Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you’d feel if a friend was with a married man

215 replies

EalingLucy · 04/11/2023 23:21

I’ve got a friend who has recently been talking a lot to a married man (well actually for quite a few months, they met through a hobby group and have been exchanging daily messages for some time). I think she would probably let things go further if he wanted to, and it seems like he might soon.

I only found this out recently — she let slip in a kind of ‘isn’t this exciting’ way with a couple of friends - and one of the friends instantly showed shock / disapproval, whereas I felt that way inwardly but also didn’t want to assume anything as at that point it could have been innocent.

I’ve since realised it’s not innocent, in that she told me today they are flirting. It’s none of my business, but also she likes to talk about it. She said she felt comfy talking to me vs the other person as I’m less judgey / realise life isn’t simple, before I then said he should be concentrating on fixing his relationship with his wife if there is an issue etc and that he needs to put his kids and marriage first. I think her attitude was that she’s not morally in the wrong as it’s his choice, and she’s not responsible for the consequences.

I didn’t want to make her feel judged but I do think she probs slightly felt it. I understand relationships are complex, and she’s not too long out of a 13 year marriage, but is it really that common to have affairs?

I feel like it’s morally wrong to encourage it but also maybe people think this is holier than thou and I should just let her live her life without judgement? I don’t know.

shes a really kind, lovely person otherwise so I’m not going to judge her whole character on this. I think she’s quite lonely, but she is playing with fire. And it’s a shared hobby group I am a part of, so really don’t want this messing the dynamic.

in this situation, would you reserve judgement, secretly judge, or outright tell the person you think it’s not ok? Interested in others’ opinions.

OP posts:
Megifer · 05/11/2023 14:32

For me its the subtle blaming of the OW for the affair happening at all that I can't get on board with.

People might say the man is to blame more, but its always the OW fault in the first place by default if any blame is assigned to her:

She shouldn't chase after the man and tempt the poor lamb = affair wouldn't happen if she didn't do that (when it's really just "affair wouldn't happen with her")

She should have ignored his advances = same as above

How about man shouldn't let himself be tempted or try to stick his dick where it doesn't belong = affair doesn't start?

Shadowonasun · 05/11/2023 14:30

My best decades-long friend (male) is having an affair with a married woman. He himself is single. It's a very convoluted/complicated/dramatic (eye-roll) situation, they've been 'together' for the past 10 or more years. Intermingled with other people, other affairs. Convoluted, like I said.

Other than not wanting to hear about it (because it's very boring at this point), I couldn't care less. I know the woman in question too and I like her. It's absolutely not my business. My friend is single/not married, the woman is, but I don't know her husband and owe no loyalty to him.

KimberleyClark · 05/11/2023 14:17

I agree with your friend that she is not morally responsible for any man's sexual behaviour. That is always on the man. His fidelity or not in his marriage is his responsibility alone.

She is however responsible for her own behaviour. And going after married men is pretty shitty behaviour.

notatthisage · 05/11/2023 14:15

If you are not comfortable with her talking about it to you, then tell her this. Sometimes friends have differing opinions and agree to disagree and not discuss that topic.

I agree with your friend that she is not morally responsible for any man's sexual behaviour. That is always on the man. His fidelity or not in his marriage is his responsibility alone.

Being a single woman with a married man is, however, a pretty shit deal unless she is only interested in NSA sex with someone she has no emotionally connection to. Otherwise its a headfuck of waiting around for when he's free and continually doing the 'pick me dance'. She'd be better off getting her self esteem in order after her marriage break up and seeking a real relationship.

Megifer · 05/11/2023 14:13

cardibach · 05/11/2023 14:09

Well that is clear.
Not something I find understandable, but clear. We don’t have to agree and you don’t have to explain why. But I really don’t get how you can feel that way.

I've explained why, a few times.

I can't understand how any blame can be assigned to anyone other than the cheater but like you say, we don't have to agree and we don't have to understand each others views.

daliesque · 05/11/2023 14:11

People who lose their partner to an affair would like it to be true, but it isn't.

I was the OW. I was single after a divorce a few years prior. He was unhappily married with adult children.
We got together because we loved each other.
He divorced his wife because he loved me and didn't love her anymore.
We stay together because we love each other.
I have never had a moments doubt about his loyalty and faithfulness with me. We've been together for over 10 years and will marry next year - it took us a while to get around to arranging it!

cardibach · 05/11/2023 14:09

Megifer · 05/11/2023 13:44

Sorry, I'll be clearer.

No, I don't. The only person responsible and morally dubious is the 'promise' breaker imo.

Well that is clear.
Not something I find understandable, but clear. We don’t have to agree and you don’t have to explain why. But I really don’t get how you can feel that way.

cardibach · 05/11/2023 14:07

@SurprisedWithAHorse why do you keep going on about friendship ending? I’ve specifically said that’s not what I’m suggesting.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 05/11/2023 13:44

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:40

I’m not suggesting she’s responsible for his behaviour. I’m saying she’s responsible for hers, and persuading someone to break serious promises isn’t good behaviour - regardless of whether the persuasion attempt is successful.
As for the anger - it’s not either or, is it? Plus, again, I haven’t said I wouldn’t continue the friendship. With that analogy though - if they angrily smash someone else’s plates when you aren’t there is it still wrong? Because if so, then I’m not sure your attitude to cheaters is consistent.

I don't need it to be "consistent". If I ended every friendship with someone who did something wrong, I'd have no friends and nobody would be friends with me. The fact that I wouldn't be friends with an out of control rage head doesn't mean I am obliged to end friendships with women who sleep with married men.

Megifer · 05/11/2023 13:44

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:36

It’s not about the relationship really though. I’m asking whether you would think it morally dubious for someone to do their level best to get someone to break a serious promise. Obviously if the person then breaks the promise they are unambiguously morally wrong, but the persuader? I think they are in the wrong too.

Sorry, I'll be clearer.

No, I don't. The only person responsible and morally dubious is the 'promise' breaker imo.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 05/11/2023 13:40

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 13:37

If you are having sex with somebody whose wife thinks he is staying late at a meeting while she sorts out the homework, and the world book day costume, you are helping someday to put his dick where it shouldn’t be.

Irrelevant. If he's a loyal husband then you could run at him naked and you wouldn't be able to do anything. Barry's made a promise, don't go after Greta. Simply being available doesn't put his commitment on you. Do you judge sex workers for being available to every married man?

But I'm not looking for a derail. In my experience, it isn't isn't before the misogynistic slurs begin - it's bad enough holding women responsible at all for men's choices with their dicks - and I haven't got the energy today. Suffice to say, I trust my husband and therefore I don't care who any other women is or what she's willing to "help" with because it doesn't matter. And if he ever betrayed me, it's on him.

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:40

SurprisedWithAHorse · 05/11/2023 13:36

She's not responsible for his commitment or sexual behaviour. It isn't honourable but at the end of the day it isn't her responsibility. Like I said, if he can't be trusted then it's over. If she doesn't want to live life constrained by marriage then she doesn't have to, as long as she doesn't marry. If everyone who makes the commitment keeps it then it'll be self policed...the only way when it comes to voluntary, consensual personal commitments.

But again, I can't ever explain this to MN's satisfaction.

Judging behaviour, well, few of us think everything a person does is right, including ourselves. Love the sinner, hate the sin and all that. I'd find it harder to be friends with someone who broke plates in a rage because I loathe uncontrolled anger and can't stand out of control angry people.

Edited

I’m not suggesting she’s responsible for his behaviour. I’m saying she’s responsible for hers, and persuading someone to break serious promises isn’t good behaviour - regardless of whether the persuasion attempt is successful.
As for the anger - it’s not either or, is it? Plus, again, I haven’t said I wouldn’t continue the friendship. With that analogy though - if they angrily smash someone else’s plates when you aren’t there is it still wrong? Because if so, then I’m not sure your attitude to cheaters is consistent.

Comedycook · 05/11/2023 13:38

I wouldn't cut off a friend or even distance myself. Life is complicated.

Melodysmum12 · 05/11/2023 13:37

Yeah I couldn’t condone that! I’d tell her what I thought.

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 13:37

SurprisedWithAHorse · 05/11/2023 13:16

I know I'm not the poster you're responding to, but as someone who wouldn't end a friendship for this... it's not that it's OK because it's not me, but that my connection to the situation - being friends with the OW - sets out what my responsibilities and remits are exactly.

It's not my place to police someone's marriage or private life. I'm friends with someone who is doing a bad thing. If this was part of a pattern that made me think she was an overall bad person, then we shouldn't be friends at all. If, as it was when I was in that situation, she was a good person who did a bad thing while in a bad place, then I don't have to think what she's doing is OK to still want to try to help her to stop doing it. She's more likely to finish it if she's still got someone for support when she leaves him.

I suppose the two key points that can never really be explained to MN's satisfaction are a) I feel that while affairs are wrong, they are not all the same and some are more forgivable than others. I don't think having an affair alone is the mark of an irredeemably evil Bad Person. I don't even think they're necessarily the worst thing you can do in a marriage. Everyone points out the "forsaking all others" vow but skims over some of the others - to have and to hold, to love and to cherish.

And b) I also don't think a woman is responsible for where a married man puts his married dick. I don't think it's good behaviour, but at the end of the day it's his commitment that he made and only he is answerable for it. No point getting Barry to promise something to you and then losing it at Greta because he failed you. If you can't trust him, it's over. Nobody else matters.

If you don't accept these two premises then you'll never get what I'm saying. If you do, then you will. But anyway, that's how I feel about it.

Edited

If you are having sex with somebody whose wife thinks he is staying late at a meeting while she sorts out the homework, and the world book day costume, you are helping someday to put his dick where it shouldn’t be.

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:36

Megifer · 05/11/2023 13:30

No, I don't. I have no feelings about it whatsoever except towards the one doing the cheating but even then, I consider they may have their reasons, especially if I don't really know them very well.

I concern myself with my relationship. No one else's.

It’s not about the relationship really though. I’m asking whether you would think it morally dubious for someone to do their level best to get someone to break a serious promise. Obviously if the person then breaks the promise they are unambiguously morally wrong, but the persuader? I think they are in the wrong too.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 05/11/2023 13:36

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:20

@SurprisedWithAHorse I haven’t anywhere said I wouldn’t be friends with the woman, just that I’d judge the behaviour - unless, as you say, it was a pattern of repeated affairs or other selfish behaviour, then I’d be off.
I have a little issue with your point b) though. I think she does have responsibility for where the married man puts his dick if that place is her vagina. That’s where the judgement comes in.

She's not responsible for his commitment or sexual behaviour. It isn't honourable but at the end of the day it isn't her responsibility. Like I said, if he can't be trusted then it's over. If she doesn't want to live life constrained by marriage then she doesn't have to, as long as she doesn't marry. If everyone who makes the commitment keeps it then it'll be self policed...the only way when it comes to voluntary, consensual personal commitments.

But again, I can't ever explain this to MN's satisfaction.

Judging behaviour, well, few of us think everything a person does is right, including ourselves. Love the sinner, hate the sin and all that. I'd find it harder to be friends with someone who broke plates in a rage because I loathe uncontrolled anger and can't stand out of control angry people.

TrashedSofa · 05/11/2023 13:36

PerkingFaintly · 05/11/2023 11:42

From experience, absolutely this. These things become drama-fests, draining anyone foolish enough still to be standing nearby.

And the drama doesn't wait till after the affair. IME (with family, friends & colleagues), OWs and some OM whine endlessly that the affair partner hasn't left their spouse, expect you to validate them as they slag off said spouse,Hmm use you as cover for their absence (with or without your permission) and generally put you in the position of lying unless you want to be the one to blow the gaff.

They don't take out their feelings on the affair partner, with whom they get very little time and to whom they are smiley and happy and encouraging (for fear of getting dumped). So they take it all out on their friends - from the excitement to the misery.

Being the "friend who doesn't judge and they can talk to" is exhausting and, when they try to turn you into a liar for them, degrading.

These days I'd absolutely do what PP have said they do: shut down talk with "I'm not interested in hearing about your affair dramas."

And if I were really fed up, add "You're already being shitty to other people and stupid to yourself; don't inflict it on us too."

Edited

The possibility of this happening is exactly what would be worrying me.

OPs friend is lonely and probably a bit vulnerable, hasn't got the sense to be discreet about the situation so has already pissed some of the group off, and has identified OP as the person she's going to share it all with.

All of this would be enough to make me want to back away. I know sometimes affair partners end up living happily ever after, but this isn't exactly screaming one of those situations. Looking at this completely aside from anyone's moral take, it's at minimum a potential shitshow that she wants to drag OP into.

Megifer · 05/11/2023 13:30

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:25

Which is why I judge him more harshly. But you genuinely don’t think it’s morally at all questionable to dangle your fanny in the face of a married man?
To, taking the situation out of it, encourage someone to break a very serious promise?

No, I don't. I have no feelings about it whatsoever except towards the one doing the cheating but even then, I consider they may have their reasons, especially if I don't really know them very well.

I concern myself with my relationship. No one else's.

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:25

Megifer · 05/11/2023 13:22

Strange you find it hard to believe. He cheated on me, not her. Even if she dangled her fanny right in his face he didn't have to do anything.

Which is why I judge him more harshly. But you genuinely don’t think it’s morally at all questionable to dangle your fanny in the face of a married man?
To, taking the situation out of it, encourage someone to break a very serious promise?

Fionaville · 05/11/2023 13:25

I had the same situation. My friend was recently divorced and decided to 'enjoy herself' One of the men she was having 'no strings attached' sex with was married with children and she knew them. She didn't see the harm because she wasn't going to break up his relationship, it was just sex. I told her that she was completely out of order and I was disgusted.
They did stop when she got a BF. I've never been the same with her though. The other man is still with his wife.

Megifer · 05/11/2023 13:22

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:01

Really? I find that hard to believe (I also speak from experience). How do you suppose your husband knowing she was interested came about? It’s morally wrong to encourage someone to break a serious promise, and I do judge that. Obviously I judge the promise breaker more harshly, but even so…

Strange you find it hard to believe. He cheated on me, not her. Even if she dangled her fanny right in his face he didn't have to do anything.

cardibach · 05/11/2023 13:20

@SurprisedWithAHorse I haven’t anywhere said I wouldn’t be friends with the woman, just that I’d judge the behaviour - unless, as you say, it was a pattern of repeated affairs or other selfish behaviour, then I’d be off.
I have a little issue with your point b) though. I think she does have responsibility for where the married man puts his dick if that place is her vagina. That’s where the judgement comes in.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 05/11/2023 13:16

cardibach · 05/11/2023 12:20

But if you wouldn’t be ok with someone cheating on you, and would judge them and the person they were doing it with, why is it ok just because it’s not you? I get you would be more upset if it was you, but if it’s wrong, it’s wrong. The degree of separation from your own emotions is irrelevant.

I know I'm not the poster you're responding to, but as someone who wouldn't end a friendship for this... it's not that it's OK because it's not me, but that my connection to the situation - being friends with the OW - sets out what my responsibilities and remits are exactly.

It's not my place to police someone's marriage or private life. I'm friends with someone who is doing a bad thing. If this was part of a pattern that made me think she was an overall bad person, then we shouldn't be friends at all. If, as it was when I was in that situation, she was a good person who did a bad thing while in a bad place, then I don't have to think what she's doing is OK to still want to try to help her to stop doing it. She's more likely to finish it if she's still got someone for support when she leaves him.

I suppose the two key points that can never really be explained to MN's satisfaction are a) I feel that while affairs are wrong, they are not all the same and some are more forgivable than others. I don't think having an affair alone is the mark of an irredeemably evil Bad Person. I don't even think they're necessarily the worst thing you can do in a marriage. Everyone points out the "forsaking all others" vow but skims over some of the others - to have and to hold, to love and to cherish.

And b) I also don't think a woman is responsible for where a married man puts his married dick. I don't think it's good behaviour, but at the end of the day it's his commitment that he made and only he is answerable for it. No point getting Barry to promise something to you and then losing it at Greta because he failed you. If you can't trust him, it's over. Nobody else matters.

If you don't accept these two premises then you'll never get what I'm saying. If you do, then you will. But anyway, that's how I feel about it.

Dweetfidilove · 05/11/2023 13:09

Malarandras · 04/11/2023 23:25

I would tell her it’s her life so up to her to make her own decisions. I would also tell that I would rather not hear about that particular aspect of her life. Then I’d leave her to it as far as that issue is concerned.

This is what we did when one of the ladies in our friendship group was in an ‘entanglement’. She was also respectful in not forcing any of it on us, even when they officially got together.

Didn’t last long, as she soon realised he wasn’t the man for her (something we’d already surmised based on the bits we heard), and we supported her through that.