Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To include my Foster Daughter on my will as my 12 year old adopted son is obviously included

83 replies

Coldcaller · 04/11/2023 22:44

I have two grown up daughters 29 and 27 who are both teachers and I have one 14 year old Foster daughter and a 12 year old adopted son. My foster daughter has lived with us since she was 9 and is dearly loved by us all. I cannot see her leaving us until at the earliest she finishes University (if ever) . She is a quite remarkable young lady that despite the fact of coming to us from difficult situations regarding her family situation still passed her 11+ and is thriving at her grammar school. It is both her and our strongest wish that she carries on living with us to at least she finishes University but she will always be my third daughter whatever happens.

Currently she has a terrible relationship with her birth mother and can not be with her for more than thirty minutes before she leaves in tears. I wait outside her mothers house, because she refuses to go and see her mother unless she can escape quickly. The last three times she has come out and ran straight in to my arms absolutely devastated telling me who she loathes her. Foster daughter has two siblings a 11 year old Sister and a 9 year old Brother who live with her. The other kids have been brainwashed by the mother to say such things as she is a 'Snob' and that they are not good enough for her. Hence, why she lives with us in a comfortable financially well off and loving family.

I have recently instructed my Solicitor to divide everything four ways rather than three ways . I believe i should have done this sooner I know it will be easier if she was Adopted by me this is a conversation I need to have with her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wellfancy · 07/11/2023 02:42

OP you are an absolute diamond . From an ex social worker .

Jellycatspyjamas · 07/11/2023 01:49

That’s one of the problems with foster care, the foster child gets a view of a very different lifestyle, benefits from
that to some extent while also maintaining relationships with a birth family where things may be much more chaotic. Part of the job as a foster care is to help manage that gap. You honestly can’t see why her telling her, by very definition, struggling mum how lovely her life is and her wonderful plans for the future - a life mum will never be able to give her siblings - would bring about an adverse reaction?

It’s not your job to call out her mum, it’s your job to support continued relationships with her family of origin by helping her understand the reasons why her mum can’t care for her in a positive, affirming way, no matter your personal opinion of mum. It’s a balance all adopters need to strike - being honest about the reasons for being in care, and ultimately being adopted, while leaving that door open should the child want a relationship with their family of origin now or in future.

She has a right to a relationship with her birth family, which in time may become very important to her. Even if you do go on to adopt her that right remains, particularly given her age. Of course as a young teenager she can see the differences in what you can offer her v what her mum can, and doesn’t want to return to her family, but that doesn’t mean cutting that legal bond is in her best interests in the longer term. You need to really think about how and what you communicate about her mum, because “look at all the lovely things I can give you that your mum can’t” may bite you on the arse when she gains maturity and understanding.

As a foster carer you have a duty to raise any concerns about contact with her social workers, because there are other children to consider here and they also need to be able to assess whether continued contact is in this child’s best interests. You seem to have lost sight of the wider responsibilities in your job, because fostering is a job, while also being much more.

Your fosterling deserves to have a sense of security about her future, which doesn’t necessarily mean adoption or a SGO, it could be that the current arrangement is secured through permanence planning without changing her legal standing with her mum. You clearly have a very privileged life, one which makes parenting much easier in lots of ways. Consider where her mum would be with your advantages, and how your parenting would be if you’d had her mums life experiences and adversity, and again think how it would be if you saw someone else giving your child everything you’d never be able to give them in a million years, and think about how to help your fosterling to straddle that gap.

Coughingdodger · 06/11/2023 23:59

It sounds tough for your FD. You’ve done really good things for her and I hope she stays with you. I do honestly think that no matter how awful her background is it is part of her and you can’t erase it, tempting as it might be, or you’ll cause her problems later in life. It’s better to swallow your dislike and facilitate some sort of relationship if you can while being around to support her. I can see why her mother feels angry with her even if it’s not right, so maybe you could help the child to understand. There’s probably as much or more grief there than anger. But yes, it sounds as if she is much better off living with you.

Coldcaller · 06/11/2023 23:44

I am not disgusted about my Foster Daughters Mother.
However, For two and half years she made no contact or even write a letter to FD. I generally wish the best for her and her other children who due to being FD's Kin I have compassion for. I can't however send Birthday presents for them but I can ensure that FD is able to buy presents for her brother and sister. However, this can be difficult to get it just right because it is not about 'Savior syndrome' it is about being caring for her Sister and Brother.

I have cared for FD for five years and I have never once called her mother, even when she chased her out of her house 3 weeks ago . This after FD told her mother how happy she is with her life school and her plans for the future. She came out of her Mothers Home crying ran over to my car and when she got in held my hand so tight, she would not let go . She was physically shaking in 'fear' that her mother would get custody of her and force her to leave her school and her current comfortable life. FD's mother would also likely expect her to give up her University aspirations to care for her Sister and Brother so she can go to the Pub every night !

OP posts:
Somanycats · 06/11/2023 23:26

I think its more complicated than it might seem. DS lived with foster carers for longer than your foster daughter has lived with you and they did want to adopt him but through no ones fault it wasn't thought to be appropriate and he was adopted by us. He has very little contact with the foster family now (many years have passed) FB friends but that's it really. They too have moved on and have now had other children for longer than they had him.i know it seems like this is forever but there are no guarantees. Might you wait until she is an adult and include her in your will at that point if it's still appropriate? If DS foster family had included him back in the day, they would presumably have had to disinherit him now as things have changed.

Pineapplepots · 06/11/2023 23:22

I find this whole thing really odd. OP’s your disgust towards your foster daughter’s mother is very clear so I assume your foster daughter has picked up on this. I was under the impression that where possible family reunification was the goal. I appreciate in a lot of circumstances that is not possible but I thought a foster carer’s role was to support their foster children in their current situation, not to tell them they social worker won’t be fooled by them pretending to love their mother (WTAF…) and thinking up ways to adopt when it’s not on the cards. There is a whole lot of saviour complex going on here. It’s all a bit fantasy - Rich and rescuing the poor child with the evil mother. I know you will get lots of “you are amazing OP” which I think you wanted but I really hope the poor FD’s social worker is picking up on this situation.

Thelnebriati · 06/11/2023 23:20

Its a lovely idea. Consider putting her share into trust, in case she comes under pressure from her birth family.

Blueeyedmale · 06/11/2023 23:12

OP this is so heartwarming you have transformed this young ladies life thank God for people like you in this world!

rentingthisglove · 06/11/2023 22:58

Of course her mother doesn't want you to adopt her child. There is no need, everything is working as well as it can now, but you seem to want full control over someone else's child? Only the courts can decide that based on the evidence presented (and your evidence won't count because you are the absolutely least important person in this process) I'm surprised your SW hasn't pointed this out to you.

rentingthisglove · 06/11/2023 22:55

You are starting to sound a little unhinged op.
If your daughters want to split that inheritance with her then who on earth is opposing that? You? Because there really seems no issue unless you have a problem with it. You need to be seen as a martyr/rescuer and you don't like the idea of relinquishing your control via money after your death?

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/11/2023 22:01

yes I would not have been able to breathe if one of my children had been taken away from me.

And yet you describe her as jealous and spiteful, not really considering that seeing her child have an immensely privileged life, that she couldn’t give her, might be incredibly hard for her.

Alohapotato · 06/11/2023 21:13

determinedtomakethiswork · 04/11/2023 23:09

I don't know why you brought it up. Your children agree with this and you are bringing up this girl as your own. What's the question? I know that you come out of this very well and it's obviously hard work bringing up foster children but there isn't an issue is there?

I agree. I don't understand why OP posted, maybe she just wanted to hear how lovely she is?

MissingMoominMamma · 06/11/2023 20:48

Coldcaller · 04/11/2023 23:03

An (SGO) Special Guardianship Order could be a middle ground solution in that it would enable her mother some rights. Ultimately her mothers rights would have to agree with my wishes.

I think Foster daughter would want to be adopted by me, i have not asked her yet because i think it is huge decision for a young girl to make. She is currently in year 10 which is a very busy time for her but perhaps it is better for her to think about what she wants now than next year.

Both daughters are the ones who have been on my back about adopting her and putting her on the will. My eldest daughter is her English teacher which is quite remarkable .

You have a lovely family.

For your foster daughter, her inclusion in your will is far more than just money- it’s you telling her that she belongs in your family equally.

Coldcaller · 06/11/2023 20:43

Thank You BrightGreenMoonBuggy

Jelly and Coughingdodger I understand that FD's birth mother might indeed be ashamed that she was not able to bring her up correctly. I also feel pity for a mother who can not appropriately care for her own daughter, that has got to be an appalling thing and yes I would not have been able to breathe if one of my children had been taken away from me.

OP posts:
BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 06/11/2023 20:34

You’re lovely. I wish I could give you a bloody big hug, and I’m not even exaggerating.

SoShallINever · 06/11/2023 20:23

ProvisionsOnTheDock · 04/11/2023 22:49

I don't think it's fair. By all means leave her something but I don't think it should be an equal split with your other (legal) children. If she was to be adopted that would be different.

What difference does a signature on a piece of paper make?

Coughingdodger · 06/11/2023 19:55

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/11/2023 19:49

FD's mother could be a stumbling block and cause problems here just to be difficult. Surely a mother should act in the best interests of their child and not out of spite or jealousy.

Think about how easily you’d give up one of your children, and come back and answer that question.

Just because her mum isn’t able to parent her doesn’t mean she doesn’t have love for her, this is a child not a favourite toy. The issues around children being removed, parental rights being removed and adoption are many and complicated.

There’s a huge amount of shame attached to parents whose children are adopted, which you may think is warranted but I think indicates a simplistic view - you may be able to provide a fantastic life for this child, but we don’t just give children to people because we think they’d be better parents. Her mum has every right to fight for her, and actually the process of doing so may make all the difference to how she processes that loss.

I agree.
Something about the OP’s attitude could be improved. The child will always be linked to her birth family - and shouldn’t be alienated from her siblings.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/11/2023 19:49

FD's mother could be a stumbling block and cause problems here just to be difficult. Surely a mother should act in the best interests of their child and not out of spite or jealousy.

Think about how easily you’d give up one of your children, and come back and answer that question.

Just because her mum isn’t able to parent her doesn’t mean she doesn’t have love for her, this is a child not a favourite toy. The issues around children being removed, parental rights being removed and adoption are many and complicated.

There’s a huge amount of shame attached to parents whose children are adopted, which you may think is warranted but I think indicates a simplistic view - you may be able to provide a fantastic life for this child, but we don’t just give children to people because we think they’d be better parents. Her mum has every right to fight for her, and actually the process of doing so may make all the difference to how she processes that loss.

Ted27 · 06/11/2023 19:40

@Coldcaller

You obviously have a lot of issues to think about.
Just a couple of things to add, I know a family with birth, adopted and foster children. They adopted a long term foster child when he was 14, so while its rare, it can happen, but a lot obviously depends on the birth mum.

My adopted son went to university this September - he had a contextual offer. I would check the Oxbridge policies, as it may be as broad as care experienced, not simply fostered at the time.

good luck

Coldcaller · 06/11/2023 19:32

I have spoken to my Social Worker which has been highlighted, she is potentially supportive about Adoption or an SGO which can be obtained quite quickly. The Social Worker h indicated that Adoption is potentially complex and could take a significant time. FD's mother could be a stumbling block and cause problems here just to be difficult. Surely a mother should act in the best interests of their child and not out of spite or jealousy.

FD's situation needs to be analysed, Adopt SGO or the current holding position which has been mentioned upfront. The current position of FD as a Foster Child for instance would likely help with Contextual offers to Oxford or Cambridge which i know FD has her eye on.

Secondly we are a financially very well off family so if she was formally Adopted before University, would bursaries and other contextual benefits she is currently entitled to become void.

The social worker did say it that is possible an 19 year old could be Adopted so after she had started University . However, it is very difficult because the application must come before they are 18. All in all I think as a family we have a lot to discuss and think about.

OP posts:
Longma · 06/11/2023 18:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

PuppyMonkey · 05/11/2023 22:07

But YOUR social worker OP. Not the foster child’s. You have one as a foster carer to support you and discuss issues?

VWdieselnightmare · 05/11/2023 21:33

ProvisionsOnTheDock · 04/11/2023 22:49

I don't think it's fair. By all means leave her something but I don't think it should be an equal split with your other (legal) children. If she was to be adopted that would be different.

You don't think it's fair that a child brought up in a family is treated differently to the other children just because forms haven't been filled in/ the court hasn't issued a piece of paper? Put yourself in her shoes and think again about what's fair.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/11/2023 21:08

There are different provisions for care experienced (in local authority care at any point) and care leavers (leaving a care placement between 16 and 25), it may be in your fosterlings interests to remain in care, remain with you under “staying put” and access leaving care support when she finishes university.

Hotcuppatea · 05/11/2023 21:07

Just stopping by to say thank goodness for people like you OP. The relationship your foster daughter has with you and the rest of your family is precious beyond words. How lucky you all are to have found each other.