Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We are not set up for electric vehicles in this country

391 replies

Pollyannaatemyjelly · 04/11/2023 13:31

We have an electric vehicle. We tend not to do too many long journeys but today it was inevitable. We have visit a very popular destination via major motorways but there is not one fast charger available on our route. I've just stopped on the M5 on what is supposed to be a dual charger (so more than one vehicle can charge) but it's not working. I've had to wait 20 minutes for the vehicle next to me to charge before I can even begin to charge mine. There is no chance this county can become all electric when the infrastructure is so poor.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
FairyMaclary · 05/11/2023 08:28

@BottleShipDown
it doesn’t make it clear if diesel/petrol fires are more common due to their being more petrol/diesel cars. I’d expect many more diesel fires as there are many more diesel cars. The fact the shipping company has banned EVs suggests they have serious concerns.

I am glad I have read this thread. I am going to do far more research before I buy electric. The government had incentives for diesels 10-20 years ago (including free road tax due to low emissions) I am not sure that was a well researched policy.

RedToothBrush · 05/11/2023 08:28

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 18:39

Well yes i live in mainland Europe. There’s a €6k ev discount, so a €17k costs €11k. You can pay in 5 year monthly instalments which is around €185 a month. The cost of insurance/ aa equivalent is included in purchase for those 5 years. For a more expensive ev it’s the same, and you can opt to pay a deposit to reduce monthly repayment. As a company our old 17 year old car could only be third party insured here and the insurance alone was around €150 a month.

Also poster: We were always going to lease to buy which can only be done new. Secondhand cars are very expensive where we live (not uk) and we didn’t have €20k cash to buy a 5 year old secondhand car.

Are you for real?! You've just given me a massive
lecture about why I should have gone EV blah blah blah.

When I said about the cost and not wanting to do finance not having £20k cash to spend on a car you CONTINUED to lecture.

You THEN reveal you live in the EU, where you get massive discounts on EV here due to governments pushing EV, say you happily get finance but didn't have £20k cash to spend on a car!!!!!!!

Yes hello!!!!???!!!! What's wrong with you?

Massive eyeroll. Maybe try listening to other posters rather than polishing your halo in your own self righteousness.

In terms of the cost per month to run a car - if you have to factor in installing your charge point and cost of finance itself, it didn't work out as favourably as you might think because my insurance was so low in the first place and I do really low mileage.

Yes, current EVs are marginally heavier than their diesel/petrol versions but this is temporary. Batteries and their vehicles are getting lighter all the time. As the push for longer range and better efficiency becomes more pressured, cars get lighter and the battery technology develops. It's only a matter of time before there's a full charge in 15 minute possibility for a car that's lighter than it ever was.

One of the things that massively annoys me about this, is we aren't having a discussion about cars getting bigger and how wasteful it is regardless of whether it's EV and petrol. It's a conversation we should be having. Very few people need a large car - even families. People are using energy moving all that weight around on a daily basis which they don't need to.

As for the battery technology - yep very aware of how this is changing so quickly. We will buy a car new and then run it into the ground so we want to go electric when we feel the technology has got to a certain point we feel happy with. In the UK people tend to buy a car for three years then change to the next car in their budget so are constantly changing their threshold for tech. We want a battery that we won't need to worry about for the lifetime of the car.

We have solar and held off getting a battery for that too because batteries are quite where we'd be happy with the tech. I think it will be about five years before we are about there but we will get there.

In the meantime, small car and reducing journeys as much as possible here.

timetochangethering · 05/11/2023 08:27

maddening · 04/11/2023 16:14

I believe that there a lots of concerns including for example older muti story carparks which are not designed for each car to be such a huge weight

Look at the weight of a diesal Range Rover (2400kg) and a Model 3 (1800kg) and decide if it's true that EV's are the problem here or just bigger heavier cars!

Please please don't believe everything you read, do some research!

Bogwood · 05/11/2023 08:27

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 08:06

Bogwood

I was alerted to the EV fire risk recently by a friend who spends lots of time going down rabbit holes on the internet and is a massive conspiracy nut - so I fact checked it as they often spout a load of crap having not given it any rational thought at all!

EVs are actually less likely to explode or catch fire than petrol and diesel cars. I can’t remember the figures but I found them reassuring as an EV driver. There is risk in everything we do of course - even crossing the road.

I don't think that the Norwegian ferry company that I cited, or the Australian Maritime Safety Agency are being influenced by conspiracy theories! ICEV fires might be more likely (and they do at the moment consist of older car stock and average more miles) but the critical point is that an EV fires can be far more intense, endanger life more quickly, pose a risk of spreading to surrounding vehicles more quickly and are more difficult to put out. The intensity of the blaze is far more likely to cause structural damage to whatever they are contained within (in the case of a car ferry, that could be disastrous). I also read that the sheer volume of water that could be required to extinguish the fire could be sufficient to catastrophically destabilise a vessel.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 08:14

Bogwood;

From the first article you quoted.

‘Referencing the Norwegian Directorate for Safety and Preparedness (DSB), the NRK news company says that fires in fossil fuel cars are4-5 times as common as fires in electric cars. ‘

**

FairyMaclary · 05/11/2023 08:13

It may only be one guy who’s writing the weight articles however The UK institution of structural engineers seems to have revised their advice so they must think he is credible.

In June 2023, the U.K.’s Institution of Structural Engineers, a professional body of engineers whose guidelines inform building codes, issued revised advice. In its own words, an updated version of the report “Design recommendations for multi-story and underground car parks” reflects “significant changes to vehicular size, weight and manoeuvrability.” Specifically, it specifies to increase the uniformly distributed load, which represents the vehicles’ weight impact, from 2.5kN/m2 to 3kN/m2,9 a 20% increase.

I read one article about weight limits for cars being introduced. I doubt you could fill the 1970s car Park near me entirely with rangerovers the spaces are too small. The format is Pillar, three spaces, Pillar. It tends to be a small car next to each pillar due to not being able to open the doors, with a large car in the middle. Presumably battery range rovers are heavier than petrol/diesel range rovers? So a car park full of battery rangerovers would be a greater load?

I am not anti electric. However replacing batteries and battery disposal I would like to know more about. Car manufacturers would presumably prefer us all to buy brand new. If batteries are expected to last 10years/100k how does that leave poorer and younger drivers? Will cars be written off or disposed of earlier? What environmental impact will this have?

A Nissa leaf battery seems to be 5k to replace. Articles vary on how long they last 5-10 years. 100k or 8 years sees to be warranty maximum with most manufacturers. At 10 years old our second car had 60k on it and was in very good condition. I gave it to my relative but I’m hoping it lasts him another 5-7years. But if it was electric with a failing battery would it be heading for scrap? Surely that’s also an environmental issue? https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/nissan/89694/nissan-leaf-battery-replacement-to-cost-4920

Nissan Leaf battery replacement to cost £4,920 | Auto Express

Nissan confirms UK battery pricing for Leaf and e-NV200 owners

https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/nissan/89694/nissan-leaf-battery-replacement-to-cost-4920

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 08:10

This is straight from that article, Bogwood: ‘many of the problems identified in the safety alert would apply to gas powered vehicles as well.’

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 08:06

Bogwood

I was alerted to the EV fire risk recently by a friend who spends lots of time going down rabbit holes on the internet and is a massive conspiracy nut - so I fact checked it as they often spout a load of crap having not given it any rational thought at all!

EVs are actually less likely to explode or catch fire than petrol and diesel cars. I can’t remember the figures but I found them reassuring as an EV driver. There is risk in everything we do of course - even crossing the road.

Bogwood · 05/11/2023 07:39

I think the issue of EV fires (far more dangerous than ICEV fires) is going to become more of a political hot potato - particularly as these vehicles age. The risk of batteries developing a critical fault will become more likely as it ages and this will have an impact if people are thinking that the second hand EV market will play an increasing role with time. In certain contexts EV fires pose a significant hazard - the fires can be ridiculously hot and explosive and very difficult to extinguish (thermal runaway) - which could be disastrous, for example, on a car ferry. It is notable that earlier this year a Norwegian ferry banned EVs https://ctif.org/news/norwegian-shipping-company-bans-electric-cars-board-classic-ferry-route.
Similarly, the Australian Maritime Safety Agency recently issued an alert about the threat posed by EVs to passenger ferries because of their capacity to cause high intensity fires (along with their low ground clearance and also their relatively high weights - which might destabilise the vessel). https://globalnews.ca/news/10064206/electric-vehicle-ferry-warning/#:~:text=The%20safety%20alert%20from%20the,toxic%20gases%20and%20gas%20explosions.

Norwegian shipping company bans electric cars on board classic ferry route

Electric car fires are seen as too difficult to extinguish to allow them on board, according to shipping company Havila Kystruten.

https://ctif.org/news/norwegian-shipping-company-bans-electric-cars-board-classic-ferry-route

Pr0fessionalLurker · 05/11/2023 07:38

People talking about disposal of the batteries should realise that there is already provision in place to dispose of them. It's not currently as easy as disposing of a petrol/diesel car, but really we're in the same position we were in with those cars 20 years ago before the introduction of the SMDA 2013. Since then, disposing of a standard fuelled vehicle has changed dramatically and the same will happen with electric vehicles.

I'm also not sure what some of you are going on about when you're talking about roads giving way because of the additional weight; they are designed to handle artics, I'm sure they can manage. Yes, current EVs are marginally heavier than their diesel/petrol versions but this is temporary. Batteries and their vehicles are getting lighter all the time. As the push for longer range and better efficiency becomes more pressured, cars get lighter and the battery technology develops. It's only a matter of time before there's a full charge in 15 minute possibility for a car that's lighter than it ever was.

BeethovenNinth · 05/11/2023 07:27

I agree. The queues to change cars put me off. Before all the other issues.

i have an old diesel that is very efficient. Low powered engine. I can no longer drive to Glasgow (where would visit and spend money) so I don’t visit Glasgow any more.

I wouldn’t mind if public transport was better but our local buses have been reduced.

Caspianberg · 05/11/2023 07:22

@Arbutusflower - if you read my message you will see someone else said they couldn’t find a second hand electric on car trader for less than £65k. I then said why would you even consider a second hand car for £65k when you could buy a brand new Tesla for half that. I did not recommend anyone spend £65k on a car.

Yes they are expensive new, but they are comparable to a new version of a similar sized car in same range from same company. Ie we were looking for new large car as rural, new baby etc our old run around was too small. We were always going to lease to buy which can only be done new. Secondhand cars are very expensive where we live (not uk) and we didn’t have €20k cash to buy a 5 year old secondhand car. So it was a much more affordable option. It includes insurance, no mot, no high repair costs we had with old car, and cheap charging. So not more expensive per month.

I think our corsa was 13 year old at purchase, rust bucket, still cost us €4500 at purchase. Kept 5 years, cost a fortune in repairs, fail a mot etc. a second hand 9 year old vw tiguan was still €19,000. The uk has a very very cheap secondhand market ( for cars/ furniture/ clothes) which most other places don’t.

RudsyFarmer · 05/11/2023 07:12

Iamonetoo · 04/11/2023 23:37

'They'? Who are 'they'?

You know those twats in charge. Honestly I know the government is inept but it’s as though people have forgotten they exist at all 🤣.

Thekirit · 05/11/2023 02:12

The main problem in this country is that we do not have enough electricity to serve businesses, properties and cars
Our sub stations simply don’t have the capacity yet.
These need to be upgraded or added to first before we can go full throttle on all electric

JenniferBooth · 05/11/2023 00:14

Most of the housing estates are owned by housing associations now not councils Considering tenants have to struggle to get them to do even basic repairs can you see them putting charging points in.

AlltheFs · 05/11/2023 00:00

I’m surprised at this, we have been electric only family since 2016 and never had an issue. It was harder in the early days with lower range cars and a vastly inferior network but these days it’s a doddle. The only place I regularly found hard these days was the New Forest but even that improved this year. I visit my grandmother in a care home there and they now have a rapid in her street at the BP.

I have sometimes had to wait for a charger but that’s all. It’s not often I exceed 300 miles though, it definitely helps now I have more range and can use the Tesla chargers and we do plan routes well.

Actually Leicester is a bit shit for charging, I work there, but rarely charge. Even they have Instavolt though at McDonalds so I indulge in a quick fix while waiting.

JenniferBooth · 04/11/2023 23:41

With an electric car you need to plan in your charging stops, expecting to leave the motorway and find a charging station with multiple chargers a little way off the motorway

More mental load and stress then

Iamonetoo · 04/11/2023 23:39

Ginisatonic · 04/11/2023 21:54

Do you worry about all the Range Rovers parked there too?

Quite....those bloody things must weigh an absolute ton

Iamonetoo · 04/11/2023 23:38

enchantedsquirrelwood · 04/11/2023 16:06

Yes that is also a big issue for me. I am far too impatient to hang around for 30 minutes and that's once you actually get onto a charger. I don't even like queueing for petrol.

Well you might just have to get used to it

Iamonetoo · 04/11/2023 23:37

RudsyFarmer · 04/11/2023 13:53

They don’t want us having cars. Have you not figured this out yet. Hence the 15 minutes towns they are trying to bind us to.

'They'? Who are 'they'?

bellac11 · 04/11/2023 23:33

meganorks · 04/11/2023 20:59

We got a plug in hybrid to test the waters as we have no way of charging at home so didn't want to go full electric. We drive relatively little; no one commutes by car and several days a week car is unused. The plan was to charge at the supermarket when kids are in an class nearby and charge here and there when out. The supermarket I go to is the only place with a decent amount of chargers (10). But slowly they are breaking and not being replaced and often they are full. 2 other places I occasionally visit have had all theirs out of action long term. It seems places either aren't renewing contracts or aren't willing to repair broken ones. So far from the infrastructure growing, it seems to be shrinking near me.

Then there is the pain of them all running off different apps, so when you come across a new one for the first time you invariably spend half an hour trying to set it up. And the other major annoyance is massive car parks advertising they have charge points but giving no indication where they are. And when you finally find them, they have 2 in a car park for thousands.

The apps thing is the thing that would drive me mad.

Its bad enough for parking at various spots throughout the country, usually with terrible signal, various attempts at creating an account and then another bloody password, and it doesnt like this password or that password, takes bloody ages

NearlyMonday · 04/11/2023 23:25

I have a self-charging hybrid and that’s as far as I’m going, life is too short for range anxiety!

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 04/11/2023 23:17

llamadrama16 · 04/11/2023 15:48

How long do you need? I have a 220m range on my car which is considered on the low end these days. I'm sure there are places in the U.K. where you live a 3 hour drive from anywhere, but that's not going to be a common experience. I can do London to Brighton and back for a day trip and don't need to worry about charge at all.

I live in North Yorkshire and my family lives in Devon. It's over 300 miles.

BottleShipDown · 04/11/2023 22:35

I live rurally but 5 mins from village - it’s has three different, very reliable, fast charging points. Better than the city we moved from. We have a drive so charge at home overnight.

The motorway chargers are the worst in my experience. We tend to come off the motorways and find chargers at nice locations where there is a nice cafe or a nice walk. We turn it into a nice bit of the journey.

In case anyone hasn’t suggested it, Zap Map can be useful but less up to date now.

Although it’s trickier if we have to do a very long journey quickly, most of the time it’s fine. But even then we would be stopping anyway.

Things will iron out. We have to stop using oil anyway, to lower carbon, but also because it is rapidly running out!

Ginisatonic · 04/11/2023 22:19

coldcallerbaiter · 04/11/2023 22:12

This thread is about EV and there is an issue with their heaviness not being anticipated when the car parks were built. So a smaller EV is heavier than the smaller regular vehicle it is replacing

The owners of the car parks need to maintain them.
I don’t see people worrying about SUVs in car parks. Many of them are heavier than EVs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread