Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question rich child/average child friendship

134 replies

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 19:23

We are average.
Average careers.
Average income.
Smaller (much smaller ....meaning TINY) than average house.
DS aged 12 is a gorgeous boy. Bright. Funny. Intelligent. Lovely. Kind. Sociable. Active. Loves going out on his bike.
Goes to the local comp which hasn't got a great reputation.
He's been biking on his own a lot down this certain area through the countryside and keeps bumping in to another kid the same age who's also out on his bike in the same area.
Today they got talking.
Other kid lives in a gigantic double fronted detached listed building surrounded by lakes and land, and attends a public school an hour away.
We live 10 min drive away in a tiny weeny semi in a tiny close with a tiny back patio.
My DS and this kid seem to have a connection and want to swap numbers to meet up and go biking together.
Can it work???
If you send your DC to a public school and live in a country pad, would you be OK with them hanging out with a kid from the local comp who lives in a house so small it's cramped?!

OP posts:
sep135 · 04/11/2023 21:01

We're fortunate in having a pool and tennis court but when my kids were younger, they'd go to their friends' houses and rave about their trampolines or PlayStations. Kids do not see differences in house size etc in the way adults do.

The only thing I'd say is that it's a shame when people seem embarrassed about having a smaller house and never reciprocate invites. Sometimes I feel I'm always hosting (which I don't mind as it's nice to see the kids enjoying being together) but when there's not been a single invite in over five years, it does occasionally start to rankle.

Inyourwildestdreams · 04/11/2023 20:56

Of course they can be friends.

I was the “poor child” among my friends. The only thing that actually affected my friendships at any point was the fact that my parents didn’t allow me to have any friends in my house. No dinners after school, no play dates, no sleepovers etc. If they came to the door to ask if I was going out to play my parents wouldn’t even invite them in while I got my shoes etc on. And I was never allowed to do anything for my birthdays.

I was always invited to things at their houses. As I got older and noticed it more, I’d feel guilty accepting the invitation knowing that I couldn’t return the invite so I’d often purposely leave myself out of things.

They don’t care about the size of houses. Be warm and welcoming to any friends.

Differentstarts · 04/11/2023 20:56

Kids don't care about crap like that and you shouldn't either

SisterMichaelsHabit · 04/11/2023 20:49

Countdowntowhat · 04/11/2023 20:18

Wow. Just wow. Would you stop your son being friends with someone who lives in a council house? Or if their parents were ill so lived on benefits? No? Then why assume this friendship can’t work just because this time you’re not the richer one in the friendship?

You and me could never be friends but hopefully your son will have a noce time with this boy who he clearly has loads in common with.

TBH if you couldn't be friends with someone because they have obvious low self-esteem/self worth and worry about their child getting invested in a friendship then being hurt when it suddenly evaporates, that says a lot more about you than the OP.

OP I grew up on a council estate and went to a very middle class school out of the area. Some kids with lots of money were lovely and I even got invited to a sleepover at a quite fancy 4 bedroom detached house in one of the extremely posh villages near the school. I remember going home and telling my mum about how this house's main living room was bigger than our entire house, and how they had three living rooms!

Some kids with lots of money were horrible and mercilessly teased me. I'll never forget this total arsehole pointing at my Kwik Save No Frills crisps at lunch and shouting, "You eat shit crisps!" at the top of their voice when I was 12. Peak twat, really.

With the decent kids, I actually had no idea how much money they had until I went round their houses or they left for private school. In the case of your son, if the friendship has developed naturally to this point, then they like each other for who they are, and I don't think it will fizzle for financial reasons if you're all decent people.

We live in a very naice town these days. I sometimes get the slight unease of feeling "I don't belong here" when I take DS to playdates (there was one on a private road in a bloody mansion last month and their parents drive a fecking Bentley, and I never even saw a Bentley in my life until we moved here last year), but I tell myself to stop being silly and that the kids don't even know what this stuff costs. Then I go home and tell DH all about the fancy houses DS's friends have and we talk Rightmove or career planning for a bit and think about how we can get ahead a little more for ourselves.

Just give the kids the time and space to get to know each other, and if you're worried, maybe make the first move and invite the other boy to your house early so you can see for yourself that they're totally fine in your surroundings.

It's just another form of imposter syndrome.

ShittyGlitter · 04/11/2023 20:47

Nah I want to see how that conversation plays out.

Sorry jimmy, you can't hang out with Quentin, his house is too big.

I don't let my daughter's hang out with the next door neighbours, they don't have an ensuite or walk in wardrobe.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 04/11/2023 20:40

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 04/11/2023 20:35

Honestly? I think it will be harder for the other boy. Being at a private school he is likely to live far away from his school friends so will only see them occasionally. Whereas your DS will live closer to his school friends and will see them more often.

That is really the only difference that matters.

Your house, if inviting, is more than sufficient.

I agree. My summers used to be pretty lonely due to that.

that’s why I used to be so keen on summer camp.

SparklyLeprechaun · 04/11/2023 20:39

Seriously? We are reasonably well off, but not super wealthy, kids are privately educated. DD is friends with a rich classmate (multi-million house, 2 pools, holidays abroad every half term) and also with a couple of girls from her football team from the rather rough council estate down the road. They are kids, they do notice differences but it doesn't stop them being friends.

Bendysnap · 04/11/2023 20:37

Why are you being so narrow minded?

of course they can be friends. I’m delighted when ds befriends someone from the local comp at one of his extra curricular clubs. I don’t want him to think that everyone lives in massive detached houses.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 04/11/2023 20:36

why wouldn’t they be friends if they “click”?

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 04/11/2023 20:35

Honestly? I think it will be harder for the other boy. Being at a private school he is likely to live far away from his school friends so will only see them occasionally. Whereas your DS will live closer to his school friends and will see them more often.

That is really the only difference that matters.

Your house, if inviting, is more than sufficient.

supersonicginandtonic · 04/11/2023 20:34

My eldest daughter has 2 best friends, friend one lives in local authority housing, mum is a single parent to 3 children, works her ass off cleaning.
Friend twos parents live in a 7'bedroomed country home with pool, parents drive expensive cars.
They are the best of friends. I've recently been away with both mums and we're all really good friends too.

Sunsetmom · 04/11/2023 20:32

It’s sad that u think this way. It doesn’t matter what u have, let them be friends, in fact you should encourage it! Don’t push your insecurities and lack of self worth on to your son!

Ididivfama · 04/11/2023 20:28

You’re already judging this kid on the size of his parents house.

Torganer · 04/11/2023 20:28

This is really sad. Children can be friends no matter what their socio-economic status, sex, race, religion is.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/11/2023 20:25

I am from an average family and have a few rich friends (the school I went to) of course it can work well - if they really hit it off it could be great for your son and expand his social network and ambitions etc (not that yours aren't good enough but some social connections can be very useful in life)

saythatagaintome · 04/11/2023 20:23

OP, what’s this really about?

please don’t pass on your insecurities and doubts and lack of self worth to your poor boy.

NettleTea · 04/11/2023 20:19

My kid is like a previous poster's DD - at a private school on scholarship and bursary, and we live in a council property. We've just had a bunch of his mates here, crammed into his 6ft x 9ft bedroom playing games, then all off out after eating pizzas. They dont care. They are his friend, not his judge and jury

SpringingJoy · 04/11/2023 20:19

Our school is quite unusual I think. Semi rural, very high performing but with an absolutely massive catchment...which encompasses a very large council estate but extends all the way to the coast and also catches massive coastal mansions and farmhouses.

My dcs friends are a mix of both. They have friends in 8 bed country piles, friends in two up, two down council houses and everything in between. It's never caused any issues at all.

Countdowntowhat · 04/11/2023 20:18

Wow. Just wow. Would you stop your son being friends with someone who lives in a council house? Or if their parents were ill so lived on benefits? No? Then why assume this friendship can’t work just because this time you’re not the richer one in the friendship?

You and me could never be friends but hopefully your son will have a noce time with this boy who he clearly has loads in common with.

alchemisty · 04/11/2023 20:09

YABU, kids don't care at all. I'd watch out though for internalised snobbery from adults in his life that he may pass on to your son.

For context I went to an expensive primary and secondary school (I didn't really know it was expensive then) as someone from an average family, and 99% of my classmates were so fun and wonderful to be friends with. Different backgrounds weren't a factor at all.

However I also became close friends with this girl with a huge house and posh parents. She would say horribly snobby things, always put down my house and family, etc... Being an impressionable child, I really came to believe that my family and I were inferior. Now, looking back as an adult, I realise that so many of the nice normal kids who didn't ever mention status were a million times wealthier and posher than her! I don't blame her as I think she was just repeating what her parents were saying, but anyway watch out for that without being overly paranoid (and don't bring it up first around your son).

Chalkdowns · 04/11/2023 20:06

Oh my goodness this is so sad

Whattodo112222 · 04/11/2023 20:02

God, I'm a single parent in a two bedroom cottage. It's clean, cosy, and our home.. anyone who judged wouldn't be our friends.

My daughters mates love coming to our house!

Don't put your hang ups and insecurity on your kid.

RMNofTikTok · 04/11/2023 20:00

Bemyclementine · 04/11/2023 19:57

@RMNofTikTok the mum is lovely, I don't know the dad, but I do know they "came from nothing", I think he has done very well for himself. Conversely, I have done badly for myself. I love my house, and if it was up to standard it wouldn't bother me. But it's not, and I don't have the money to improve it. That's what bothers me. (Carpets need replacing, peeling wall paper, bare plaster etc)

Wealth is usually accumulated through luck of birth parents or luck of wealth opportunities. You shouldn't feel embarrassed. My friend is mega rich, and this afternoon he lobbed a pack of donuts at me and sat in my lounge scoffing a pot noodle 😂 he doesn't give a shit that I live in a 2 bedroom semi. And I'm sure your friends don't either 😁

Hooplahooping · 04/11/2023 20:00

l I’m sorry this is stressing you! My husband + my brother both went to boarding school - which means you live so far away from your friends in the holidays. Their ‘home friends’ who went to other schools or local schools were and are still SO important to them.

although this kid sound like his parents are the wealthier end of the spectrum - even at public school there are plenty of kids who have ‘normal’ houses because their parents spend all their money on school!

1000000% let your son do nice, screen free, outdoors adventuring with another local kid he enjoys spending time with.

78Summer · 04/11/2023 19:59

One of my best friends comes from old money and is wonderful. I would not do a voucher meal deal with her on an evening out as with most of my friends, but jokes aside I cherish every year of our friendship.