Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Man in ladies loo (with little daughter)

745 replies

CallmePaul · 04/11/2023 21:15

Hello Mumsnet, 1st poster here.

So I'm the man in question here, my 4yr old girl needed the loo in a big store today, went into the men's, stinky & horrible & the only 1 available cubicle is engaged, the disabled one is locked & my little one is busting.
I opened the ladies door, wow much nicer than the men's! I asked loudly if it was OK if a man came in with his little girl to the loo, got an OK from a cubicle, business attended to.

Washing her & my hands afterwards I got a pretty loud tut & mumble of humph womans toilets, from a lady who just entered, I get it, I'm a bloke in a ladies loos, I really shouldn't be in there.

I've never taken her in the ladies before, always the men's & some pretty nasty loos at times.

So acceptable behaviour from me or was I out of order?

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 16:57

Nothanksthanksanyway · 05/11/2023 16:46

Oh I absolutely agree. Just the MN responses would have been all ‘we are all for inclusion blah blah’

It could be that you're right. There are some Mumsnetters who would undoubtedly take that view. The problem is that if 'inclusion' is pursued to the extent that many women would self-exclude, then 'inclusivity' is not going to be the end result. Isn't that ironic? Inclusion, to the exclusion of the people that facility was designed for in the first place.

And to what end? Would some women, for instance the severely traumatised or those belonging to the more orthodox branches of some religions, no longer be able to participate in public life? Is it seriously expected that they will just stay at home? Those women matter, too.

As to those who believe women's feelings, autonomy and actual needs - as oppose to someone else's wants - don't matter, this is doubtless fine and dandy for those who hold these views. But the PP above nails it, because it's the height of naivety to imagine that predatory men won't take advantage.

They absolutely will. And OP might not be such a predatory man, and a man presenting as a woman and simply wanting to get on with life in peace might not be one, but the fetishist who followed him in might be, and by appearances only it's impossible to tell who is and isn't a threat. Hence the single sex facilities. The PP above has this bang to rights: once you chip chip chip away at this boundary, and say we'll make an exception for you, and you, and you ... then the safeguarding boundary is down. And we've seen this happening in various public arenas in recent years.

This calls to mind that old maxim: 'your right to swing your fist ends where my nose starts'. And there are important discussions to be had when the rights of some potentially vulnerable groups directly conflict with those of another.

It's the moderates on both sides whose voices are desperately needed on that point. Telling women: 'we are what we say you are, and YOU are what we say you are, and there is no conflict (when there clearly is) and you're a bigot if you try to address the nuances of this', will no longer cut it.

Sometimes, sex matters.

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:50

BigFatLiar · 05/11/2023 16:42

Just let her wet herself and tell her she's upholding womens dignity (or let her pee in a gutter or drain outside)

No need. Just take some responsibility and plan better. There is no need to get to the toilet at the point at which a 4 year old can't hold it long enough for the person in the cubicle to finish.

Windywuss · 05/11/2023 16:50

My question was a genuine one. If the woman in the cubicle said don't come in, what would you have done?

It's fine as a one off and I would have understood but then does it become normalized?. We all start saying it's ok for men to come in if they're with their kids. It isn't. I would not like to see men make a habit of it.

You only have to read on here about women's changing rooms and how many men come in now it's a free for all. It's not ok.

It's shit there isn't a good solution for Dads but Dads should push for better facilities I think.

Nothanksthanksanyway · 05/11/2023 16:46

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:45

It makes no difference to me whether a man identifies as a woman or not. He should not be in the ladies.

Oh I absolutely agree. Just the MN responses would have been all ‘we are all for inclusion blah blah’

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:45

Nothanksthanksanyway · 05/11/2023 16:41

Bloody hell. Of course it was fine. You asked before entering and you were as quick as you could be. If you ‘identified as a women’ all these posters would have been fine!! I wouldn’t want my daughter into the vile men’s.

ridiculous responses here!

It makes no difference to me whether a man identifies as a woman or not. He should not be in the ladies.

Callyem · 05/11/2023 16:44

God I hate this place sometimes. People would rather allow a 4 year old to wet herself than tolerate a father taking his daughter in.

BigFatLiar · 05/11/2023 16:42

Just let her wet herself and tell her she's upholding womens dignity (or let her pee in a gutter or drain outside)

Nothanksthanksanyway · 05/11/2023 16:41

Bloody hell. Of course it was fine. You asked before entering and you were as quick as you could be. If you ‘identified as a women’ all these posters would have been fine!! I wouldn’t want my daughter into the vile men’s.

ridiculous responses here!

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:41

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 16:27

Because women's feelings are less important. I truly believe there are some people out there - stridently misogynistic men and sadly all too many of their women supporters - who view females as less than human.

What was that phrase I've heard used? 'Reframe your trauma'. Those offensive words - implying an absolute disregard for women's feelings, autonomy and dignity - have not been used on this thread, but the thread nonetheless absolutely reeks of precisely that sentiment.

I'm sorry about what happened to your mother.

Edited

Thank you. It's a trauma that impacted down the generations to despite her being long dead, it's still very live and impactful. This thread does reek of exactly that. How on earth my OH managed to care for a dd without encountering this! Who knew he was such a special man!

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:37

Universalsnail · 05/11/2023 16:32

Women still have dignity and privacy if there is a man briefly in the communal part of a women's toilet because the man is not in the stall with them whilst they are exposed, this is why men are allowed to be toilet attendants in women's toilets.
The kid being held over a urinal though has none of that privacy or dignity because they are being held genitalia exposed in a male space.

You think a 4 year old should be made to wee themselves because your husband has a change of clothes so oh well? Sometimes small children suddenly declare they are desperate for a wee. Most 4 year olds would feel embarrassment at weeing themselves if they were no longer in nappies. Would you be happy being expected to wee yourself because you need assistance in a toilet and some stranger isn't happy about that?

Honestly I get some women have a trauma response to men in their spaces. I am one of those women. I would feel afraid of an alone man randomly in the womens toilets, but I am completely capable of assessing a situation, seeing that this is a father with a small female child who announced he was coming in and then just dealing with my feelings, because it is not my place to be projecting my trauma as if my feelings or trauma response is more important then the needs of a small child. Every women in this thread is capable of doing the same. Women are not weak hapless victims who are so fragile we can't possible cope with the existence of a father with a child in a communal sink area who we would rather wasn't there.

Some women are so fragile and I think they matter. It's not privacy if a man is in the ladies. He can see women come out with blood on their hands, for example. You might not care about that but others do and it's not your right to give away female spaces. If the urinal thing bothers you, don't do it. That's still no excuse to for a man to be in the ladies. I'm also one of those ladies and my assessment would be that there is no excuse for the man in the ladies so this is a man who is happy to violate women's boundaries. So he's someone I'm scared of.

CallmePaul · 05/11/2023 16:35

funinthesun19 · 05/11/2023 13:56

Your daughter will be fine. She’s with you. In a couple of years she will be able to go in to the ladies on her own anyway.

As a grown arsed man, you can’t just come in to the ladies just because you don’t want your dd to go in to the men’s toilets. Just take her in to the men’s, carry her if needs be so she doesn’t have to walk on the smelly floor.

Men aren’t allowed in women’s toilets. Men in women’s spaces is usually frowned upon. So I don’t see why it should be any different when a man has his daughter with him.

Did you miss that the one single cubicle in the mens was occupied?

OP posts:
Universalsnail · 05/11/2023 16:32

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:19

Women deserve dignity and privacy. It's not about feeling uncomfortable for a few moments. What a way to minimise the impact which men invading women's spaces has on some women. How unpleasant. The OP can ask men to not use the urinal for the moments when his dd was using it if it came to that. Men too can hold on for a few minutes. In reality I don't think my OH would have done this because he planned well enough to not take to our DD to the toilet with 0 seconds left of her ability to hold it in and if her trigger was still that quick he'd have had a chance of clothes with him.

Women still have dignity and privacy if there is a man briefly in the communal part of a women's toilet because the man is not in the stall with them whilst they are exposed, this is why men are allowed to be toilet attendants in women's toilets.
The kid being held over a urinal though has none of that privacy or dignity because they are being held genitalia exposed in a male space.

You think a 4 year old should be made to wee themselves because your husband has a change of clothes so oh well? Sometimes small children suddenly declare they are desperate for a wee. Most 4 year olds would feel embarrassment at weeing themselves if they were no longer in nappies. Would you be happy being expected to wee yourself because you need assistance in a toilet and some stranger isn't happy about that?

Honestly I get some women have a trauma response to men in their spaces. I am one of those women. I would feel afraid of an alone man randomly in the womens toilets, but I am completely capable of assessing a situation, seeing that this is a father with a small female child who announced he was coming in and then just dealing with my feelings, because it is not my place to be projecting my trauma as if my feelings or trauma response is more important then the needs of a small child. Every women in this thread is capable of doing the same. Women are not weak hapless victims who are so fragile we can't possible cope with the existence of a father with a child in a communal sink area who we would rather wasn't there.

jeaux90 · 05/11/2023 16:31

No it's not ok, and any women on here consenting to you in a female space can not consent for other women. Consent is not transferable.

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 16:27

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:23

My mother was sexually abused by countless men in her family. She was traumatised all her life. Her 'hatred' of men was simply cold hard fear. I think that's actually quite common. She's one of the women who would have been so horrified to find a man in the ladies loos that she'd have likely never gone back to them. IMHO it's hatred to make excuses for men who cba to figure out another solution to the logistical challenge he faced rather than stand up for women's rights.

Because women's feelings are less important. I truly believe there are some people out there - stridently misogynistic men and sadly all too many of their women supporters - who view females as less than human.

What was that phrase I've heard used? 'Reframe your trauma'. Those offensive words - implying an absolute disregard for women's feelings, autonomy and dignity - have not been used on this thread, but the thread nonetheless absolutely reeks of precisely that sentiment.

I'm sorry about what happened to your mother.

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:23

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:49

I am sorry if that came across that way. It was meant as it was said. I do find it sad. Really sad. There is man hating on this thread. I have a son and I’m raiding him to be the best version of himself he can. The hostility in here and in other threads towards makes me sad and angry on his behalf but I also, as a woman who has been on the receiving end of toxic masculinity, can understand why there is the hate. And it makes me sad that some women are so badly hurt and the summarised that they hate men so much. Genuinely. My mother is one of those women who hated men for years because of her experiences.

My mother was sexually abused by countless men in her family. She was traumatised all her life. Her 'hatred' of men was simply cold hard fear. I think that's actually quite common. She's one of the women who would have been so horrified to find a man in the ladies loos that she'd have likely never gone back to them. IMHO it's hatred to make excuses for men who cba to figure out another solution to the logistical challenge he faced rather than stand up for women's rights.

CousinGreg55 · 05/11/2023 16:22

It is the social convention that toilets are single sex after about age eight.
The trouble with saying it's fine for a man to go into the ladies with a 4 year old girl is that its chips away at this convention. If a man with a 4 year is fine what about with a 5/6/7 year old. If the problem is the gent's being occupied then this same situation might happen with a young boy and dad might decide it is fine for him to take his young son into the ladies. If it became socially acceptable for men to be in the ladies for a good reason then men will take advantage of the loosened boundaries to go in there for any old reason and people are naive if they think they won't.

literalviolence · 05/11/2023 16:19

Universalsnail · 05/11/2023 15:35

It is more acceptable to hold a female child over a dirty man's urinal then a man shout into the women's to make his presence known and to go in there to help his child? Urinals are not in private cubicles, any man can just walk in and while his penis out in the urinal next to the child be held exposed over the dirty urinal.

Do small female children not deserve dignity and privacy because adult women might feel a bit uncomfortable for a few moments that a man with a small child is briefly in the communal part of a toilet facility.

Women deserve dignity and privacy. It's not about feeling uncomfortable for a few moments. What a way to minimise the impact which men invading women's spaces has on some women. How unpleasant. The OP can ask men to not use the urinal for the moments when his dd was using it if it came to that. Men too can hold on for a few minutes. In reality I don't think my OH would have done this because he planned well enough to not take to our DD to the toilet with 0 seconds left of her ability to hold it in and if her trigger was still that quick he'd have had a chance of clothes with him.

Spermscarecrow · 05/11/2023 16:16

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 16:13

Ad hominem again. More accuasations of aggression. You're accusing me of emotional abuse? You have some nerve. You're also devoid of any sense of irony.

I consider this exchange pointless and unhelpful and will not be continuing it.

Thank fuck for that !!!!!

Fionaville · 05/11/2023 16:15

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 15:08

At this age they often can’t get up onto the toilet. Can’t reach the paper. Can’t reach the sinks. They leave the toilet in a mess left alone.

My 4 year olds were able to use 'adult sized' toilets, most can get on the toilet fine. They start school at 4, so they need to be using the toilet independently. I personally would rather see a bit of a toilet roll on the floor and water splashed round the sink etc, than a man in the ladies toilet.

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 16:13

Spermscarecrow · 05/11/2023 16:06

You're very aggressive to other women as well. I will say it again , I would not want my child exposed to this aggression . It is also very damaging. Many women have been suffered sexual abuse including myself . I do not allow my trauma to manifest into the emotional abuse of others .

Ad hominem again. More accuasations of aggression. You're accusing me of emotional abuse? You have some nerve. You're also devoid of any sense of irony.

I consider this exchange pointless and unhelpful and will not be continuing it.

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 16:10

Alifestylechoice · 05/11/2023 15:57

@SerafinasGoose hit me up, I want to go for a drink with you!

Bottoms up! 🍻

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 16:10

GoBackRewind · 05/11/2023 15:57

There is man hating on this thread.

It is not man hating to want safe spaces for women to be respected by men.

I have a very lovely male partner and a son who has been raised well to respect women. I still understand that other women do not know my partner and son and so don’t know that they are good men. And I still understand that even if they did know they are good men, they still do not necessarily want to share a woman’s safe space with them.

More importantly, my partner and son understand that, meaning that they would never invade a woman’s safe space.

I applaud this comment.

At my gym/swimming pool, 8 is the age at which boys are no longer permitted in the female changing rooms. A lot of the mothers of sons disregard this rule. There are clearly boys in there changing with their mothers who are a LOT older than eight. But the message that girls should automatically be expected to cede over their spaces because boys' feelings are more important was not a code I wanted instilled in my son from a young age. There were girls from his class at school engaging in the same swimming lessons. It was no longer appropriate.

His dad - who also believes such boundaries are important - has taken over swimming duty (I'd been taking him since 3.5 months). On the rare occasion I've taken him alone, I've put a warm dry robe on him and some soft joggers and his crocs by the poolside, then taken him off in the car to shower and clean up at home.

There are always ways around these particular issues, and as parents, it's up to us to find them in such a way as this is not at the expense of other groups. A point upthread questions - in very emotive and manipulative terms - the positioning of women's rights above those of 'small female children'. The point is that every woman and girl has the entitlement to change, have their toileting needs met, and/or being in a vulnerable state of undress without the presence of males. Because this is not their space. And suggesting female spaces are not for men is in no way tantamount to being a 'man hater'.

Some disabled loos are designated changing facilities. I'm not questioning whether this is morally right (I lean towards it not being so) but it's the way it is. So when particularly small children need toileting help, I'd assumed the 'changing facility' lavatories applied to such children.

As it's not ideal, an obvious answer is a third space. Not unisex for everyone - this does not account for the women who, for reasons of trauma or religion or because they just plainly don't want to share with males. It's an alternative. When I have my DS with me, it's one I'd welcome. Otherwise, in all cases I'd use single sex facilties, such as these have been left to us.

The trouble is some parents can't bear to take the initative upon themselves to take care of their children's needs without this being at someone else's expense.

This is not a lesson I want my child to learn.

Spermscarecrow · 05/11/2023 16:06

SerafinasGoose · 05/11/2023 15:47

Do you wish to take issue with any of the points I've made, @Spermscarecrow? Or are you more interested in ad hominem attacks?

IMO it is your approach that's the 'aggressive' one. It's designed (as ever) to shut women up. Women are the carers, the complacent ones, the ones who meekly cede over their rights or strength of opinion on what happens to be a very important issue at present. They are not supposed to be, had the precise same language been written by a man, 'assertive', but when it comes to a woman it's deemed aggression, shrewishness, bullying, add accusation of choice ad nauseam. And ad nauseam is precisely what it is. It's tedious.

I'm angry. That is true. I'm angry at the cavalier lack of regard (not to mention patrony, as upthread) that women who have been victims of trauma are routinely given on this site. I'm angry with the 'you are a man-hater' accusation every time a woman dares to take issue with male behaviour. I'm angry with the constant assumptions that we are the sex who should be kind, who should make concessions for male behaviour because men's feelings matter more than ours, who should constantly cede to the demands of that sex or be called 'aggressive', or 'unkind', or 'Karens', as they frequently are. And, when they say 'no', it's women who are constantly expected to find a solution for situations they never created in the first place.

Damned right women are angry. Some of our positions are hardening precisely because we've had enough of this attitude. And 'anger' is another thing we're told to swallow, doubtless from the assumption that it's unladylike.

In some situations, anger is healthy. It gets things done.

'Hatred' is your own interpretation. And that's your language, not mine.

Edited

You're very aggressive to other women as well. I will say it again , I would not want my child exposed to this aggression . It is also very damaging. Many women have been suffered sexual abuse including myself . I do not allow my trauma to manifest into the emotional abuse of others .

Alifestylechoice · 05/11/2023 15:57

@SerafinasGoose hit me up, I want to go for a drink with you!

GoBackRewind · 05/11/2023 15:57

There is man hating on this thread.

It is not man hating to want safe spaces for women to be respected by men.

I have a very lovely male partner and a son who has been raised well to respect women. I still understand that other women do not know my partner and son and so don’t know that they are good men. And I still understand that even if they did know they are good men, they still do not necessarily want to share a woman’s safe space with them.

More importantly, my partner and son understand that, meaning that they would never invade a woman’s safe space.