YY to the above.
Basically, if cities want lively town centers, there are two types of policy choice (you have to choose - you can’t do both).
- You can design city centers around cars, assuming that most people live in the suburbs etc and want to drive in. So you let them drive in freely along big roads without many restrictions and without having to pay road tolls or congestion charges and provide lots of cheap government-issued parking areas at well below the true market cost of parking.
- You can house lots of people in the urban center instead to so that they can walk and bike easily to their urban shops and services without needing parking - you enable this by building on the land which otherwise would have been used for parking. Dense agglomerations of people in the urban center makes it possible to develop proper fast public transit for the first time, ideally rail or trams (as the highly populated, profitable stretches of public transit effectively subsidize the loss-making stretches that reach into the suburbs). Public transit is paid for by making drivers pay heavily for using roads and motorways, for entering the city center by car, and by paying high costs for the few parking spaces that remain.
You can’t do both of these things at the same time.
If you design cities around cars, nobody is going to want to live in the car-clogged urban centers of cities, which means you won’t get the dense urban populations that are necessary if you want to develop fiscally viable public transport, and if you keep giving road and parking access away to motorists for free or really cheap, you won’t be able to afford to set up and run those nice trains and trams.
And conversely, if you start to house lots of people in the urban core, drivers need to accept that it is gradually going to become close to impossible to drive into the center of cities. Because firstly, nearly all the areas where cars might have parked will get houses and flats built all over them. And secondly, urban core residents who mostly don’t drive will push strongly for cars to be kept out of city centers - pedestrianization schemes, ever-tighter speed limits, ever-tighter pollution controls, congestion charges that get higher over time, bans on parking on inner city street sides. Also, bus lanes and cycle lanes start to take over roads, further reducing space for cars, and train lines are built on former roads, and trams get in the way of cars.
If you are going to build cities around public transport, it inevitably involves heavy restrictions on cars. Anyone who believes otherwise is living in Pollyanna territory.
Right now, the UK is facing a housing crisis, and we’re getting moans and whines wherever we try to build stuff. You propose building on the green belt - No, naughty! Mustn’t build on the green belt. You propose densifying existing suburbs - “But this will add to the pressure on local residents’ services like GPs! And the construction work will be noisy and dusty! Not here, please. Build on brownfield sites in the center of cities instead!!”
Which I think is fine, but I wonder if the suburbanites and villagers demanding “Brownfield first!!”have really realized what the consequences of this will be - like, are they aware that this is likely to set in motion a chain of events which will eventually mean they become unable to drive into the center of cities like they currently expect to be able to do?