Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Government thinks I am an extremist

133 replies

cakeorwine · 04/11/2023 21:46

I am a member of Republic.
Republic are a pressure group that wants to see an end to the Monarchy.
The Monarchy is an institution in the UK.
I will try ti undermine it.

That makes me an extremist.

Revealed: plan to brand anyone ‘undermining’ UK as extremist | UK security and counter-terrorism | The Guardian

Government officials have drawn up deeply controversial proposals to broaden the definition of extremism to include anyone who “undermines” the country’s institutions and its values, according to documents seen by the Observer.

Revealed: plan to brand anyone ‘undermining’ UK as extremist

Leaked documents spark furious backlash from groups who fear freedom of expression could be suppressed

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/nov/04/plans-to-redefine-extremism-would-include-undermining-uk-values

OP posts:
maddening · 05/11/2023 17:33

We need to challenge the definition - surely extremism is based on lengths gone to - eg terrorism and threat to life/physical safety and damage to property on a mass scale not having an opinion and lobbying or publicising an opinion

Araminta1003 · 05/11/2023 17:18

What is the solution though to recruiting the right kind of police officers so some people are allowed to go express themselves publicly? When people with options don’t want to be police officers anymore? Because it is far easier and safer to work from home in a flexi job and get paid better?
A lot of these public facing roles are in a recruitment crisis - there is the real truth. Because entitled Joe Bloggs in the public believes it is all the evil Tories fault and he or she is entitled to the best by birth. And the Government of whatever colour owes him or her big time.
I do hope things will get better again under Labour but pre 2008 the U.K. was booming not least because Blair and Co encouraged the City of London to thrive. That gravy train has sailed? Where is all this extra tax going to come from and more importantly who is going to fill the important jobs? What incentives will be offered?

TheMarzipanDildo · 05/11/2023 14:21

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 12:57

Errr. The OP could be a brain surgeon for all you know. I am a professional in a senior role. I am a member of an organisation that would most likely be classed as extremist.

Ghandi and his followers would have been classed as extremist.
The suffragettes would have been classed as extremist.
People opposing the Nazi regime might have been classed as extremist.

Who gets to decide?

Tbf as much as I admire them the suffragettes were definitely (and proudly!) extremists, and they did plenty of actual law breaking rather than just waving placards about.

cardibach · 05/11/2023 14:21

mumda · 04/11/2023 22:24

All Hail president Blair.

Eh? I am utterly unable to comprehend what this post is about/for.

TheMarzipanDildo · 05/11/2023 14:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Grin Mate

bombastix · 05/11/2023 14:13

Fundamental British values indeed. A red flag in terms of the relationship between a citizen and their government I never saw more clearly. Vote them out.

TheQuestToStopPigeonWoppie · 05/11/2023 14:09

From the article, I think these two parts summarise the change that the govt is considering:

...2011 Prevent strategy defined extremism as the “active opposition to fundamental British values, including democracy, the rule of law, individual liberty and the mutual respect and tolerance of different faiths and beliefs”

and

The documents state: “Extremism is the promotion or advancement of any ideology which aims to overturn or undermine the UK’s system of parliamentary democracy, its institutions and values.”

These parts don't say anything about what objectives might make something extremist (disbanding the monarchy/changing the UK's state religion etc). Maybe objectives are covered elsewhere in the documents.

Instead it broadens what behaviour might* count, from "active opposition" (eg blocking Charles from getting to his coronation) to "promotion or advancement"* (writing to your MP/marching/liking it on X).

I'm not surprised there are people objecting.

Roussette · 05/11/2023 13:38

What a mess the Conservatives have made of what was once a sensible and wealthy country. Every right thinking person should be repelled at their failures and see this for what it is, a paper thin attempt to cover up the fact that policing and the criminal justice system is in its knees because of their total mismanagement of it.

So agree with this.

I am quite obviously an extremist being a member of Republic too. And anyone saying that their members went to disrupt the Coronation are totally wrong. They spent months liaising with the Met as to how many would attend, what area would be allocated to them to peacefully protest so that no one's enjoyment of the Coronation would be disrupted. They were then double crossed and arrested and kept in a cell all day. Along with arresting them, they also managed to arrest Westminster Council's Women's Safety Team who hand out rape alarms to women.

The Police behaved appallingly, so much so that 3 Senior Officers actually went to Graham Smith's house (he is CEO of Republic) to apologise.
So please do not talk of Republic spoiling anyone's Coronation. That is untrue.

Extremisim? God help us if our right to protest is eroded like this Government is aiming to do.

bombastix · 05/11/2023 13:18

The sooner this lunatic government goes the better. We managed to survive the Cold War without bullshit like this, and the supposition that Conservatives would not be "extreme" under a future government is wrong. They assume, incorrectly, that these repressive laws would never be applied to them because they are "decent".

What a mess the Conservatives have made of what was once a sensible and wealthy country. Every right thinking person should be repelled at their failures and see this for what it is, a paper thin attempt to cover up the fact that policing and the criminal justice system is in its knees because of their total mismanagement of it.

Fionaville · 05/11/2023 13:17

HairyMcHairyFace · 04/11/2023 23:51

Can I ask what your reasons are? I live in a country where home education isn't legal so I find it really interesting to talk to people who do it.

Of course. A few reasons. I think the current classroom model is still based on the Victorian system. Young children made to sit at their desk for most of the day, listening to teacher at the front of the room. Preparing them to be good workers in the industrial revolution. When there are so many better models around the world. Where children learn through collaboration, playing and exploring their interests.
I believe that the world has changed and is still changing dramatically, so the skills school children are learning won't serve the majority of them well in the future. There is a great Ted talk by Sir Ken Robinson, about how schools kill creativity. Being a creative thinker is what is required to succeed in the modern world.
I want my children to enjoy their childhood, be free to explore and to maintain their love of learning. Most adults are doing jobs that they don't really enjoy, because they never got the chance to really explore their interests and develop the skills that might have better served them.
There are obviously exceptions to the rule and majority of people may argue that I'm totally wrong. That's fine, I'm not here to convince anybody.
I also don't like the level of bullying and sexualisation of children that is happening in schools, but that's another thread.

Clavinova · 05/11/2023 13:15

BottleShipDown
The suffragettes would have been classed as extremist

Certainly - the suffragettes orchestrated a bombing and arson campaign.

topnoddy · 05/11/2023 13:02

Slightly off the Republic bit ( I agree to ending the monarchy as well) I read that Braverman is calling the marches supporting Palestine "hate marches" now .

Hating the genocide that is being carried out in name of defence ?

Janinejones · 05/11/2023 13:02

Further to what I said last night: The SNP wants to split from UK, It has built up a following and it has become a political force and is taken very seriously. It persuaded by arguing and convincing many people that their ideas would be beneficial to Scotland. Rational argument is part of democracy.
They did not vandalise with paint randomly owned buildings in order to convince the rest of us. They realised that that influences nobody.

Was it not the Scottish Stuart King James 6 who wanted to be King James 1 of the entire British Isles after the death of Elizabeth1st?

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 12:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Errr. The OP could be a brain surgeon for all you know. I am a professional in a senior role. I am a member of an organisation that would most likely be classed as extremist.

Ghandi and his followers would have been classed as extremist.
The suffragettes would have been classed as extremist.
People opposing the Nazi regime might have been classed as extremist.

Who gets to decide?

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 12:53

lljkk · 05/11/2023 11:15

it's not often that people argue that Thatcher didn't do anything to erode civil liberties.

Oh no. Sorry. Wasn’t ignoring Thatcher at all! Just explaining why Blair might have been mentioned. I was a child during the Thatcher years so know less about it but by the time Blair was elected I was a student, more politically aware and full of hope for change. And then slowly that hope was eroded. I watched the film ‘Taking Liberties’ which opened my eyes to the erosion of our rights. No comment on Thatcher at all! I just can’t talk with any degree of knowledge about that era.

KimberleyClark · 05/11/2023 12:47

mumda · 04/11/2023 22:24

All Hail president Blair.

This thread is not about the monarchy and you have completely missed the point.

1dayatatime · 05/11/2023 12:43

"I am a member of Republic.
Republic are a pressure group that wants to see an end to the Monarchy.
The Monarchy is an institution in the UK.
I will try ti undermine it."

+++

Well that all depends on exactly how you intend to undermine it.

Putting barrels of gunpowder under the Houses of Parliament on November 5th would definitely put you in the extremist category whereas writing a letter to your MP or newspaper would not.

Araminta1003 · 05/11/2023 12:37

Freedom of speech is important and peaceful protesting is fine. However, larger successful groups that are well funded need to take responsibility for their members too. So if you allow angry crazy people to join your ranks and protest on your behalf in an unhinged way harming others there have to be some laws that make your organisation rand responsibility too. Why should police officers have to suffer etc?

Janinejones · 05/11/2023 12:34

@Notonthestairs Did you miss out the idea of an answer to my question for substance? such as a definition of something.
Quoting about another topic is pointless.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 05/11/2023 12:33

I home educate for ideological reasons. I wonder if I could be classed as an extremist as I'm 'undermining the countries institutions and values' That's if we count the education system as an institution. I definitely undermine it, as I think it's outdated and not fit for purpose.

No. Choosing not sending your child to school does not undermine the education system, because the education system allows you to legally home-educate your child. That's like saying you undermine the NHS by choosing to go to a private doctor.

gotomomo · 05/11/2023 12:27

Devil is in the detail. I'm all for arresting people who block motorways, major junctions preventing emergency vehicles getting through etc, but I believe those same people are free to protest with placards etc outside of parliament ... Fine to want to end the monarchy peacefully, fine to go to debates on the subject and protest with aforementioned placards but not to disrupt the actual coronation procession as the vast majority there have a right to enjoy it. (And afterall shouting slogans wouldn't change anything, just ruin the day for others)

pointythings · 05/11/2023 12:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

How do you know OP doesn't have a job? And Republic were given an apology by the Met for the way they were treated, so clearly the Met got it wrong on the day of the coronation.

The100AcreWood · 05/11/2023 12:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

HaveALaff · 05/11/2023 12:19

Notonthestairs · 05/11/2023 11:50

In fairness the Mail on Sunday are focusing on the Conservative Party covering up sexual assault by one of their MPs.

Really????!

Notonthestairs · 05/11/2023 11:50

Janinejones · 05/11/2023 11:36

Still no substance to the clickbait from the, Oh! so successful Guardian/Observer article.

In fairness the Mail on Sunday are focusing on the Conservative Party covering up sexual assault by one of their MPs.