Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who gets to keep the compensation?

211 replies

Memba · 04/11/2023 15:13

This may well be hypothetical as airline hasn't agreed to anything yet but in the event that they do, who gets the money?

Situation as follows... DH and I took DC1 (18) and DC2 (15) overseas for a week for half term. Each DC brought a friend (same ages).

Both friends parents paid for their flights at approx £250 each. We paid for accommodation, car hire and activities/food/drink. They were effectively our guests.

Return flight was delayed by over 24hrs at fault of airline. I have checked and we are entitled to 600euros compensation per passenger. I have submitted claim on behalf all passengers.

In the event that the airline pays out, who gets the compensation?

Each passenger gets 600 Euros meaning friends parents make a profit on the holiday? Or we refund value of flight and keep the rest as contribution towards the cost of the trip.

FWIW DH and I are both financially disadvantaged by delay (self-employed) so actually lost income. The teenagers had no loss of earnings but got a free bonus night in a star hotel!

So, my AIBU is, in the event that airline cough up, do keep the majority of the compensation?

YANBU - refund flights to parent of each teen and keep the rest
YABU - give each set of parents the full €600

Or some other split?

OP posts:
Pinkfluff76 · 05/11/2023 23:12

I’d give them back the flight cost only

LaundryandDirt · 05/11/2023 23:07

Cost of flights back and that’s being generous, seeing as they got to go on a lovely holiday anyway!

Blogswife · 05/11/2023 22:24

Surely the refund & compensation goes to whoever paid for the original flight ?
I can’t see why you’d think otherwise

notimagain · 05/11/2023 21:39

It gives airlines an incentive not to fuck up. Delays are often out of their control, but very often not

As I understood from way back when 261 was introduced the actual original intent was to incentivise airlines to not cancel flights at the last minute simply because the sector wasn't going to turn a profit....

There were rumours that was exactly what some LoCos were doing in the early days of Eurpean deregulation and the politicians in Brussels took a dim view...

Problem now as many see it is the law was overly simplistically drafted or codified (how exactly do you define a "fuck up".) and also it does appear at times the amount of compensation triggered is way out of proportion to the inconvenience actually caused to many passengers.

261 also probably to some extent hasn't helped customer service in the event of those delays that do happen. There's no point in an airline employing lots of reps/ground staff at all their outstations who are in position to smooth things over when everybody is going to lawyer up at the 3 hour 1 minute point regardless, leaving the company on the hook for potentially the best part of 100k total comp on many flights.

The airline might as well save on wages (so the lack of ground staff these days shouldn't be a surprise)..and of course down the road the comp will get recovered in ticket prices...so there go your "cheap" fares next season.

At least partially as a result of the above as @KingsleyBorder says, revising the law has been discussed.

Blacknosugarplease · 05/11/2023 21:17

Thedm · 05/11/2023 14:08

Would you like to go around every passenger on the flight and see who wasn’t actually that inconvenienced, and then take their compensation to split it between the passengers who actually were? No, you wouldn’t do that. Same thing here.

It isn’t about level of inconvenience. It is simply a blanket payment to all travellers who has to suffer the delay; regardless of how much they enjoyed that delay. Stop trying to find ways to validate your attempt to steal money from others.

You can ask the parents. They might let you keep it.

@Thedm wind your neck in. You’ve clearly not read the OP’s replies/comments.

Sleeplikeababy · 05/11/2023 21:03

Exactly this! As the paying parent I’m not inconvenienced. My kid had a great time and lost nothing financially or work etc.
why should I profit? I’d want you to take the extra beyond the ticket money and even then I’m not sure I even need that.

morally / legally you should offer me the full amount but I think any reasonable person would not want to take it.

I don’t see why my child regardless of age needs the money and I’d hope they’d be respectful enough to see that they’d spent nothing, lost nothing and had a great time so any payout would not need to go to them.

Thatladdo · 05/11/2023 20:20

600 each

KingsleyBorder · 05/11/2023 20:14

In case anybody is interested, the original EU Regulation 261/2004 only provided for fixed compensation when a flight was completely cancelled, not when it was delayed (though it was always payable in addition to the airline having to put you on the next available flight, so people weren’t stranded).

Then someone took an airline to court to argue that a long delay was just as inconvenient as a cancellation, partly because what had started to happen was that airlines would avoid officially cancelling in order to dodge paying the compensation.

It went all the way to the European Court of Justice and the ECJ held that, from that point onwards, any delay of 3 hours or more would give rise to a right to compensation.

The case is called Sturgeon (no relation to Nicola!)

It has resulted in huge expenses for airlines and they can’t buy insurance against this liability as it is supposed to act as a punitive measure if they don’t perform well. Huge amounts of admin and lots of no win no fee “claims farms” all across Europe that specialise in encouraging people to claim. Lots of court time taken up dealing with cases that are brought by people who didn’t really suffer much inconvenience at all.

But as long as it’s the law then fair play, I would still claim it myself if the opportunity presented.

I would back a change in the law though. It’s been proposed and consulted on in the UK for domestic flights and there is a legislative project to revise the system under way, but it won’t happen in this government. For international flights, even post-Brexit, there are too many complicating factors for change to happen any time soon. Only hope is new EU legislation and no sign of that on the horizon.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 05/11/2023 20:01

The compensation is for the delay suffered by the passengers - they were also passengers and they get the whole amount. Their parents paid for the flight, with the compensation in the ‘contract’ and their children were delayed. Of. Course you can’t steal it!
if you bought meals, drinks etc in the delay time for them you could subtract that, but nothing more, it’s fraudulent.
it doesn’t matter how financially disadvantaged you are, you cannot steal somebody else’s compensation for the delayed flight that they paid for! Obviously!

Justontherightsideofnormal · 05/11/2023 19:52

If you booked all flights, any compensation returned goes back into your next holiday fund.

DupontetDupond · 05/11/2023 19:21

Having read the thread I think people need to get off the OP’s back.

She has previously posted that she subsequently contacted the 2 sets of friends’ parents and put them in the picture about the possible 600 euros per child compo and the fact that the compensation could well be higher than the actual flight cost. The correct thing to do.

That said I would hope that the parents would tell OP to keep the cash as a thank you for giving my kid a fab holiday - I think one has already indicated as much. Or at very most only accept payment to cover cost of the £250 flight and tell OP to keep the rest.

coffeeneedsmummy · 05/11/2023 19:15

Sorry, seems that legally I'm wrong, still don't think it's right. The money should go to whoever experienced the loss IMO

ChampagneLassie · 05/11/2023 19:15

When I got compensation from BA for flights I’d paid for me and DP they wanted written confirmation from DP that he was happy for them to pay the compensation to me. They’re compensating the person inconvenienced NOT the cost of the flight from my understanding.

YireosDodeAver · 05/11/2023 18:50

It is not your money to keep. The compensation is set at €600 per passenger even though the flight was much cheaper because each passenger lost a day of their lives. Each passenger deserves their compensation.

celticprincess · 05/11/2023 18:46

Interestingly in the case of compensation for a car accident I had to go to court and wear that my kids would have their money deposited in a bank account until they turned 18 and could access it. Was about £1.5k each though and they were quite young. It has been put in a bank account but one they can actually access now - although they haven’t spent it as I keep the book!! I was surprised that I didn’t just receive one cheque for us all.

Thedm · 05/11/2023 18:45

coffeeneedsmummy · 05/11/2023 18:42

I have no words, it really makes me despair 🤦🏻‍♀️

It gives airlines an incentive not to fuck up. Delays are often out of their control, but very often not.

coffeeneedsmummy · 05/11/2023 18:42

Thedm · 05/11/2023 18:31

It is an entitlement. By law, you are entitled to it purely because you experienced a delay. You don’t have to have suffered any financial loss. Even if you’re a teen and enjoyed the extra night, you still experienced the delay and are legally entitled to a payment as an apology.
You are completely wrong. Like it or not. You’re completely wrong.

I have no words, it really makes me despair 🤦🏻‍♀️

Thedm · 05/11/2023 18:31

coffeeneedsmummy · 05/11/2023 18:17

No, compensation is if you experience inconvenience or a loss. If you didn't, its not a bloody entitlement!! Where do you think the compensation money comes from? Do you think the airlines go and print money to give you money grabbers some extra dosh for Christmas??? No, they do not! The OP is claiming because the OP GENUINELY was inconvenienced AND experienced a loss because they couldn't work and lost money. If your kids were on hols and it was a holiday camp and the flight was delayed do you think they would just graciously look after your kids out of the goodness of their hearts? Would they ####! Just unreal. Absolutely unreal. I feel like I'm actually living in an alternate universe where no one can see beyond the end of their nose. Bring on global warming and the end of humanity I say!

It is an entitlement. By law, you are entitled to it purely because you experienced a delay. You don’t have to have suffered any financial loss. Even if you’re a teen and enjoyed the extra night, you still experienced the delay and are legally entitled to a payment as an apology.
You are completely wrong. Like it or not. You’re completely wrong.

coffeeneedsmummy · 05/11/2023 18:17

No, compensation is if you experience inconvenience or a loss. If you didn't, its not a bloody entitlement!! Where do you think the compensation money comes from? Do you think the airlines go and print money to give you money grabbers some extra dosh for Christmas??? No, they do not! The OP is claiming because the OP GENUINELY was inconvenienced AND experienced a loss because they couldn't work and lost money. If your kids were on hols and it was a holiday camp and the flight was delayed do you think they would just graciously look after your kids out of the goodness of their hearts? Would they ####! Just unreal. Absolutely unreal. I feel like I'm actually living in an alternate universe where no one can see beyond the end of their nose. Bring on global warming and the end of humanity I say!

spookehtooth · 05/11/2023 18:05

Compensation belongs to those who experienced it, not who paid. Compensation is a kind of apology of sorts for the experience of the delay/cancellation/etc.

I never had to think about this until a holiday I paid for got compensation for, for me and an ex. I was going to keep it until she asked, then I thought about it a little bit and thought the above was the fairest way to think about it. We'd split up a while, so I could've acted any way I wished, but it it felt right to share equally. Of course, by common consent, it can be distributed differently

coffeeneedsmummy · 05/11/2023 17:58

Obviously in the minority here but if someone had offered to take my kids for 1 week overseas and only asked for flight money, unless there was a cost incurred by me for the delay or a loss for my kids, I would be delighted if offered the flight money back, but in truth would not have expected anything and just been super grateful that you had taken such good care of my kids even when things went to shit in the end. What the flip is wrong with people at the moment - this entitlement is bloody unreal!!

Memba · 05/11/2023 14:19

@Thedm have you actually read and understood all my previous posts?

I asked a question at the start about what would be the right thing to do. I have acknowledged I was wrong and I have taken necessary steps to ensure everyone gets what they are entitled to (if we ever get it).

I think it's very unfair of you to continue accusing me of trying to steal anyone else's money.

I was simply responding to a previous post about different levels of inconvenience.

OP posts:
Thedm · 05/11/2023 14:08

Memba · 05/11/2023 14:05

Thank you for acknowledging that @poetryandwine

Someone up thread suggested that all passengers were equally inconvenienced, which is simply not true. All equally delayed? Yes. But inconvenienced? No.

The DCs had a night in a suite in a luxury hotel with their BFFs, stuffed their faces at an all you can eat buffet and we bought (the older ones) cocktails etc. They had a great night.

We had to rearrange work commitments/cancel meetings for the following day, rearrange onward transfer from airport in UK, dog boarding etc and lost a day's income.

As I have been informed by some very knowledgable posters, the compensation is per passenger so all of the above info (including who paid for hols/tickets etc) is irrelevant.

The passengers will get their compensation (if we ever see it). What they choose to do with it is their business.

Would you like to go around every passenger on the flight and see who wasn’t actually that inconvenienced, and then take their compensation to split it between the passengers who actually were? No, you wouldn’t do that. Same thing here.

It isn’t about level of inconvenience. It is simply a blanket payment to all travellers who has to suffer the delay; regardless of how much they enjoyed that delay. Stop trying to find ways to validate your attempt to steal money from others.

You can ask the parents. They might let you keep it.

Thedm · 05/11/2023 14:06

Mazuslongtoenail · 05/11/2023 13:50

If the parents accepted a profit, knowing that you paid for accommodation, food etc they would be massive CFs imo.

But why? It’s compensation for the kids having to wait. That’s what it is for. It isn’t a refund on the holiday, it has nothing to do with holiday or flight costs.
It’s compensation. The OP is getting her own compensation. She enjoyed her holiday; she doesn’t need a refund or to get any money back for it. She doesn’t need their compensation. It isn’t hers.
The compensation goes to each individual traveller. Some will end up with a profit, others won’t. Same as if you flew business and your company paid; you get the compensation and make a profit.

Why is everyone acting like the OP is somehow missing out? She is being reimbursed for costs plus getting her own compensation on top. Why should she get everyone else’s as well? It doesn’t belong to her, not legally, not morally.

If the families choose to give it to her, as one has done, then that’s lovely of them. But it is THEIR choice, not the OP’s as it isn’t her money. She cannot just steal it. And it sounds like she planned to do just that; steal it.

Memba · 05/11/2023 14:05

Thank you for acknowledging that @poetryandwine

Someone up thread suggested that all passengers were equally inconvenienced, which is simply not true. All equally delayed? Yes. But inconvenienced? No.

The DCs had a night in a suite in a luxury hotel with their BFFs, stuffed their faces at an all you can eat buffet and we bought (the older ones) cocktails etc. They had a great night.

We had to rearrange work commitments/cancel meetings for the following day, rearrange onward transfer from airport in UK, dog boarding etc and lost a day's income.

As I have been informed by some very knowledgable posters, the compensation is per passenger so all of the above info (including who paid for hols/tickets etc) is irrelevant.

The passengers will get their compensation (if we ever see it). What they choose to do with it is their business.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread