Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We are not set up for electric vehicles in this country

391 replies

Pollyannaatemyjelly · 04/11/2023 13:31

We have an electric vehicle. We tend not to do too many long journeys but today it was inevitable. We have visit a very popular destination via major motorways but there is not one fast charger available on our route. I've just stopped on the M5 on what is supposed to be a dual charger (so more than one vehicle can charge) but it's not working. I've had to wait 20 minutes for the vehicle next to me to charge before I can even begin to charge mine. There is no chance this county can become all electric when the infrastructure is so poor.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
timetochangethering · 04/11/2023 15:57

Pasithean · 04/11/2023 15:44

Won’t ever get an electric car. Dangerous and we will not be ready for them I live rurally and have no gas so oil and every winter since we mined here have had no electricity for at least two days.

What do you think is dangerous? Having had various EV's for the last 8 years, I'd say they are very much safer than petrol cars.

Likewise I don't see the problem with no electric occasionally, the car will still drive. What do you think is the problem?

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 15:56

@Pasithean - no electricity for 2 days isn’t really a problem. Unless you’re doing a huge amount of daily mileage and charging every single night. Our car does over 500km on a single charge, so we only charge 1-2 times a month on average. It only gets extra charge on long holiday trips. Even if you use more, it’s not going to need daily charging.
We live rural, hilly, with minus temperatures for months and never had a problem

that’s why for many it’s fine to just charge at supermarket or shared charger

RedToothBrush · 04/11/2023 15:55

SlightlyJaded · 04/11/2023 13:50

Not to mention car parks...

They are talking of banning electric cars from multi-story car parks (which would be every shopping centre/airport in the uK) because they weigh too much for a standard multi story to support a floor full of them.

There have already been entire floor collapses and it's widely reported that older carparks in particular are very vulnerable - and that is before every car parked in a bay is electric.

As ever - not thought through properly. Just lots of utopian style blanket policies being made with no connection to reality.

There's talk of making the bays bigger because of the fire risk too.

Personally I'm yet to be convinced of the environmental benefit due to the cost of manufacture (in environmental terms) for electric cars. Keeping in mind the UK market hasn't yet got a cheap electric city car with four seats.

We did look at replacing mine with an electric two years ago.

The numbers didn't stack up. A low mileage efficient city car was working out comparably to a large electric which I would struggle to drive (I'm tiny and find visibility an issue in most cars which are designed for the average male size). The outlay was more money than we had and we were reluctant to do finance.

There are a couple of new models of electric cars that fit into the cheap city car market that look set to hit the market in the next two years. I think they are ultimately the game changers. The price point will drop enough for people wanting a small runaround as a second car. That will in turn help to improve the infrastructure.

In terms of infrastructure, the government needs reform on charge points. At the moment public ones need planning permission. For each and every one. That adds cost and beaucracy so also makes them unattractive.

I think it will change. But I'd argue that our attitude to cars generally needs changing too. People want these huge SUVs and people carriers - which they just don't need. Or use maybe once or twice for a family trip (it'd be cheaper to rent for one off trips than spend thousands more on a bigger car).

Cars are seen as status symbols not functional devices. That's what needs tackling next.

llamadrama16 · 04/11/2023 15:51

BitofaStramash · 04/11/2023 15:44

How will people without a driveway charge their cars? Or those in flats?

There are discussions taking place about converting street lights into charging points that you can plug into. Discussions not actual plans.

But until they sort of thing happens there will be no great increase in electric car usage.

There's also the extra challenges god places like Scotland where so much is rural. We gone even have good broadband coverage yet never mind charging points.

And there is the cost. With electric vehicles so much more expensive they are out of many peoples price range.

No, they absolutely are plans. Considering mine is currently Charing from a lamppost outside my house as I type 🤔

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2023 15:50

MasterBeth · 04/11/2023 13:38

Of course there aren't an overabundance of charging points now.

Obviously, there will be more as more of us drive electric vehicles.

But people won't buy electric cars if they're not confident about charging points.

llamadrama16 · 04/11/2023 15:48

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 04/11/2023 13:59

But those of us who live very rurally will continue to need cars. And yet these are the locations where there are least numbers of electric chargers, in my hamlet there are no streetlights or points where electric chargers could be installed onstreet, yet several runs of terraced houses without driveways, and with long front gardens so cabling can't be run from the house to the street. There are very few charging points in local car parks, and many of us work in environments where you can't charge the car while you're at work.

I won't be getting an electric car until there are batteries capable of doing long journeys or long periods between charges.

How long do you need? I have a 220m range on my car which is considered on the low end these days. I'm sure there are places in the U.K. where you live a 3 hour drive from anywhere, but that's not going to be a common experience. I can do London to Brighton and back for a day trip and don't need to worry about charge at all.

coxesorangepippin · 04/11/2023 15:45

Totally agree. It will never work.

We live in Canada and there are chargers everywhere

llamadrama16 · 04/11/2023 15:44

We've been electric for nearly 4 years and we've seen a huge difference in that time. There are many more high-speed chargers on regular routes we take (we're in London and mostly stay within the south-east).

No- it's not amazing. But I think for people who have home chargers who don't do a huge amount of long-distance driving, you're mostly okay. (We don't have a home charger so rely on the public charging network and would never go back to petrol).

BitofaStramash · 04/11/2023 15:44

How will people without a driveway charge their cars? Or those in flats?

There are discussions taking place about converting street lights into charging points that you can plug into. Discussions not actual plans.

But until they sort of thing happens there will be no great increase in electric car usage.

There's also the extra challenges god places like Scotland where so much is rural. We gone even have good broadband coverage yet never mind charging points.

And there is the cost. With electric vehicles so much more expensive they are out of many peoples price range.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 04/11/2023 15:44

I’m always interested to know who it is the government are hoping will give up car ownership? Those in towns and cities with fairly good transport links and those who work from home/ work in an office/ could car share?

Very unlikely that those of us rurally and who rely on cars for work such as carers and myself a community nurse will be giving up our personal cars and I am a long way off swapping to electric due to no availability of chargers or personal drive, I also live in a tiny village which is literally houses either side of a main road with 2 street lights so unsure how that will work. I am holding out for something else synthetic fuel or such and I only run a 1.2 litre petrol anyway

Pasithean · 04/11/2023 15:44

Won’t ever get an electric car. Dangerous and we will not be ready for them I live rurally and have no gas so oil and every winter since we mined here have had no electricity for at least two days.

StamppotAndGravy · 04/11/2023 15:41

annahay · 04/11/2023 13:43

I agree. How will people without a driveway charge their cars? Or those in flats? Will renters be allowed to install the faster chargers? Will workplaces provide charge points? Can the grid even manage? Too many questions not being talked about.

Yes! I live in a flat in the Netherlands with all of those things! We have shared charging points outside the flats, chargers at work and p&r stations and fast chargers along main roads. We have exactly the same infastructure in minature for electric bikes. The grid is starting to struggle, mostly as a result of domestic solar panels and huge data centres, but there is political will to sort it (partly because rich people who vote have solar panels, electric cars and run businesses reliant on data centres)

Blanketpolicy · 04/11/2023 15:41

timetochangethering · 04/11/2023 15:20

There is so much misinformation in this thread. I also drive an EV, we are an all electric family.

We have driven to the South of France in the EV, several times and have had no issues. We have driven from London to Liverpool, no issues. London to Scotland, no issues.

There are rarely queues to charge - just like occasionally you come across queues to get petrol...but not often.

There are planners that tell you where to stop.

The "weight in car parks" is complete fiction. Do people not know what Range Rovers weigh? Some old car parks are just that, old. Modern SUV's of any description are very heavy. EV's are heavy but not compared to a Range Rover, that is heavier.

"causing potholes" complete fiction. it's just roads not being repaired as often and generally more SUV's.

"needs different tyres" again, uses similar tires to existing petrol vehicles.

"uses more tyres" - Nope

Oh and it's PETROL and DIESEL that is up to 20 times more likely to catch fire than electric. That one always shocks people and it is completely true!

There are so many fictional stories out there to put people off EVs, I mostly put it down to fear of change and the unknown.

There is also a strong political aspect to a lot of these stories that have little substance and are designed to worry gullible people.

Take the story of the carparks - it compares the weight of the heaviest EVs with a car that went out of production over 40 years ago! There are many many ICE cars on the road today that are much heavier than my EV.

MintJulia · 04/11/2023 15:38

OP, you are correct, which is why I bought a diesel to use until 2030.

At that point if the infrastructure has improved, I will buy an EV, or if not, I will buy the smallest EV I can find as a local runaround, and hire a petrol car/travel by train for the occasional longer journey.

I'll be retired by then so it will be more practical.

timetochangethering · 04/11/2023 15:37

AQuantityOfNaughtyCats · 04/11/2023 15:23

The only way it’ll work is standardised removable batteries. So you drive to a ex petrol station, take out the battery, replace with a charged one and drive off. Takes 2 minutes just like topping up with petrol. Also gets round the issue of ageing batteries being the most expensive part of the car. But the car manufacturers don’t want it because it’ll damage their profit margins.

If you actually had an electric car, you would realise this is just a non-issue.

Batteries last way way longer than you think and there are lots of EV's around (Taxis etc) that have gone over 200k miles successfully.

Most people's driving is such that overnight charging or workplace charging is all that's needed.

Yes, there needs to be more infrastructure but at the moment the traditional vehicle industry is trying to hang on as they have realised how much money they will lose if EV's become the norm.

PermanentTemporary · 04/11/2023 15:35

This car park collapse thing looks like a total web of bullshit.

I've read the article linked to above, which interviews a 'car park consultant' (ie a guy who makes a living telling councils their car parks could collapse unless they pay him to report on it) saying that older car parks MIGHT not be able to cope with the additional weight of EVs because their construction might not be adequate and they'd need a consultant to sort that out No evidence on this is presented.

I've just had a look at multiple articles on the car park collapses in Wolverhampton (1997) and Luton Airport much more recently. It was thought that Wolverhampton might be due to its type of construction, but it wasn't- it was neglected and nobody bothered to repair it. Luton Airport car park collapsed after a DIESEL vehicle caught fire.

TimeForACider · 04/11/2023 15:34

We’ve got an EV and I know what you mean. We’ve got a home charger so 9/10 use that but have had the odd problem with public chargers. Range anxiety is definitely a thing if you haven’t been able to find somewhere and you’ve got 3 miles to home and only 3 or 4 miles left on the car 😬

Ittastesvile · 04/11/2023 15:34

I agree with you. We have a Tesla and it's great locally. It's also generally great long distance if we plan around Tesla fast chargers on motorways (it's rare we've found them all full).

As soon as we have to use public non-Tesla chargers it's incredibly stressful. The chargers are full, broken, or there are issues with yet another app. We avoid them as much as possible. We went on holiday to Lincs a while ago and the first FOUR charging locations weren't working. We almost ran out of charge because the fifth was miles away, and that was a trickle charger. You can't function like this.

DiscoBeat · 04/11/2023 15:32

I totally agree. We've got an EV but for exactly that reason we've got a second diesel car for longer journeys and only ever charge the EV at home. Kind of defeats the object!

NoTouch · 04/11/2023 15:31

AQuantityOfNaughtyCats · 04/11/2023 15:23

The only way it’ll work is standardised removable batteries. So you drive to a ex petrol station, take out the battery, replace with a charged one and drive off. Takes 2 minutes just like topping up with petrol. Also gets round the issue of ageing batteries being the most expensive part of the car. But the car manufacturers don’t want it because it’ll damage their profit margins.

Have you seen the size of an EV battery? It generally is built into the chassis for space and weight distribution and the size of the full floor of the car.

It would need some major technical advances and investments to get to that stage and I expect won't be in my life time! We need to crawl before we can run.

AQuantityOfNaughtyCats · 04/11/2023 15:23

The only way it’ll work is standardised removable batteries. So you drive to a ex petrol station, take out the battery, replace with a charged one and drive off. Takes 2 minutes just like topping up with petrol. Also gets round the issue of ageing batteries being the most expensive part of the car. But the car manufacturers don’t want it because it’ll damage their profit margins.

timetochangethering · 04/11/2023 15:20

There is so much misinformation in this thread. I also drive an EV, we are an all electric family.

We have driven to the South of France in the EV, several times and have had no issues. We have driven from London to Liverpool, no issues. London to Scotland, no issues.

There are rarely queues to charge - just like occasionally you come across queues to get petrol...but not often.

There are planners that tell you where to stop.

The "weight in car parks" is complete fiction. Do people not know what Range Rovers weigh? Some old car parks are just that, old. Modern SUV's of any description are very heavy. EV's are heavy but not compared to a Range Rover, that is heavier.

"causing potholes" complete fiction. it's just roads not being repaired as often and generally more SUV's.

"needs different tyres" again, uses similar tires to existing petrol vehicles.

"uses more tyres" - Nope

Oh and it's PETROL and DIESEL that is up to 20 times more likely to catch fire than electric. That one always shocks people and it is completely true!

neverenoughplants · 04/11/2023 15:19

I agree, there needs to be a pre-emptive boost to the infrastructure - not just wait until more people have EVs and then go 'ahh, it seems we need more chargers/facilities, who could have predicted this??'

If they wait for the demand to rise, it'll either be a disaster (because suddenly there'll be insane queues at service stations as 40 cars wait to use 5 chargers) or the demand will just never happen because people will hold off buying an EV until the infrastructure is better. But pre-emptive planning/work isn't something the UK govt is very good at...

Blanketpolicy · 04/11/2023 15:17

Moonmelodies · 04/11/2023 15:01

First one built in 1884.

ok, the popular uptake of EVs is comparatively new, but it was obvious to most what I meant 🙄

RudsyFarmer · 04/11/2023 15:17

Squidlette · 04/11/2023 14:43

But what would the purpose of that be?

How are the binnies going to do their jobs from home?

If you Google ‘15 min city’ you’ll see the utopian vision and what they are trying to achieve. My irritation is it’s another blow to our personal freedoms and I’d rather they were just honest about it. However I know that climate activists see it as the progressive way forward and anyone pushing back are right wing zealots.