Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To include my Foster Daughter on my will as my 12 year old adopted son is obviously included

83 replies

Coldcaller · 04/11/2023 22:44

I have two grown up daughters 29 and 27 who are both teachers and I have one 14 year old Foster daughter and a 12 year old adopted son. My foster daughter has lived with us since she was 9 and is dearly loved by us all. I cannot see her leaving us until at the earliest she finishes University (if ever) . She is a quite remarkable young lady that despite the fact of coming to us from difficult situations regarding her family situation still passed her 11+ and is thriving at her grammar school. It is both her and our strongest wish that she carries on living with us to at least she finishes University but she will always be my third daughter whatever happens.

Currently she has a terrible relationship with her birth mother and can not be with her for more than thirty minutes before she leaves in tears. I wait outside her mothers house, because she refuses to go and see her mother unless she can escape quickly. The last three times she has come out and ran straight in to my arms absolutely devastated telling me who she loathes her. Foster daughter has two siblings a 11 year old Sister and a 9 year old Brother who live with her. The other kids have been brainwashed by the mother to say such things as she is a 'Snob' and that they are not good enough for her. Hence, why she lives with us in a comfortable financially well off and loving family.

I have recently instructed my Solicitor to divide everything four ways rather than three ways . I believe i should have done this sooner I know it will be easier if she was Adopted by me this is a conversation I need to have with her.

OP posts:
Coldcaller · 05/11/2023 21:05

DD 1 and DD 2 .

OP posts:
Coldcaller · 05/11/2023 21:01

I have just seen that they is a lot of support post 18! It was my 'naive; intention to fully fund FD and Son through University . DD 1 and DD are fortunate in not having any student debt as all their fees and lodgings were paid by DH and me.

I have not asked Social Services or the local Council so did not know about. Son has been at a Private school since 4 . Therefore support available for care leavers at University or Council tax rebates is not a regular conversation.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 05/11/2023 20:59

I would hope that after five years Social Services and the Courts would support me in assuming that my care rather than any care her mother is in FD's best interests.

It’s difficult with children in long term foster care, to be honest I’d have expected a permanence decision to already have been made after 5 years. That doesn’t necessarily mean adoption for older children but permanent foster care or a SGO. Her mum still has parental rights presumably so the local authority would need to show that there is no chance of successful rehabilitation back to her mum - given she has care of her other children that might be tricky to prove. It could be argued that unsettling her now would be unreasonable but that doesn’t necessarily mean there needs to be any change in her legal status if the current arrangements work for her.

I guess what I’m saying is, if everything is going ok just now, this might not be a cage you want to rattle. You clearly have worked hard to settle this young person and it’s understandable you’d want her status with you to be more secure, have a chat with social work and see what their thinking is.

Coldcaller · 05/11/2023 20:45

I will be contacting FD's Social Worker tomorrow morning and asking for a meeting regarding best interests/ outcomes for FD. I would hope that after five years Social Services and the Courts would support me in assuming that my care rather than any care her mother is in FD's best interests. An example is how far she has already come in her schooling. One of the reasons she was taken from her mother was she was often not going to school she had less 50% attendance in years 3 and 4. Due to Intensive tutoring over 18 months from DD 1 and other tutors FD managed to pass the 11+. Other areas where she has excelled due to the care of my family is that she is now a very confident teenage girl with excellent prospects. This from a 9 year old girl who would just shake with fear and constantly hang on to me . She was frightened to talk to anybody and at times barely eat food . it has been a long five years with issues but due to her indefatigable effort we have achieved miracles . How many children in care are in a grammar school, especially ones with less than 50% attendance and a birth mother who thinks education is pointless !

At present Foster Daughter has a staying put arrangement that covers up to the age of 21 this is especially relevant because it is all our intentions that FD gets to University. It is highly likely she will get to University as all her current target grades for GCSE's are 7-9 . I understand that after the age of 18 a Staying put arrangement means i will no longer be a Foster Carer. Obviously I would because she is always going to be my Daughter. This is another reason why Adoption is my preferred option because it would give FD certainly as to where still stands.

OP posts:
KinshipGran · 05/11/2023 20:19

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

PuppyMonkey · 05/11/2023 20:05

Again OP, have you discussed your plans with your supervising social worker? Rather than MN?

smilesup · 05/11/2023 20:01

ProvisionsOnTheDock · 04/11/2023 22:49

I don't think it's fair. By all means leave her something but I don't think it should be an equal split with your other (legal) children. If she was to be adopted that would be different.

It's probably even more unfair that she is penalised because she can't be adopted.
OP I think this is the right thing to do.
I would have a very open conversation with your older children first and explain what you plan to do so they know in advance. Be open and honest and listen to any grievances they may have.

Wasywasydoodah · 05/11/2023 19:58

Wouldn’t automatically get the SGO transferred, I mean

Wasywasydoodah · 05/11/2023 19:57

Speak to a solicitor. The adoption process is much harder and more uncertain. A more rigorous assessment, you have to be approved by the Agency Decision Maker, etc. Your FD’s mum may very understandably object because she will lose parental responsibility.

But, as a foster carer who has had your FD in placement to 5 years, you already have the right to make a court application for a SGO. The assessment period is around 12 weeks. The mum doesn’t lose parental responsibility so less likely to object so strongly. You get parental responsibility and also some financial support for the placement. It’s loads better. If you die, you can say in your will that your adult daughter should care for your FD. She would automatically get the SGO transferred however.

Trillie · 05/11/2023 19:28

the foster daughter might decide to give her mother money, notwithstanding any legal claims. She’s simply not in the same position as the OP’s legal children and it causes difficulties to pretend she is.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/11/2023 19:01

The child has lived with the op for over 5 years, living 'as her daughter' - does a different piece of paper really change things that much?

It really does, the child can be removed at any point either to another foster placement or back to her birth family. The legal differences are really quite significant.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/11/2023 18:59

I would like in that case for DD1 to become her legal Guardian. However, of course that means talking to a lawyer, would that mean she would take over the SGO if we chose that way forward rather than an adoption

I think you’re missing the point that as a foster cared you don’t have any rights to make those decisions. The local authority are her corporate parent holding joint responsibility with her mum. Your rights extend as far as you need to provide care for her. You also don’t have the power to decide to adopt her, that decision will be made by the Courts if the local author think it’s in her best interests.

Has a decision been made about permanence planning for her, is it intended that she remains in foster care until adulthood or is there the hope that she’ll be reunified with her family? Until you know her legal status discussion about SGO or adoption are pretty pointless, because it’s not your decision.

Of course she loves her mum, most care experienced children do regardless of what went before. You can leave her whatever you like in your will, it’s a lovely gesture and may make a huge difference in her life.

Longma · 05/11/2023 18:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Longma · 05/11/2023 18:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Coldcaller · 05/11/2023 18:08

I have been out all day with FD and Son firstly watching FD play hockey and then some Shopping for Sons 13th Birthday next week! What do you buy a 13 year old Boy who has X Box's PC 50 Games and So on who does not want a party.

I have noted a lot of what has been posted specifically the difficulty in ensuring FD would not be put under pressure from her mother in case of my death. I would like in that case for DD1 to become her legal Guardian. However, of course that means talking to a lawyer, would that mean she would take over the SGO if we chose that way forward rather than an adoption . I understand that 14 is a difficult age for adoption some of the reasons why have been stated here. I also agree i need to talk to a specialist Family Lawyer and Social Services before asking her the question. She has of the cuff said she wants me to be her forever 'Mum' so whether that is a plea for me to adopt her who knows. DD1 and DD2 are currently beneficiaries of a trust set up for them, so in theory could act as 'trusties' to FD until she was 25 or so in which case her mother would be out of the picture regarding any Inheritance.

Anyway if i did formally adopt FD surely she could still have a strong relationship with her Sister and Brother. However, maybe her mother would make that difficult by means of brainwashing and bad mouthing her to her siblings.

There is a lot to think about and consider hence why I am only thinking about the formal adoption part now after five years. She is currently staying with my mum and her 'Gran' tonight who will take her to school tomorrow.

OP posts:
Rocksonabeach · 05/11/2023 09:08

My children have different fathers. Eldest has a father who has never seen or acknowledged her - he is a millionaire he has no other children. Highly likely he won’t leave them anything. Although he could leave them the lot - more likely to go to a spouse if he had married by then.
youngest will inherit his fathers estate again a millionaire - and an only child.

I’m not sure what they will do - but I think given how close they are they will split everything 50/50 down the middle. My estate is divided.

if I had an adopted or foster child - likewise an even split.

GiantCheeseMonster · 05/11/2023 09:08

rentingthisglove · 05/11/2023 08:52

I might be wrong but there's no way you can just decide to adopt a child, they will have a care plan that states they have to be removed from their birth relatives and are to be looked after in foster care or a children's care residential home.
A judge has to decide a child's best interests are to be adopted and the legal relationship & parental rights between the child and their birth parents is to be severed and the child will be issued a new birth certificate which removes the birth parents from there.
It may not seem it but there's a huge difference between fostering (even long term) and adoption.
Of course it's possible, but I would think unlikely in this case? Especially as it seems even the child understands she should maintain a relationship with her birth mum and her siblings.

Re the inheritance absolutely include your foster daughter, use that as a way of going some way to creating the equality she would have as an adopted child. She sounds wonderful and your birth children sound wonderful and they want to do the right thing so there's no need to ask anyone else really.
It's really heartbreaking that some posters can't see her value as a member of your family unless you had given birth to her or adopted her. Or somehow suggesting she has bad blood and therefore can't be trusted with any generous or fair split of
an inheritance.
Child in care need love and support, not to be treated as if they are toxic or tainted. They are discriminated against (see some posters in this thread as just a tiny example) throughout their lives and are starting their lives from a place of disadvantage.
I grew up in a family where my parents values were Christian and although I would never describe as religious I was taught that one should go out into the world spreading love and hope and to extend the hand of generosity to those who need it the most and I would say this is what you are doing through including her equally.

This is right. Adoption orders follow placement orders, which state that the child’s plan is one of adoption.

I have not known a child to have a placement order much over 4 years old. Over that age and it is usually felt the child would have too many memories of birth family and find the shift to having other legal parents too difficult. The aim for all children is permanence, but for older children that is usually achieved by long term fostering with the same carer (“staying put”) or SGO.

Once the child is 18, of course it is up to them what they do and if they wish to sever all contact with birth family and live permanently with their foster family, being treated as a family member, then that is different. But before 18, I would be cautious with wills - simply as as a PP has said, if you die, she will be moved to a different carer and her next of kin will still be her birth family. You would need to speak to a solicitor about how you make a will so that her birth family cannot access the money.

pointythings · 05/11/2023 09:03

Why wouldn't you? I've done the same with my (now adult) foster son, with the full agreement of my DC. He doesn't have a relationship with his mother (and fortunately no siblings) so we are his family, end of story.

PuppyMonkey · 05/11/2023 09:02

Have you spoken to your supervising social worker about your plan? That would be my first port of call.

rentingthisglove · 05/11/2023 08:52

I might be wrong but there's no way you can just decide to adopt a child, they will have a care plan that states they have to be removed from their birth relatives and are to be looked after in foster care or a children's care residential home.
A judge has to decide a child's best interests are to be adopted and the legal relationship & parental rights between the child and their birth parents is to be severed and the child will be issued a new birth certificate which removes the birth parents from there.
It may not seem it but there's a huge difference between fostering (even long term) and adoption.
Of course it's possible, but I would think unlikely in this case? Especially as it seems even the child understands she should maintain a relationship with her birth mum and her siblings.

Re the inheritance absolutely include your foster daughter, use that as a way of going some way to creating the equality she would have as an adopted child. She sounds wonderful and your birth children sound wonderful and they want to do the right thing so there's no need to ask anyone else really.
It's really heartbreaking that some posters can't see her value as a member of your family unless you had given birth to her or adopted her. Or somehow suggesting she has bad blood and therefore can't be trusted with any generous or fair split of
an inheritance.
Child in care need love and support, not to be treated as if they are toxic or tainted. They are discriminated against (see some posters in this thread as just a tiny example) throughout their lives and are starting their lives from a place of disadvantage.
I grew up in a family where my parents values were Christian and although I would never describe as religious I was taught that one should go out into the world spreading love and hope and to extend the hand of generosity to those who need it the most and I would say this is what you are doing through including her equally.

Snowdayplease · 05/11/2023 01:59

Coldcaller · 04/11/2023 23:19

I think she wants to see her mother because part of her wants to believe it will be different with her the next time. The Social Worker has asked her does she want to see her Mother on numerous occasions, every-time she tells the Social Worker how much she loves her mother sister and brother. She is adamant with the Social Worker that she sees her mother. It is only in private with me she tells the truth. She tells the Social Worker that she always has a lovely time with her mother and siblings.

I think she is frightened, that her siblings might be placed in care if she complains and does not agree to see her Mother once a week. She wants the Social Worker to believe that her Mother is good for the sake of her siblings. I have told her the Social Worker will not be fooled by her pretending to love her mother. She does not believe me and is always concerned about the motives and actions of Social Services.

Why do you say the social worker won't be fooled by her pretending to love her mother? No matter how hurt her mother makes her, is it not almost certain that her daughter loves her? And that will be why she keeps giving her another chance?
Don't make your foster daughter think she has to not love her birth mother in order to please you.

Agapornis · 05/11/2023 00:50

What about setting up a trust with the adult children in charge? If things ever go wrong and her mother guilt trips her into giving money, it will be limited to a small amount.

Obviously that is redundant if there isn't all that much to will.

fernsandlilies · 05/11/2023 00:05

you sound like an amazing caring person and all the children are lucky to have you.

Please can I ask you though not to have a conversation with your foster daughter about adoption before you have fully discussed it with your social worker. She is not available to be adopted, and it would be terribly unfair to raise the idea in her mind if it could not actually happen.

As to the money, I think it’s a lovely idea, but I would also want to write something to each of your children explaining your decision so that they all feel acknowledged in their different ways.

Widgets · 04/11/2023 23:40

Trillie · 04/11/2023 23:37

I think you should limit yourself to your three children and change your will if you do adopt your foster child. The fact is the status and dynamics of a relationship with a foster child is different to a birth or adopted child, it is much more likely to change. There is also the chance that anything she inherits could end up going to her mother.

This

Ponoka7 · 04/11/2023 23:39

If she won't tell the truth to her SW then the adoption will never happen. I'd make your DD, who is her teacher aware that you want her to inherit, but I wouldn't yet put it in writing. You can discuss it with your DD to protect the girl from her Mother being manipulative and conning her out of her inheritance should anything happen to you. Your DD could be in the background with the offer of financial help once she is an adult. She'll get various funding because she's a looked after child, as you know. Write her in your will at present and it could be the Mother who gets it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread