Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you’d feel if a friend was with a married man

215 replies

EalingLucy · 04/11/2023 23:21

I’ve got a friend who has recently been talking a lot to a married man (well actually for quite a few months, they met through a hobby group and have been exchanging daily messages for some time). I think she would probably let things go further if he wanted to, and it seems like he might soon.

I only found this out recently — she let slip in a kind of ‘isn’t this exciting’ way with a couple of friends - and one of the friends instantly showed shock / disapproval, whereas I felt that way inwardly but also didn’t want to assume anything as at that point it could have been innocent.

I’ve since realised it’s not innocent, in that she told me today they are flirting. It’s none of my business, but also she likes to talk about it. She said she felt comfy talking to me vs the other person as I’m less judgey / realise life isn’t simple, before I then said he should be concentrating on fixing his relationship with his wife if there is an issue etc and that he needs to put his kids and marriage first. I think her attitude was that she’s not morally in the wrong as it’s his choice, and she’s not responsible for the consequences.

I didn’t want to make her feel judged but I do think she probs slightly felt it. I understand relationships are complex, and she’s not too long out of a 13 year marriage, but is it really that common to have affairs?

I feel like it’s morally wrong to encourage it but also maybe people think this is holier than thou and I should just let her live her life without judgement? I don’t know.

shes a really kind, lovely person otherwise so I’m not going to judge her whole character on this. I think she’s quite lonely, but she is playing with fire. And it’s a shared hobby group I am a part of, so really don’t want this messing the dynamic.

in this situation, would you reserve judgement, secretly judge, or outright tell the person you think it’s not ok? Interested in others’ opinions.

OP posts:
Fifteenth · 05/11/2023 15:47

Warn her that she is being abused and it won’t get better.

notatthisage · 05/11/2023 15:47

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:34

‘Oh my wife is so mean to me that I have to have an affair but I can’t leave the children because she would take them from me, but I mysteriously have all this free time for an affair and yes I can say I have a work thing next weekend’.

yes some people are very naive.

I'm talking about married women having affairs. I said that clearly in my post. The naivety of yours I was also very clearly talking about was assuming all women in bad marriages are in them just due to short term financial constraints which can be overcome.

Though interestingly, your strategy of moving the conversational goal posts as soon as you are challenged, does remind me of my twatty quite abusive Ex.

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:46

To say ‘oh, some people have an affair because they are trapped in an awful marriage’ comes straight from the cheaters handbook, however

Yes

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:45

Megifer · 05/11/2023 15:37

I'll ask my old friend how easy it is to end an abusive relationship so she can go on and be happy with the other man she was getting close to.

Oh wait I can't, her H battered her nearly to death and took her out of the country when she tried to leave.

At least she didn't betray him 👍

And you think she had the opportunity to have an affair in this situation????

We are talking specifically about ‘being trapped’ being used as an excuse to have an affair.

Baconisdelicious · 05/11/2023 15:43

notatthisage · 05/11/2023 15:04

  • no one is 'trapped'. We live in a modern world where divorce and new relationships are a well-accepted norm of our society

You only need to read the relationships boards to see there are plenty of women who do feel trapped in bad relationships for a variety of reasons. But that's a different thread.

From a financial,perspective, maybe - although lord knows there are enough of us out there rocking single parenting with no financial support from the ex to make this an unreasonable way to think. And from fearing what an abuser might do if you leave, absolutely. But if you’re in fear of leaving because of abuse, how will having an affair make that better? Will you not be on the receiving end of abuse because there is another person? It doesn’t make sense to me.

I was perhaps not thinking things through - of course people feel trapped. But they’re not actually trapped and there are services out there to help people leave difficult relationships. To say ‘oh, some people have an affair because they are trapped in an awful marriage’ comes straight from the cheaters handbook, however. People have choices, some maybe less than others in a given moment, but there are always options.

I’m not sure cheating is one of them.

OVienna · 05/11/2023 15:41

I've re-read the OP and from what's been written here, it sounds like the friend could well be a bit of a fantastist.

It's possible it's in 'Emotional Affair' territory but also that the bloke is just a bit flattered by the attention and has no intention of taking things further than that. "Isn't it exciting?!" What, that he's texting her? Have you seen these @EalingLucy ? Is it possible she's reading something into this that just isn't there?

Could she be about to make an absolute tit of herself?

It's interesting though that she's also already at the stage of: "It's his relationship, not mine..." sort of thing. On that basis - is what she is saying something HAS already happened?

I would not be focusing on him and his choices vis a vis his wife - this could feed any fantasies if that is all this is - but on her own well-being and ask her why she's become so fixated on someone who isn't available. If she's a good friend and not an acquaintance this is the bit of the conversation I wouldn't let go.

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:40

You know what you don’t see on the relationship boards ‘is it normal for my husband to get so cross when I don’t get dinner on the table (I was a having a quickie with Greg from next door).‘

Much more likely to be ‘DH keeps getting texts from his new work colleague and he seems really quiet, but he gets cross when I ask about it and says I shouldn’t be snooping’

Megifer · 05/11/2023 15:37

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:30

But you should give a fuck about stepping from one toxic relationship into another.

I did not in any way say that sexual infidelity is a greater crime than abuse.

The ONLY solution to an abusive relationship is to end the relationship.

I'll ask my old friend how easy it is to end an abusive relationship so she can go on and be happy with the other man she was getting close to.

Oh wait I can't, her H battered her nearly to death and took her out of the country when she tried to leave.

At least she didn't betray him 👍

ThomasinaLivesHere · 05/11/2023 15:36

I’ve seen a few posts saying it’s none of your business but by telling you and constantly updating you without asking they’re involving you in a way that would make me uncomfortable.

My sister had an affair with a married man and it did make me think less of her. Not only the moral aspect but I think of her as more stupid than I used to. She would tell me what a great guy he was as he would buy her flowers etc. but he was going home to a wife and kids. I just don’t get how someone can be won over so cheaply. What’s more she introduced him to my parents but of course just presented him as a boyfriend and not the truth. I didn’t want to tell them but I purposely avoided that meet up.

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:34

notatthisage · 05/11/2023 15:24

Quite.

And its not only financial reasons that make women feel trapped in relationships.

And the reasons that keep them there are not always short term.

The naivety in some posts is astounding.

‘Oh my wife is so mean to me that I have to have an affair but I can’t leave the children because she would take them from me, but I mysteriously have all this free time for an affair and yes I can say I have a work thing next weekend’.

yes some people are very naive.

CanIPetThatDawg · 05/11/2023 15:32

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:30

But you should give a fuck about stepping from one toxic relationship into another.

I did not in any way say that sexual infidelity is a greater crime than abuse.

The ONLY solution to an abusive relationship is to end the relationship.

It certainly read that way.

You said 'The answer is never lying and betrayal.'

How can you betray your abuser?

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:30

CanIPetThatDawg · 05/11/2023 15:22

If I was in an abusive marriage and started an affair I would not give half a fuck as to whether my abusive partner felt betrayed.

I do find it odd that some people find sexual infidelity a greater crime than abuse.

But you should give a fuck about stepping from one toxic relationship into another.

I did not in any way say that sexual infidelity is a greater crime than abuse.

The ONLY solution to an abusive relationship is to end the relationship.

notatthisage · 05/11/2023 15:24

CanIPetThatDawg · 05/11/2023 15:22

If I was in an abusive marriage and started an affair I would not give half a fuck as to whether my abusive partner felt betrayed.

I do find it odd that some people find sexual infidelity a greater crime than abuse.

Quite.

And its not only financial reasons that make women feel trapped in relationships.

And the reasons that keep them there are not always short term.

The naivety in some posts is astounding.

CanIPetThatDawg · 05/11/2023 15:22

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:19

If somebody is trapped in an abusive marriage the answer is not an affair.

If the relationship is over but it is difficult to separate for financial reasons, the answer is not an affair, it’s honesty and finding a way to deal with the financial problems, whilst cohabiting in the short term.

The answer is never lying and betrayal.

If I was in an abusive marriage and started an affair I would not give half a fuck as to whether my abusive partner felt betrayed.

I do find it odd that some people find sexual infidelity a greater crime than abuse.

Merrymouse · 05/11/2023 15:19

Megifer · 05/11/2023 15:10

"no one is 'trapped'. We live in a modern world where divorce and new relationships are a well-accepted norm of our society"

Its nice to think no one is ever trapped, however this is simply not true unfortunately. Usually women trapped more than men IME but I imagine it happens the other way round too.

If somebody is trapped in an abusive marriage the answer is not an affair.

If the relationship is over but it is difficult to separate for financial reasons, the answer is not an affair, it’s honesty and finding a way to deal with the financial problems, whilst cohabiting in the short term.

The answer is never lying and betrayal.

Getmeoutofheere · 05/11/2023 15:11

If he treats his wife like this how will he treat your friend? I’d frame it as concern for her…: which I’m sure you are. It may all feel very genuine from both sides but if he thinks it’s ok to do this to his wife what does the future hold for your friend…

Megifer · 05/11/2023 15:10

"no one is 'trapped'. We live in a modern world where divorce and new relationships are a well-accepted norm of our society"

Its nice to think no one is ever trapped, however this is simply not true unfortunately. Usually women trapped more than men IME but I imagine it happens the other way round too.

shieldmaiden7 · 05/11/2023 15:09

After being in a marriage where the other person had multiple affairs, I wouldn't be able to be friends with someone who has openly admitted to talking to a married man. I would probably figure out who his wife was and let her know. I will be eternally grateful to the person who told me.

Hbh17 · 05/11/2023 15:05

I might be uncomfortable. I might be worried she will get hurt. But she is my friend, so I have to be loyal to her - even if I choose not to discuss it with her, if/when things go wrong then I will be there to support her and pick up the pieces. That's what friends do, without judgement.

notatthisage · 05/11/2023 15:04
  • no one is 'trapped'. We live in a modern world where divorce and new relationships are a well-accepted norm of our society

You only need to read the relationships boards to see there are plenty of women who do feel trapped in bad relationships for a variety of reasons. But that's a different thread.

coldcallerbaiter · 05/11/2023 15:03

I would give my opinion if it was asked if me directly and would say it was unfair on his wife and that she should not be a part of this deception. I would still be her friend but I would lose respect for her and it has actually happened to me many times with friends. Also my friends have been the married woman having the affair. If I was not asked it would show on my face and silence and not wanting to engage in the gossip would speak volumes.

Baconisdelicious · 05/11/2023 14:57

Nobody knows what goes on behind closed doors. What if he’s trapped in an unhappy marriage and it’s the real thing for both of them? I know several couples where one or both had an affair who are still with their affair partners 20+ years later. Life is not black or white

  • do not blame the person being cheated on for being cheated on. The only person who needs to take responsbility for that is the cheater.
  • no one is 'trapped'. We live in a modern world where divorce and new relationships are a well-accepted norm of our society.
  • the 'real thing' doesn't come from hiding behind corners and lying to the person you took solemn vows with.
  • No, life isn't black and white. But you can leave a marriage before starting something new. That reduces the stress and upset for all concerned. The reality is, people don't leave their marriages because it suits them not to. In my ex's case, his relationship with the OW only came out at the point it was going to be exposed to me and he needed to take control of what was going to happen.
Baconisdelicious · 05/11/2023 14:53

Babyroobs · 05/11/2023 11:44

Yes exactly. She does go on short breaks with him, goodness knows what he tells his wife.

I would suggest after 30 years, the wife is very much aware of that is going on and is turning a blind eye. For whatever reason, the husband wants to stay married (and at this point, it really can't be 'for the sake of the children'). OW gets to maintain her independence. It's possible that all 3 people here are getting whatever it is they need from the relationship. Not sure I could do it.

Mutters123 · 05/11/2023 14:49

Nobody knows what goes on behind closed doors. What if he’s trapped in an unhappy marriage and it’s the real thing for both of them? I know several couples where one or both had an affair who are still with their affair partners 20+ years later. Life is not black or white.

notatthisage · 05/11/2023 14:44

Megifer · 05/11/2023 14:32

For me its the subtle blaming of the OW for the affair happening at all that I can't get on board with.

People might say the man is to blame more, but its always the OW fault in the first place by default if any blame is assigned to her:

She shouldn't chase after the man and tempt the poor lamb = affair wouldn't happen if she didn't do that (when it's really just "affair wouldn't happen with her")

She should have ignored his advances = same as above

How about man shouldn't let himself be tempted or try to stick his dick where it doesn't belong = affair doesn't start?

I completely agree with this.

The obsessive focus on the OW, the absolutely vitriolic language attached to the OW (you never hear this kind of language about the H), the overt, and frankly insane, refusal to accept that she cannot have any redeemable or good qualities at all. This is never said about the man, After all, why would you be mad that an OW has stolen a man with an irredeemably bad personality? Normally, if an OP is with a man with arsey qualities, we tell OP that they are lucky the man showed his true qualities and how you are free of him now, OP. But with affairs its all, 'its so terrible, the happy family has been destroyed.' But hang on, if having an affair makes one irredeemably evil, surely the H was too, and the marriage cannot have been a good one?

Unless having sex when you shouldn't only makes women evil but not men? But hang on, isn't that a misogyny as old (older) as the bible?