very high amounts. In the past OPs in that position have been quite worried by the huge amounts some others have. The OP hasn't been back and I hope she's not feeling like that. I was posting to some research on the range of amounts that people actually spend in retirement. We know that lots of people feel so overwhelmed by the scale of the numbers that they don't feel it's worth doing anything. Seeing what is manageable might be useful.

HeavenKnowsIamMiserableNow · 06/11/2023 13:43

Yes I did mean to @ you, @Mia85

No point in telling OP that these threads are worrying, because private pensions are now sadly a part of life, because as we all know the state pension is not very generous.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 06/11/2023 13:36

@Mia85 ahhh yes apologies, I didn't see you'd linked to both already! That would explain some of the anomalies in the Which? analysis, if it's including state pension in the figures. Bit of a gamble though to assume that will be (inflation adjusted) the same as it is now, potentially decades away for some people planning!! And their 1% average inflation per annum over a working life in their assumptions is just 🤯, given by that estimation we've had 30 years of their assumed inflation in the last 3 years! Doesn't inspire confidence in their calculations. 🤣

That's interesting that Loughborough are recalculating their figures now, will certainly be worth a look given inflation has been so uneven over different types of goods/ services. I shall keep an eye out for that, thanks!

Bacarach · 06/11/2023 13:27

I've been temping for decades so never really got sorted for a pension, I'm perm since last year and have been putting aside £150 per month pluse£100 from company, plus £28 I have always paid myself for years and years.

Mia85 · 06/11/2023 13:24

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 06/11/2023 13:11

I've just run the total value pension pots that they are suggesting would provide annuities at the levels they are suggesting through some calculators and even if people worked all the way through to 68 it appears that at present savings of the value they are quoting would yield roughly half of the annual income they are claiming, so that is very misleading. Obviously annuity rates can change but it is worrying that this could give people a totally false sense of security so that they believe they'll receive double the income that they may in fact receive. Clearly there's a lot of uncertainty involved in any long-term projections but these ones seem off the charts in terms of optimism. 😐

If you are talking about Which I haven't looked at it recently but my recollection is that it is slightly confusingly written because they assume that you have the full state pension too so the annuity etc is for the remainder.

If you look above the Which link I've also linked to this https://www.retirementlivingstandards.org.uk which seems more thorough and clear. They are just redoing their research (the last couple of years are simply applying inflation to the previous research) which will be interesting.

Home - PLSA - Retirement Living Standards

Home - The Retirement Living Standards have been developed to help us to picture what kind of lifestyle we could have in retirement.

https://www.retirementlivingstandards.org.uk

Mia85 · 06/11/2023 13:22

HeavenKnowsIamMiserableNow · 06/11/2023 13:10

@Mia85

I learnt a lot from these threads over the years, the basics for posters are the same, the figures are just different.

I also learned that if someone told me that they could get my largish pension lump sum (it wasn’t part of our planning, but annoyingly just over the lump sum limit.) out in one go, that they were lying and would have required me to pay a huge sum of money to indemnify them for any future claims.

So between that and annuities, I learned quite a bit before we found the right FA for us.

Ditto charges and what to expect annually, oh and ditto that when you do draw your 25% to draw £100 first other wise if that is your first draw down the pension company will stick you on emergency tax and it is a bugger to get back from HMRC until they are good and ready.

So in conclusion, in the days when we were still hammering the pensions I learnt more, than I lost, in feeling a bit overwhelmed by other peoples sums.

I had H&N cancer eight years ago, not as widely diagnosed then as it is now.

Consequently I am eagle eyed and eared for people with similar symptoms, someone was talking to me at the golf club and mentioned their symptoms, I told them to go to their doctors asap.

They weren’t as lucky as me in the end, but I was able to help them navigate the early days of appointments and what to ask for.

So in the immortal worlds of the BT advert it is good to talk.

And if it is not hateful talk I fail to see the problem.

Edited

Did you mean to @ someone else? I haven't suggested people shouldn't make these threads. Just linked to two pieces of research on what people actually spend in retirement, which might be reassuring to people who are put off by the very high numbers that some posters have. If it seems utterly impossible then people will give up.

Memememestillme · 06/11/2023 13:12

God. I absolutely hate reading threads like this. They totally freak me out. At the moment DH and I are mid 40s and both have a defined contribution pension which added together comes to about 100k. We wil be on track.at least for the state pension but whether it will still be around in 20 years who knows. I think I need to try and move to the public sector just for the pension and benefits. Currently work for a charity so get low salary AND low benefits. I pay 5% in and employer adds 3% on top but since I only earn 25k and live in London I can't afford to add more. Don't see how I'll afford to live when I do finally retire.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 06/11/2023 13:11

I've just run the total value pension pots that they are suggesting would provide annuities at the levels they are suggesting through some calculators and even if people worked all the way through to 68 it appears that at present savings of the value they are quoting would yield roughly half of the annual income they are claiming, so that is very misleading. Obviously annuity rates can change but it is worrying that this could give people a totally false sense of security so that they believe they'll receive double the income that they may in fact receive. Clearly there's a lot of uncertainty involved in any long-term projections but these ones seem off the charts in terms of optimism. 😐

HeavenKnowsIamMiserableNow · 06/11/2023 13:10

@Mia85

I learnt a lot from these threads over the years, the basics for posters are the same, the figures are just different.

I also learned that if someone told me that they could get my largish pension lump sum (it wasn’t part of our planning, but annoyingly just over the lump sum limit.) out in one go, that they were lying and would have required me to pay a huge sum of money to indemnify them for any future claims.

So between that and annuities, I learned quite a bit before we found the right FA for us.

Ditto charges and what to expect annually, oh and ditto that when you do draw your 25% to draw £100 first other wise if that is your first draw down the pension company will stick you on emergency tax and it is a bugger to get back from HMRC until they are good and ready.

So in conclusion, in the days when we were still hammering the pensions I learnt more, than I lost, in feeling a bit overwhelmed by other peoples sums.

I had H&N cancer eight years ago, not as widely diagnosed then as it is now.

Consequently I am eagle eyed and eared for people with similar symptoms, someone was talking to me at the golf club and mentioned their symptoms, I told them to go to their doctors asap.

They weren’t as lucky as me in the end, but I was able to help them navigate the early days of appointments and what to ask for.

So in the immortal worlds of the BT advert it is good to talk.

And if it is not hateful talk I fail to see the problem.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 06/11/2023 13:00

Their comparison of annuities to drawdowns also seems pie in the sky! It says they have assumed inflation at 1% and investment growth at 3%. What the....? On what basis?

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 06/11/2023 12:58

Mia85 · 06/11/2023 12:00

OP these kinds of threads are always quite worrying for people as they tend to atrract quite a range of posters including those at the very high end and that can make it seem completely impossible to get to a decent level.

Do you mind saying how old you are? Of course you will get tax relief on the £500 a month if you do follow the advice of the financial advisor. Depending on what tax band you/DH is in that means the £500 won't be as much of a hit as you think. If there is any kind of employer matching of salary sacrifice available that'll make it more manageable.

There are some good pieces of research on what people actually spend in retirement:
https://www.retirementlivingstandards.org.uk
https://www.which.co.uk/money/pensions-and-retirement/planning-your-retirement/how-much-will-you-need-to-retire-aNmlv7V7sVe9

They might be more reassuring than some of the higher posts on here might suggest. Of course there's nothing wrong with wanting a high income in retirement but it can be quite worrying for anyone looking to see whether they can manage more modest plans.

This is interesting, thanks for the link. I find some of the figures quoted in it bizarre though! I am a member of Which? and usually find their research thorough but some of this seems very unlikely to me, for example the amounts quoted for private medical insurance (for a supposedly "luxurious lifestyle") which are less than it costs people decades younger than retirees. I know some older people with medical insurance who are not in terrible health and they pay per month what this says it would cost per year. The amounts quoted for long haul travel, utilities and gorceries also seem highly unrealistic (£48 per week on groceries is a "luxury lifestyle", given current food prices?).

Interesting how it compares to this research on retirement standards that many pension providers use in their illustrations to people:

www.retirementlivingstandards.org.uk

The two seems similar at the lower end (in terms of the cost of meeting totally essential needs and subsistence level existence) but vary more in terms of their analysis of what is needed to be "comfortable". I found even the Loughborough research I've linked to be very low in terms of what it was claiming could be provided for that level of income, though, and the one you posted says a similar standard of living is achievable on even less money! And compounding that, it appears that the Which? analysis is expecting some rent/ mortgage payments to be included within the specified income levels, whereas the Loughborough research us quoting figures without housing costs (it includes house maintenance/ upgrading kitchens/ bathrooms periodically but is assuming a mortgage fully paid by retirement, no mortgage/ rent payments). So the Which? numbers seem really low for what they're claiming could be achieve on the specified incomes. I shall dig further into their research!

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 06/11/2023 12:39

I thought Labour had committed to brining the lifetime allowance back in again? They said they would do something bespoke for Drs but bring it back for everyone else.

That would be hugely discriminatory, especially given the multiplier applied to defined benefit pension schemes to establish a "pot value" for the purposes of the lifetime allowance is already incredibly generous, meaning that a DC pension to provide equivalent income to a DB one will be hit by the lifetime allowance limit at a far lower value in terms of annual income achievable from the total. I think if they try to make specific rules exempting doctors from the limits imposed on everyone else then they will be challenged in court and likely lose.

To be honest the lifetime limit should be scrapped entirely. Pension saving should be encouraged and it's peverse for a Government to expect people to predict investment growth decades into the future to try and avoid an arbitrary tax cliff edge, particularly when successive Governments keep changing the rules for political reasons.

It's this type of unneccessarily complicated system and lack of reliability that creates distrust in the system and reduces pension savings across the Board. All politicians should agree to leave pension tax laws as they are, so that there is finally a stable platform with no more raids or tinkering, with all threshold uprated by inflation every year, if they want more people to become self-sufficient in retirement.

Mia85 · 06/11/2023 12:00

OP these kinds of threads are always quite worrying for people as they tend to atrract quite a range of posters including those at the very high end and that can make it seem completely impossible to get to a decent level.

Do you mind saying how old you are? Of course you will get tax relief on the £500 a month if you do follow the advice of the financial advisor. Depending on what tax band you/DH is in that means the £500 won't be as much of a hit as you think. If there is any kind of employer matching of salary sacrifice available that'll make it more manageable.

There are some good pieces of research on what people actually spend in retirement:
https://www.retirementlivingstandards.org.uk
https://www.which.co.uk/money/pensions-and-retirement/planning-your-retirement/how-much-will-you-need-to-retire-aNmlv7V7sVe9

They might be more reassuring than some of the higher posts on here might suggest. Of course there's nothing wrong with wanting a high income in retirement but it can be quite worrying for anyone looking to see whether they can manage more modest plans.

Home - PLSA - Retirement Living Standards

Home - The Retirement Living Standards have been developed to help us to picture what kind of lifestyle we could have in retirement.

https://www.retirementlivingstandards.org.uk

Mia85 · 06/11/2023 11:53

Loubilou23 · 06/11/2023 10:42

It all depends on when I retire (currently 53) and how my investments do over that time. I currently have about £600K in my DC pots, if I retire at 65 and pay maximum annual allowance into them, they do well and the government doesn't tinker with annual payments or life time allowance, then I could have circa £1.6-£1.8M in there, which I will draw down as needed throughout my retirement. So many variables though, I could retire earlier than 65, I could get ill, I could die before then, the goverment messes around with pensions again, my investments don't do as well as I would hope....

It's a long game but I would think there will be enough whatever the outcome. My husband doesn't have much in pensions but we will both get full state pension.

We will have a house we can downsize from, and savings/investments elsewhere.

I thought Labour had committed to brining the lifetime allowance back in again? They said they would do something bespoke for Drs but bring it back for everyone else. Not sure whether they are still continuing with that plan but if they bring it back at the old rate it will be expensive for a few people on here, including those with high DB pensions.

Igmum · 06/11/2023 11:41

@Notjustamum10 you can buy in extra years of NI contributions if you fall short at retirement age - might be a rolling 3 years IIRC. Worth checking out

Loubilou23 · 06/11/2023 10:42

It all depends on when I retire (currently 53) and how my investments do over that time. I currently have about £600K in my DC pots, if I retire at 65 and pay maximum annual allowance into them, they do well and the government doesn't tinker with annual payments or life time allowance, then I could have circa £1.6-£1.8M in there, which I will draw down as needed throughout my retirement. So many variables though, I could retire earlier than 65, I could get ill, I could die before then, the goverment messes around with pensions again, my investments don't do as well as I would hope....

It's a long game but I would think there will be enough whatever the outcome. My husband doesn't have much in pensions but we will both get full state pension.

We will have a house we can downsize from, and savings/investments elsewhere.

honeyandfizz · 06/11/2023 10:31

Mine should be around £1900 private that I'll take at 60 with a 70k ish lump sum that'll I use to top up my monthly pension until I hit state pension age. Should have the mortgage paid off in around 7 years so I'll save hard for the remaining 6 years of work and fully intend to go at 60.

LinkyDooda · 06/11/2023 10:25

Mum and stepdad get just under 800 each i think....

Loubilou23 · 06/11/2023 10:21

NameChanged0800 · 05/11/2023 11:36

I'm 40. Private pension pot of around £500k. What will that give me is anyone's guess. I am not keen to keep paying into it and would prefer to just build up ISAs and savings, but I pay in to keep my taxable income below £100k (otherwise I end up worse off due to childcare benefits cut off) so end up adding about £25k per year from income. I presume I will also qualify for full state pension when I get there. Have around £9k per year in dividends which will probably continue. House will be paid off and is currently worth around £950k - we will sell it and move somewhere cheaper. Expect to have at between 200 or 300k in savings as well by retirement age. DH is in defined benefit scheme but was a student forever so has not built up many years (it's not based on final salary but still a lot better than DC schemes). If he carries on his pension will be about £50k in today's money plus a modest private pension of around £10k and probably full state pension too. I worry we will not have enough to support us and to give the help to our children that we would like to give them. We have family overseas and travelling to see them is important but increasingly expensive so limits what we can save. We will both probably also get some inheritance but a lot of this has already been passed on, probably another £200k but this will go straight from us to our children unless we need it. I don't think we can rely on the state pension being there, nor the other "perks" all pensioners now get. We expect it to be means tested and also for the NHS to be massively reduced and so expect huge health and social care bills. I don't think we can even rely on our private defined contrib pensions being worth anything. I know too many people who lost so much money from their pensions. House prices could also massively tumble. We live in a popular area which has sticky house prices because of the good schools and grammars. A change in policy on grammar schools and we could see house prices collapse. So I take nothing for granted and will save as much as possible over the next 25 years. We may retire overseas where it is cheaper (DH is dual national) and money will go further but will cross that bridge as and when.

At your level on income you'd be far better off paying more into your pensions rather than savings and investments due to the tax relief surely?

User1990C · 06/11/2023 07:23

About £45k from private and then the state on top of that. That's a teacher pension though of career average, with me paying 10.2% contributions my entire working life.

findingmeeee · 06/11/2023 07:19

State pension plus an NHS defined benefit one. I'm 31 right now and it would pay out £7k a year from age 68. That should start going up quite quickly now as I am done with children and my salary has nearly doubled in four years.

Huntre · 06/11/2023 07:09

I have an old DB scheme that will give me £14k a year at 55 next year. State pension will give me £203 a week or the equivalent by then at 67 (unless they change it). I also have funds in a private pension that if I converted to income would give me around £6k a year so probably about £30k a year once I am passed 67. Plenty for me that with no mortgage to pay.

Swipe left for the next trending thread