Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We are not set up for electric vehicles in this country

391 replies

Pollyannaatemyjelly · 04/11/2023 13:31

We have an electric vehicle. We tend not to do too many long journeys but today it was inevitable. We have visit a very popular destination via major motorways but there is not one fast charger available on our route. I've just stopped on the M5 on what is supposed to be a dual charger (so more than one vehicle can charge) but it's not working. I've had to wait 20 minutes for the vehicle next to me to charge before I can even begin to charge mine. There is no chance this county can become all electric when the infrastructure is so poor.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Bogwood · 05/11/2023 09:33

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 09:08

Bogwood Thanks for the info - any links to robust research around that please? Our second car is petrol. Any guidance on what to look out for in that please? You sound like an expert in all things car and fire related?

Haha - I really can't claim to be an expert on all things car related (I have never driven and have no intention of doing so...no love of vehicles, whether EVs or ICEVs!). As for fires, I am indeed an expert, but only the ones that are safely contained in a hearth! I am sure there is plenty of robust research out there though - I very much doubt that the Norwegian ferry company that banned EVs from its vessels did so on a whim...and I am sure that there must have been credible evidence underpinning the Australian Maritime Safety Agency's warnings!

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 09:28

TheHoover · 05/11/2023 08:49

I hardly think that net zero targets can be dismissed as ‘emotive propaganda’. Yes there are other environmental concerns with EVs but these are far outstripped by the benefits to the environment of not burning fossil fuels.

no, there is no joined up plan but how can there be when senior politicians (and their family + friends) have a personal interest in maintaining the wealth derived from oil and gas. There are one or two anti-EV stories in the right wing rags each week. I wonder why….

Edited

I had noticed that the information re EV issues seems linked to right wing politics. The friend that told me my EV was more likely to explode has gone down a very far right rabbit hole.

So hard to get good unbiased information. That’s why I always do my own research when I can, rather than rely on headlines.

I think come election time it will be so important that we all dig deep into the manifestos rather than rely on the media. So much bias out there and so many attention grabbing headlines with no real substance or debate.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 05/11/2023 09:24

People keep saying they don't want to queue (for hours!) to charge. Where are all these queues? I've been driving electric for a year, my mum for 3 years. We've never queued. I have queued for diesel, in my previous car.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 09:18

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 05/11/2023 08:54

I wonder if mumsnet was around for the past 120 years there'd be thread after thread of people complaining about the change from horse and cars to ICE cars, boats to aeroplanes, letters to email, etc, etc.

I'd imagine so, some people just hate change.

That made me chuckle. I have to say that I’m not a fan of change much either. Our EV was DH driven but I’m glad we did shift to it I really like it now, especially being able to accelerate so quickly to overtake as I get really nervous about that!

I think there were protests against cars initially weren’t there? Which makes sense. Suddenly going faster in a man made device after being stuck with horses must have been a bit scary! Human nature to be suspicious of new things I guess. Survival
instinct.

TheHoover · 05/11/2023 09:18

@Bogwood
there is simply not enough data to draw the conclusions that you have about environmental impact over the lifetime of the car, especially considering that the oldest EVs necessarily had a higher impact being new to production.

Air quality in cities is also a huge issue (and the knock-on impact on public health). Oh and Electric buses are on the way and very much part of this ‘net zero malarkey’ - a bad idea?

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 09:12

RedToothBrush

Not trying to convince you either way. I couldn’t care less what car you drive, but have you actually looked into the environmental impact of both types properly? There is a lot of misinformation out there. My understanding is, that whilst not perfect, EVs, overall are less damaging to the environment- even when you take into account the things you mention. Certainly in terms of air pollution of course.

LadyMacB · 05/11/2023 09:09

We’ve had an EV for the last 6 months and whilst I wouldn’t rule out going back to a petrol car when we look to change next, I don’t think we will. I really like the car and how it drives, and haven’t experienced any issues with charging points. I’m in the north-west and there are chargers everywhere. Longer trips require a bit more planning but nothing too onerous and have only been to one services where had to wait for the fast chargers.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 09:08

Bogwood Thanks for the info - any links to robust research around that please? Our second car is petrol. Any guidance on what to look out for in that please? You sound like an expert in all things car and fire related?

RedToothBrush · 05/11/2023 09:07

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 05/11/2023 08:54

I wonder if mumsnet was around for the past 120 years there'd be thread after thread of people complaining about the change from horse and cars to ICE cars, boats to aeroplanes, letters to email, etc, etc.

I'd imagine so, some people just hate change.

Of course they would.

It also doesn't mean that those people weren't wrong in their concerns either those. If you were a carriage maker you might well be fair in your worries and concerns over your livelihood! (I have a bunch of carriage makers in my family)

As a rule DH and I have tended to be earlier adopters of tech than average. But on this EV aren't offering anything new in terms of notable advantage to the user and certainly not on a budget that works for us. And that's the biggest barrier to adoption for any new tech.

The climate change argument isn't as obvious and as tangible and tbh I think there are plenty of ways to reduce your impact with regards to cars without going to EV just yet. I remain unconvinced that during the lifetime of a very small petrol vehicle you are causing less of an issue than a very large EV. Not when you consider all the hidden costs involved in manufacturing and mining. I do think it will hit a tipping point but I don't think we have reached that critical mass point (and tbh I don't think lithium batteries are the solution - batteries are, it's just lithium ones aren't it).

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 09:03

Bogwood · 05/11/2023 08:27

I don't think that the Norwegian ferry company that I cited, or the Australian Maritime Safety Agency are being influenced by conspiracy theories! ICEV fires might be more likely (and they do at the moment consist of older car stock and average more miles) but the critical point is that an EV fires can be far more intense, endanger life more quickly, pose a risk of spreading to surrounding vehicles more quickly and are more difficult to put out. The intensity of the blaze is far more likely to cause structural damage to whatever they are contained within (in the case of a car ferry, that could be disastrous). I also read that the sheer volume of water that could be required to extinguish the fire could be sufficient to catastrophically destabilise a vessel.

Sorry. Wasn’t suggesting they were influenced by conspiracy theories. Just shared that to explain why I fact check this friend! I don’t fact check most of my friends! 😂

The articles you posted are actually not that heavy in detail but do state clearly that EVs are less likely to catch fire in the first place. It also says that the risks highlighted about EV fires would also, mostly, apply to petrol cars. So jury is out even in the two articles you posted.

In my research I couldn’t find any robust information about the intensity of the fires etc so can’t comment on that. I can only comment on my personal risk assessment which went;

I don’t want my car to go on fire - that would be bad! Slight panic was had! Then I remembered my friend is notorious for believing any crap she’s sees on You Tube. So I researched as best I could with my limited expertise in this area;

Research currently shows: EV cars less likely than petrol to go on fire. Found several robust sources for this. But there are some people saying that if it does go on fire it could be a worse fire (but I don’t know that for sure).

I don’t really want any risk of fire as any car fire is likely to be bad, but I have to drive.

There is risk in everything I do - so I’ll stick with the EV as it’s less likely to catch fire in the first place.

But that’s just my assessment based on my research and I’m not suggesting other people should do the Bogwood

Bogwood · 05/11/2023 09:02

@TheHoover But in many cases, electric vehicles never pay back the carbon footprint of their production (particularly those used for city=based use with low mileage) - so, it is disingenuous for them to be pushed as part of the rush for 'net zero' if the negative environmental impact of their production and disposal is in fact not offset significantly by a lower carbon footprint.

@BottleShipDown - given that you are "very risk averse '' make sure you are properly aware of the early signs of thermal runaway in the battery cells - as you may have very little time if this happens (popping noises etc). Obviously the chance of it happening is very low - but best to be aware of the dangers...get well away from the vehicle if you are ever unfortunate enough to be involved in a collision.

megletthesecond · 05/11/2023 09:02

@annahay yes. Same here. Street lights go off at 1am to save money.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 05/11/2023 08:54

I wonder if mumsnet was around for the past 120 years there'd be thread after thread of people complaining about the change from horse and cars to ICE cars, boats to aeroplanes, letters to email, etc, etc.

I'd imagine so, some people just hate change.

TheHoover · 05/11/2023 08:49

I hardly think that net zero targets can be dismissed as ‘emotive propaganda’. Yes there are other environmental concerns with EVs but these are far outstripped by the benefits to the environment of not burning fossil fuels.

no, there is no joined up plan but how can there be when senior politicians (and their family + friends) have a personal interest in maintaining the wealth derived from oil and gas. There are one or two anti-EV stories in the right wing rags each week. I wonder why….

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 08:48

timetochangethering

We bought our used EV a few years ago for £13,000. It’s old so the range is one of the lowest but it’s good enough for us.

NoNonsenseNelly · 05/11/2023 08:47

Of course I’m spouting nonsense, until you realise there is no high street left for shopping

It's not 'them' removing high streets. It's people who refuse to visit high streets and shop online. And those who do visit choose Starbucks and Nando's over the local restaurants and cafes.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 08:46

annahay

Well, may be, but I didn’t find any strong evidence of this in my research. I guess my risk assessment for myself is: how likely is it and what are the consequences?

So an EV fire is 4-5 times less likely than petrol/diesel to catch fire. There is a chance that an EV vehicle fire would be worse, but I don’t know that for sure. Pretty much, if your car is on fire it’s going to be bad right? So I want to minimise that. I have to drive, so actually the car with less chance of going on fire is the lesser of two evils in my mind. I mean we already had it when I was altered to these headlines so that’s a factor too - is it worth switching back? In my mind there wasn’t a reason to switch back to petrol.

But that was just my assessment for myself. Not suggesting anyone else does anything different.

Bogwood · 05/11/2023 08:43

@FairyMaclary I completely share your concerns about the environmental implications of used battery disposal. There are also major issues with respect to the environmental damage caused by mining necessary for the EV batteries - lithium, copper, rare earth metals etc. Interestingly, at current output of raw materials there will be insufficient supply to meet ambitions for the transition to EVs anyway - and to those who think that supply will simply be increased to meet demand, research how long it takes to get a new copper mine up and running! We are going to face some critical bottlenecks with this whole 'net zero' malarkey (and in reality, when the carbon footprint of these vehicles includes their production, rather than just their running, they are very far from carbon neutral)...this is what happens when you let emotive propaganda run away with itself instead of having policy directed by transparent joined-up thinking!

timetochangethering · 05/11/2023 08:40

margotrose · 04/11/2023 17:24

Electric corsa we looked at in 2020, fiat do a tiny electric also, Dacia spring is due out next year as a small electric around £17k

17k is over four times what we can afford to spend on a car.

Saying "you can get them cheaper" is irrelevant when "cheaper" still means "extortionate" and is well out of the price range of most people.

DH and I both rely on our cars for work and neither of us spend more than 4k on either of our vehicles. I genuinely can't afford 17k!

Yes, you will have to wait for them to come into the used car market. Right now on a new car to new car basis they are similar but not on a new to used obviously.

Also you have to remember that the cost calculation is different. So my new EV cost more than I would have spent on a petrol car, but I generally spend about 10%-20% on electricity compared to what i was buying in petrol. Tax is zero, no or minimal servicing as no oil to change etc.... My last petrol car was alternate years £350 and £650 to service.

Its a higher upfront cost but no where near as high running cost.

BottleShipDown · 05/11/2023 08:38

FairyMaclary

The figures I read were per 100,000. I checked very carefully as I drive an EV and have DC. I’m very risk averse.

For sure, do your own due diligence though. I’m not trying to push EVs. Just want to have good quality information out there for people.

If you read past the attention grabbing headlines of those two articles there isn’t much substance to them in either pro or against EV camps.

CasperGutman · 05/11/2023 08:34

SlightlyJaded · 04/11/2023 19:19

A couple of people have questioned my comment about the weight of electric cars and multi-story car parks. If you Google, there is loads of info as well as reports of car park collapses.

Here are a couple of credible source articles for starters.

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/05/electric-cars-too-heavy-old-multi-storey-car-parks/

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/electriccars/article-11956197/Ageing-multi-storey-car-parks-collapse-weight-heavier-electric-vehicles.html

www.topgear.com/car-news/suvs/uk-car-parks-are-apparently-danger-collapsing-because-new-cars-are-so-heavy

LOL. Did you read so much as the headlines of the articles you linked to? The third is about issues caused by the increased weight of "new cars" in general, not EVs.

In fact, it specifically addresses the fact that the car park issue is being hijacked as a political talking point by the anti-EV lobby, and throws in a sarcastic dig at the writers of one of the other two articles you posted:

"An article in the Telegraph points to the added weight of batteries in EVs as the main risk factor, neatly sidestepping the fact that the average petrol-powered car is twice as heavy today as it was when these car parks were built. Which we’re positive is just an oversight." Source: https://www.topgear.com/car-news/suvs/uk-car-parks-are-apparently-danger-collapsing-because-new-cars-are-so-heavy

Car parks could collapse under the weight of electric cars

Electric vehicles are typically much heavier than petrol or diesel cars, with their batteries accounting for a lot of the extra weight

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/04/08/old-car-parks-could-collapse-under-weight-electric-cars

maddening · 05/11/2023 08:33

timetochangethering · 05/11/2023 08:27

Look at the weight of a diesal Range Rover (2400kg) and a Model 3 (1800kg) and decide if it's true that EV's are the problem here or just bigger heavier cars!

Please please don't believe everything you read, do some research!

I am.just commenting on a discussion on a public forum fgs, if I were purporting my view ro be an expert one in some arena where the discussion meant something then of course i.would research, and if I could be arsed I would do some maths around it but seriously this is just a fucking chat forum.

annahay · 05/11/2023 08:32

annahay · 05/11/2023 08:31

@Bogwood but they're much easier to put out.

Sorry! Meant to quote @BottleShipDown

annahay · 05/11/2023 08:31

@Bogwood but they're much easier to put out.