Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Man in ladies loo (with little daughter)

745 replies

CallmePaul · 04/11/2023 21:15

Hello Mumsnet, 1st poster here.

So I'm the man in question here, my 4yr old girl needed the loo in a big store today, went into the men's, stinky & horrible & the only 1 available cubicle is engaged, the disabled one is locked & my little one is busting.
I opened the ladies door, wow much nicer than the men's! I asked loudly if it was OK if a man came in with his little girl to the loo, got an OK from a cubicle, business attended to.

Washing her & my hands afterwards I got a pretty loud tut & mumble of humph womans toilets, from a lady who just entered, I get it, I'm a bloke in a ladies loos, I really shouldn't be in there.

I've never taken her in the ladies before, always the men's & some pretty nasty loos at times.

So acceptable behaviour from me or was I out of order?

OP posts:
BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:51

SerafinasGoose

When the boundaries are so black and white that they ignore the needs and rights of a child then they need challenging. Just because women have been oppressed doesn’t give them the right to demand that a small child’s needs aren’t met.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:49

Alifestylechoice · 05/11/2023 15:40

I feel so sad that there are women who have been so badly traumatised by men that they hate men. It’s dreadful and makes me genuinely sad

what a passive aggressive, disingenuous and manipulative comment. Women not wanting men in their spaces does not mean they ‘hate men.’ It means they don’t want them in their spaces.

I am sorry if that came across that way. It was meant as it was said. I do find it sad. Really sad. There is man hating on this thread. I have a son and I’m raiding him to be the best version of himself he can. The hostility in here and in other threads towards makes me sad and angry on his behalf but I also, as a woman who has been on the receiving end of toxic masculinity, can understand why there is the hate. And it makes me sad that some women are so badly hurt and the summarised that they hate men so much. Genuinely. My mother is one of those women who hated men for years because of her experiences.

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 15:48

Alifestylechoice · 05/11/2023 15:40

I feel so sad that there are women who have been so badly traumatised by men that they hate men. It’s dreadful and makes me genuinely sad

what a passive aggressive, disingenuous and manipulative comment. Women not wanting men in their spaces does not mean they ‘hate men.’ It means they don’t want them in their spaces.

Asserting boundaries is very often, when they are asserted by women, deemed as aggression or hatred. When men assert boundaries, or make demands, women are expected to capitulate to these and cede over our feelings to the more important sex.

This is misogyny. Plain and simple.

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 15:47

Spermscarecrow · 05/11/2023 15:31

Personally I would not want my young child in a womens toilet with you .you are very aggressive and I would not want my child around such hatred .

Do you wish to take issue with any of the points I've made, @Spermscarecrow? Or are you more interested in ad hominem attacks?

IMO it is your approach that's the 'aggressive' one. It's designed (as ever) to shut women up. Women are the carers, the complacent ones, the ones who meekly cede over their rights or strength of opinion on what happens to be a very important issue at present. They are not supposed to be, had the precise same language been written by a man, 'assertive', but when it comes to a woman it's deemed aggression, shrewishness, bullying, add accusation of choice ad nauseam. And ad nauseam is precisely what it is. It's tedious.

I'm angry. That is true. I'm angry at the cavalier lack of regard (not to mention patrony, as upthread) that women who have been victims of trauma are routinely given on this site. I'm angry with the 'you are a man-hater' accusation every time a woman dares to take issue with male behaviour. I'm angry with the constant assumptions that we are the sex who should be kind, who should make concessions for male behaviour because men's feelings matter more than ours, who should constantly cede to the demands of that sex or be called 'aggressive', or 'unkind', or 'Karens', as they frequently are. And, when they say 'no', it's women who are constantly expected to find a solution for situations they never created in the first place.

Damned right women are angry. Some of our positions are hardening precisely because we've had enough of this attitude. And 'anger' is another thing we're told to swallow, doubtless from the assumption that it's unladylike.

In some situations, anger is healthy. It gets things done.

'Hatred' is your own interpretation. And that's your language, not mine.

GoBackRewind · 05/11/2023 15:44

That doesn't change the fact its someone chosing to use the other sex's toilet because its convenient. It's still invading their space

And I’ve said it’s wrong because both men and women deserve privacy. Neither should be invading the others space.

An impatient woman using a male toilet doesn’t justify men using women’s toilets. Two wrongs don’t make a right.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:43

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 15:28

So have I. It's nothing to do with perfect toileting skills. It's just normal toileting skills. The question is how long after they say they need to go can they hold it for. The OP is saying the girl couldn't wait long enough for the man in the cubicle to finish. She had to go within the next 2 minutes. That's not usual. If it were, given how spread out toilets are in city centres, there would be a awful lot more accidents than there are.

Well, to be fair, we don’t know how far apart the toilets are. How long they’d had to walk to find one. Whether she had a stomach bug. Etc. My 12 year old still missed cues if he’s distracted and then has to dash. To be fair. I do too. If I’m trying to get something done I’ll put off going to the loo. Human beings eh?

Alifestylechoice · 05/11/2023 15:40

I feel so sad that there are women who have been so badly traumatised by men that they hate men. It’s dreadful and makes me genuinely sad

what a passive aggressive, disingenuous and manipulative comment. Women not wanting men in their spaces does not mean they ‘hate men.’ It means they don’t want them in their spaces.

Teegan89 · 05/11/2023 15:39

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 10:53

'Some folk' include women who have been victims of sexual abuse, and who experience involuntary trauma responses when they find themselves in a potentially vulnerable situation with a man.

'Some folk' are women who could be dealing with heavy periods, even possibly miscarriage, in women's facilities, on the expected understanding that they are single sex facilities.

That you are okay with this doesn't override consent on behalf of other women.

And you would suggest women with legitimate issues such as this - or merely who are uncomfortable with sharing their protected spaces with males, 'have a stick up their butt'.

Nice. Real nice.

They aren’t in a potentially vulnerable situation though. He was there with his small child. Men have to access female facilities all the time as cleaners, plumbers, etc. We all use these facilities knowing that the single sex expectation is dependent on context. If you can’t see the context here then yes, it does appear to be very rigid thinking on your part.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 05/11/2023 15:37

There is a difference because women are not a danger to men.

That doesn't change the fact its someone chosing to use the other sex's toilet because its convenient. It's still invading their space

*are less of a danger to men

Universalsnail · 05/11/2023 15:35

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 15:21

I just asked my OH re: this dilemma. We have a DD. He did 50% of the childcare when they were little. We have no family support. He said he would never have gone into the ladies. He says he'd have told her to hold it in and if abso desperate would have wondered whether he could hold her over the urinal. So no, it's not about whether there's a woman around to help. Some people would just never invade women's spaces .

It is more acceptable to hold a female child over a dirty man's urinal then a man shout into the women's to make his presence known and to go in there to help his child? Urinals are not in private cubicles, any man can just walk in and while his penis out in the urinal next to the child be held exposed over the dirty urinal.

Do small female children not deserve dignity and privacy because adult women might feel a bit uncomfortable for a few moments that a man with a small child is briefly in the communal part of a toilet facility.

Spermscarecrow · 05/11/2023 15:31

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 14:02

For 'broken and unhealed' read 'women who dare to assert boundaries, and men who really do not like hearing the word "no" coming from a woman'.

And if some women are 'broken and unhealed', what could possibly have broken them to the extent that using mixed-sex facilities might be traumatising to them? Any takers? Would it be other women, perchance?

(Spoiler alert: No).

Personally I would not want my young child in a womens toilet with you .you are very aggressive and I would not want my child around such hatred .

GoBackRewind · 05/11/2023 15:29

A man taking his young daughter to the toilet because its the only space is no more invading the space as a woman deciding that there aren't many men at a concert and so they'll just use the men's as there's a queue....

There is a difference because women are not a danger to men. But I wouldn’t use a men’s toilet. Men and women both deserve single sex spaces for privacy and dignity.

Plan your trips with young kids, take them to the toilet often and before they ask, take spare clothes in case of accidents.

My partner would never have used a women’s toilet with our children. Just like if he forgot his wallet and lunch, he wouldn’t go and steal for food from a shop and justify it as necessary.

It’s a boundary he wouldn’t cross because he respects women. If the men in your life would cross that boundary, then they’re not men I would want to know.

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 15:28

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 14:57

My experience of being a parent and working with children is that, at the age of 4, urgent toilet needs are frequent. They are learning and developing so much that they don’t notice their body’s signals and then suddenly need to go. Or, like adults, sometimes just need to go very quickly. You obviously have only met perfect children, with perfect toileting skills. Lucky you. I’ve been on the motorway countless times where we’ve passed services (any one need the loo? No!) and the five minutes past the services - ‘mum!!!! I need the loo’ Irritating. Annoying. But perfectly normal.

So have I. It's nothing to do with perfect toileting skills. It's just normal toileting skills. The question is how long after they say they need to go can they hold it for. The OP is saying the girl couldn't wait long enough for the man in the cubicle to finish. She had to go within the next 2 minutes. That's not usual. If it were, given how spread out toilets are in city centres, there would be a awful lot more accidents than there are.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:24

hold her over the urinal.

Really? He’d hold a 4 year old girl over a urinal to do poo? There are so many many things wrong with that I do t even know where to start.

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 15:21

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 05/11/2023 14:50

Probably cause they were able to ask a female relative to go in with them. But situations like this do arise and many men would prefer not to have to enter a women's space - they aren't all delighted at the prospect.

I just asked my OH re: this dilemma. We have a DD. He did 50% of the childcare when they were little. We have no family support. He said he would never have gone into the ladies. He says he'd have told her to hold it in and if abso desperate would have wondered whether he could hold her over the urinal. So no, it's not about whether there's a woman around to help. Some people would just never invade women's spaces .

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 05/11/2023 15:19

And
A man taking his young daughter to the toilet because its the only space is no more invading the space as a woman deciding that there aren't many men at a concert and so they'll just use the men's as there's a queue....

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 05/11/2023 15:18

Is there a reason whyit might be unsafe for a 4-YO kid to use single-sex facilities on her own?

Oh, yes. Because when those facilities are infiltrated by the other sex, they're no longer single sex.

Aside from the fact there are quite literally women out there who abduct children....

A 4 year old not using the facilities alone is more to do with the fact that those facilities are created for adults. Bigger toilets, higher up sinks and toilet rolls and paper towels. As well as them potentially still struggling with clothing and fastenings

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:16

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 05/11/2023 15:09

Decent men don’t invade women’s spaces. It’s very simple for those men.

A man who allowed his daughter to have a mishap in public would also be criticised for being a shit dad. And bodily functions don't always work like clockwork, sometimes with all the planning in the world - situations do arise. Especially with young children.

Would rather concede that occasionally exceptional situations arise and be pragmatic about that, than insist on enforcing a blanket rule that trumps my needs over the needs of a distressed child.

Hear hear. Well put.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 05/11/2023 15:09

Decent men don’t invade women’s spaces. It’s very simple for those men.

A man who allowed his daughter to have a mishap in public would also be criticised for being a shit dad. And bodily functions don't always work like clockwork, sometimes with all the planning in the world - situations do arise. Especially with young children.

Would rather concede that occasionally exceptional situations arise and be pragmatic about that, than insist on enforcing a blanket rule that trumps my needs over the needs of a distressed child.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:08

Fionaville · 05/11/2023 15:02

Ideally at 4, you could open the main door to the toilets and watch your daughter go into a cubicle herself. At 4, most kids are capable of using the toilet alone (but I get not letting her in there alone because of safety) Just stay stood at the threshold and explain to the women coming in and out what you were doing, but don't actually enter the toilets.

At this age they often can’t get up onto the toilet. Can’t reach the paper. Can’t reach the sinks. They leave the toilet in a mess left alone.

Underhisi · 05/11/2023 15:08

"Those thinking I avoided the men's because it stank are completely wrong, I've used it with her before, it's pretty foul but IT WAS OCCUPIED!"

You need to plan your trips out better.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:07

GoBackRewind · 05/11/2023 15:03

The original OP wasn’t goady. The OP handled some pretty horrible posts with equal and even more restrained language than some incredibly goady posters.

You are incredible naive if your believe that. But then you’ve already admitted you didn’t know there were piss and poo trolls on here so you are naive to some people’s motives on here.

I think most dads, faced with that situation woukd do the same for their daughter’s dignity.

Decent men don’t invade women’s spaces. It’s very simple for those men.

I’m not at all naive. I just can fully imagine my DH having exactly the same dilemma and posting exactly the same thread.

He didn’t ‘invade’ he called out and asked permission. What could he have done differently? If he’s such a twat then he needs educating. Tell him the alternative. There was no available cubicle in the men’s (I wouldn’t want her in there anyway if it was my daughter), no easy access toilet available. He called out to check it was OK. His daughter was desperate and might have had an accident.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:03

electriclight · 05/11/2023 15:00

So many posters who, through superior planning and parenting, have never been in an emergency toileting situation with their child. I am sure most of us have the imagination to understand what it would be like if it happened though.

If only I had had those skills 😂

My 12 year old DC still sometimes misses the signals and we have to do an about-turn.

GoBackRewind · 05/11/2023 15:03

The original OP wasn’t goady. The OP handled some pretty horrible posts with equal and even more restrained language than some incredibly goady posters.

You are incredible naive if your believe that. But then you’ve already admitted you didn’t know there were piss and poo trolls on here so you are naive to some people’s motives on here.

I think most dads, faced with that situation woukd do the same for their daughter’s dignity.

Decent men don’t invade women’s spaces. It’s very simple for those men.

Fionaville · 05/11/2023 15:02

Ideally at 4, you could open the main door to the toilets and watch your daughter go into a cubicle herself. At 4, most kids are capable of using the toilet alone (but I get not letting her in there alone because of safety) Just stay stood at the threshold and explain to the women coming in and out what you were doing, but don't actually enter the toilets.