Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We are not set up for electric vehicles in this country

391 replies

Pollyannaatemyjelly · 04/11/2023 13:31

We have an electric vehicle. We tend not to do too many long journeys but today it was inevitable. We have visit a very popular destination via major motorways but there is not one fast charger available on our route. I've just stopped on the M5 on what is supposed to be a dual charger (so more than one vehicle can charge) but it's not working. I've had to wait 20 minutes for the vehicle next to me to charge before I can even begin to charge mine. There is no chance this county can become all electric when the infrastructure is so poor.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
user1477391263 · 08/11/2023 23:52

YY to the above.

Basically, if cities want lively town centers, there are two types of policy choice (you have to choose - you can’t do both).

  1. You can design city centers around cars, assuming that most people live in the suburbs etc and want to drive in. So you let them drive in freely along big roads without many restrictions and without having to pay road tolls or congestion charges and provide lots of cheap government-issued parking areas at well below the true market cost of parking.
  2. You can house lots of people in the urban center instead to so that they can walk and bike easily to their urban shops and services without needing parking - you enable this by building on the land which otherwise would have been used for parking. Dense agglomerations of people in the urban center makes it possible to develop proper fast public transit for the first time, ideally rail or trams (as the highly populated, profitable stretches of public transit effectively subsidize the loss-making stretches that reach into the suburbs). Public transit is paid for by making drivers pay heavily for using roads and motorways, for entering the city center by car, and by paying high costs for the few parking spaces that remain.

You can’t do both of these things at the same time.

If you design cities around cars, nobody is going to want to live in the car-clogged urban centers of cities, which means you won’t get the dense urban populations that are necessary if you want to develop fiscally viable public transport, and if you keep giving road and parking access away to motorists for free or really cheap, you won’t be able to afford to set up and run those nice trains and trams.

And conversely, if you start to house lots of people in the urban core, drivers need to accept that it is gradually going to become close to impossible to drive into the center of cities. Because firstly, nearly all the areas where cars might have parked will get houses and flats built all over them. And secondly, urban core residents who mostly don’t drive will push strongly for cars to be kept out of city centers - pedestrianization schemes, ever-tighter speed limits, ever-tighter pollution controls, congestion charges that get higher over time, bans on parking on inner city street sides. Also, bus lanes and cycle lanes start to take over roads, further reducing space for cars, and train lines are built on former roads, and trams get in the way of cars.

If you are going to build cities around public transport, it inevitably involves heavy restrictions on cars. Anyone who believes otherwise is living in Pollyanna territory.

Right now, the UK is facing a housing crisis, and we’re getting moans and whines wherever we try to build stuff. You propose building on the green belt - No, naughty! Mustn’t build on the green belt. You propose densifying existing suburbs - “But this will add to the pressure on local residents’ services like GPs! And the construction work will be noisy and dusty! Not here, please. Build on brownfield sites in the center of cities instead!!”

Which I think is fine, but I wonder if the suburbanites and villagers demanding “Brownfield first!!”have really realized what the consequences of this will be - like, are they aware that this is likely to set in motion a chain of events which will eventually mean they become unable to drive into the center of cities like they currently expect to be able to do?

SoupDragon · 08/11/2023 23:14

Car-free high streets with good public transport are booming

Not everywhere they aren't.

DdraigGoch · 08/11/2023 18:47

Badbadbunny · 08/11/2023 17:18

@DdraigGoch

Car-free high streets with good public transport are booming.

The key point being "good" public transport which many towns simply don't have. Eg a 5 mile journey between my son's flat and the garage to pick up his car after a service. By bus, it takes 1.5 hours, on 3 different buses, and that involves walking for 45 minutes of it between bus stops on different routes! By road, an easy/direct 5 minutes! The garage is next to a huge retail park, so if he didn't have a car, it'd basically take him all day to go shopping and back! That's along the town's orbital by pass road - no buses at all run along the by pass road between the out of town retail parks etc - they all run into the town so it's a bus into town and another bus out of town on a different route.

As far "car free" high streets, plenty of vibrant town centres are car friendly and remain very popular because they have sensibly sized/priced car parks and no stupid traffic calming and one way systems causing gridlock. People can still drive to them and park easily/cheaply. Yes, a pedestrianised central High Street is attractive, but when the councils go too far and pedestrianise lots of other roads around it and then implement all kinds of one way systems, no entry roads, access only, bus only, etc etc it just alienates drivers and they go to the out of town places instead.

As for denying planning permission, where would you put a huge Tesco superstore on the High Street? Not only will there not be any existing buildings big enough, how would people buy "big" things like TVs or a week's shopping in several full carrier bags (along with a crate of lager), carry all that back home on a bike or a bus? It makes sense to have out of town retail parks and superstores than are good for motorists - the problem was local councils not including public transport options as a condition of PP, i.e. making the developer work with local bus firms to ensure new routes added or existing routes changed to make the out of town sites accessible for locals without cars.

Edited

Good public transport often requires the removal of cars from the streets. It stops buses and trams from becoming stuck in traffic.

I'm not sure that we really need massive superstores in the first place. These are killing our high streets.

In the town plan (the maps that set out council planning policy) the land allocated for development should be along public transport corridors. That applies to residential development too. New housing should encourage walking, with the full range of essential amenities available within walking distance of all of the new houses. The developer can construct this and underwrite the first few years of services.

The proportion of land that can be dedicated to parking would be restricted too. If you really need gargantuan car parks you can build them under your store. 1,000 space car parks between shops just result in more suburban sprawl. I'd prefer it if the UK didn't descend further into becoming a mini version of the US.

A few changes short of full pedestrianisation that can be made include knips (Dutch for 'cut'). You can still drive into a street, but it has been bisected so that if you want to make a through journey you'll have to go a much longer way around - and that doesn't mean that the next street over becomes a rat-run, you would be forced to use the ring road. Bikes and pedestrians are unobstructed meanwhile. Electric bollards allow buses, emergency vehicles and people with permits (perhaps blue badges, residents or people making deliveries) to go through.

Sadly we've got a PM who flies everywhere in a helicopter so don't expect this lot to boost public transport.

Badbadbunny · 08/11/2023 17:18

@DdraigGoch

Car-free high streets with good public transport are booming.

The key point being "good" public transport which many towns simply don't have. Eg a 5 mile journey between my son's flat and the garage to pick up his car after a service. By bus, it takes 1.5 hours, on 3 different buses, and that involves walking for 45 minutes of it between bus stops on different routes! By road, an easy/direct 5 minutes! The garage is next to a huge retail park, so if he didn't have a car, it'd basically take him all day to go shopping and back! That's along the town's orbital by pass road - no buses at all run along the by pass road between the out of town retail parks etc - they all run into the town so it's a bus into town and another bus out of town on a different route.

As far "car free" high streets, plenty of vibrant town centres are car friendly and remain very popular because they have sensibly sized/priced car parks and no stupid traffic calming and one way systems causing gridlock. People can still drive to them and park easily/cheaply. Yes, a pedestrianised central High Street is attractive, but when the councils go too far and pedestrianise lots of other roads around it and then implement all kinds of one way systems, no entry roads, access only, bus only, etc etc it just alienates drivers and they go to the out of town places instead.

As for denying planning permission, where would you put a huge Tesco superstore on the High Street? Not only will there not be any existing buildings big enough, how would people buy "big" things like TVs or a week's shopping in several full carrier bags (along with a crate of lager), carry all that back home on a bike or a bus? It makes sense to have out of town retail parks and superstores than are good for motorists - the problem was local councils not including public transport options as a condition of PP, i.e. making the developer work with local bus firms to ensure new routes added or existing routes changed to make the out of town sites accessible for locals without cars.

DdraigGoch · 08/11/2023 16:02

RudsyFarmer · 06/11/2023 15:48

You’re successfully high lighting one of the problems with this utopian vision. All the shops are shutting.

The high street is dying because people are going to out-of-town big box stores. This is the problem with US-style car-centric development. Permission should never have been granted.

High streets clogged with badly-parked cars are unattractive places to visit. Car-free high streets with good public transport are booming.

sleepwouldbenice · 08/11/2023 00:23

RudsyFarmer · 04/11/2023 13:53

They don’t want us having cars. Have you not figured this out yet. Hence the 15 minutes towns they are trying to bind us to.

Isn't there another copy of the Light to keep you distracted?

JenniferBooth · 08/11/2023 00:18

If you had noticed my previous posts on this thread i was wondering where all the EV evangelists were (who are insisting the batteries in EVs arent a fire hazard) when mobility scooter owners were and still are being told that the batteries in their mobility scooters are a hazard. Fucking tumbleweed when it came to sticking up for the latter.

Is that any clearer?

user1477391263 · 08/11/2023 00:01

I can see that the bolder bit is a quote and I still can’t understand what you are trying to say. Are you angry with someone who says pavement parking is bad, or are you angry at people who pavement park, or are you saying that “if someone complains about pavement parking, this is discriminating against mobility scooters?”

SoupDragon · 07/11/2023 22:36

bellac11 · 07/11/2023 18:32

I would people would use the quote system properly, replies to posts are hard to read otherwise

Given you can't quote just part of a post and people whinge if you quote too much, what do you suggest...?

NoTouch · 07/11/2023 19:12

Ive been on here for 12 years and it was the way it was always done for a long time so its just force of habit. Im getting used to the fact there is a quote button

@JenniferBooth And absolutely nothing wrong with that. Still common practice on this forum. Unfortunately, becoming more common on this forum recently is thread police who make up their own bylaws whether it is don't use bold or dont requote long posts. Post however you like and ignore the police.

JenniferBooth · 07/11/2023 19:00

Ive been on here for 12 years and it was the way it was always done for a long time so its just force of habit. Im getting used to the fact there is a quote button

bellac11 · 07/11/2023 18:32

I would people would use the quote system properly, replies to posts are hard to read otherwise

JenniferBooth · 07/11/2023 14:11

Uh no The sentence in bold is a quote from someone else. The rest of my post is the reply. Im pointing out the hypocrisy

user1477391263 · 07/11/2023 13:27

JenniferBooth · 07/11/2023 13:06

Not ideal but people parking on pavements is even worse

Wow just wow. More proof that the mobility scooter hate is disability discrimination. MS users are told they cant run cables everywhere because its a trip hazard.

If only the reaction DH had got was simply "not ideal" and his cable wasnt running on the pavement or the floor indoors.

Huh? I’ve read your post three times and I can’t understand what point you’re trying to make. You’re trying to say that pavement parking isn’t a bad thing? I’m confused.

JenniferBooth · 07/11/2023 13:06

Not ideal but people parking on pavements is even worse

Wow just wow. More proof that the mobility scooter hate is disability discrimination. MS users are told they cant run cables everywhere because its a trip hazard.

If only the reaction DH had got was simply "not ideal" and his cable wasnt running on the pavement or the floor indoors.

wonkylegs · 07/11/2023 12:43

KittenKins · 06/11/2023 23:23

Something a lot of people don't consider is how a lot of disabled people will cope.

Getting access to the few charging points available in some areas is often impossible because of how many are designed eg steps, lack of space between vehicles etc. That is before you consider the physical weight of the charging cables themselves.

Currently there are no electric WAVs (wheelchair accessible vehicles) due to the additional weight & access required on those already for ramps or lifts.

Don't start me on the hazards those running charging cables directly over kerbs poses.

This isn't true there are EVs that are WAV already
True there aren't loads but there is at least a Nissan, Vauxhall and Peugeot version that I know of and there may be more
As with all emerging technology it takes time to work through for more specialised applications

I know lots of people with my disability who prefer their EVs because charging is actually much easier especially at home with limited mobility and dexterity than using a petrol pump.
As you know not all disabilities are equal and what works for one won't necessarily work for others but I would say that the charging cables are lighter and easier to fix in place than a petrol pump hose.

user1477391263 · 07/11/2023 12:08

SoupDragon · 06/11/2023 23:34

Driving isn't what has killed the highstreet. The internet has done that.

Lively city center hubs seem to work OK in Asian and European cities that are designed around public transport. The train/tram/metro stations become hubs for shopping and services; we all use them before and after getting on a train. It works well and is nice. Everything can be put together in one place because cars and parking do not clog everything up and there is no need for areas to be cluttered up with car parks. Controlling parking tightly means that people can live near stations and shops without the fear of “Oh no, it’ll be a nightmare with people parking all over your street,” which in turn means you have most things you need within walking distances.

I come back to the UK each summer and get more depressed each time I come. British people moan non-stop about the problems caused by their car-addicted society - obesity, the decaying urban centers, fat coddled kids with no independent mobility, chronic illness caused by lack of outdoor time and movement, the parking wars with neighbors, the hours spent taxiing children and elderly parents around because they can’t go anywhere by themselves - but look at you in horror if you suggest that maybe it’s time to design cities differently and shift away from car use. They want to continue driving absolutely everywhere and parking everywhere, and they also want the problems caused by all this to just magically go away by themselves. I give up. I’ve decided to go to meet my family in Europe this year instead.

RedPony1 · 07/11/2023 09:45

Estermay · 06/11/2023 12:38

I do gey ht. You have to have a certain lifestyle to make it work. I can envisage the user journey now.

This, really. i'll never have a lifestyle where EV will be a viable option. Luckily as i adore the sound and driving experience of a petrol manual car. i dont own cars just as i mode of transport and i havent stepped foot on a bus since i was 16. I also kick, scream and sulk if i have to get a train which i can count on two hands

Selfishly, the decline of the High street doesn't have an impact on me, or my parents. We've never had a life where you go wandering on an afternoon through shops.
I love the out of town retail parks, free parking, can whizz over, run in the shop, get back in the car and carry on with my day.

Our company car fleet has declined from a full EV fleet to just 3 EV's and 8 Hybrids and the rest petrol. The lure of cheap tax got them in,but the practicality of the massive mileage our Ops managers do wasnt realistic, it was a logistical nightmare. they are all back to petrols and a few hybrids now.

Panda89 · 07/11/2023 09:23

I use the superchargers at Solstice services on the A303 regularly and have never had to wait.
So yeah in my experience, queuing for a charge is not an issue.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 07/11/2023 09:09

Don't start me on the hazards those running charging cables directly over kerbs poses

Not ideal but people parking on pavements is even worse and the government seems very unwilling to do anything about that, given that the consultation ended 3 years ago.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 07/11/2023 09:08

I think it would take hours because on busy days there are queues for petrol pumps. It takes 5 minutes to fill a car with petrol and pay. It takes significantly longer to charge a car so you could be waiting a very long time.

Ah, you 'think' it will take hours. So they are imaginary queues. I see

Queues at service areas in the middle of the summer holidays are not the figments of my imagination! For goodness sake. Have you ever driven along the A303 in the summer, for example?

And why so aggressive? All you need to do is say that in your experience there haven't been queues.

Estermay · 07/11/2023 09:01

I agree retail parks are still popular here. But they have free parking.

Badbadbunny · 07/11/2023 07:39

SoupDragon · 06/11/2023 23:34

Driving isn't what has killed the highstreet. The internet has done that.

Depends on the town. Out of town retail parks and supermarkets HAVE killed the High Street in many towns, long before internet shopping became so popular. M&S, Tesco and several other chain stores left our Hight Street in the 90's!

megletthesecond · 07/11/2023 06:53

What would help reduce shorter trip car use is better designed towns for pedestrians. DS is starting an Xmas job less than a mile from here, large town centre. Due to the stupid isolated footpaths and two hidden underpasses I'll have to pop out in the car and pick him up when he finishes at 9. If there was a well lit path (no gloomy energy saving lights either) running alongside the road route he could walk it. Everyone in our estate has to use the car to get to "that" part of town as it's too scary to walk. Basically every route out of the ring road is isolated and creepy after dark.

Kpo58 · 06/11/2023 23:40

SoupDragon · 06/11/2023 23:34

Driving isn't what has killed the highstreet. The internet has done that.

I'm pretty sure that shops not actually stocking basic things is what is killing the high street. I've been in a large town and have been unable to buy basic items such as a plant pot and a pair of shoes that fit me. It also annoys me when the item you want is cheaper on the shop's website than it is in the store and when it doesn't let you see which locations have the item that you want to buy in stock.