Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my family to interact with my children.

33 replies

Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 16:41

I live 4 hours from my family and generally see them 5 times a year at either their or my house. I have 3 children 6 months , 2 and 5.

I feel my parents my brother (40) do not engage with my children.

My parents complain they don’t see the children but when they are in the company of my children after the initial hello and cuddle they mainly just chat to me or sit on their phones. They are happy to hold the baby or push a pram but that’s about as much as they will do. Also, sometimes I want help with the older children yet they seem to just want to see the baby.

I was feeding the baby so left older 2 ( aged 2 and 5) with my family. All I could hear was my sons being told off. I walked down into the room everyone was sat on their phone’s ignoring the children.

We went to the park -
My parents decided to go for a walk for hours so I was left with my children alone . They could walk any time ? why not play with the children ?

My dad often sits in the chair and tells my son aged 2 - don’t touch x , y or z. They don’t see he is just 2. They don’t bother to play a game with him.

I have very rarely seen my parents play with the children , read to them or offer to take them to the park/ pool etc. Yet they complain they don’t see the children as I live away.

By comparison- my inlaws and SIL fully engage with my children . They talk to them and play with them. They ask to take the children out and fully enjoy this . They build Lego / line up cars and offer me such support .

e.g- we will take John and Kate for a walk so you can have a few hours with the baby.

You are tired- let me make you some lunch while you feed the baby.

SIL always mKss games for all the cousins to play.

DH says this is what my family should do.

AIBU to expect more from my parents .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Iheartpizza · 04/11/2023 20:27

My in-laws were the same. A big song and dance about not seeing us enough (live hours away) and then when we did, they just wanted to sit and chat to us, read the paper or go on their iPads.

No help whatsoever, no attempt to play or interact with their grandchild! On one memorable occasion, our child said 'Nanny will you please come and play a game with me'? And she promptly told him to go and play by himself!

Said child is older now and not arsed any more. Their loss I guess!

CowCatsRule · 04/11/2023 19:54

I don’t think YABU and the vote agrees so don’t feel bad. I sincerely hope if I become a grandparent I will be like your inlaws. Having said this I doubt your family will change so you will just have to take it on the chin. You are lucky to have such helpful, involved and supportive in laws.

Ibravedaflood · 04/11/2023 19:41

Imo them often asking after your dc is just a box ticking excersie...

UsingChangeofName · 04/11/2023 19:30

I have to say - your dh strikes me as rather unpleasant op

Why ? Confused
Because he is saying that his parents and sister aren't in any way 'out of the ordinary' and that they are just acting like natural Grandparents and Aunties tend to do ?

I think your dh is right, to some extent.
I don't agree with all the threads on here where people "expect" the child's grandparents to have their dc overnight / for weekends / for childcare when they are at work. Yes, we do have less energy as a rule as we get older but if your grandchildren are visiting for a long weekend, and you know they are only there for that time, I would expect them to interact.
Yes, some people find that comes more naturally than others (in the same way some people find small talk easy and others don't), but if my dd were staying with 3 young dc, I would be asking what I could do to help her, even if it didn't come naturally.

YANBU OP.
I actually think traveling 4 hrs each way to see them with 3 small dc is challenging enough. If they are neither willing to help you because you are their dd and they want to make your life a bit easier for a couple of days, nor are they wanting to engage with the dc, then I think I'd scale back the visits a bit.

Fizzadora · 04/11/2023 18:15

Oh I couldn't be arsed with all this. Your parents are shocking to be honest and quite clearly couldn't give much of a shit about you when you were a child and obviously aren't going to bother with their grandchildren either.
Your DH is right. They are just selfish and can't be bothered.
That's people though. Everyone's different and you can't change them even if you put loads of effort into trying. It just becomes forced and unnatural and who wants that for themselves or their children.
Me and DH are pretty hands on for our granddaughter but her other grandparents, not so much. My DIL takes what she's offered, although it's often withdrawn or conditional, but is philosophical about it and thankful that she can rely on us.
My DH thinks less of the other grandparents for this. (I sort of do too but try not to).
I would reduce the visits and if they complain that they don't see enough of the children then have a full and frank discussion about their lack of interaction if you can. If not just make excuses til they get the message.

KVick · 04/11/2023 18:08

I have to agree with Op’s parents' stance “children having power…" My parents provided me, my twin and my older sister a really idyllic childhood, but we were never under the illusion that we kids were in charge! I think the parents are supposed to be running the show!
And I also think they’re right about taking kids to (full-service) restaurants being a waste of money! Restaurants are a treat to adults. Most kids would be happier if you ordered a pizza and let watch some animated movie for the hundredth time or play video games. Having to sit for an hour (or more!) in a restaurant moving the same chicken finger around their plate, watching the adults get drunk is essentially torture for a kid.

I think the crux of the issue is that things that interest children bore the hell out of adults and visa versa. Some adults are better at feigning interest than others.

TheWelshposter · 04/11/2023 17:44

My family are exactly the same. After a few words asking "how is school, what are you doing?" they don't really bother with the kids, and certainly no day trips or babysitting. I get pangs of envy when I see other families on day trips/at the pantomime etc with grandparents and aunties....but I'm used to it now.

I really notice it in comparison my in laws, who would be on the ground playing with the kids, singing songs and making buns.

Anyway, you're definitely not alone OP!

Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 17:38

QWERTYoutside · 04/11/2023 17:28

I think yabu and I think your dh is not being supportive, but a shit stirrer. All family dynamics are different, everyone loves in their own way. If you needed your parents would they help you? That’s what would matter to me.

If I needed them they would be there . You are right - everyone loves in their own way. I’m feeling awful now

OP posts:
Flipdiddle · 04/11/2023 17:34

I have to say - your dh strikes me as rather unpleasant op

QWERTYoutside · 04/11/2023 17:28

I think yabu and I think your dh is not being supportive, but a shit stirrer. All family dynamics are different, everyone loves in their own way. If you needed your parents would they help you? That’s what would matter to me.

Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 17:20

Flipdiddle · 04/11/2023 17:12

Op is this your dad plus partner or your mum plus partner?

and what is the other one like??

Hi
this is my mum and partner but my step dad has been in my life since I have been 5 and i class him as My dad. I have met my biological dad now I’m an adult but had no contact as a child.

OP posts:
Flipdiddle · 04/11/2023 17:12

Op is this your dad plus partner or your mum plus partner?

and what is the other one like??

Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 17:11

I guess my parents are visiting to see me not just the grandchildren and if they don’t seem the often they don’t have a natural bond with them so it is unfair to expect them to just crack on and play with them ( especially if I don’t give direction.)

I am feeling abit guilty now !!!

OP posts:
Lizzieregina · 04/11/2023 17:10

I do think this could be generational. My parents were definitely more as long as you’re clean, fed and not bleeding profusely, you’re alright! They never played with us as kids or read stories or anything. They also wouldn’t have done that with my kids.

I also think a lot of people aren’t much interested in playing with little kids.

I would read or colour with little ones, or play a board game with older kids, but I don’t want to be Prince Charming or a Ninja! I have been known to go down a slide as recently as last year, but I wouldn’t be up for running around at the park.

If you were my DD and visited with your little kids though, I wouldn’t be scolding them. I’d find something to keep them amused.

TulipOH · 04/11/2023 17:04

Does DB have kids?

It sounds like your parents aren't really kid people based on what you've said about your childhood.

I'm similar, I don't have kids out of choice however.

When we're around family children I'd happily chat to them for a bit and play the odd game, but I would offer to take over with them or take them out.

Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 17:03

@melj1213 i do agree it’s harder because If as my family don't see the children very often then they may not know how to interact with them

OP posts:
Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 17:02

@Reugny im 40 . I do agree parents weren’t as child focused .

@melj1213 i don’t direct very well . I suppose I assume they know how to play and interact which I shouldn’t . I def

OP posts:
Flipdiddle · 04/11/2023 16:59

So is this your mum and step dad or dad and step mum? And what’s the other like?

Reugny · 04/11/2023 16:58

I always felt we played second fiddle to my parents as children. We didn’t go to clubs because my parents didn’t want to take us ( it was their time to relax ) We did what our parents wanted ( we were never asked what we might enjoy ) . My parents believe children shouldn’t hold much power . Would never take children out to meals ( waste of money ) .

How old are you? As previous generations weren't as child centric.

melj1213 · 04/11/2023 16:58

I think you are being a bit unreasonable.

If your family don't see the children very often then they may not know how to interact with them (especially as they are very young) - I love my nieces and nephews but the older the get the easier they are to spend time with as you can talk to them and have conversations etc as some people just aren't very good at "little kid play".

Do you direct them when you visit? IE when you visit you tell them "Oh, Katie just learned a poem about conkers at school, Katie do you want to show granny?," or "We have this book here that Baby Jack loves to read - do you want to read it with him? He loves to turn the pages himself though" etc so they have a bit of structure/framework to the visit that can help them out with what to do.

Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 16:58

Flipdiddle · 04/11/2023 16:53

Op you started a thread about your mum moving her boyfriend in and you were worried about your 14 year old sister.

is this the family you’re talking about?

Hi,

It was my bio dad and half sister . Then my sister mum moving her bf in.

OP posts:
Reugny · 04/11/2023 16:56

What I mean is my DH explains that grandparents should play and engage with children and my parents are being lazy

It's more likely that they find young children tiring and boring. I know older people like this. However once their grandchildren got to school age they engaged much better with them.

Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 16:56

OrigamiOwl · 04/11/2023 16:46

Unfortunately you can't make them take an interest. What was your relationship like before your had kids? And how hands on where they as parents when you were small?

I always felt we played second fiddle to my parents as children. We didn’t go to clubs because my parents didn’t want to take us ( it was their time to relax ) We did what our parents wanted ( we were never asked what we might enjoy ) . My parents believe children shouldn’t hold much power . Would never take children out to meals ( waste of money ) .

ive always loved my parents but wouldn’t say they were great. I felt abit alone at times. I remember them going on holidays whilst we were left behind !!

OP posts:
Flipdiddle · 04/11/2023 16:53

Op you started a thread about your mum moving her boyfriend in and you were worried about your 14 year old sister.

is this the family you’re talking about?

Mummasummer · 04/11/2023 16:52

Flipdiddle · 04/11/2023 16:45

DH says this is what my family should do.

oh right so if DH says they “should” do something then that’s gospel?! 😂

when in reality - there’s a lot more to family dynamics

What I mean is my DH explains that grandparents should play and engage with children and my parents are being lazy . He is saying his family aren’t amazing at all and are doing why grandparents do .

He believes my parents are takers and treat me poorly. But I don’t know as I have only ever had my parents !

OP posts: