Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question rich child/average child friendship

134 replies

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 19:23

We are average.
Average careers.
Average income.
Smaller (much smaller ....meaning TINY) than average house.
DS aged 12 is a gorgeous boy. Bright. Funny. Intelligent. Lovely. Kind. Sociable. Active. Loves going out on his bike.
Goes to the local comp which hasn't got a great reputation.
He's been biking on his own a lot down this certain area through the countryside and keeps bumping in to another kid the same age who's also out on his bike in the same area.
Today they got talking.
Other kid lives in a gigantic double fronted detached listed building surrounded by lakes and land, and attends a public school an hour away.
We live 10 min drive away in a tiny weeny semi in a tiny close with a tiny back patio.
My DS and this kid seem to have a connection and want to swap numbers to meet up and go biking together.
Can it work???
If you send your DC to a public school and live in a country pad, would you be OK with them hanging out with a kid from the local comp who lives in a house so small it's cramped?!

OP posts:
Avacadoandtoast · 05/11/2023 06:05

This post is ridiculous - we all can afford / prioritise different things in life, but having a commonality or hobby (like biking) is what makes true friendships. Please don’t give your boy insecurities like this - I promise you he will be happier without them!

healthadvice123 · 05/11/2023 06:00

My da has a good friend who lives in a similar sounding size house we live in a 3 bed terraced HA house. They know each other through a team sport and despite not being in same team for 4 years , still keep in touch and spent time at each others houses. If you get on , you get on

Maddy70 · 05/11/2023 05:33

Are you serious? Wow.

Let your child be friends with who he wants to and don't let your prejudices be known to him

MiddleParking · 05/11/2023 05:28

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 23:14

Oh no, I cannot, just cannot do it.

I've seen the house because we've walked past and DS has said that's where he lives.
I've just checked it out online, looked at pics. It's opulent. Sheer, pure opulence.
Looking at the floorplan, their kitchen is much, much bigger than the entire footprint of the downstairs of our house!!! Just their kitchen! Then there's living rooms, lounges, a study, guestroom, music studio.....no, just no.
We can't even fit 2 people in to our kitchen at the same time. We don't have a hallway, front door goes straight in to the lounge.
Nope. Can't do this to DS. He is just going to feel completely and utterly inferior.

"Do you want to come round and play tennis in our court?"
"Umm, I cant play tennis. Parents can't afford tennis lessons."

"Are you around to go biking next week?"
"No, I'll be on a school trip to Switzerland."

"What are you doing in the summer holidays?"
"Going camping for a week. What are you doing?"
"Oh we'll be in the Maldives for 6 weeks".

Fast forward 5 years.
"I'm learning to drive. Parents are getting me a new SUV. You gonna learn to drive?"
"Might do. Don't know. Parents can't afford to buy me a car."

Anyone who thinks this is going to play out well is naive at best. Deluded at worst.

I actually met this kid on a walk through countryside with my DS. He stopped to chat to my DS. When he asked my DS where he goes to school, my DS told him the name of the local comp, and I saw this kid say "Oh, Bishopston school" and hang his head down, quickly looking at the ground, in response to where my DS goes to school. This to me showed the body language of someone who thought badly of the school, or whod heard bad things about it. It's 15 mins away from his house. Instead he travels an hour away to a private school.

Such a shame. My DS says he's a really nice boy and would love to be friends with him. But it's not worth making my DS feel rubbish for.

Edited

Are you pissed?

RantyAnty · 05/11/2023 05:01

How would you feel if your DS ended up being wealthy like that?

Inyourwildestdreams · 05/11/2023 04:27

Your updates make things even worse @FireworksAreFantastic 🙄

Out of interest, would you allow him to be friends with someone who you thought was in a worse position than yourself?

Just let them be kids. If your son comes questioning your housing and financial situation then you use it as a teaching opportunity.

Auntiedear · 05/11/2023 00:47

I certainly don't think you should stop a friendship forming and you should trust your son to decide who he does and doesn't want to be friends with.

However, I disagree with previous posters who say that money wont have any impact. Of course there will be a difference and it will potentially play a role in the shape of the friendship - being able to afford the same activities, having the same frame of reference etc.

But this could also well be a valuable learning for your son, including how to navigate friendships where there is a difference in income - because let's face it, there is always someone who will have more money!

FireworksAreFantastic · 05/11/2023 00:39

Agapornis · 05/11/2023 00:35

This is about you and your lack of confidence. Stop projecting. You telling him he can't be friends with the people he chooses is going to have more impact than comparing hypothetical holidays. He's 12, not 5.

They both love biking, so I doubt this other boy enjoys a 'lie on the beach for 6 weeks and do nothing' holiday. Also... have you seen him go in and out of this house? Kids do make stuff up :)

DS has seen him go in and out of house. Also said bye to each other then see his parents come out of house and get in to range rover with them and drive off.
Another time we walked past, saw dog in grounds, DS said oh that's his dog, he's cute, I stroked him.
It's his house.

OP posts:
Agapornis · 05/11/2023 00:35

This is about you and your lack of confidence. Stop projecting. You telling him he can't be friends with the people he chooses is going to have more impact than comparing hypothetical holidays. He's 12, not 5.

They both love biking, so I doubt this other boy enjoys a 'lie on the beach for 6 weeks and do nothing' holiday. Also... have you seen him go in and out of this house? Kids do make stuff up :)

CoQ10 · 05/11/2023 00:26

OP, it sounds like you are making decisions about your childs friendships, which are frankly not yours to make.

Step back and allow them to play and decide for themselves like we all had to.

dancingdaisies · 05/11/2023 00:17

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the request of the poster.

Showmethemoneyyy · 05/11/2023 00:15

My God OP, sort yourself out, this is absolute madness. It’s you, and only you, with the problem here. Get a grip.

joan12 · 05/11/2023 00:14

Oh come on! My dss have friends much richer financially than we are but honestly, I know that we have to offer are things their kids truly value that they don't get at home

sense of perspective, groundedness, our values, feeling listened to

Kids all at pricey selective private school

Best party ever?

When they were invited to camp out at the allotment of a boy who was on 100% bursary

You have lost sight of what is good, grounded and important!

feelingalittlehorse · 05/11/2023 00:14

Also, throughout your son’s life he is going to meet people 100x wealthier than him, and people 100x worse off. That’s part of the rich (pardon the pun) tapestry of life. Restricting his social circles will do him no favours.

ditalini · 04/11/2023 23:58

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 23:14

Oh no, I cannot, just cannot do it.

I've seen the house because we've walked past and DS has said that's where he lives.
I've just checked it out online, looked at pics. It's opulent. Sheer, pure opulence.
Looking at the floorplan, their kitchen is much, much bigger than the entire footprint of the downstairs of our house!!! Just their kitchen! Then there's living rooms, lounges, a study, guestroom, music studio.....no, just no.
We can't even fit 2 people in to our kitchen at the same time. We don't have a hallway, front door goes straight in to the lounge.
Nope. Can't do this to DS. He is just going to feel completely and utterly inferior.

"Do you want to come round and play tennis in our court?"
"Umm, I cant play tennis. Parents can't afford tennis lessons."

"Are you around to go biking next week?"
"No, I'll be on a school trip to Switzerland."

"What are you doing in the summer holidays?"
"Going camping for a week. What are you doing?"
"Oh we'll be in the Maldives for 6 weeks".

Fast forward 5 years.
"I'm learning to drive. Parents are getting me a new SUV. You gonna learn to drive?"
"Might do. Don't know. Parents can't afford to buy me a car."

Anyone who thinks this is going to play out well is naive at best. Deluded at worst.

I actually met this kid on a walk through countryside with my DS. He stopped to chat to my DS. When he asked my DS where he goes to school, my DS told him the name of the local comp, and I saw this kid say "Oh, Bishopston school" and hang his head down, quickly looking at the ground, in response to where my DS goes to school. This to me showed the body language of someone who thought badly of the school, or whod heard bad things about it. It's 15 mins away from his house. Instead he travels an hour away to a private school.

Such a shame. My DS says he's a really nice boy and would love to be friends with him. But it's not worth making my DS feel rubbish for.

Edited

Your scenarios are absolutely bonkers and based on nothing but your own inverted snobbery.

WinteryWonderland · 04/11/2023 23:58

Wealth doesn't make a person worthy of anything more than a poor person.
He can be friends with anyone in life he feels a connection with, regardless of Wealth, Ethnicity, etc etc we are all just people.

feelingalittlehorse · 04/11/2023 23:55

Hi OP, I got a bursary and a scholarship to a private school in a very wealthy area, and therefore my single parent family on an average income was the exception, not the norm.

All my friends from school were markedly wealthier, but it never really mattered. On occasion, I was sad that I didn’t get to go on the big holidays/ got the newest trends etc etc but it was few and far between. Had much more teenage angst stuff to worry about….
I’m still extremely good friends with people from school, and how much their parents earned/ the money divide has never once had any impact on our friendships.

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 23:43

It's not a wind up.

OP posts:
Lysianthus · 04/11/2023 23:41

With the kindest of motives....OP you are projecting !
My best friend has a mansion, I'm I rented.

I'm not going to lie, there are times when I have to rein in my potential green eyed monster.

But all in all, and I am clearly great at the reining in shit, it works brilliantly.

She'd be horrified if she could only be friends with rich people.... think about it, OP. Very very limiting, isn't it.

Just be happy that your child and the other child are happy to be friends for all the Right Reasons. None of which include money.

lostonmars · 04/11/2023 23:39

This has to be a wind up. It makes YOU feel inferior, not your son. Stop projecting your insecurities onto him.

threecupsofteaminimum · 04/11/2023 23:38

Nope. Can't do this to DS. He is just going to feel completely and utterly inferior.
*
*
No, only YOU are making him feel inferior. This is really fucking annoying to read. I'll tell you something..

I grew up on a council estate. Single parent family. I loved horses and ended up getting lessons in exchange for working at a local stables, aged between 10 - 14, mucking out, cleaning tack that type of stuff.

I ended up being in demand, riding other peoples horses for them as I was so good at it. I won lots at of gymkhanas and local showjumping competitions.

Most of the kids who I rode with were much richer than me. No one cared, no one judged, no snotty parents, it was about shared interest and love of the ponies and horses.

You really need to check yourself. I'm really appalled at your attitude OP.

Albioncreed · 04/11/2023 23:33

DigitalGoat · 04/11/2023 19:43

Going against the grain here but I know what you mean OP. We live in the smallest house on a housing estate and all DCs friends tended to be better off than us and used to having bigger gardens, less cramped homes etc. I remember one of them (probably aged 9 or so) looking around and observing "You're quite poor, aren't you?".

He's now 21 and still friends with DS and I laugh about it these days, but I can't deny it stung at the time.

Kids can be a bit blunt. A few of my friends kids have asked why we have such a small television. My friends are mortified. But I find it hilarious

threecupsofteaminimum · 04/11/2023 23:31

Why on earth not!?

XelaM · 04/11/2023 23:30

My daughter competes in show jumping 🐎 Almost all her friends are kids of multi-millionaires who live in gorgeous houses/actual mansions. I'm a single mother and we live in a ground floor maisonette flat with a small garden. We're not poor, but not even close to the wealth of some of her friends. It doesn't stop her from being very popular and hanging out with them (at their places 😂).

Thisilldo · 04/11/2023 23:29

The only person being judgemental is you. The connections your son could make through this friend could set him up for bigger things later in life.

Dont drag your child down because you think so little of yourself