Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question rich child/average child friendship

134 replies

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 19:23

We are average.
Average careers.
Average income.
Smaller (much smaller ....meaning TINY) than average house.
DS aged 12 is a gorgeous boy. Bright. Funny. Intelligent. Lovely. Kind. Sociable. Active. Loves going out on his bike.
Goes to the local comp which hasn't got a great reputation.
He's been biking on his own a lot down this certain area through the countryside and keeps bumping in to another kid the same age who's also out on his bike in the same area.
Today they got talking.
Other kid lives in a gigantic double fronted detached listed building surrounded by lakes and land, and attends a public school an hour away.
We live 10 min drive away in a tiny weeny semi in a tiny close with a tiny back patio.
My DS and this kid seem to have a connection and want to swap numbers to meet up and go biking together.
Can it work???
If you send your DC to a public school and live in a country pad, would you be OK with them hanging out with a kid from the local comp who lives in a house so small it's cramped?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notlucreziaborgia · 05/11/2023 18:31

You’re hiding behind ‘protecting’ your son as an excuse (protecting him from what? People who are, by the sounds of it, perfectly decent?), but I’m not sure who you’re trying to kid tbh, us or yourself.

It isn’t about your son being exposed to people that have more, it’s about your own discomfort in proximity to wealth.

Vitriolinsanity · 05/11/2023 18:04

The utter beauty of kids is they just don't care about this shit.

They meet, they click, they hang out.

My child goes to a private school, when asked about his friends all he can tell you is whether they're good guys to hang with.

In return, because he started there in Y7, I have no idea whatsoever about the parents. They do seem to have raised really smashing kids though, so who cares about their house?

RantyAnty · 05/11/2023 17:07

AmiablePedant · 05/11/2023 13:11

It makes me sad to see, given the OP's entrenched attitudes, that the most vicious snobbery in the UK is still the "inverted" variety.

Indeed it is. They truly hold their children back with this crab in a bucket shit.

I've found that inverted snobbery the worst. They look down on those better off far far more than any better off person looks down on them.

My mum was like that, always jealous and critical of anyone who had more. She had very very low expectations of her children.

She hated that I went to university and became a success.

Allcalm · 05/11/2023 14:03

Just let the friendship playout naturally, either it will work or it won't. I live in a beautiful area of the UK, home to the extremely wealthy, hanging about on their yaughts at weekends and also home to some of the worst poverty in the UK. Kids mix, many of the wealthy ones travel quite far to school or board Mon-Friday so they're very keen on making local friends and their parents aren't snobby about it.

AmiablePedant · 05/11/2023 13:11

It makes me sad to see, given the OP's entrenched attitudes, that the most vicious snobbery in the UK is still the "inverted" variety.

funinthesun19 · 05/11/2023 13:07

One of my DS’s good friends lives in a very affluent leafy area. Lovely big house.

We live in a tiny 2 bed council house.

Their lives are inevitably like chalk and cheese.

But they get on so well and have a really good friendship which I would never discourage. I’m glad his parents aren’t the type to discourage it either, even with us being lower in class to them. I do get admittedly get very embarrassed when his friend comes to our house and the house is a bit chaotic/ds doesn’t have his own room. And when I take them out to bowling or something and we have to get 2 buses/ get a taxi rather than me driving them around everywhere. I do wonder what his parents must think sometimes.

In contrast, when his best best friend comes here who is in the same boat as my ds, he’s basically coming from home to home and things are much more laid back. He doesn’t care about waiting for a bus and the concept of sharing a bedroom is nothing new to him. He’s also from a big family and has lots of siblings like my ds, so loads of kids being around is again just normal.

MiddleParking · 05/11/2023 12:38

SmokeyToo · 05/11/2023 08:41

@MiddleParking Lol! Ok, then. I'm glad someone out there knows my life better than I know myself. You plonker!

Well, anyone who knows what the words ‘lifetime’ and ‘upper class’ mean would know that. It’s good to challenge and not perpetuate the idea that private school attendance, or generational wealth in general, is linked to hard work or sacrifice from parents.

LydiaTomos · 05/11/2023 10:38

My son is in a very similar situation. He also rides his bike a lot but with his friends. During summer holidays, they met a boy who goes to a boarding school who was on his bike on his own.

They befriended him and arranged to see him again because they felt sorry for him because he doesn't have any local friends. They definitely measure wealth in a different way to yours.

TotalOverhaul · 05/11/2023 10:17

FireworksAreFantastic · 04/11/2023 23:14

Oh no, I cannot, just cannot do it.

I've seen the house because we've walked past and DS has said that's where he lives.
I've just checked it out online, looked at pics. It's opulent. Sheer, pure opulence.
Looking at the floorplan, their kitchen is much, much bigger than the entire footprint of the downstairs of our house!!! Just their kitchen! Then there's living rooms, lounges, a study, guestroom, music studio.....no, just no.
We can't even fit 2 people in to our kitchen at the same time. We don't have a hallway, front door goes straight in to the lounge.
Nope. Can't do this to DS. He is just going to feel completely and utterly inferior.

"Do you want to come round and play tennis in our court?"
"Umm, I cant play tennis. Parents can't afford tennis lessons."

"Are you around to go biking next week?"
"No, I'll be on a school trip to Switzerland."

"What are you doing in the summer holidays?"
"Going camping for a week. What are you doing?"
"Oh we'll be in the Maldives for 6 weeks".

Fast forward 5 years.
"I'm learning to drive. Parents are getting me a new SUV. You gonna learn to drive?"
"Might do. Don't know. Parents can't afford to buy me a car."

Anyone who thinks this is going to play out well is naive at best. Deluded at worst.

I actually met this kid on a walk through countryside with my DS. He stopped to chat to my DS. When he asked my DS where he goes to school, my DS told him the name of the local comp, and I saw this kid say "Oh, Bishopston school" and hang his head down, quickly looking at the ground, in response to where my DS goes to school. This to me showed the body language of someone who thought badly of the school, or whod heard bad things about it. It's 15 mins away from his house. Instead he travels an hour away to a private school.

Such a shame. My DS says he's a really nice boy and would love to be friends with him. But it's not worth making my DS feel rubbish for.

Edited

Your response suggests you are ashamed of how you live. You don't need to be. If you took a positive slant on it, you might think: my son can teach this boy that perfectly decent, lovely, intelligent pupils exist in state schools. And maybe this boy's home life can teach my son that if he wants material goods, he needs to focus on a high earning career. But he might learn something else. The rich boy might learn that you don't need immense wealth to have a happy, cosy, secure home life. It might let him off the hook from having to pursue a high earning career. He might think: I can do what I really want to do and scale down. Unlikely, but you just don't know.

In my DC's friendship group the richest boy also happened to be one of the nicest. Really thoughtful and sensitive. Lovely parents who welcomed anyone. No snobbery. Lots of generosity. But... they were always at work. This boy liked coming to our house because we were around, making pizzas with them, not ordering them in, asking all about his news, his plans etc. The friendship group loved hanging at the rich house and the poorer house.

I'm off this month to a reunion of my teenage friendship group. It was a big crowd who got together through a shared hobby. In our group there were lots of private school teens, lots of state school teens, a couple from boarding school, some SEN and autistic teens, some in care, some from deeply dysfunctional families, some who lived alone from age 16. We just loved each other. No one was ever excluded. I see a bit of that mood in my sons' friendship group. it is possible.

cocksstrideintheevening · 05/11/2023 09:57

You're being ridiculous op.

SmokeyToo · 05/11/2023 09:54

@YankeeDad and @alchemisty Thanks for the explanation. I probably should have said I'm not in the UK, for starters. But both my parents really were born to 'working class' families and did work very hard and invest wisely during their working life to become extremely wealthy. And they did sacrifice a lot to send us to top private schools along the way. No need to elaborate further, as the whole thing means jack shit anyway.

Frankly, I couldn't give a shit about what 'class' I belong to. Or what class anyone belongs to, for that matter. It's not really a thing where I live, to a large extent. Besides, I was raised never to judge a book by its cover and what people have or don't have materially means nothing to me. It's the calibre of the person that matters.

I just wanted the OP to think about denying her child a friendship and, possibly, connections that may be of benefit to him later down the track.

Leah5678 · 05/11/2023 09:50

Lol get over yourself and let your son play with his friend. You're average and live in a house when I was a kid I was below average in a shit flat and I still had a rich friend. Who even cares

alchemisty · 05/11/2023 09:43

@SmokeyToo yeah I wanted to explain that you can't be upper class if you weren't born upper class, and name some working class billionaires as examples... btw referencing PP above, Kate Middleton is still widely known as upper middle class despite being born into millions of family wealth, an elite education and a family background with hundreds of years of aristocratic ties (not blood though)... But the whole thing is rather stupid really

YankeeDad · 05/11/2023 09:37

@SmokeyToo I think that @MiddleParking is just being pedantic.

If your background is not upper class, then in the UK I think it is kind of true that you are not upper-upper class, because you generally have to be born into money, preferably several generations of it (unless you marry into the Royal Family which seems to be the only shortcut!), in order to be considered truly upper class.

And unless your parents are both died as soon as your private school was paid for, it was not literally a “lifetime” of hard work and sacrifice.

But I think anyone who read you without a pedantic mindset will have understood, and probably agreed with, the essence of what you wrote. I, for one, certainly understood and agree!

Congratulations on having made your way. It can be more difficult to navigate life as a “class traveller” but if you are kind, empathetic, and of good character, while also keeping a healthy unwillingness to tolerate too much bullshit, it helps a lot!

YankeeDad · 05/11/2023 09:28

@FireworksAreFantastic we have more than enough money and live in a big house, and most of our friends happen to have a lot less money than we do. Maybe that is partly because we are not part of the jet set, nor do we want to be.

We choose them as friends because they are amazing people who also have time for us. We aren’t thinking about house sizes when we get invited over to theirs, and we hope they aren’t either.

I agree with PPs who say it’s a real pity if your son cannot be friends with their son because they have more money than you, and because that makes you feel inferior to them in some way.. Money is not a yardstick of human worth, even though our language has been corrupted to imply that (eg “what is he worth?”) Maybe their kid, just like every other kid, wants a friend who is nice to him and has time for him

sep135 · 05/11/2023 08:47

Your parents are not upper class nor did they send you and your brother to private school through ‘a lifetime’ of hard work and sacrifice.

There's really no need.

SmokeyToo · 05/11/2023 08:41

@MiddleParking Lol! Ok, then. I'm glad someone out there knows my life better than I know myself. You plonker!

MiddleParking · 05/11/2023 08:28

SmokeyToo · 05/11/2023 07:20

I'm sad to think your son may miss out on a great friendship because you have a chip on your shoulder.

My parents were working class, but they built themselves up through a lifetime of hard work and ended up 'upper class', for want of a better phrase. They sacrificed a hell of a lot to send my brother and I to private schools (which, I think is the UK version of public school) and I mixed with dozens of kids from extremely wealthy families. Kids that would get a BMW or Porsche for their 16th birthday etc. I had loads of friends from families who were multi millionaires or billionaires. It never really bothered me that my parents couldn't afford to give us what my friends had. Friendship is based on much, much more than 'who has what'.

One thing about having wealthy friends/connections is that it does open doors later in life. Don't deny your son that opportunity.

Most importantly, don't teach your son to be down on himself just because you guys don't have money. That's your hang up, not his. There are far more important things in life than money! Good character, empathy and kindness are much more important.

Your parents are not upper class nor did they send you and your brother to private school through ‘a lifetime’ of hard work and sacrifice.

NeedToChangeName · 05/11/2023 07:35

OP, I think you are getting a hard time on here. I can understand your concerns

But, I think children are generally less aware of money / status than adults, so it would be a pity to write off a potential friendship

SmokeyToo · 05/11/2023 07:20

I'm sad to think your son may miss out on a great friendship because you have a chip on your shoulder.

My parents were working class, but they built themselves up through a lifetime of hard work and ended up 'upper class', for want of a better phrase. They sacrificed a hell of a lot to send my brother and I to private schools (which, I think is the UK version of public school) and I mixed with dozens of kids from extremely wealthy families. Kids that would get a BMW or Porsche for their 16th birthday etc. I had loads of friends from families who were multi millionaires or billionaires. It never really bothered me that my parents couldn't afford to give us what my friends had. Friendship is based on much, much more than 'who has what'.

One thing about having wealthy friends/connections is that it does open doors later in life. Don't deny your son that opportunity.

Most importantly, don't teach your son to be down on himself just because you guys don't have money. That's your hang up, not his. There are far more important things in life than money! Good character, empathy and kindness are much more important.

TheresaOfAvila · 05/11/2023 07:02

Caggers · 04/11/2023 19:25

Please don’t let your hang-ups impact your son’s ability to make friends.

Yes this.

AgentProvocateur · 05/11/2023 07:01

The massive chip on your shoulder is disadvantaging your son. Why would you do that to him?

alchemisty · 05/11/2023 06:59

Nah, it's a wind up

ohfook · 05/11/2023 06:33

The best thing in the world for both children and adults is to mix with people with different experiences, upbringings and viewpoints to them. I think this will be a good thing for both boys.

healthadvice123 · 05/11/2023 06:05

Also yes my Ds was impressed by the big house etc but he knows the vast majority don’t live like that, but as the other boy and his family are just very nice people they also know they are lucky and not how most live and also are the sort of family who accept people for who they are , not where they live , how big a car they drive. Ds friend now at 18 drives an expensive car , DS drives a cheap little banger , but both go from a to b ,one thing I like about DS playing in a team sport was it was nice him having friends from all walks of lives as its a big world out there