Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who gets to keep the compensation?

211 replies

Memba · 04/11/2023 15:13

This may well be hypothetical as airline hasn't agreed to anything yet but in the event that they do, who gets the money?

Situation as follows... DH and I took DC1 (18) and DC2 (15) overseas for a week for half term. Each DC brought a friend (same ages).

Both friends parents paid for their flights at approx £250 each. We paid for accommodation, car hire and activities/food/drink. They were effectively our guests.

Return flight was delayed by over 24hrs at fault of airline. I have checked and we are entitled to 600euros compensation per passenger. I have submitted claim on behalf all passengers.

In the event that the airline pays out, who gets the compensation?

Each passenger gets 600 Euros meaning friends parents make a profit on the holiday? Or we refund value of flight and keep the rest as contribution towards the cost of the trip.

FWIW DH and I are both financially disadvantaged by delay (self-employed) so actually lost income. The teenagers had no loss of earnings but got a free bonus night in a star hotel!

So, my AIBU is, in the event that airline cough up, do keep the majority of the compensation?

YANBU - refund flights to parent of each teen and keep the rest
YABU - give each set of parents the full €600

Or some other split?

OP posts:
Daffodilsandtuplips · 04/11/2023 20:39

What would you do if the compensation was paid out in travel vouchers and not cash?

notimagain · 04/11/2023 19:16

@KingsleyBorder

And I’m not sure it’s possible to travel 3500km and stay within the EU?

It seems it is, but into/out of UK it appears there's only a really tiny number of airport pairs that would fit the bill..

Hours of fun here:

https://www.greatcirclemap.com/

Great Circle Map

Great Circle Map displays the shortest route between airports and calculates the distance. It draws geodesic flight paths on top of Google maps, so you can create your own route map.

https://www.greatcirclemap.com

KingsleyBorder · 04/11/2023 18:45

Memba · 04/11/2023 18:31

@KingsleyBorder we're in UK but as flight was from an EU country claim was made in Euros.

Interested in issue of a child's money, from whatever source. So if a young child is gifted money, does a parent have the legal right to spend that on the child's behalf?

No, that’s not right. The place you flew from is irrelevant. You are claiming in the UK because the UK was the destination of your return flight. Your claim is made under UK law and calculated in GBP. A court in the UK will not make an order to pay Euro.

And I’m not sure it’s possible to travel 3500km and stay within the EU?

Rights over children’s money is not my area, beyond the very high level principles I mentioned, you’d need to research that. What I can tell you for definite is that any compensation money belongs to the individual passenger.

wited · 04/11/2023 18:40

Would be interesting to know what the legal point is. It's given to each individual passenger. Not the lead booker to decide to keep it Grin

Bouncyball23 · 04/11/2023 18:38

There is a reason you get more back than the cost of the flight its for the inconvenience, why do you get to keep it? You didn't lose any more, yes you paided for accommodation but you was doing that anyway and there would be no money owing at all if flight was on time stop being grabby and give them what's rightfully theirs!

xyz111 · 04/11/2023 18:36

You would be massively cheeky to keep each passengers money!! You're going to make money from being delayed, you can't keep theirs either!!

Memba · 04/11/2023 18:31

@KingsleyBorder we're in UK but as flight was from an EU country claim was made in Euros.

Interested in issue of a child's money, from whatever source. So if a young child is gifted money, does a parent have the legal right to spend that on the child's behalf?

OP posts:
TheOneWhereWeDontGiveAPhuck · 04/11/2023 18:27

It goes to the people who were delayed. Its compensation, because they were delayed. Its to say sorry for delaying you for 24 hours. It should go to the people who were delayed. Not their parents, and not you.

CantFindTheBeat · 04/11/2023 18:27

Oh god, what an awkward situation!

I'd definitely give any relevant money to the parents of the children.

I might be secretly miffed at their unearned windfall but would do it anyway, to guard against the inevitable sods laws that it
Would get out somehow.

Can't risk being forever compared with Arthur Fowler - forever be known as the mum who nicked the compo money!

KingsleyBorder · 04/11/2023 18:24

Memba · 04/11/2023 18:06

Yes, this is what I am wondering.

Obviously for 18 year olds, it's legally theirs.

Not so clear for 15 year olds! What if they were even younger? 6 year olds? I'm assuming for under 18s (financially dependent) it is at the discretion of the parent?

The money legally belongs to the passenger. Even infants, they can claim as long as the flight cost something and was not free of charge.

A minor needs an adult to act in the claim on their behalf but any compensation paid belongs to the minor. The law around the adult’s ability to deal with/administer the child’s money is no different here than it would be in relation to Christmas money given by an auntie, money won in a competition, or earnings of a child actor. That’s potentially quite complex area and may vary depending where you/the other family live- you are still talking about Euros so not sure if UK or not?

BellaAndDave · 04/11/2023 18:22

travelallthetime · 04/11/2023 17:25

Personally I think you would have to be a pretty shitty person to accept more than the cost of the flight when someone has taken your child away for a week and paid for all their meals accommodation, regardless of whether that was what was arranged or not. If you offered me the money I would tell you to keep the lot, including the cost of the flight, but then, im not a money grabbing weirdo like a lot of the people on here

Personally I wouldn’t have sent my child on a holiday and expected anyone else to pay for accommodation/food/activities/drinks etc I highly doubt those did did either…

Memba · 04/11/2023 18:19

@Mumofthreeteenagers Not a chance! The 15 year old would go and spend the whole lot in Sephora on products they've seen on TikTok 😂 But they will benefit from next years holiday, which is what we would use our £s for.

Will discuss with older DC. They are going travelling next summer so we will suggest that we hold it for them to put towards cost of trip.

OP posts:
MumblesParty · 04/11/2023 18:19

OP you say you’re self employed. How much to you charge for your time? Because making a claim is going to take a lot of time in my experience, and lots of arguing. There’s no way on earth I’d have been in charge of 2 extra teens for 24 hours and also go through the sheer hell of dealing with an insurance company, only to hand over a ton of cash to people who did literally nothing.

If - and it’s a big IF - you do manage to secure the compensation money, I would deduct a chunk for your time and inconvenience. I would ensure the parents of the guests had their flight costs covered and a bit more, but I wouldn’t be giving them the whole lot.

Mumofthreeteenagers · 04/11/2023 18:12

I assume you aren't giving your children the 600 are you? As parents, you made the financial decisions, take the hits.... and the gains. You were proxy parents at that point so the financial belong to you. It was your decisions and acumen to claim. It's yours. Giving the 250 is a kind gesture. Or you could do a weekend away for the same group (and make it cost less than the compensation) and not give any money to the parents.

Yalta · 04/11/2023 18:09

Correctly you should pay them the full £600 each

Although I think you would still be correct in splitting the extra £100 you spent pro rata within the group

However if you don’t think any of the parents would ask for the evidence from the airline and you know you and dh don’t breathe a word of this to anyone (not even your children or talk to your dh within earshot of your dc) and you can destroy the evidence it would never be found out. I would refund them the flight costs only

Although the airline might write to the parents who booked the ticket directly with the refund or send a cheque to them even though you were the one claiming compensation on their behalf as they booked directly for the flights and I would find it odd if someone else could claim compensation on my behalf and the compensation was paid directly to them

You could in theory claim compensation for anyone in that flight.

Memba · 04/11/2023 18:09

Smurf123 · 04/11/2023 18:05

Good luck getting it back. We applied after a cancelled flight last December and are still awaiting a response from the airline

Haha! Yes, I think this is most likely scenario!

I have given all concerned the case number so they can track progress if they choose to...

OP posts:
Memba · 04/11/2023 18:06

KingsleyBorder · 04/11/2023 18:03

There is a much more interesting question here- should the 18 and 15 year olds (in both families) give their compensation money to their parents?

It’s legally theirs. Does not matter who paid for the flights. Morally, of course, a different matter…

Yes, this is what I am wondering.

Obviously for 18 year olds, it's legally theirs.

Not so clear for 15 year olds! What if they were even younger? 6 year olds? I'm assuming for under 18s (financially dependent) it is at the discretion of the parent?

OP posts:
OneTC · 04/11/2023 18:06

The parents didn't get what they paid for, so they get 600 back per child

Smurf123 · 04/11/2023 18:05

Good luck getting it back. We applied after a cancelled flight last December and are still awaiting a response from the airline

KingsleyBorder · 04/11/2023 18:03

There is a much more interesting question here- should the 18 and 15 year olds (in both families) give their compensation money to their parents?

It’s legally theirs. Does not matter who paid for the flights. Morally, of course, a different matter…

Nonimai · 04/11/2023 17:59

The parents weren’t disadvantaged, you were. You were good enough to take these kids on hols in the first place at considerable cost and let’s face it significant responsibility for you. If one of those kids had been in hospital for several days you would have accepted the time lost from your holiday, not charged the parents for time lost. I’m waffling but as I see it the flights have been reimbursed with £350 extra per person which should go towards the cost of the holiday (which everyone who was delayed benefitted from)It would be ridiculous to give any more than the flight reimbursement to the parents imo.

Motomum23 · 04/11/2023 17:57

I'd refund the cost of the flight. You qwre obliged to care for their children from an extra day - therefore you should keep thw compensation imo.

Notwhatyouwanttohear · 04/11/2023 17:53

This is ridiculous.

Do you have no morals.

If you wanted them to contribute to the holiday you should have asked for money.

Instead you want to STEAL the children's compensation.

If you couldn't afford to take them you shouldn't have, now being grabby with compensation to make up with it is low.

rookiemere · 04/11/2023 17:48

OP you say you lost income. Was it more than 1200 euros? Or in fact 2400 euros if you factor in your own DCs as well ?

Anyway I see you told the DPs and one set told you to keep the money and the other hasn't so far, so you've done the right thing anyway.

tellittothemoon · 04/11/2023 17:41

what @BellaEllaWella said