Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question rich child/average child friendship

134 replies

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 19:23

We are average.
Average careers.
Average income.
Smaller (much smaller ....meaning TINY) than average house.
DS aged 12 is a gorgeous boy. Bright. Funny. Intelligent. Lovely. Kind. Sociable. Active. Loves going out on his bike.
Goes to the local comp which hasn't got a great reputation.
He's been biking on his own a lot down this certain area through the countryside and keeps bumping in to another kid the same age who's also out on his bike in the same area.
Today they got talking.
Other kid lives in a gigantic double fronted detached listed building surrounded by lakes and land, and attends a public school an hour away.
We live 10 min drive away in a tiny weeny semi in a tiny close with a tiny back patio.
My DS and this kid seem to have a connection and want to swap numbers to meet up and go biking together.
Can it work???
If you send your DC to a public school and live in a country pad, would you be OK with them hanging out with a kid from the local comp who lives in a house so small it's cramped?!

OP posts:
Jeannie88 · 04/11/2023 23:24

Of course, hnless the parents are arseholes? Of it were the other way round and your house was a mansion to a new friend who lived in a poor area would it make any difference? Hopefully answer no, so just let them go ahead and don't feel intimidated, just humans with a bit more money on the surface 😉

TedMullins · 04/11/2023 23:23

Omfg get over yourself. YOU are making this an issue, not your son or the other boy. I grew up poor AF and now have friends who have kitchens bigger than my flat and massive house deposits from parents and second homes. It’s really not a big deal. If anything I get a sense of pride and achievement that they can’t feel, knowing I bought my tiny flat myself with no help or handouts.

YankeeDad · 04/11/2023 23:18

Provided that the other child, and their parents, understand that having more money does not make people better or more worthy of respect or admiration, I would have no concerns whatsoever about that.

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 23:14

Oh no, I cannot, just cannot do it.

I've seen the house because we've walked past and DS has said that's where he lives.
I've just checked it out online, looked at pics. It's opulent. Sheer, pure opulence.
Looking at the floorplan, their kitchen is much, much bigger than the entire footprint of the downstairs of our house!!! Just their kitchen! Then there's living rooms, lounges, a study, guestroom, music studio.....no, just no.
We can't even fit 2 people in to our kitchen at the same time. We don't have a hallway, front door goes straight in to the lounge.
Nope. Can't do this to DS. He is just going to feel completely and utterly inferior.

"Do you want to come round and play tennis in our court?"
"Umm, I cant play tennis. Parents can't afford tennis lessons."

"Are you around to go biking next week?"
"No, I'll be on a school trip to Switzerland."

"What are you doing in the summer holidays?"
"Going camping for a week. What are you doing?"
"Oh we'll be in the Maldives for 6 weeks".

Fast forward 5 years.
"I'm learning to drive. Parents are getting me a new SUV. You gonna learn to drive?"
"Might do. Don't know. Parents can't afford to buy me a car."

Anyone who thinks this is going to play out well is naive at best. Deluded at worst.

I actually met this kid on a walk through countryside with my DS. He stopped to chat to my DS. When he asked my DS where he goes to school, my DS told him the name of the local comp, and I saw this kid say "Oh, Bishopston school" and hang his head down, quickly looking at the ground, in response to where my DS goes to school. This to me showed the body language of someone who thought badly of the school, or whod heard bad things about it. It's 15 mins away from his house. Instead he travels an hour away to a private school.

Such a shame. My DS says he's a really nice boy and would love to be friends with him. But it's not worth making my DS feel rubbish for.

OP posts:
JustKen · 04/11/2023 23:11

We are average with average jobs and can just about afford a flat in a naice area of London. DD's friends all live in Mahoosive houses and their parents have "professional" middle-class jobs. It just the area we live in, the school catchment, which has Big Nice Roads and more ordinary housing mixed together. I'm not bothered, except DD has escaped adopting a London accent, which I find weird. Her dad's a Cockney, her schooling was State, and we have Olivia Colman living in the flat.

Coffeeandanap · 04/11/2023 23:05

Of course it can work, kids often don’t see the differences the way we do. For example, I’m not rich but my daughter mixes with children that come from well off families. One child came for a sleepover & thought the electric blanket on the bed was ‘fancy’ genuinely fancy & not realising it’s because I’m trying to cut down on having the central heating on 😄. Kids are great, encourage their bond & just observe. I’ve met some of the rich parents and they’ve been lovely too, it doesn’t always have to be a ‘thing’.

Tulipblank · 04/11/2023 23:00

@MiddleParking Grin can't believe no one did it earlier.

I actually thought this was one of those stupid pretend threads....but seems not. Although op hasn't updated. Maybe they'll be a big drip feed where the OP says how much she loves dancing.

Fionaville · 04/11/2023 22:54

It's really not the issue you think it is. We are the 'better off' family in this scenario. My kids have friends who are richer and friends from a bit of a rough estate. We regard them all the same, as do my kids. My kids don't even realise to be honest. The 11 year old came home from a sleepover at her friends (who lives in a really small council house) saying how brilliant it was because they've got a wetroom and a telly in the kitchen!
If parents are nice, the kids are usually nice. The only kids I know who've ever been 'competitive' or braggy, have parents who are the same.

buckeejit · 04/11/2023 22:53

Crikey op, catch a grip. My friends were from breadline to very wealthy. I was closer to breadline with caretaker dad & pt cook mum. Nobody cared. We took the piss out of our rich friends a bit & enjoyed the rare perks that came with them.

Day to day it usually makes no difference to friends how wealthy their parents are. Let them Enjoy themselves & welcome his new friend. Try not to think you're somehow inferior because you don't have as much money 💐

MiddleParking · 04/11/2023 22:44

Tulipblank · 04/11/2023 21:09

Are you Liverpool based, with a cracking singing voice? If so, I'd keep them apart....won't end well.

Otherwise, let them crack on.

Fuck sake I was checking to make sure no one had done this joke before posting it and got nearly to the end of the thread before it appeared. Day ruined.

tunainatin · 04/11/2023 22:37

Children see things in a really different way to adults. I grew up in a house like that and had friends with much smaller houses, which I thought were lovely!

LilQueenie · 04/11/2023 22:34

why shouldn't it work. They don't judge each other so why should you? Don't let your attitude spoil a friendship. they are kids.

onetwothreeee · 04/11/2023 22:25

of course they can be friends

My children go to independant school, live in a large house, and are good friends with so many children who go to state schools and live in smaller houses than ours.

I couldnt care less which school / what type of home their friends live in, and i'd be mortified if anyone thought their children were not worthy to be friends with mine because of the school I send them to and home they live in.

Let them exchange numbers, be friends and hang out together.

(I went to state school myself so no judgement at all about which school people send their children to, and a grew up in a house much smaller than the home I live in now)

TotalOverhaul · 04/11/2023 22:10

Yes it can work. In DC's friendship group one family owns several houses and a yacht. A proper millionaire-style yacht not a boat with a sail. And another family owns two castles. We live in a pretty shabby house and have very little money, some of the friendship group are on a par with us - not that wealthy and the rest are richer. None of them care. What they care about is making each other laugh and supporting each other when they have a tough time or celebrating successes. They are lovely boys and have been friends since they were about 12.

DeeCeeCherry · 04/11/2023 22:05

Stop with the working class reverse snobbery. They are children. Be careful you dont cause your son to feel inferior/'not as good as'.

BottleShipDown · 04/11/2023 21:59

I have multi-millionaire friends, aristocrat friends, friends who have to count every penny and everything inbetween. We are average salary and house. My friends are my friends because they are kind, funny, interesting and we have lots in common. The only issue is being careful about what we do. Not picking costly activities and meet-ups for my friends with less and suggesting cheaper options to the friends that splash the cash.

lostonmars · 04/11/2023 21:56

What's the problem?

Forgotmylogindetails · 04/11/2023 21:55

I’ve been well off …

I am currently skint.

my friends are still the same people.

whowhy · 04/11/2023 21:44

The things OPs post on here.

GoodlifeGlow · 04/11/2023 21:44

We live in the “ big “ house in our village (that’s what it’s called locally) if we required all our friends/daughters friends to have houses of a similar size we would have precisely zero friends. Houses mean nothing it’s the people inside that count, it’s fantastic they both get on let them get on with it!

Winter42 · 04/11/2023 21:34

We live in a bog standard semi in a not very glamorous area. My son goes to a bog standard state school.

However, he plays cricket and a lot of his teammates are much better off. His best friend from cricket is particularly wealthy. Goes to a very exclusive boarding school. It is not an issue at all. They are boys with a shared interest who get on well.

Tulipblank · 04/11/2023 21:09

Are you Liverpool based, with a cracking singing voice? If so, I'd keep them apart....won't end well.

Otherwise, let them crack on.

Girlattheback · 04/11/2023 21:06

Agree with the PPs who’ve said that kids who go to private/boarding schools often don’t have local friends. I remember the school holidays being long and lonely because all my school friends were so scattered. I would imagine the other child’s family will be over the moon that their son has a local friend to hang out with. Please encourage your son to swap numbers with the other boy, sounds like they’ve clicked and will have a great time together.

MumblesParty · 04/11/2023 21:06

DigitalGoat · 04/11/2023 19:43

Going against the grain here but I know what you mean OP. We live in the smallest house on a housing estate and all DCs friends tended to be better off than us and used to having bigger gardens, less cramped homes etc. I remember one of them (probably aged 9 or so) looking around and observing "You're quite poor, aren't you?".

He's now 21 and still friends with DS and I laugh about it these days, but I can't deny it stung at the time.

Yes but your child is living proof that it can work!

edwinbear · 04/11/2023 21:05

DC are both at private school, they have loads of friends from all sorts of backgrounds that they’ve made through out of school clubs. I think that’s completely normal isn’t it?