Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect some swimming at swimming lessons?

42 replies

UpUpUpU · 04/11/2023 14:05

I’m not sure if I’m just wildly expecting to much, but how long did your average swimmers take to complete stages 1 and 2 from starting Reception kind of age?

These are council lessons and are 30 minutes once a week. How long were your kids actually being taught for the 30 minute lesson?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UpUpUpU · 07/11/2023 18:34

So we have had our private lesson tonight and jumped from 64% to 86%. She has said he is ready to move up, just needs to go into the deeper end of the pool first.
I wonder how long it would I’ve taken to get to this point with his group lessons.

anyway, he loved all the attention and I am happy!

OP posts:
Skyscrapers921 · 06/11/2023 09:27

Teacher matters hugely. I picked swimming up in a day because mine was so good. And scarily persistent.

prescribingmum · 06/11/2023 08:58

Based on your background, I would have expected much faster progression. DC1 achieved stage 1 in their first term of swim lessons (end of reception), stage 2 the following term (start of Y1) and stage 3 by end of Y1 with a range of distance badges. They could comfortably swim 25m at the time of getting stage 3 badge. DC1 is water confident as you describe yours to be, always been happy with face getting wet/jumping in and the body positions when swimming seem to come naturally to them.

All group lessons with private swim school, I think you've done the right thing switching them. DC spend no time outside the pool and practically no time waiting once they got their stage 2 as they send 2 or 3 at a time

Cramlington567 · 06/11/2023 08:55

Get in the pool after and do another 30 minutes practicing/playing. 30 minutes a week is such a short time especially when half of it is wasted as you say

enchantedsquirrelwood · 06/11/2023 08:48

Orchidgarden · 04/11/2023 17:00

This is an unpopular opinion, but I think the ability to swim is not very helpful.
It's fine to be a good swimmer in a heated indoor pool, but it wouldn't help if someone got into difficulties in a cold sea or a river.

https://www.thewirh.com/blog/dpw2022#:~:text=Ensure%20your%20child%20knows%20the,but%20it%20is%20not%20sufficient.

I've had arguments on here about swimming being a life skill. It's a life enhancing skill, in that it's a good leisure activity, you can get work as a lifeguard or swimming teacher, do watersports etc.

But it is not a lifesaving skill, as you rightly point out (although some people do personal survival awards, which are probably more useful than the actual swimming bit).

As for teaching kids yourself, there is a reason we have professionally qualified swimming teachers, because they know what they are doing. Most parents don't, and would like their kids to learn properly.

Doggymummar · 04/11/2023 17:45

margotrose · 04/11/2023 16:36

Swimming lessons are hardly "new", though. They were the norm when I grew up thirty years ago.

In my fifties and we did swimming lessons, not till secondary tho, mum and dad took us at primary

CheesyChipsOnWembleyWay · 04/11/2023 17:40

Our council pool lessons are great. In the pool swimming the whole time, and the instructors have an app so you can see what skills they're working on and their attainment.

And cheap as chips, with free swimming at all other times for the kids. Win win.

JADS · 04/11/2023 17:40

My DS2 has done council lessons. He started at the age of 4 and at 8, he is swimming 400m. His progress has definitely been related to his teachers and whether we went on holiday where there was a pool (this seems to really help with progress). He has got stuck at a couple of stages and then skipped through a stage in a month. He's in the final stage now, but he got stuck in the previous stage because he was the youngest and smallest which meant he struggled to keep up.

His older brother has 1 to 1 lessons as he has ASD and would struggle otherwise. He's done so well from where he started. He also seems to come on loads after holidays, even though he is very resistant to swimming in strange pools.

Hope the private lessons go well. They have been brilliant for our son.

Orchidgarden · 04/11/2023 17:40

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/11/2023 17:19

I couldn't agree less, we are an island nation, if your child cannot swim there is a huge range of activities and sports they are automatically excluded from ( sailing, surfing, canoeing, paddle boarding) also do you never go to the beach ? Being able to swim is absolutely a life skill.

I did say it would be an unpopular opinion. In my experience, most people don't go sailing, etc. Not everyone enjoys water sports.
As for the beach, yes I went when my children were small but all they did was paddle and an adult was with them.

Rhombus79 · 04/11/2023 17:39

You will notice a difference quite quickly, now that he is doing 1-2-1 lessons. We had the same problem with our son, even in a rather small 6 children group setting with a private swim school. He wasn't enjoying it anymore.

He had 1-2-1 sessions for 2 months now (working on stage 5). He is progressing so quickly. His teacher is great, they concentrate on one stroke per session, very technique oriented, with corrections as they go along. Best decision ever.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/11/2023 17:19

Orchidgarden · 04/11/2023 17:00

This is an unpopular opinion, but I think the ability to swim is not very helpful.
It's fine to be a good swimmer in a heated indoor pool, but it wouldn't help if someone got into difficulties in a cold sea or a river.

https://www.thewirh.com/blog/dpw2022#:~:text=Ensure%20your%20child%20knows%20the,but%20it%20is%20not%20sufficient.

I couldn't agree less, we are an island nation, if your child cannot swim there is a huge range of activities and sports they are automatically excluded from ( sailing, surfing, canoeing, paddle boarding) also do you never go to the beach ? Being able to swim is absolutely a life skill.

Orchidgarden · 04/11/2023 17:00

This is an unpopular opinion, but I think the ability to swim is not very helpful.
It's fine to be a good swimmer in a heated indoor pool, but it wouldn't help if someone got into difficulties in a cold sea or a river.

https://www.thewirh.com/blog/dpw2022#:~:text=Ensure%20your%20child%20knows%20the,but%20it%20is%20not%20sufficient.

Does the ability to swim keep my child safe around open water?

https://www.thewirh.com/blog/dpw2022#:~:text=Ensure%20your%20child%20knows%20the,but%20it%20is%20not%20sufficient.

LovePoppy · 04/11/2023 16:47

iminvestednow · 04/11/2023 15:10

What happened to taking your kids swimming until they could swim if thrown in water? What is stage 4? What does that even mean? Unless your child wants to swim competitively surely it’s just, child can swim, yay!

I want my children to be a strong confident swimmer. I want them to finish the set lessons, and if they want then start life saving courses.

Where I live that’s level 9. Technically 7-9 are junior lifeguarding courses Swimmers are challenged with 600 m workouts, 300 m timed swims and a 25 m object carry. Strokes are refined over 100 m swims. First aid focuses on treatment of bone or joint injuries and respiratory emergencies including asthma and allergic reactions. Lifesaving skills include defence methods, victim removals and rolling over and supporting a victim face up in shallow water.

My 9 year old is about to start swimmer 6. We had a few bumpy years of lessons through covid, but she did two levels this past summer. We live in a community with lots of swimming activities. Pools, boats, rivers/lakes/ocean. Being a passable swimmer is not enough for me.

maw29 · 04/11/2023 16:40

We moved from council lessons to private lessons. Ds was only 3 at the time but there were 8 kids in the class. Spent more time getting dressed after the lesson than he did doing any swimming.

BarbaraAllen · 04/11/2023 16:39

Why not just teach them yourself? Speaking as a granny who taught her own children 45+ years ago, just do it.

Both my children were good swimmers by age 6 or so, and our 6 year old son taught himself to dive, just watching others.

Just do it! Why waste money on expensive lessons when your own kids hardly get a look in.

No wonder you mums have no money!

PuttingDownRoots · 04/11/2023 16:36

Mine originally learnt abroad so missed stages 1-3, but every area seems to interpretation the stages differently.

The first UK area mine had lessons in the early stages were in the children's pool and all the children could stand in it so were never sitting on the side waiting their turn like I've seen described. Second area it was deeper, but they could still stand.

In the country mine learnt in the parents were in the water until 5yo and the aim was 25m of propelling themselves, treading water etc and it was tiring for the parents let alone the kids!

margotrose · 04/11/2023 16:36

iminvestednow · 04/11/2023 15:10

What happened to taking your kids swimming until they could swim if thrown in water? What is stage 4? What does that even mean? Unless your child wants to swim competitively surely it’s just, child can swim, yay!

Swimming lessons are hardly "new", though. They were the norm when I grew up thirty years ago.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 04/11/2023 16:29

I wonder if you live in my area OP as there is a massive snobbishness about "council" lessons (even though very few centres are now council-run, they are run by companies and ours is no exception). The teachers are well qualified and do a good job. However, the groups can be a bit too big at times.

I think the important factor is the teacher.

tulippa · 04/11/2023 16:25

I’ve sorted it now with the private lessons but just wondered if this was the norm for council pool lessons?

Agree with others saying it completely depends on the teacher. DCs had council lessons. The first sessions were at the new fancy aquatics centre taught by (I assume) students who weren't the best at dealing with younger children and I got fed up watching DS walk up and down the pool blowing bubbles for months.

We moved to the older run down pool in another part of town because we heard good things about the teacher there. She was amazing - very encouraging but took no nonsense and just had a really good approach. DS was swimming in no time and both DCs ended up as strong swimmers who really enjoy it. I am forever grateful for this lady teaching my DCs such an important life skill.

Don't know if this answers your questions I but wouldn't write off council lessons - ask around about the teachers.

soxthecat22 · 04/11/2023 16:12

We pay for a private lessons. 4 in a class for half an hour. That still means they only get 7.5 minutes of swimming a week as they take it in turns and spend the rest of the time sitting whilst the others have a go. £40 a month for that pleasure.

Girasoli · 04/11/2023 15:51

Pretty much all of the time - there was a teacher poolside and an assistant in the water and the class sizes were between 3 and 6 (private lessons though).

JustMarriedBecca · 04/11/2023 15:48

Depends on the Council. Son just started YR2 and in Stage 5. He didn't really start until reception at all because of COVID. He's quite a sporty / confident kid though.

Even in Council lessons, numbers are 7-8 to a lesson.

Have noticed that depends on teacher though. DD took 18 months to pass stage 5 because she had a teacher who was thorough. Providing they are actually enjoying, becoming more confident and developing / keeping fit, I don't care what level they are.

Doveyouknow · 04/11/2023 15:47

Council lessons vary enormously depending on the teacher and class size. The teachers in ds current class are very hit and miss about updating their assessments but he does a lot more swimming and he is clearly learning a lot. In his previous pool he spent way more time waiting his turn so learnt less but the assessments were up to date.

Giveuprobot · 04/11/2023 15:42

iminvestednow · 04/11/2023 15:10

What happened to taking your kids swimming until they could swim if thrown in water? What is stage 4? What does that even mean? Unless your child wants to swim competitively surely it’s just, child can swim, yay!

How have you managed to convince yourself that swimming lessons are a new phenomenon?

pointythings · 04/11/2023 15:39

My two had council sessions but that was a long time ago when the stages were different - the later stages were 1 hour lessons! They were absolutely in the water and on the go the entire time, and both could swim 300m and more by age 7 or 8 at multiple strokes, could dive, tread water, swim under water, scull and do a basic tumble turn. Very low teacher turnover too. Clearly times have changed, though to be fair people booked in to our local council lessons from other areas so perhaps they were just particularly good.